Wessington Springs Herald · Wessington Springs, S.D.
A man recounts meeting Billy the Kid, describing his mild appearance and unsettling charm, and recalls witnessing him kill two cowboys who had bragged they would kill the Kid. The story is framed as personal anecdote, building the outlaw's legendary reputation years after his death.
Wessington Springs Herald · 9 September 1887 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
BILLY THE KID.
"Billy the Kid, was, an' no mistake, a holy terror. He was one of those strange things you come across once in a life time, an' while he was as smooth an' pleasant a little feller as yer could wish to 'sociate with, he filled a feller with a sort o' awe—I think that's the word. He was slim and light-haired, an' blue-eyed, an' his face was sort o' pale; his upper teeth stuck out a little bit; an' that made him look more innocent than ever. You somehow ain't afeerd of a feller whose teeth sticks out in front. He didn't weigh very much more than 130 pounds, an' he was a pleasant companion. His eyes were pleasant until he got mad, an' then they shot fire.
See moreSee less
"I seen Billy kil two men, an' he did the job up clean. They never kicked, and they had their lights put out in grand shape. They were cow-boys, an' they swore they'd kill the Kid 'cause they heard so much about him. That time, at least, the Kid wasn't to blame. He hadn't killed no relative of their'n. It wasn't very fur f'm Socorro, which wasn't much more'n a village then, an' we was in camp when the Kid an'