As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

May 1889

2 articles

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A Wichita newspaper profile describes Deputy U.S. Marshal Jack 'Comanche Jack' Stillwell, a noted Western gunman and hangman's aide, comparing visitors of his notoriety to figures like Billy the Kid and Jesse James. The piece details his reputed killings and role in frontier justice in Indian Territory.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 3 May 1889 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

COMANCHE JACK'S RECORD.

A Man Who Has Shot Thirty-One Others and Helped Hang Seventeen. In this Western city on the streets and in the hotel lobbies every day one meets with many of the most noted Western characters of the day, writes the Wichita (Kan.) correspondent of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. Bret Harte would here find many subjects for wild Western history that would throw some of his previous creations of fiction into the shade. The Indian Territory is near by, where there is employed a large number of brave and hardy men as Deputy United States Marshals who appear periodically in the largest city most convenient to their working place, so that Wichita is often called upon to entertain visitors of almost as much notoriety as "Billy, the Kid," or Jesse James.

See moreSee less

Chief among this number

See the clipping

The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.

This is a dramatized, literary retelling (credited to 'Lex, in Ye Humbugge') of the shooting of Billy the Kid, embellished with suspenseful narrative detail about the gunfight with the sheriff. It reads as a short fiction piece rather than straight news reporting, published years after the actual 1881 killing.

The Telegraph-Courier · 23 May 1889 · page 2

Bang—bang—the two reports are almost simultaneous, and the bullets speed—the sheriff’s '“snap shot,” made by pure good luck a second before Billy's finger pressed the trig ger, and made almost at random, yet finds its way to the outlaw’s heart, while the latter’s weapon, slightly jerked upward by a convulsive mus cular action that accompanied the passage of the ball through his body, sent its bullet into the ceiling. A gasp—a staggering movement —a crash, —and Billy the Kid’s days of triumphant crime were forever over, as he fell at full length upon the clay floor, dead. —Lex, in Ye Lfumbugge.

See the clipping