The Sully County Watchman · Clifton, S.D.
A dispatch describes the capture of a man called "Billy the Kid," described as the terror of cattlemen in Western Kansas, who was taken near Boston, Colorado and transported to Trinidad. The account details a chase by armed posses, a gunfight, and his eventual capture by a lone farmer who held him at shotgun-point.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 162 days later.
The Sully County Watchman · 3 November 1888 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
HOW "BILLY THE KID" WAS TAKEN.
The Terror of Kansas Cattlemen Outwitted by a Lone Captor and Imprisoned.
See moreSee less
"Billy the Kid," who was captured recently has been taken to Trinidad. The notorious dare-devil was the terror of the cattlemen of Western Kansas. He was captured six miles from Boston and taken to Granada, where he and the officers took the train for Trinidad. He had produced more excitement in the Southwest country during the past month than any other man had for years. He seemed to have held a grudge against Boston, the town of which he was marshal about nine months. He was chased by thirty-two men from Boston and Stonington for about one week. This party was well armed, and went to the house of Billy's uncle, who lives near Springfield. One night recently eight miles from Springfield, they came upon him. There was a light moon, and Billy could be plainly seen and recognized. The party opened fire, but Billy leaned over in his saddle and put spurs to his horse. He soon outdistanced the party, though they fired fully 200 shots at him. He had a pair of good ponies which he was leading, and these he let go as soon as the firing began. They were captured and proved to be a pair which he had stolen in the neighborhood. He was captured at night by a farmer, who, passing a claim house that he knew to be vacant and seeing a light, looked into the building and recognized "Billy the Kid." He covered him with a double barreled shotgun and called to him to throw up his hands. This Billy lost no time in doing. The farmer intended to take him to Boston but "The Kid" begged so hard that he took him to Granada and gave him to the officers.