As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

June 1876

1 article

The Arizona Sentinel · Arizona City Yuma, Ariz.

A Kansas City Times report corrects an earlier telegraph dispatch that claimed vigilantes hanged two horse thieves near Fort Dodge. Investigation by the father of one victim revealed that Calahan, a buffalo bone gatherer, was innocent and had only given shelter to the actual thief before both were hanged together.

The Arizona Sentinel · 17 June 1876 · page 2

An Innocent Man Hanged. From the Kansas City TimeB. A few day 8 ago the Times pub lished a brief teleeranh in dpsnatnh from Dodge City, Kansas, anuuuucing mat a hand of vigilantes had hanged two men near Fort Dodge for stealing horses in Sum mer county, Kansas. Subsequent inquiries.made by the grief-stricken father of one of the men hang eda young man named Calahan, son of a preacher in Topeka proved beyond a doubt that Cala han was guiltless of any connec tion with the crime. He was eng gaged in Catherine buffalo bones on the plains, and had been haul ing someirom his "augouc" to the railroad, when one of the horse thieves came to his place.

See moreSee less

He gave him shelter. While he was there the vigilantes from Summer county came up and ar rested both parties, and notwith standing Calahan's protestations and his endeavor to show that he lived there and had not been to Summer county, took him with the guilty man and hanged him then and there. The Rev. Mr. Calahan says that his murdered son was in no way implicated in this crime.

See the clipping