As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

February 1914

18 articles

The Log Cabin Democrat · Conway, Ark.

A local vaudeville theater advertises a two-reel Western feature film depicting trick roping, ranch life, and footage of the largest buffalo herd in the world alongside wild Texas cattle. The ad is part of a daily entertainment listing alongside comedies and dramas showing that night.

The Log Cabin Democrat · 3 February 1914 · page 1

PARKWAY THEATRE

Trick and Fancy Roping in connection with a two-reel Western Feature, showing the largest herd of Buffalo in the world and also herds of wild Texas cattle. Vaudeville Tonight “Ranch Life” “The Escape” Powers Comedy

See the clipping

Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · Annapolis, Md.

An editorial-style piece speculates on why certain wild animals, including the American bison, were never domesticated despite their usefulness, contrasting them with species like the Indian elephant and domestic fowl. It poses rhetorical questions about missed opportunities in human use of nature, including why buffalo are not bred in larger numbers despite their proven value in the American West.

Evening Capital and Maryland Gazette · 10 February 1914 · page 3

Wild and Tame. An American professor recently : t'de a list of 17 common “weeds” which in his judgment ought to he cultivated for food. This was a mere off-hand Jotting down of facts which occurred to him. not a study of the o bject, but ft shows that man has not nvide very extensive use of the t • ,'Ortunlties which nature affords bun. The learned professor might nave included the animal world as well. Why was not the American bison or buffalo domesticated by Indians? ! Why, w hen he baa proved his value in many parts of the west, is he not

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

Sellers of the Philip buffalo herd, numbering 410 head, report many inquiries for small shipments but are holding out hope of disposing of the whole herd at once. They are negotiating with the Canadian government after failing to get offers from the American government, while also closing deals for carloads to San Francisco and New York.

The Madison Daily Leader · 10 February 1914 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Tabor Independent · Tabor, S.D.

Owners of the famous buffalo herd at Pierre, South Dakota are negotiating with the Canadian government to sell 390 head, while also planning to ship animals to New York and San Francisco. They have numerous requests for smaller purchases but prefer to sell the entire herd at once rather than parcel it out.

The Tabor Independent · 12 February 1914 · page 6

CANADIAN GOVERNMENT MAY BUY BUFFALO HERD Pierre, S. D., Feb. 9.—The owners of the famous buffalo herd at Pierre have negotiations under way with the Can adian government for the disposal of

See the clipping

Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D.

Owners of the well-known buffalo herd at Pierre, South Dakota are in talks with the Canadian government to sell 300 head, while also planning to ship additional animals to New York and San Francisco. They have numerous requests for smaller lots from parks across the U.S. but prefer to sell the herd as a whole to Canada first before considering other offers.

Pierre Weekly Free Press · 12 February 1914 · page 6

CANADIAN GOVERNMENT MAY BUY BUFFALO HERD Pierre, S. D., Feb. 9.—The owners of th^ famous buffalo herd at Pierre have negotiations under way with the Can adian government for the disposal of 300 head, and alBo have plans under way to ship two carloads to Mew York And two carloads to San Francisco. They also have scores of requests for (ftjjr© or/'thrift animals from over the 'dotifitry,' but will not especially consider thewS until the plana for sale to the Canadian government have been settled jcine way or another. They prefer to get fld of ttw .W-hote. hsrl at one time than to parisei If t6' various parks over the Vnlted' States In such small lots.

See the clipping

The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D.

The owners of the famous buffalo herd at Pierre, South Dakota are negotiating with the Canadian government to sell 300 head, and also plan to ship additional animals to New York and San Francisco. They have received many requests for smaller numbers of animals but prefer to sell the entire herd at once rather than parcel it out.

The Citizen-Republican · 12 February 1914 · page 2

CANADIAN GOVERNMENT MAY BUY BUFFALO HERD Pierre. S. D., Feb. 9.—The owners of the famous buffalo herd at Pierre have negotiations under way with the Can adian government for the disposal of

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

The article reflects on how civilization's rapid expansion has transformed the former Wild West of Wyoming and Montana, with railways, farms, and settlers replacing the vast buffalo, antelope, and wapiti herds. It also mourns the decline of the Native American tribes and the disappearance of the authentic cowboy culture, now reduced to imitation by idle youths.

Perrysburg Journal · 13 February 1914 · page 6

HE mnrch o civilization has so rap Idly overrun tho faco of our globo that during recent years many ot theso placoa which wcro formerly llttlo known, oxcopt to aavnges or wandering white hunters, aro to day becoming thickly populated, whllo tho natlvo savago and wild gatno alllco havo disappeared for ever from their ancient haunts. In i few countries Is this moro marked than In tho fa mous Wild West ot America. Tho hardy frontiers men or backwoodsmen of a few decades past would marvel indeed could thoy now seo what onco wcro tho great rolling prairies or denso for ests of Wyoming and Montana. Gono for over nro tho vast herds of buffalo, antolopo and wapiti

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The report says the U.S. government doesn't want the entire Scotty Philip buffalo herd at Fort Pierre, so most of it may be sold to Canada, with only 15 head already purchased for Wind Cave National Park. It also recounts buffalo history in South Dakota, including their disappearance during the Sioux conflicts and the shooting of the last wild buffalo in Potter County.

The Madison Daily Leader · 16 February 1914 · page 2

Some Buffalo History. Gettysburg, Feb. 16 —Because the uited State* government does not want the entire herd of buffalo of tbe Scotty Pbillip'e estate at Fort Pierre,

See the clipping

New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.

After the death of rancher 'Scotty' Philip, his sons are arranging to sell his large buffalo herd of 400 head near Pierre, South Dakota. Some animals have already been sold to the U.S. government for Wind Cave National Park, with the rest possibly headed to Canadian preserves.

New Ulm Review · 18 February 1914 · page 1

'Scotty" Philip's Buffaloes Sold. Many of our residents will no doubt remember the late "Scotty" Philip who was at one time associated with Charles Stuebe in the cattle business. To them it will prove of interest to learn that the famous "Scotty" Philip buffalo herd will "soon be put on the market We clip the following from one of the Review's exchanges: The famous "Scotty" Philip buffalo herd kept in a 10.000 acre pasture near Pierre, 8 D., has been placed on the market by PhilipPhilip aud Geo Philip Jr., sons of and administrators of tbe estate ot the late James ("Scot 1 ty") Philip.

See moreSee less

This herd of buffalo tbe largest in tbe United States, now in cludes 70 head of yearlings, 55 head of 2 year-olds. and 275 head 3 years old and older These are all full bloods, most of them born in captiv-

See the clipping

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

The administrators of the Scotty Philip estate have placed his renowned buffalo herd, the largest in the United States with over 400 head, up for sale. Fifteen animals have already been purchased by the U.S. government for Wind Cave National Park in South Dakota.

The River Press · 18 February 1914 · page 2

Will Sell Buffalo Herd Gettysburg, S. D., Feb. 10.—The famous Scotty Philip herd of buffalo kept in a 10,000-acre pasture near Fort Pierre, has been placed on the market by Philip Philip and George Philip, Jr., administrators of the es tate. The herd, the largest in the United States, includes 70 head of yearlings, 55 head of two-year-olds, and 275 head of three-year-olds and older. They are all full bloods. Fifteen head of the herd have al ready been sold to the United States government, to be sent to the Wind Cave National park, near Hot Springs, South Dakota.

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

The report describes the successful recovery of American bison populations in government-managed reserves, including the Wichita forest reservation where a herd of 15 grew to 48 animals. It also notes the National Bison Range in Montana, Yellowstone's fenced range, and Canada's larger herd at Wainwright, Alberta, exceeding 1000 animals.

The Mirror and Farmer · 19 February 1914 · page 2

All of the bison in the Wichita national herd are strong, perfect animals. They wander in safety over the grassy plains, where they frequent the wallows and trails that their ancestors made 50 years ago. The United States has two other Buf falo parks—the National Bison Range in northwestern Montana, with more than 70 animals, and the fenced-in range in Yel lowstone National Park, with over 140 animals. Canada, however, has the largest fenced-in game preserve and the largest herd of buffaloes in the world. It is sit uated at Wainwright, Alberta, and a year

See the clipping

In the story →

The Tabor Independent · Tabor, S.D. · and 2 other papers

The Scotty Phillip buffalo herd at Fort Pierre is likely to be sold mostly to Canada since the U.S. government only wants part of it, ending the famous herd's presence in South Dakota. The article recounts buffalo history in the region, including the 1883 killing of the last wild buffalo and old tales of boatloads of dried tongues shipped from Chamberlain in 1881.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Tabor Independent · 19 February 1914 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

BUFFALO TONGUE WAS SOLD BY BOAT LOADS NOT MANY YEARS AGO

Reminiscences Brought Out by Effort to Sell Last Great American Herd.

See moreSee less

Gettysburg, S. D., Feb. 16.—Because the United States government does not want the entire herd of buffalo of the Scotty Phillip's estate at Fort Pierre, it is likely that the bulk of the herd will be sold to the Canadian government. This famous herd of buffalo will be lost for all time to the states.

The herd now numbers 70 yearlings, 55 head of 2-year-olds, and 275 head of 3-year-olds and older. Fifteen head have already been sold to the United States government for the Wind Cave National park near Hot Springs, S. D. Carson Williams of Sioux City and John Sloat of Gettysburg are arranging the sale of the buffaloes for the administrators of the estate of Scotty Phillip of Fort Pierre.

Prior to 1876 buffalo were plentiful in South Dakota, particularly near the Missouri river and Black Hills. The Sioux under Sitting Bull, in 1876, went on the warpath and the massacre of Custer at the Little Big Horn followed. The Sioux then became outlaws and wandered north, driving the buffalo before then through North Dakota and Montana. In the summer of 1880, the Sioux surrendered and returned to South Dakota. The buffalo also returned to their native homes.

The only part of the buffalo that hunters used in flush times were the tongue and the hide. A Chamberlain paper, published in 1881, told of a boat that arrived at that city filled with dried buffalo tongues.

The rest of the carcass of the buffalo were left to rot on the prairies. The hides were sold to the traders.

The last wild buffalo was shot by E. F. Gross in Potter county in 1883. Mr. Gross came unexpectedly upon the buffalo and shot it with a horse pistol.

This last large herd of buffalo was organized by a rancher named Dupree living near the Cheyenne river, who captured some of the orphan buffalo calves, their mothers having been killed by hunters. He turned these calves onto his ranch and soon had a large herd of several hundred head. Scotty Phillip later purchased the herd and it has remained on the 13,000 acre ranch near Fort Pierre until now, when it is to be dispersed.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D. · 19 February 1914
  • The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D. · 19 February 1914

Saturday News · Watertown, S.D.

The Scotty Philip buffalo herd, the largest in the United States and kept on a 13,000-acre pasture near Fort Pierre, South Dakota, has been put on the market by the administrators of his estate. The herd includes hundreds of full-blood buffalo of various ages plus some cattle crosses, and those familiar with its history regret its possible breakup, hoping arrangements can be made to keep it intact.

Saturday News · 19 February 1914 · page 4

History of the Buffalo in the Pioneer Days Potcw 'Co. News-Courier: The fam ous ScoUy Phillip herd of buffalo, ,_lsept in a 13,000 acre pasture near Port Pierre, South Dakota, has been placed on the market by the admin prices. istrators of the estate of the late own er. Scatty Phillip This heid of buf falo, tfee largest in the United States, .now includes 70 yearlings. 5C head of lwo-ji.,rol(l8. and 275 liead of three-. year-olds and older. They are all full ani bloods, most of them born in captivity, S""'4 There arte in addition a number oflwho know breeds crossed with the domestic co\y.' herd ls 'The-su.te of the herd is being arruns -|8action' ed by John Sloat of Gettysburg South'dent Dakota, and Mr. Carson Williams ofjunwriUc'n

See the clipping

Saturday News · Watertown, S.D.

The report contrasts Indian hunting methods on horseback with brutal white hunters using heavy .50 caliber rifles that let them slaughter buffalo from a distance, taking only hides and tongues. It then traces the origin of a famous surviving herd from orphaned calves raised by a rancher named Dupree, later purchased by Scotty Philip, which is now being sold and dispersed, including sales to Canada and the U.S. government.

Saturday News · 19 February 1914 · page 4

Chamberlain paper, published in 1881, records the arrival of a hunter from up thft river with a bmnboat filled wlth drled buffalo tongues, for which he found a ready-sale. 'Buffalo hides In «itiy quantity could be bought for ^S0 'j •So far -laat'-wllif'but J! ,ialQ killed east of the .river was one J&lio{.{by''l!VI!\ Gross, in .hotter county, iii 1^3 -"'Mr. Gtioas carina upon the So-Jl^Me^pectediy and killed,- it jSifW pistol. J§ff f'Thfe herd "buffaitf^vhieii i^-tervv $!t'K' jilace1 on market, had its origin sdui'SnsE ttme dk tfee great buttaltj 188,0 and 181A man Dupre%-w^ fanehing on v-WtfeaptjA|s

See the clipping

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · Kadoka, S.D.

The famous Scotty Philip buffalo herd at Fort Pierre, now numbering over 160 head, may be sold to the Canadian government after the U.S. government declined to buy the entire herd, having already purchased only 15 head for Wind Cave National Park. Negotiations are underway between local men and Canadian officials to send the herd to reserves in Alberta, following the earlier precedent of the Pablo herd.

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · 20 February 1914 · page 1

Famous Buffalo Herd May Be Sold to the Canadian Gov’nt Gettysburg. Feb. 14.—Because the United States government does not want the entire herd of buffalo of the

See the clipping

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · Kadoka, S.D.

This article recounts the history of buffalo in South Dakota, including their displacement during Sitting Bull's war and the Custer massacre, and the market hunting era when only tongues and hides were taken. It describes the famous Dupree-Philip herd, started from orphaned calves, now being dispersed from the Fort Pierre ranch.

The Kadoka Press and Kadoka Reporter · 20 February 1914 · page 1

AND KADOKA REPORTER The last wild buffalo w as shot by K. F. Gross in Potter county in 1883. Mr. Gross came unexpectedly upon the buffalo and shot it with a horse pistol. This last larg-s herd of buffalo was organized by a rancher named Dupree living near the Cheyenne river, who captured some of the orphan buffalo calves, their mothers having been killed by merciless hunters. He turn ed these calves into his ranch and soon had a large herd of several hun dred head. Scotty Philip purchased this herd and it has remained oh tin* Id.ooo acre ranch near Fort Pierre until now. when it is to be dispersed, Witli the passing of this herd <f buffalo from South Dakota and niav the 17th amendment.

See the clipping

The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.

Congressman Ed T. Taylor is working to establish a buffalo, elk, and wildlife preserve in Monument Park, with support from the American Bison Society and federal bureaus. Plans involve fencing a canyon and securing a government maintenance appropriation, with Taylor expecting success soon.

The Daily Sentinel · 21 February 1914 · page 4

~ Congressman Ed T. Taylor has ap parentiy found a sclution for the Ivexing problem of locating a num | ber of buffalo, elk and other wild | animals in Monument park. John |Otto has been agitating the matter ‘tor gome time and bhas secured the | cooperation of many influential men | connected with the American Bison | society, the biological survey and oth | cr bureaus of the government. | | It is not prcbable that it will be necessary for a local fund to be rais led to fence in the lower end of one |ef the blind canons in the park and (#n annual maintenace appropriation |for the continuance of the game pre eerve will then be made by the gov

See the clipping

The Copper Era and Morenci Leader · Clifton, Ariz. · and 2 other papers

The U.S. Forest Service's annual report describes increased livestock grazing on national forests despite a less favorable season, crediting improved forage production and management. It also notes the Wichita forest's buffalo herd as a showplace, cooperation stocking elk and trout, and extensive discussion of fraudulent mining and homestead claims used to grab forest land.

The Copper Era and Morenci Leader · 27 February 1914 · page 2

BEST YEAR FOR U.

In connection with the grazing work, the forests serve to protect game; and the Wichita forest, with its buffalo herd, is one of the show places of Oklahoma. During the year the service co-operated With the biological survey In placing over two hundred elk on various national forests. . A large number of streams were, stocked with trout fry .

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Coconino Sun · Flagstaff, Ariz. · 26 December 1913
  • Oxford Democrat · Paris, Me. · 13 January 1914