As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

July 1913

14 articles

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis. · and 2 other papers

A year after the event, Oklahoman Emmert Anderson recounts how his ranch partner helped kill what was called the last wild buffalo cow in South Dakota, a survivor that had run with a cattleman's herd for years. The animal, born of wild buffalo that wandered south about 14 years earlier, evaded capture until hunters finally tracked her down.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

Grant County Herald · 2 July 1913 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

KILL ONLY BUFFALO

Hunters Slay Cow Running With a Stockman's Herd.

See moreSee less

Declared to Be the Last Wild Bison of All the Millions That Once Roamed at Will in South Dakota.

Guthrie, Okla.—"Just about a year ago my ranch partner, Phil Ellison, helped kill the last range buffalo in South Dakota," said Emmert Anderson, a stalwart former Oklahoman, who came here to visit his parents. Anderson and Ellison have a cattle ranch at Rattlesnake Butte, and get their mail at the little postoffice town of Dupree, which is 100 miles northeast of Pierre.

"This buffalo was a cow," said Anderson, "and about fourteen years old. She was a full blood, and the last of millions that once roamed that country. Her presence had been known for a long time, and the cowboys protected her. For the last five or six years she had kept with the herd of a cattle man named Simon Lutz.

"About 14 years ago three wild buffalo came from the north and were seen on the Lutz range. One of the cows dropped a calf, and this calf shortly became the only wild buffalo in that part of South Dakota, as its mother and her two companions were killed by hunters.

"After this cow began going with the Lutz herd, she grew more or less acquainted with Lutz, and would not stampede when he came in sight, though he was never able to get close to her. The moment a stranger appeared, however, the cow broke for the hills and remained in hiding until he disappeared, but she could outrun the fleetest horse, and nobody ever succeeded in roping her.

"About a year ago 'Chuck' Hall, a butcher at Faith, S. D.; Ed Carr, and Phil Ellison outfitted and started after the cow. They got sight of her in a day or two, and gradually drew closer to where she was grazing. Carr stalked her from behind a hill when the wind was favorable. Peering over the ridge, Carr saw the cow not more than a hundred yards distant. His first shot merely wounded her, and she charged viciously upon him. A second shot brought her down. Hall has her head mounted in his butcher shop at Faith.

"On this same hunt, and in the same locality where the buffalo cow was found, these hunters made another kill that added a trophy to their expedition.

"For nine years there had been an 'outlaw' steer of giant size ranging the country. His color was solid white, and he could be seen for miles on a bright, sunshiny day. His horns were of phenomenal size and breadth. He carried the brand of the old Turkey Track ranch, once one of the most widely known outfits in the west, and whose headquarters were far down in the Texas Panhandle, where the battle between buffalo hunters and a big war party of Comanche Indians took place in the early '70s.

"The most persistent effort extending through a period of years failed to get this old steer to the railroad when cattle shipments were made. He would drift in for miles, but seemed to have a kind of uncanny intuition of final danger, and at night would sneak away from the herd and return to his old freedom. Usually a steer will stay with the herd to the end.

"Hall and his companions shot the old fellow and his horns are hanging in the butcher shop at Faith. He had been a moving landmark for years in that part of South Dakota, and, like the buffalo cow, was perhaps the last of his kind, as the old Turkey Track ranch is gone, and cattle no longer are brought up the trail from the Panhandle country to the north."

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Greene County Herald · Leakesville, Miss. · 4 April 1913
  • Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis. · 9 April 1913

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Theodore Roosevelt recounts a rough hunting trip he took with Joe Ferris along the Little Missouri, during which he killed a bison bull. He describes camping without wood, tying horses to saddle horns, and a night stampede that scattered their gear.

The Washington Herald · 6 July 1913 · page 22

hunted bears, both the black and the grizzly, cougars and wolves, and moose. wapiti, and whits goat On one of these trips I killed a bison bull, and I also killed a bison bull on the Little Missouri, some fifty miles south of my ranch, on a trip which "Joe 'Ferris and I took to gether, f , If was rather' a rough? trip. Each of us carried only his slicker behind him on' the saddle,-with some flour and bacon done up In It. We met with all kinds of misadventures. Finally, one night.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This passage recounts a historical journey by Ermatinger and his party through Athabaska Pass and down the Athabaska and Saskatchewan rivers to Winnipeg Lake, describing harsh conditions and abundant game. It notes that the party only killed bull buffalo, contrasting this conservation practice with American hunters who slaughtered buffalo of any age or sex, contributing to their near-extermination.

Evening Star · 6 July 1913 · page 14

The party saw herds of buffalo and shot as many as they needed. It is interesting to learn from Ermatingers faithful jour nal that only bulls were slain. If Ameri i can hunters had been wise enough to pur sue the same policy, these animals would not have been exterminated but on the plains to the southward they were killed by the thousands for their hides and horns no age or sex being spared. Besides the intrinsic interest of Kr matinger's narrative, it derives some eco nomic importance in our day from the project of the Canadian government to build a railroad from the I acllic to Fort York, on Hudson's bay.

See moreSee less

Such a road j would naturally follow the course of the ; Columbia to Athabaska pass and then proceed down the Saskatchewan to Win nipeg lake. Thus Ermatinger's sketchy but entirely reliable observations mUht become the basis of a scientinc survey.

See the clipping

The Liberal Democrat · Liberal, Kan.

The buffalo herd in the Wichita National Forest, begun six years earlier with seventeen animals shipped from the New York Zoological Garden, has grown to forty-two after four calves were born this spring. Officials expect the herd to reach at least forty-five by summer.

The Liberal Democrat · 11 July 1913 · page 10

Wichita Buffalo Herd Increasing. The buffalo herd In .the Wichita Na tional Forest which started six years ago with a shipment of seventeen from the New York Zoo Garden, is rapidly Bearing the half hundred mark. With the addition of four calves this spring, the herd numbers forty-two and there will be an additional Increase yet this spring and summer to raise the number at least above forty-five.

See the clipping

The Lemmon Herald · Lemmon, S.D.

A South Dakota farmer's lucrative steer-raising business is described, with the article noting that the plains once supported countless buffalo herds. Domestic cattle are presented as the natural successors to the vanished buffalo on these same grasslands.

The Lemmon Herald · 11 July 1913 · page 1

The Steer as an Asset

|employed them In their wild condition they supported count less herds of buffalo, of which the domestic cattle of today are -the natural successors. The Charles Mix county stork 'growing farmer is said to be up I to-date in his methods. He is a progressive soil ti'ler. He plants [corn and alfalfa and hay, instead

See the clipping

The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · Edgerton, Wis.

A traveling Wild West circus advertisement claims the American Indian and the American bison are both fast disappearing into extinction, urging readers to see 'the last of the buffalo' at its Edgerton show. The ad frames both peoples and animals as doomed relics of a vanishing frontier era, using extinction as a marketing draw.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 11 July 1913 · page 5

Old West Fast Disappearing. The American Indian will soon exist only in history. His extermination has been gradual but will be sure. He has gradually been driven from his happy home in the east to a few barren reser vations in the west, where, by amalga mation. dissipation or separation he is fast becoming extinct With Kit Carson’s Buffalo Ranch Big Three-Ring Wild West Circus there are some of the most noted of the dif ferent tribes of Indians as well as the largest herd and most magnificent specimens of buffalo in existence to day.

See moreSee less

The American bison is now one of the rarest and most expensive of animals and it will pay you to visit this world famous attraction if for nothing but to see the last of the buffalo. Will exhibit one day only, afternoon and night, at Edgerton on Tuesday, July 15.

See the clipping

The Chronicle=news · Trinidad, Colo.

A veteran buffalo hunter, testifying in a shooting case, is also asked about an earlier adventure when his party of twenty-one hunters was besieged by about 1,000 Indian warriors in a Texas Panhandle hunting camp. He describes being trapped in two stores and a saloon from late June until July 12, enduring daily attacks.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Chronicle=news · 15 July 1913 · page 6

.7. t ! huffxto hunters, fie said: “These twenty-one buffalo hunter* were distributed In three buildings. I '• t

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The American Bison Society's sixth annual report shows bison are increasing rather than declining, with 1,651 captive in the U.S. and 1,303 in Canada. The society plans to establish new state and municipal herds in regions where bison are no longer found.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Grant County Herald, 2 July 1913, The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter, 11 July 1913.

Evening Star · 17 July 1913 · page 20

BISON, LORD OF PLAINS, INCREASING IN NUMBERS Society Seeking Preservation Hopes to Scatter Herds Over Country. The American bison, lord of the west ern plains in years gone by, is not de creasing in numbers, as is the popular conception, but is increasing. This is shown in the sixth annual report of the American Bison Society, the organization which is responsible for this condition. The report has just been made public and contains much valuable and interest ing information. The fact is made known in the report that there are many people in the United States, especially children, who have nev er seen any specimens of the great Amer ican animal.

See moreSee less

In eleven southern states as well as in several states in the north west and on the Pacific coast there are no specimens of the animal. To rectify this condition the society in tends making earnest efforts toward the creation of state herds of bison in differ ent states and also toward the establish ment of municipal herds. New York and Missouri are expected to establish state herds, and Atlanta. Ga., and Memphis, Tenn., are considering founding city herds, according to the report. Animals in United States. At present there are captive in the United States 1,651 bison of pure blood, and 1,303 captive in Canada. In 1912 there were 1,288 captive in the United States, in 1911 there were 1,331, in 1910 there were 1,007, and in 1908 there were only 909. In l!t03 there were only 41 captive bison in Canada. In all North America there are at pres ent 2,954 bisoj. in captivity, and 4i?l> wild ones, making a total of 3.453 pure-blood ed bison in North America. The total shows a steady increase from year to year. Most of the specimens are scattered over the country in small herds, the largest herd of bis? n in captivity being the one at Fort Pierre, S. Dak., number ing 345. The District is credited with six males, seven females and an "infant" born in 1912. In some parks there is only one bison. New Game Preserve. A large part of the report is taken up with discussions of the project for estab lishing a new herd at the Wind Cave na tlnonal preserve, in South Dakota. In 1912 the society recommended to the gov ernment that land adjoining the park be acquired as a bison park and wild game preserve, and Congress appropriat ed $20?*K> for this purpose. The land has now been l*>ught, and the society is to provide a herd of at least fifteen bison to stock it. The New York Zoological Society has already offered to give ten animais for this project, and five are to be given by another organ.zation. Prof. Franklin W. Hooper is president i of the American Bison Society, Prof. Henry Fairfield Osborn and Dr. John C. Phillips are vice presidents, William P. Wharton is secretary and Clark Williams is treasurer. in Saturday Accommodation Train Service, W. S. Ry. Commencing July 19, Saturday accom modation train will leave Washington for local stations to Fredericksburg inclu I sive at 2 p.m. instead of 10:55 a.m. as on other week " s. This train will not run between Fredericksburg and Milford

See the clipping

The Chickasha Daily Express · Chickasha, Indian Territory Okla.

The buffalo herd in Wichita National Forest, started six years earlier with seventeen animals from the New York Zoo, has grown to forty-two after four new calves this spring. More calves are expected, potentially raising the total above forty-five by summer.

The Chickasha Daily Express · 19 July 1913 · page 8

Wichita Buffalo Herd Increasing, The buffalo herd in the Wichita Na tional Forest which started six years ro with a shipment of seventeen from the New York Zoo Gnrdn, is rapidly neariue the hsif hundred mark. With the addition of four calves this spring, the herd numbers forty-two and there will be an additional lucres vet this spring and summer to raise tha number at least abov forty-flva.

See the clipping

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · Lakeland, Fla.

The sixth annual report of the American Bison Society reveals that, contrary to popular belief, the American bison population is increasing rather than declining. The report cites rising captive bison numbers in the US and Canada from 1903 to 1913 and outlines plans to establish new state and municipal herds.

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · 23 July 1913 · page 1

a: OF BISON IN Washington, July . 23 .The American bison, lord of the western . plains in years gone by, is not de creasing in numbers, as is the pop ular conception, but is Increasing. f This is shown in the sixth annual 1 report of the American Bison So-. ciety, the organization which is responsible for this condition . The report has Just been made public and contains much valuable and interesting Information. ' The fact is made known in the ' report that there are many people,' in the United States,, especially children, who have never seen any specimens of the reat American , animal.

See moreSee less

In elecen southern states as f weljl aa in several States in the northwest and on the Pacific coast there are no specimens of the anl- ' mal. To rectify this condition the so- ' citjr intends making earnest ef- ' foi ls" toward the creation of State " herds of bison in different States ' and also toward the establishment of municipal herds. New York an4 Missouri are expected to establish) t State herds, and Atlanta, Ga., and, ; Memphis. Tenn., are considering : founding city herds, according to the report. , At present there are captive in the United StateB 1,651 bison ot pure blood, and 1,303 captive in Canada 'In 1912 there were 1,288 captive in the United States, ia 1911 there were 1,?31," in 191(T " there were 1,007, and in 1903 there k were only 969. In 1903 there were ; only 41 captive bison in Canada. In all North America there are at present 2,954 bison in eantlvlt and 499 wild ones, making a total or d,453 pure-blooded bison in North America.. The total shows a steady increase from year to year. Most of the specimens arc scat tered over the country in small herd the largest herd of bison In captivity being the one at Port

See the clipping

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · Lakeland, Fla.

The American Bison Society's report shows captive bison in the US and Canada have risen steadily from under 1,000 in 1903 to over 2,900 by 1913, with scattered herds across the country. The report also discusses plans for new state and municipal herds and a project to stock the Wind Cave National Preserve in South Dakota with bison donated by the society.

The Lakeland Evening Telegram · 23 July 1913 · page 1

Pierre, S. Dak., numbering 345.. The District of Columbia is credited vflth six males and seven femalee and an "infant" born in 1912. In, some parks there Is only one bison. A large part of the report is tak en up with discussion of the pro ject for establishing a new herd at the Wind Cave national preserve in South Dakota. In 1912 the sol clety recommended to the govern ment that land adjoining the park be acquired as a bison park-and wild game preserve, and Congresn appropriated $26,000 for this pur pose. The land has been bought, and the society is to provide a herd of at least fifteen bison to stock clet has already offered to give ten ; animals for this pr0jec n l!

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A report relays news from explorer Harry V. Radford, who discovered a wild bison herd in Canada's Great Slave Lake region and sent a skeleton specimen from it. Radford, having adopted Eskimo dress, intends to continue his explorations in the north until 1915, with the update coming via a whaling outfit worker who brought the first authentic word from him in years.

The Washington Herald · 28 July 1913 · page 3

RARE SPECIMEN

Who Ditcorered Animals, Contmaes Exploration. Edmonton, Alta., July IT Harry V. Radford, the American explorer, who dlBCovered a large herd of wild bison in the Great Slave Lake District of the Hudson Bay county recently sent a note to the outpost on Herschel Island telling the factor in charge of the trading station that he in tended to work farther north and prob ably would remain, in the country until 1313 He has adopted the dress of .the Eskimos and will lie with them the latter part of his stay. Howard Allen, who is interested in two whaling outfits which go out from Herschel ever jear, and who has passed tne last lour ears on the Arctic Coast, brought the foregoing news to Edmon ton esterday This Is the first authentic word received o-i the outside in several J ears from the explorer who has been In the North four jears.

See moreSee less

making a special studj of animal life.

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report recounts explorer Radford's expedition to the Barren Lands to study the wood bison, noting he was last confirmed alive and continuing research after earlier rumors he had lost his mind. It also credits naturalist Samuel Rhoads with scientifically establishing wood buffalo as distinct from plains buffalo, with specimens now held at the Smithsonian and Edmonton museums.

The Washington Herald · 28 July 1913 · page 3

w me ouisiae worm Radford, who Is widely known in sci entific circles, had as the obect of his expedition to isit the home of the wood bison In the almost unknown region of .-orinweslern Canada, west of the Slae River and north of the lower Peace River This expedition started In 1303 ana lias included track survejs over mam hundreds of miles, and furnished Radford the opportunity of cloelv cturiiing the wood bison In Its haunts and or making the first recorded observations of this rare animal in life Spcolmm for Smithsonian.

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The article recounts how naturalist Samuel Nicholson Rhoads established in an 1897 paper that the Canadian wood buffalo was a distinct variety from the American plains bison. It notes that Dr. William Hornaday had earlier disputed this classification before later evidence confirmed Rhoads's findings.

The Washington Herald · 28 July 1913 · page 3

partment of mammals of the L nited States National Museum, and one of the world's greatest authorities savs that n existence of wood buffalo belongs to Samuel Nicholson Rhoadb. a life member! of the Academj of Natural sciences, o PhilTdelphla. who has collected museun s-pecimens of natural historj in evfy State of the Union, Canada. British o lumbla, Mexico, and South America, f IH.ons Are Differis ' In a paper prepared It the Philadel phia Academv of Natural Sciences, in JS37. Rhoads gave the results of his ex tended search through all literature touching on the subject, and also gave the results of his examinitions of a specimen of the Canadian wood bison This description convinced him and most scientific men.

See moreSee less

that the wood bison and the American prairie bion are of dif ferent varieties The records of the department of mimmals of the National Museum show that Dr. William T Hornaday. director of the New York Zoological Park, in his mono graph on the American bison, written in 1SSJ. while he was chief taxidermist of the National Museum at Washington, re fused to assent to the claim that the wood bison belonged to a different race from the American prairie bison At that time Dr Hornadav had never seen a wood bison, and. In the absence of facts based on personal observation, he contended there was not the slightest

See the clipping