As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

December 1920

26 articles

Casper Daily Tribune · Casper, Wyo.

A Canadian government engineer reports finding a legendary wild buffalo herd of about 1,000 head in the Mackenzie river basin, confirming long-standing Indian and trapper tales. The report notes this herd and a possibly larger one further north, along with Yellowstone's 90 wild bison, represent the last wild buffalo on the continent.

Casper Daily Tribune · 2 December 1920 · page 6

Canadian Wilds EDMONTON, ALTA (By Mail).—The phantom herd of the north has been found. For years a tradition of a great herd of buffalo somewhere in the Mac kenzie river basin has lingered among the fur posts. Indians told of sighting it blackening the wild pastures of re mote valleys. No white men had seen it. But trappers had chunoed upon its ' trampled trails and ten years ago. two mighty bulls, that had straggled far | from their fellows, were killed. F. H. Kitto, engineer of the natural resources branch of the department us the interior, who has returned from ** live months of explorations in the Mac kenzie country, reports that he saw ‘ the herd and estimates it at 1,000 head.

See moreSee less

1 He received reports, he says, from In- ’ dians that another herd equally as j large exists farther north. Canada has the largest bison herd , _____ in the world in the national park at j Wainwright. Alta., on January 1. it'

See the clipping

The Sun · Price, Utah

A letter received by H. H. Rideway from the American Humane Society indicates that definite steps are being taken to save the buffalo herd on Antelope Island in Great Salt Lake. Unlike earlier rumors, funds are now actually being raised, as the bison will be destroyed unless active measures are taken.

The Sun · 3 December 1920 · page 5

worse beforo tho first of tho year. Defiillto slops arc being talcen lo save the herd of buffalo on Anttlojic Island, in Great Salt Lake, according lo n letter received last week by If H. Riihloway from thy fimericnn llumani) society. Former-Idlers hse been vogue, but this one' shows that the intention is definite and that the cash is being raised to save tho bison, which will bo destroyed unless., ael.vo

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

F. H. Kitto, a government engineer, reports finding the long-rumored 'phantom herd' of wild buffalo in the Mackenzie River basin, estimating it at 1,000 head. He also heard Indian reports of another equally large herd farther north, and the article notes Canada's captive herd at Wainwright and the small wild herd in Yellowstone.

Paper unidentified · 4 December 1920 · page 3

Of MACKENZIE RIVER Bdmonton, November SO. — The phantom herd of the north haa been found. For years a tradition of a great herd of buffalo somewhere la the Mackenzie river basin has ling ered among the fur poets. Indians told of sighting it blackening the wild pastures of remote valleys. No white man had seen it. But trappers had chanced upon Its trampled trails and ten years ago two mighty bulls, that had straggled far from their fellows, were killed. F. H. Kltto, engineer of the natur al resources branch of the depart ment of the Interior, who has re turned from five months of explora tions in the Mackenzie country, re ports that be saw the herd and es timates it at 1000 head.

See moreSee less

He received reports, he says, from Indians that another herd equally as large exists further north. Canada has the largest bison herd in the world in the national park at.

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

A dispatch from Winnipeg says explorer F. H. Kitto of Canada's natural resources intelligence branch discovered a herd of more than 1,000 wild bison in the Mackenzie River basin, described as the last herd on the American continent. Kitto also received reports of another equally large herd further north.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.

Wrong

South Bend News-Times · 5 December 1920 · page 11

IJIKT1I HIXOHI). Twin daUL'hti-f! ur. ).rPTi tn t r I and Mrs. I. ster ( k .-! a , Iinc.vlr Way west, yesterday. A dau'hfar wa.s burn to Mr. and Mrs. Jos. jili UrciJin-r, (JhiciiKo. S,it tirdaj. Mrs. ilrediuT w.is form -rlj Mis.s Henrietta Voder of this city. co(TA'ii:s visit iii:ki:. Mrs. I ). Morrison h.is returned t h r home in flrand Ilapids, Mich., after sp ndini; a few weeks with relatives here. Chicken pl Presbyterian supper. church. Dec. S. Advt. -tf. Feed prices down. Jaiuith's feed ftore. 22G N.

See moreSee less

Main t. Phone Misha waka 207, 21tl 4 Advt. Order Christmas photon now at "Ostrarder's photo Gallery." p.iono 31. Advt. A herd of wild bison, numbering more than 1.000 animals, said to be the last herd on the American con tinent, has been discovered roaminp In the country' of the McKenzie riv er basin, says a report from Winni peg, Manitoba. F. II. Kitto, explor ing engineer of the natural re sources intelligence branch of the department of the interior, Ottowa. i. the discoverer, and he s.-ivs that

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A dispatch from Winnipeg reports that explorer F. H. Kitto discovered a herd of more than 1,000 wild bison roaming the McKenzie River basin, believed to be the last such herd on the continent. Kitto also said he had received reports of another equally large herd further north.

Evening Times-Republican · 6 December 1920 · page 6

"A herd of wild bison, numbering aoiore than 1.M0 animals, said to be the last herd on the American con tinent has been discovered roaming the oountry of the McKenzie river basin, says a report from Winnipeg. F. H. Kitto, exploring engineer of the natural resources intelligence branch |f t)i* of the

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah

The Salt Lake Commercial Club is pursuing negotiations to save a herd of 1,000+ buffalo on Antelope Island from being hunted for sport by the owning livestock company. Talks are underway with the American Humane Society's president about purchasing or leasing the island as a game sanctuary, with a response expected within days.

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 7 December 1920 · page 3

FURTHER PLANS TO SAVE BUFFALO HERD SALT LAKE. Dee 7. The herd of' 1CB buffalo on Antelope Island may be saved from destruction. The campaign of the Salt Lake Commercial club to I

See the clipping

The Powder River County Examiner and the Broadus Independent · Broadus, Mont. · and 5 other papers

The report traces the buffalo's original range across North America and cites historical estimates of herd sizes, including a 1871 sighting of a massive migrating herd. It details the destruction of the southern and northern herds following railroad construction, with slaughter by hide hunters and Indigenous hunters reducing the population to scattered remnants.

The Powder River County Examiner and the Broadus Independent · 10 December 1920 · page 5

000 bison. About the same time Fre mont bore witness to the appalling de struction. The death knell of the bison was struck when Union Pacific construc tion began In I860. Previously the difficulties of marketing served as a alight check on the rate of extermina tion. This railroad divided the orig inal body Into southern and northern herds. Hornaday estimates that In 1871 the southern herd contained 3. 000,000 animals, though most estimates give a higher total. Between 1871 and 1875 the great southern herd was wiped out of existence.

See moreSee less

Final slaughter of the northern herd was inaugurated by the opening of the Northern Pacific in 1880, when the half-breeds of Manitoba, the Plains Cree of Qu'Appelle and the Bluckfeet of South Saskatchewan swept hare a great belt of country stretching east and west between the Rocky Moun tains and Manitoba. A few thousand remained In the country arounfl the headwaters of Battle River, between

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • · · 26 November 1920
  • The Ordway New Era · Ordway, Colo. · 26 November 1920
  • Northern Wisconsin Advertiser · Wabeno, Wis. · 26 November 1920
  • The Brookings Register · Brookings, S.D. · 2 December 1920
  • The Washburn Times · Washburn, Wis. · 9 December 1920

The Morning Tulsa Daily World · Tulsa, Okla.

An opinionated editorial mocks conservationists for mourning the destruction of the American bison, framing the slaughter as an inevitable and even divinely ordained step in settling the Great Plains. The writer argues it is absurd to value buffalo herds over the farms, cities, and industry that replaced them.

The Morning Tulsa Daily World · 12 December 1920 · page 28

CONSERVATION AND COMMON SENSE

('(l.Vsr.HV.VI Kl.V AM COMMON SI'.NSI'.. It neeuis that we effect mi unholy alllanro when o attempt to couple the two tenim. That hltoiidu't be so but It Is. In (i current publication tbile Is u great ileal said about the crime we as a people niiimit ted In destroying the li'.g imiiio of the country, eiedal stress being laid on the iliKtriictlun of tho American bison or buffalo, S'n-i nllcil con

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

This article describes the prairie provinces of Canada—Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Alberta—and their notable features, including the fact that the last wild buffalo herds in America now range through northwestern Alberta. It also discusses the region's coal supply, migratory birds, and influence on U.S. weather patterns.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 December 1920 · page 6

WINNING THE CANADIAN WEST

The National Geological society describes these most recent recruits to the pro hibition forces in a bulletin issued from its Washington, D. C., headquaters. The prairie provinces of Canada—Man itoba, .Saskatchewan and Alberta—are not without their bids to fame. For ex ample : •The last of the wild buffalo herds

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah

A federal park service official writes to Utah's livestock board suggesting the state consider turning Antelope Island into a state park to preserve its buffalo herd. The reply details the island's size, ownership, land value, and reports 21 head of buffalo currently on the island.

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 14 December 1920 · page 4

SUGGESTS PARK FOR BISON HERD

To State Board Concern ing Buffalo SALT LAKE. Dec. 14. In a letter to Thomas Redmond, aecretary of the M.i to livestock board, Aro B. Cammer er, acting director for the national park aemcei United States department of Interior, has express, d lus opinion Of the proposal that the government t,et aside Antelope Island as a natural breeding place for bison. A portion of his letter follows:

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah

A report details the private ownership and valuation of Antelope Island, including a herd of 21 buffalo descended from animals brought from Green River, Wyoming by William Glassmann about 25 years earlier. The owners, now raising pure beef cattle, are selling permits to kill the buffalo at $200 each since the animals damage crops and harm young cattle, while a dispute also continues over the tax valuation of the herd.

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 14 December 1920 · page 4

FOR BISON HERD

! breeding pure beef cattle on the ls ', land and the bison kill ami cripple I many of the bulls a id .oiing calves. ; besides destroying hay and forage j crops and otherwise making themsi es a nuisani e. "The buffalo,'.' cites Mr. Redmond, ! "are on practically natue ranges, from Which they cannot stray, and any at ' tetnpt lo ship them to other reserva tions ould result In killing and crip I p'.ing a large percentage of the am mals, as they are very wild, and run , without restriction In their native siate."

See moreSee less

Protest was made to the -;.it, board I of eQuallsatibn a few w,k. ago by John B, Dooly, principal owner of the island, against an assessed iluatlon of ; 150 a head placed on the buffalo He

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

The American Bison Society reports 3,393 wild and tame buffalo in the United States as of January 1920, easing earlier fears of extinction. Government herds at Wichita and Dixon, Montana are thriving, with plans to distribute surplus animals to parks and municipalities to safeguard against disease or misfortune.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

Evening Times-Republican · 21 December 1920 · page 10

BUFFALO HERDS INCREASE. Little Danger of Animals Becoming Extinct. Washington, Dec. $1.—The Ameri can Bison Society reports that in January, 1920, there were 3,393 wild and tame buffalo in the United States. This encouraging report sets at rest the very real fear that existed not long ago lest the native buffalo, which once roamed the western plains, would soon become extinct. Of the nine government-owned herds, two of the largest are located in the Wichita national game pre serve", Oklahoma, and|on the national bison range at Dixon, Mont. The herd on the Wichita preserve now numbers 154, including 28 calves of this year.

See moreSee less

In this herd 4 bulls and 12 cows are 101 years of age or over and one cow is 29 years old. The 15 ani mals that constituted the original Wichita herd came from the New York Zoological Park. In accordance with the provisions made by the 1919 appropriations bill for their care, it is planned this year to dispose of some ofthe surplus buffalo in the government herds.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The American Bison Society suggested establishing a federal or state prison on Antelope Island in Great Salt Lake, using prisoners to guard the 240 buffalo there. The writer calls the idea more picturesque than practical, but says it would be unfortunate if the herd were allowed to be exterminated.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 December 1920 · page 1

The American bison society’s pro posal of a federal or state prison on Antelope island, in Great Salt lake, for the purpose of furnishing prisoners to guard the herd of 240

See the clipping

The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN

The American Bison Society reports 3,393 wild and tame buffalo in the United States as of January 1920, up from 1,116 in 1908, easing fears of extinction. Government herds at Wichita and Dixon, Montana are thriving, with surplus animals being distributed to public parks; Canada's herd, boosted by the Pablo herd purchase, numbers 5,080.

The Kanabec County Times · 23 December 1920 · page 7

BUFFALO HERDS IN-UNITED) I STATES INCREASE RAPIDLY The American Bison. Society, reports that in January, 1920 there were 3,393. wild and tame buffalo' in the United States. - This encouraging report sets at rest the very real fear that existed not long ago lest the native buffalo, which once roamed the western plains, would soon; become extinct. » , Of the 9 Government owned herds two of the largest under the care of the United States Departanent of Agriculture are located in the Wichi ta national game reserve,. Oklahoma, and on the national bison range at Dixon, MontThe herd on the Wichita reserve now numbers F 54, including 28 calves of this year.

See moreSee less

In this herd 4 bulls and 12. cows are 10 years of age or over and one cow is 29 years old; The 15. animals that constituted the original Wichita herd came from.

See the clipping

The Wolf Point Herald · Wolf Point, Mont.

The Bureau of Biological Survey's report states the National Bison Range near Dixon, Montana holds 332 buffalo, making it the second largest government-owned herd and fourth largest in the U.S. It also describes range improvements, fire threats in 1919, and concerns over grazing and cattle disease risks to the herd.

The Wolf Point Herald · 23 December 1920 · page 5

332 HEAD BUFFALO ON DIXON RESERVE MONTANA HERD NOW SECOND IN SIZE BELONGING TO FEDERAL GOVERNMENT

ERAL GOVERNMENT The federal government has 332 head of buffalo on the national bison range near Dixon, according to the report of the bureau of biological survey, just issued, and which, in part, is as follows: During the past year substantial improvements were made at the Na tional Bison Range, including the construction of a residence for an as

See the clipping

Carthage Courier · Carthage, Tenn.

The article reports that buffalo herds in the United States are increasing rapidly under the care of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. It notes that these herds are located in the national Wichita game preserve.

Carthage Courier · 23 December 1920 · page 3

Buffalo Herds in United j care of the United States Department States TnrrAasinpRnnidlviof Agriculture are located m the rm a .: T : cni-,r - ' Y1CHVII I P TPYV Wichita national game . preserve,

See the clipping

The Logan Republican · Logan, Utah

Senator Smoot and Congressman Welling acknowledged telegrams from the local Chamber of Commerce requesting that Antelope Island be made a national game preserve to protect its roaming herd of over 200 buffalo. Welling introduced a bill in Congress for this purpose, and the American Bison Protective Association has shown strong interest in the effort.

The Logan Republican · 23 December 1920 · page 8

Senator Heed Smoot and Congress man Wolllng have acknowledged re ceipt of telegrams sent by the local Chnmbor ot Commerce asking that Antelope Island bo taken over as a nntlnml game preserve to save tho present buffalo herd which is roam ing over the Island in a wild state. Thin herd numbers over two hundred and if the island were taken over as i antlonal garoo preserve, other game such as antelope and birds, could be placed thero, and tho pre serve would become one of the at tractions of the country: Congress man Welling has Introduced a bill In congress asking that Antelope Is land be made a national game pre serve. Tho American Bison Protec

See the clipping

The Glasgow Courier · Glasgow, Mont.

L.W. Gibson, an early Montana pioneer who died at 74, is remembered for his frontier career that included railroad contracting, buffalo hunting, cattle ranching, and sheep farming. The obituary notes his later success in sheep ranching, oil development, and civic and patriotic contributions to his community.

The Glasgow Courier · 24 December 1920 · page 1

THE PASSING OF A PIONEER

who seenvnl bent < n frontier aHve-dure, , . „ , , . j c h I became buffalo hunters, and finally they freighted overland in 188(i and settled in old Dawson county, where they embarked in the cattle business.

See the clipping

The Bucyrus Evening Telegraph · Bucyrus, Ohio

A government engineer reports finding a long-rumored herd of wild buffalo in the Mackenzie river basin of northern Canada, estimated at 1,000 head, confirming Indian and trapper traditions. The report notes these are among the last truly wild buffalo left on the continent, alongside a small group in Yellowstone and a managed herd at Wainwright park.

The Bucyrus Evening Telegraph · 27 December 1920 · page 6

PHANTOM HERD IS FOUND

Canada hug the largest bison herd in the world in the National park at Wainwright. January 1 it numbered i 4,835, With the exception of DO ani mals that still live in untamed free dom In the northern fastnesses of Yel lowstone park the Mackenzie river herds are the only wild buffalo left n the continent.

See the clipping

The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho

The American Bison Society reports that buffalo herds in the United States are increasing rapidly. The item appears to be cut off by surrounding classified ads before further details are given.

The Caldwell Tribune · 28 December 1920 · page 5

ful precautions art none too careful The proper design of the boxes is one of the factors which makes for safety. In testing boxes, the Madison la boratory employs a standard box-test BUFFALO HERDS IN UNITED STATES INCREASE RAPIDLY. The American Bison Society re

See the clipping

The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho

A government report shows 3,393 wild and tame buffalo in the United States as of January 1920, up 300 percent from 1,116 in 1908, easing fears of extinction. Canada holds a larger herd of 5,080, partly because it purchased the Pablo herd from Montana when American buyers showed insufficient interest.

The Caldwell Tribune · 28 December 1920 · page 5

FRED L. EVANS, 106-107-108c Secretary. ports that in January, 1920, there were 3,393 wild and tame buffalo in the Uni ted States. This encouraging report sets at rest the very real fear that ex isted not long ago lest the native buf falo, which once roamed the western plains, would soon become extinct. Of the nine Government-owned herds, two of the largest under the care of the United States Department of Agriculture are located in the Wichita national game preserve, Okla homa, and on the national bison range at Dixon, Mont.

See moreSee less

The herd on the Wichita preserve now numbers 154, in cluding 28 calves of this year. In this herd four bulls and 12 cows are 10 years of age or over and one cow is 29 years old. The 15 animals that con stituted the original Wichita herd came from the New York Zoological Park. In accordance with the provisions made by the 1919 appropriation bill fof their care, it is planned this year : to dispose of some of the surplus buf falo in the Government herds. Public parks and municipalities are the larg

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A prized herd of 200 buffalo on Antelope Island in Great Salt Lake faces slaughter after sixty kill permits were sold, prompting worldwide protests. Senator Reed Smoot and the National Park Service are considering government action, including possibly making the island a national preserve, to save the descendants of Buffalo Jones's famous herd.

Evening Journal · 29 December 1920 · page 10

FINEST BUFFALO HERD IS PASSING

SALT LAKE CITY. I tah, Dec. 29 - Two tiumlred of the finest specimens of buffalo left in the I nited Stales to day ace In immediate danger of slaughter. They are on Antelop^ isl and in Great Salt Lake, UTah, and It is said ttiat sixty permits have been sold to individuals to kill these animals. They are nearly as wild as the great trampling herds of which they are. survivors. Protests have been received by Utah officials from all over the world against the proposed destruc p. tion of the bison.

See moreSee less

The owners say that they want to = set rid of the buffalo because they and cripple many of the bulls and calves of the ipure-bred beef cattle ./ 'h e Island and also break through fences, destroying hay and forage oropg. Senator Reed Smoot may move.to »ave these animals by special leglsla fjf n . . .. rrammer aetirnr rtlrec l,on A r " 0 .. 0 - L^ammer, aumg ai eo 'lop of national park service, l ni ted Slates Department of the Interior, has become interested In the proposal lhat ^ ie government make the island a nat . rano .„ UI ®}Jt*»h 4V i. I ht l tab herd of buffalo are tbe descendants of some of the famous

See the clipping

Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.

A National Geographic Society bulletin describes Canada's prairie provinces, noting Alberta's prohibition status and other claims to fame. It states that the last wild buffalo herds in America, survivors of the millions that once roamed the continent, now range through northwestern Alberta.

Norwich Bulletin · 30 December 1920 · page 4

IN THE DAY'S NEWS The Prairie PrTlae ( Cmmtt. Imagine the American west of pio neer days "going dryi" It Is a difficult feat And yet the latest regions to adopt pVohibition fe tho three prairie prov inces of Canada-Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Alberta which are to be compared in some ways to such states as Kansas, the Dakotas, on Montana in the late eighties. The National Geographic So ciety describes these most recent re cruits to the prohibition forces in a bul letin issued from its Washington, D. C, headquarters. "The prairie provinces of Cnda Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Albertaare not without their bids to fame.

See moreSee less

For example : Tiie last of tho wild buffalo herds of America, survivors of tho millions of animals which roamed tho viaias and woodlands of the continent now ranges through northwestern Alberta. . 'This province alone lsx estimated' te contain 15 per cent of the world's known

See the clipping

The Williams News · Williams, Ariz.

The American Bison Society reports that fears of the buffalo's extinction, strong not long ago, have eased as numbers increase. Government-owned herds, including two large ones in Oklahoma and Montana, are cited as part of this recovery.

The Williams News · 31 December 1920 · page 1

- The American Bison Society the reports that in January, 1920, received the folWiri, -J--- telegram from Congressman This encoura&ing report sets at Carl Hayden: .. . rest the very real fear that ex- , "President has sighed Bill isted not long ago lest the na extending time for assessment tive buffalo, which once roam work on mining 'claims to July ed the western plains, would first. Notice of intention to soon become extinct. hold claims not required under Of the nine Government-own ed herds, two of the largest un this law.

See the clipping

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

A reader writes to the New York Herald correcting an earlier contributor's claims about Native American weaponry, insisting the lance was a standard tool used in buffalo hunting and warfare. He cites authorities such as Custer, Lewis and Clark, Catlin, and Buffalo Bill biographies to support that spears were common among Plains tribes into the late 1800s.

The New York Herald · 31 December 1920 · page 6

Spears in Peace and War

southern borders ured the spear?lance \ ?with:'great dexterity, and it was their s!i chief weapon In buffalo hunting. j K Tlic groat mounted tribes, among whom were the Kiowas. AVacoes and II Comanches, regarded the lance as one 12 of the Indispensable weapons of their t armament. It Is possible they learned ! its use from the Mexican Clboleros or i buffalo hunters. The Comanches, like I ancient Greeks, measured tlieir courage b>v the shortness of their lances. In

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah

Utah congressmen report little optimism that Congress will fund a national game preserve or purchase the buffalo herd on Antelope Island. A letter from Congressman Welling explains the government already owns many buffalo and is introducing a bill to buy the island and herd, with price details mentioned.

The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 31 December 1920 · page 3

;h buffalo he;-d." ( Congrersman Vr!lllg ask:, as to th 1 minimum price the owners ask for the j Island and the herd of buffalo. m Vow mention." ho adds, "Jl'OO pr , , . head for '"'0 buffalo and $17 to $2i. per acre for 2.V0U0 acres of land. Is 1 that their minimum price': If it J., it ' might as well be understood now that the government would not look at it." Congressman Mays, writes that "I ' feel nlsolutely confident that t:ch 1 I' bill can not be passed at this scs s ..ri of congress, If i?

See moreSee less

can be passed ai all.' He fears that harm mlsht be I done hy .alslng false hopes of govern - . ment action, and adds: , "If this buffalo herd is to be saved. , it If. my Judgment that l"th and I'tah t.o. pic will have to do It." I 00

See the clipping