A Rhode Island reform-school report on banning dime novels reprints a Detroit Free Press anecdote in which scout Jack Crawford claims to have met and conversed with the outlaw Billy the Kid, who blamed his criminal downfall on reading dime novels. The story is presented as a cautionary moral tale rather than current news.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 57 days later.
Wrong
Howard Times · 7 November 1891 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
"Billy the Kid," who attributes his downfall to reading "Dime Novels." The article is taken from the Detroit Free Press as follows: "In riding down a gulch that evening I came upon a young man sitting upon a rock, his horse
Sharp County Record · Evening Shade, Ark. · and 6 other papers
This anecdotal piece recalls various western 'bad men' including Russian Bill and Sandy King, who were lynched at Shakespeare, Arizona, and lists numerous frontier figures who shared the name 'Bill,' including Billy the Kid. It also recounts a humorous story of Cheyenne Bill failing to intimidate a tenderfoot in Raton, New Mexico.
Sharp County Record · 19 November 1891 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
TYPES OF BORDER BAD MEN.
Bill, a Butcher Knife Bill and Bill Bonney or Billy the Kid that I have known of. "Cheyenne Bill was and is one of the false killers referred to, and always trying to 'run a blazer' upon some tenderfoot and scare him to death. Raton,