As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

May 1876

6 articles

The Morning Herald · Wilmington, Del.

The Kansas City Times reports that a vigilante hanging near Fort Dodge, Kansas, earlier described as the lynching of two horse thieves, actually included an innocent man named Calahan, a preacher's son who gathered buffalo bones for a living. Investigation by his grieving father showed Calahan had merely sheltered a horse thief and had no part in the crime, yet was hanged alongside him despite his protests.

The Morning Herald · 9 May 1876 · page 3

An Innocent Man Hanged. [From tlie Kansas City Times.) A few days ago the Times published a briuf telegraphic despatch from Dodge City, Kau., announcing that a band of vigilantes had hanged two men near Fort Dodge for stealing horses iu Sumner county, Kansas. Subsequent inquiries made by the grief stricken father of one of the men banged—a young man named Calahan,sonof a preach er in Topeka—proved beyond a doubt that Caialian was guiltless of any connection with the crime. He was engaged In gath ering buffalo bones on the plains, and had been hauling some from his "dug-out" to t he railroad when one of tho horse thieves to his place.

See moreSee less

lie gave him shelter. 'lime While he was there the vigilantes from Sumner county camo up and arrested both parties, and notwithstanding Caiahan's pro lestutions and his endeavor to show that lie lived there and had not been to Sumner county, took him with the guilty man and hanged him then and there. The Kev. Mr. Caialian says that his murdered son was in no way implicated in this crime.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An earlier dispatch reported vigilantes had hanged two horse thieves near Rock Ridge, Kansas, but investigation by a grieving father revealed one of the men, Calahan, was innocent. Calahan had merely given shelter to an actual horse thief while himself engaged in gathering buffalo bones on the plains, yet was hanged alongside the guilty man despite his protests.

Evening Star · 9 May 1876 · page 1

AN INNOCENT MAN HANGED

Y. World, Hh. Ah Iitkoc*j?t Ma* Hairio ?A few days ago the Tunea published a orW tele graphic dispatch trom 1)oiU;? City. Kanaas. announcing that a baud or vlgiiants bad bangrrt two men near Ko<*t l?lge for steal ing horses in Sumner county. Kanaas. Hnb seqnent inquiry, made by the grief-stricken rather of one of the men banged?a young man named Ca!sban, son of a preacher in Tope as?proved beyond a doubt that Cala han was guiltless of any connection with the crime. He wax engaged in gathering buffalo bones on the plains, and nad been hauling some from his "dug-out" to tbe rail road when one of the horse-thieves earn* to his place.

See moreSee less

Ht gave him shelter. While be was there the vigilant* from Sumner county came up and arrested both parties, and, not withstanding calahan's protests li oos ac t hia endeavor to sbow ibat bs lived there aod bad not been to Bumner county, took htm with the guilty man and hanged blm than aad there. The Rev. Mr Calahan says tba< bis murdered son was In no way iatp Ilea let In this crtaas (A'aasaa City ? ~

See the clipping

The Bossier Banner · Bellevue, La.

A report describes how the Wilcox Tanning Company in Pennsylvania received 120,000 bull-buffalo hides in the spring of 1875, taken over just a few months. It estimates the total number of buffalo killed in that period at half a million, with bullets recovered from the hides to be displayed at the Centennial exhibition.

The Bossier Banner · 25 May 1876 · page 4

Some idea of the extent to which the extermination of the buffalo is going on at the present time may be learned from the fact that the Wilcox Tanning Com pany, of Elk County, Pennsylvania, said to be the largest of the kind in the world, and which is especially engaged in tanning buffalo skins, received m the spring of 1875 120,000 bull-buffalo hides. These were all taken within a few

See the clipping

The Pulaski Citizen · Pulaski, Tenn.

The report notes that seven railroad cars loaded with buffalo bones arrived in New York, to be made into buttons and knife-handles. It cites this as evidence of the immense ongoing slaughter of buffalo on the plains, which is rapidly driving the species toward total extinction.

The Pulaski Citizen · 25 May 1876 · page 1

When you see a particularly hap py merchant in town man who is always contented, cheer fid, and walks -along snapping his fingers, and smiling benignantly on passing acquaintances, and never stopping to kick a dog oil the sidewalk ust you look in the local paper. and you will find that his auveriscmeut is the bitrest in the heet. rotensviIl Dtmocrc.1. Some idea of the immense slaughter of buffaloes which every ear takes place on the plains and which is rapidly leading to the to tal extinction of that animal, may be gleaned from the fact tha t seven cars freighted with buffalo bones re

See the clipping

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

Rep. Fort of Illinois introduced a 'National Game Law' bill in Congress aimed at protecting buffalo by regulating the hide trade and restricting hunting seasons. The bill would require government inspectors to examine hides before sale and limit buffalo hunting to outside the June-October period.

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 26 May 1876 · page 2

A bill has been introduced in Con gress by Mr. Fort, of Illinois, entitled a "National Game Law," which has for its special object the protection of buffalo. It proposes to regulate the traffic in buffalo hides and restrict the killing of the animals to certain sea sons of the year. Government inspec tors are to be appointed and no sale of hides allowed without their exami nation by these officers. Buffalo hunt ing is to be wholly restricted between June and October. Here is a chance for somebody to be Buffalo Inspector for Montana.

See the clipping

Northern Ohio Journal · Painesville, Ohio

A Dodge City vigilante mob hanged two men for horse theft, but subsequent investigation by a grieving father proved one victim, young Calahan, was innocent and merely gathering buffalo bones. The piece also recalls a similar wrongful lynching of an innocent man named George C. in Ellsworth, Kansas.

Northern Ohio Journal · 27 May 1876 · page 1

Judge Lynch's Mistake. A few days ago the Times published a brief telegraphic dispatch from Dodge City, Kan., announcing that a band of vigilantes had hung two men near Fort Dodge for stealing horses in Sumner County, Kan. Subsequent inquiries, made by the grief -stricken father of one of the men hung a young man named Calahan, sou of a preacher in Topeka proved beyond a doubt that Calahan was guiltless of any connection with the crime. He was engaged in gathering buffalo bones on the plains, and had

See the clipping