As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

September 1887

2 articles

Wessington Springs Herald · Wessington Springs, S.D.

A man recounts meeting Billy the Kid, describing his mild appearance and unsettling charm, and recalls witnessing him kill two cowboys who had bragged they would kill the Kid. The story is framed as personal anecdote, building the outlaw's legendary reputation years after his death.

Wessington Springs Herald · 9 September 1887 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

BILLY THE KID.

"Billy the Kid, was, an' no mistake, a holy terror. He was one of those strange things you come across once in a life time, an' while he was as smooth an' pleasant a little feller as yer could wish to 'sociate with, he filled a feller with a sort o' awe—I think that's the word. He was slim and light-haired, an' blue-eyed, an' his face was sort o' pale; his upper teeth stuck out a little bit; an' that made him look more innocent than ever. You somehow ain't afeerd of a feller whose teeth sticks out in front. He didn't weigh very much more than 130 pounds, an' he was a pleasant companion. His eyes were pleasant until he got mad, an' then they shot fire.

See moreSee less

"I seen Billy kil two men, an' he did the job up clean. They never kicked, and they had their lights put out in grand shape. They were cow-boys, an' they swore they'd kill the Kid 'cause they heard so much about him. That time, at least, the Kid wasn't to blame. He hadn't killed no relative of their'n. It wasn't very fur f'm Socorro, which wasn't much more'n a village then, an' we was in camp when the Kid an'

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands · and 3 other papers

A man who claims to have been in New Mexico when Billy the Kid was killed recounts his memories of the outlaw's skill with a gun and his deceptively innocent appearance. He asserts that Pat Garrett did not give the Kid a fair chance, since no one could outshoot him.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Belmont Chronicle, 7 July 1887, Wichita Eagle, 11 August 1887.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 15 September 1887 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WHAT HE REMEMBERS OF THE WAYS OF "BILLY THE KID."

The Quickest Man with a Weapon in the Whole Southwest Was the Innocent Looking Dare Devil the Kid--He Never Missed.

See moreSee less

There was a look of great disgust on the face of the man from Dodge the other day when the reporter saw him, and he appeared to be dejected as well. "I hev ben figurin' on goin' back to Dodge," said he, "but that scheme is busted; I see by the telegraph items in the newspapers that the s'loons is all closed down there, and what is life wuth livin' fur whur the s'loons is all shet up? But that wasn't what I was goin' to talk about. I was readin' 'bout fellers that was handy with the gun an' how fast they could fan the hammer. There was something about Pat Garrett's killin' Billy the Kid. Now it happened that I was down that way when the Kid was killed an' know somethin' about it, an' I know, too, that Pat didn't give him a square show fer his life. But then he'd a' been a fool if he had, 'cause Billy could outshoot any man in New Mexico. The Kid was, an' no mistake, a holy terror. He was one of those strange things you come across oncet in a lifetime, an' while he was as smooth an' pleasant a little feller as yer could wish to 'sociate with, he filled a feller with a sort o' awe--I think that's the word. He was like a snake a shinin' in the sun, so slick an' so han'some, an' yet his touch meant death. He was slim an' light haired, an' blue eyed, an' his face was sort o' pale; his upper teeth stuck out a little bit, an' that made him look more innocent than ever. You somehow ain't afeared of a fellow whose teeth sticks out in front. He didn't weigh very much more than 130 pounds, an' he was a pleasant companion; his eyes was rather pleasant until he got mad, an' then they shot fire.

"I seen Billy kill two men, an' he did the job up clean. They never kicked, an' they had their lights put out in great shape. They was cowboys, an' they swore they'd kill the Kid 'cause they'd heard so much about him. That time at least the Kid wasn't to blame. He hadn't killed no relatives of their'n. It wasn't very fur f'm Socorro, which wasn't much more'n a village then, an' we was in camp when the Kid an' another fellow come up. Now we wasn't overglad to see Billy 'cause he had a hard name; they said he'd kill a man if he didn't happen to be stuck on the color o' his hair an' sich like. But we wasn't goin' to let on. That little devil was so sweet on us that you'd a thought butter would a been safe in his mouth, an' that made us more uneasy than ever, though there was ten o' us an' only two o' 'em, the Kid an' the feller with him. Well, as I was sayin', we was eatin' dinner, or supper, fer it was after sundown, when two fellers rode up. The Kid had seen 'em, but he never let on an' kept on eatin' as nateral as if there wasn't nobody in a hundred miles that was goin' to hurt him.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Independent Statesman · Concord, N.H. · 5 May 1887
  • Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D. · 27 May 1887
  • Belmont Chronicle · St. Clairsville, Ohio · 7 July 1887