As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

September 1896

11 articles

Crawford Avalanche · Grayling, Mich.

The article recounts how millions of buffalo once covered the American plains, citing historical observers like Boone and Filson, and notes that fewer than 1,000 now survive after mass killing. It frames the decline as a shift from contempt to belated value once scarcity raised prices for hides and skeletons.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Highland Recorder, 21 August 1896, Freeland Tribune, 24 August 1896.

Crawford Avalanche · 3 September 1896 · page 8

UNPRECEDENTED CLAUCHTtR OF THIS AMERICAN ANIMAL, Upward of 6,000,000 in an lnerdlbly Short Space of Tim. Not Over 1,000 Now Runninf Wild in North America, William T. Horunday. the Superin tendent of the National Zoological Fark, at Wajhlngtou.. a student and banter of tbe buffalo In the old days, has -Interested himself In the. question of preventing their extermination, and baa done what he could to bring the matter to tbe attention of Congress. Unfortunately, all attempt at legis lation for tbe protection of this animal bare been In vnln, and tbe result la that upward of il.OOO.ixw were slaugh tered in an Incredibly short space of time cnrly 4.000.000 killed In three years until now there are not oyer 1,000 of these animals running wild In North America.

See moreSee less

Such a wanton des truction of a valuable beast, purely and distinctively American in Its char acter, is unprecedented in tbe history of the world. The familiarity of the Americans with the buffalo seems to have bred contempt, for the great number of these animals Ikis led the people to think of them as animals which were valuable cidy for what their skins would brlugMu tbe market. Hut owing to tbe vast destruction of the herds, and tbe fact that the reduced number has Increased the price of the skins and the other products, there has come a revulsion of popular sentiment In re gard to them, and they hare become very valuable In the eyes of the gener al public, and, it Is needles to say, in the eyes of those surviving among the old hunters who can now get large sums of money for the robes and skel etons. Of all the qnadruicds that have lived upon the earth, Mr. Horunday says that probably no other siecles has ever mar shaled such innumerable hosts as those of the Amcricau bison. It would have been as easy to count or to estimate the number of leaves In the forest as to 'calculate the numler of buffaloes living at any given time during the history of the upecics up to 1870. Even In South Central Africa, which has al ways leen so prolific in great herds of game. It Is probable that all of its quadrupeds taken together on on equal area would never have more than equaled the total numler of buffaloes In this country forty or fifty years ago. To the African hunter such a statement might seem incredible, but Mr. Ilorna day says that it Is fully warranted by the literature of both branches of the snbjeet. Mr. John Fllson, in 1784, wrote of the Blue Licks In Kentucky: "The amazing herds of buffalo which resort thither by their size and number fill the traveler with astonishment and terror, especially when he beholds the prodigious roads they have made from all quarters, us If leading to some popu lous city." In 1770, where Nashville now stands, were immense numbers of buffaloes and other wild game. The country was black with them. Daniel Boone found vast herds of buffaloes grazing In the valleys of East Tennes see, between the spurs of the Cumler land Mountains. Between the Rocky Mountains and the States lying along the Misslssipppl Kiver and the west from Minnesota to Louisiana, tbe whole country was one vast buffalo range, Inhabited by millions of buffa loes. A volume could be filled with the records of plainsmen and pioneers who penetrated that vast region in the early part of the century, and who were us m tounded by the number of buffaloes they observed. Col. Dodge described a herd which he ciw on the Arkansas River. According to his recorded ob servation, the herd extended along the river for a distance of twenty-five miles, which was In reality the width of the vast procession that was moving north and back from the road as far as the eye could reach on both sides. At a low estimate, the ground visible from the road where Col. Dodge was driving, which was covered by the herd, extend ed for a mile. This would give a strip of country two miles wide and twenty five long, or a total of fifty square miles covered with buffaloes, averaging, at Oal. Dodge's estimate, from fifteen to twenty to the acre. By the lesser num ber, fifteen, It is found that the num ber actually seen on that day by Col. ,Dodge was In the neighborhood of 480, ;,000. If the advancing herd had In-en at points fifty miles In length, as It was known to have leen In some places, 'by twenty-five miles in width, and still 'averaging fifteen head to the acre, It ' would have contained the enormous number of 12,000,000 head, but, Judg ing from tbe principles which governed their periodical migrations, the moving mass probably advanced In tbe shape , of a wedge, w hich would leave about 4,000,000 ns a fair estimate of the ac tual numlHr'of buffaloes In the great southern herd. It Is no wonder, there fore, that the men of the West of those days, both white and red, thought It would be impossible to exterminate sucn a mignry rruirituue. me Indians of some tribes lx lleved that the buffa loes Issucl from the earth continually, and that the supply was Inexhaustible; and yet, In four years that southern herd was almost totally extinct. "With such a lesson lefore our eyes," said Air. jiomnuay, "connrmeci in every de tail by living testimony, who will dare to say that there will be an elk, a moose, caribou, mountain goat, moun tain sheep, antelope, or black-tall deer left alive In the United States In a wild state fifty years from this date, or even twenty-five?" If In the earlier days before the buffalo's almost complete extermina tion, the people bad realized the Im mense money value of the great herd as it existed In 1870, tbe slaughter could probably have been stopped. At that time, 500,000 head of bulls, young and old, could have been killed every year for a score of years without appreciably diminishing the size of tbe herd. At Mr, Hornaday's estimate these could easily hare leen made to yield various products, worth $3 each, as follows: Robe, $2.50; tongue, 23 cents; meat of hind quarters, $2; bones, horns, and hoofs, 23 cents; total, $3. And tbe amount annually added to ttie wealth of the UriteJ CUtes wocU tars been not less than 0,000 on all the robes taken for the market, say 200,000. The Government could have collected a tax of 30 cents each, which would have yielded a sum doubly sufficient to have maintained a force of mounted police fully coroietent to enforce tbe laws regulating tbe slaughter. Tbe American people, it seems, have not yet learned to spend money for the protection of valuable game, and by tbe time they have learned It, there will be no game to protect. Even despite the enormous waste of raw material that has been shown In the utilization of the buffalo product, tbe total cash value of all material derived from this source. If It could only be reckoned up would certainly amount to many mill Ions of dollars, perhaps 2O,000,000 nj told. New York Times.

See the clipping

The Opelousas Courier · Opelousas, La.

A Texas rancher interviewed in Pittsburgh dismisses reports of buffalo extinction, claiming bison are being successfully ranched in Montana and Texas, including crossbreeding experiments with Angus cattle. He cites cattleman Goodnight's 2,000,000-acre ranch breeding pure bison stock and selling animals to zoos and show people.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Opelousas Courier · 5 September 1896 · page 3

union. "Goodnight, the greatest Texas cat tleman, has fully 2,000,000 acres of ground ranched in, and is breeding the bison pure. He has fenced off a big tract of land, and is well satisfied that he will make a success of his new enterprise. He has already sold many animals of his own raising to show people and to zoos in several places. Goodnight, too, has a herd of elk, but they are not profitable. There is lit tle or no sale for them. For meat purposes the buffalo is not in it.

See moreSee less

The tongue makes good eating and por tions of the hindquarters, but the rest of the carcass is worth little for eat ing. It would make mighty good phosphate, though. "I have sent a lot of cattle on to New York. My partner is in charge. We will get but four cents per pound or $4 per hundred, while parties in Texas who herd cattle to Galveston and ship to England get eleven cents per pound."-Pittsburg Dispatch.

See the clipping

Democratic Northwest and Henry County News · Napoleon, Ohio · and 1 other paper

A writer reminisces about a journey through Winnipeg and the Canadian prairies, recalling accounts of spring floods on the Red River that drowned thousands of buffalo and left their carcasses along the banks. He muses whether similar flood events might explain the mammoth remains found along Siberian rivers.

Democratic Northwest and Henry County News · 10 September 1896 · page 6

drods, nay, in thousands, and X connect ed this in my mind with what I had read of the vast amount of mammoth ivory and skeletons of elephants found at the mouths of the giant rivers of Si beria. Was it not possible that the de posits of extinct mammals owed their origin to like causes? May not herds of elephants as numerous as the nerds of our American bison have grazed in

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass. · 3 January 1890

The Free Press · Poplarville, Miss.

The article reports that over 6,000,000 buffalo were slaughtered in an incredibly short time, with nearly 4,000,000 killed in just three years, leaving fewer than 1,000 running wild in North America. It credits William T. Hornaday with trying to alert Congress to prevent the species' extermination, though legislative efforts had failed.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Free Press · 10 September 1896 · page 1

UNPRECEDENTED SLAUCHTER OF THIS AMERICAN ANIMAL. Upward of 6,000,000 in an Incredibly Short Space of Time. Not Over 1,000 Now Running Wild in North America. William T. Hornaday, the Superin- | teudeut of the National Zoological Park, ut Washington, a student and hunter of the buffalo in the old days, has Interested himself In the question of preventing their extermination, and has done what he could to bring the j matter to the attention of Congress. Unfortunately, all attempts at legis lation for the protection of this animal have been in vain, and the result is that upward of B.OOO.tKHl were slaugh tered In an Incredibly short space of time—nearly 4.000,000 killed in three years—until now there are not over 1,000 of these animals running wild in

See the clipping

The Free Press · Poplarville, Miss.

This report recounts William Hornaday's calculations estimating the great southern buffalo herd at roughly 1,000,000 animals, despite higher theoretical counts from density and area figures, and notes it was nearly wiped out within four years. It also reflects on the lost economic value of sustainable buffalo harvesting and warns that other American wildlife species face similar extinction without protective measures.

The Free Press · 10 September 1896 · page 1

The Iron mines of the Island of Elba appear to have been worked uninter ruptedly for at least 3,000 years; loeal tradition says 4,000. According to this tradition the people of Syracuse were the first to work the mines. Later, as we know, the ancient Etruscans used them, and after that the Romans. They still nppear inexhaustible to us, as they did to Virgil (Aeneid X., 173). Up to 1754 the amount of ore exca vated annually is estimated at 4,000 tons. From that date until 1851 it Is said to have been about 14,000 tons; from 1851 to 1881 about 130,000 tons, In 1881 400.000 tons were taken out.

See moreSee less

The government, fearing that at this rate the ore would soon be exhausted, fixed the annual maximum at 180,000 tons, at which it still remains. The ore is of the highest quality, but the methods of extraction used are still very primitive. Hawaiian Huckleberries, Near the Volcanic House on the isla. of Hawaii arc great thickets of the obclo, or Hawaiian huckleberry,says the Popular Science Monthly, which the natives con sider sacred to I'ele. the goddess who is supposed to preside over the famous crater of Kilauca, and which, together with white pig9 and chickens, are thrown by them into the boilim red lake durin' an eruption to appease the wrath of the aggressive dame and thus cause the river3 of lava to cease flowing on their destruct ive course. These berries grow in clusters on low bushes right on the very brink of the brimstone beds, and are so numerous that t a bushel may be easily gathered in half an hour. In appearance ihey somewhat resemble a cranberry, and the flavor is nleaaaatlv suggestive ef grapes and yet, in four years that southern herd was almost totally extinct. "With such a lesson before our eyes," said Mr. Hornaday, "eontirmed in every de tail by living testimony, who will dafe to say that there will be an elk, a moose, caribou, mountain goat, moun tain sheep, antelope, or black-tail deer left alive in the T’nited States in a wild state fifty years from this date, or even twenty-fitfV” If in the earlier days l>efore the buffalo’s almost complete extermina tion, the people had realized the Im mense money value of the great herd as it existed in 1870, the slaughter could probably have been stopped. At that time, 500,000 head of bulls, young and old, could have been killed every year for a score of years without appreciably diminishing the size of the herd. At Mr. Hornaday’s estimate

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The article recounts the extinction of the great auk, noting its high market value for remains, before turning to the American bison's rapid decline. It traces the buffalo's range contraction from coast-to-coast to isolated small herds in Yellowstone, Montana, and Canada by the early 1880s due to massive slaughters.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 18 September 1896 · page 6

for $1,500. Every one knows of the frightfully rapid extinction of the American bison or buffalo in this country. This, ac cording to American scientists, is the saddest of all cases of the extinction of species. The wild buffalo is practically gone forever, and in a few more years, as Professor Hornaday, the superinten dent of the National Zoological Park, has said, "when the whitened bones of the last bleaching skeleton shall have been picked up and shipped east for commercial uses, nothing will remain of him save his old well-worn trails along the water courses, a few muse um specimens, and regret for his fate." The area once inhabited by the Ameri can bison extended almost from the

See the clipping

New York Journal · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the rise of private hunting and fishing preserves among wealthy Americans, starting with the Kildave Club in 1887 and expanding to over sixty estates covering 1.2 million acres by 1896. It details specific preserves like Austin Corbin's New Hampshire ranch with buffalo, Dr. Seward Webb's Nehasane Park with moose and elk, and George Gould's Furlough Lodge with elk and deer.

New York Journal · 20 September 1896 · page 47

THEIR FAD.

The elk and deer placed there did not thrive, however, and boon began to die. His eon, Austin Corbin, J ft, told his father what they needed was a larger range in a rough mountainous country, and he suggested taking the remainder of the herd to New port, N. H., his father's native place. This suggestion was adopted, and as a result there are to-day over<jl,000 animals of vari ous kinds, including a big herd of buffalo,

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

A country-news column from Windsor and Mt. Pleasant reports local happenings, including that Frank Balch shipped a car load of buffalo bones to Chicago the previous week. This brief mention reflects the post-slaughter bone-collecting trade that followed the destruction of the great herds.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 24 September 1896 · page 8

WINDSOR AND MT. PLEASANT

Buffalo bones to Chicago last week. MONTPElilER. Miss Alice Hodge returned to her school Monday last. She has been spending a oouple of weeks in the Twin

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

The article describes the rapid disappearance of the American buffalo from the North American continent, noting it is the last of three bison varieties worldwide. It discusses the species' former range, its peaceful nature despite a fighting reputation, and mentions a new breeding ground established at Adrian, Michigan, as well as the Smithsonian's efforts to preserve specimens.

Freeland Tribune · 24 September 1896 · page 4

L&w\ys can continent is V* the rapid disap penrance of tin fylW buffalo,which erst while roamed ovei vast ranges of territory in almost count less herds and in absolutely countless numbers. The American bison, more popularly and commonly termed the buffalo, is the last of three varieties of this peculiar species of the ox family. The first was the Eur-Asiatic variety, uhich in the days of Komulus and Heinus roamed through the forests of (Saul and Gerniania, now, like its Amer ican cousin, nearly extinct, being-found very rarely in the forests of Lithuania. The second of the species is the Indian bison, frequenting the wooded ranges <>f the Himalayas; and tlie third, the short-necked, broad-breasted, hairy shouldered with whose appear*

See the clipping

The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.

Henri Menier, the Paris chocolate magnate who now owns Anticosti Island, has decided to rebuild the nearly extinct American bison by purchasing a captive cow and seeking more buffalo from remaining private herds. He plans to release them on his island, where hunting is impossible, fearing the Yellowstone herd will vanish without better state protection, and also sees commercial promise in the venture.

The Star · 30 September 1896 · page 6

Saving the Bison. The reproduction on a large scale of the all but extinot American bison or buffalo of the plains has been de cided upon by Mr. Henri Menier, the millionaire chocolate manufacturer of Paris and new proprietor of the Island of Antioosti. He has purchased a young buffalo oow, whioh was for some time kept in captivity by a Qaebeo dealer in furs, and his agents are now in correspondence with the proprietors of the few remaining prU vate herds of this noble animal, with a view to the purchase of as many as possible of thorn for breeding pur poses.

See moreSee less

The intention is to ship them this autumn to Antotoosti, where they will be turned loose npon the island, and be per nutted to roam at will throughout its night I recoived a shock. It was in tensely dark in the shadows of the trees, and as I sat at the root of a big oak some white object glidod swiftly and noiselessly just above tho centro of the road. It made the cold chills run over me, though I have no pa tience with those who toll of visits or communications with the departed. "I was determined to enlighten myself and seonred a good saddle horse as companion of my vigils. The second night the 'ghost' flow by and I galloped in its wake at all tho speed my horse could command. A mile ahead the 'appnrition' swerved to the right of the road and ended our mad race. Tying my horse in a fence corner I crept nearer. Slowcly I made out that tho'ghost' was a woman of stately proportions wearing a dain tily milled night robe. She leaned for a brief time over the hollow stump that had been her evident destination nnd then turning mounted her flying machine, which was a modern bicycle, aud went scorching back over tho conrno she had come. Again I fol $10 apiece. lowed and did not atop uutil I saw her disappear iu tho side door of the Penzil house. Hastening back to tho hollow stump I explored the interior." "And found tho stolen property, of course," interrupted a listener. "Not a sign of it I could discover nothing that did not naturally belong there. Failing to find tho thief in tho

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

A former cowboy and Colorado legislator, dining in Washington, tells a tale of a buffalo bull that fought off two Sioux hunters on horseback while surveying crews for the Union Pacific railway watched. The bull, wounded by arrows, charges the wagon carrying the narrator and his party, creating a moment of terror as the driver fails to react.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 30 September 1896 · page 2

Iriving across the country and makj ng observations. A couple of Sioux fell in with our party and were riding ilong looking for a chance to steal something, when we came suddenly ( lpon a small herd of buffalo. The rear guard, a sturdy old bull, was feed- . ng along in a sag between the sand ' lills, and, the wind blowing from him bo us, prevented him from scenting >ur party until the two Indians dashed by, cutting him off from the main herd. Lowering his head the great brnte bounded away up the little hill, it tlie top ot wmcn ine iwo oioux sai waiting to receive him. Each of the

See the clipping