As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

September 1929

2 articles

Farmers Independent · Bagley, Minn.

Carlos Avery, writing for the American Game Protective Association, argues that the 'balance of nature' is a myth and that the gun alone did not exterminate the passenger pigeon. He claims destruction of roosting and nesting groves was another major factor in the species' extinction.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Farmers Independent · 12 September 1929 · page 8

Unable To Restore Balance Of Nature The disturbance of the natural con ditions existing in this country prior to settlement by the advance of civil ization is often deplored and blamed for the disappearance of certain forms of wild life. This change is referred to as having destroyed “nature’s bal ance” and we are given to understand that if this mythical balance of nature could be restored all again would be well, says Carlos Avery, president of the American Game Protective associ ation. A very earnest and conscientious conservationist recently said: “History records no extermination of any spe cies, no observable diminution of num bers of any form preyed upon, until man and his gun upset nature’s per fect balance.’’ The author of this assertion has evi dently forgotten the innumerable forms of life which disappeared from the face of the earth long before man appeared.

See moreSee less

The changes have been go ing on on earth since the beginning of time and while it is undoubtedly true that the use of the gun has hastened the disappearance of certain forms it has been only one of many factors re sponsible for changes which are con stantly in progress. The gun did not exterminate the Passenger pigeon; other devices were more destructive than firearms. The cutting away of the favorite roosting and nesting groves resorted to by this exceptionally gregarious species doubtless was another cause of has tened extinction. The Passenger pigeon did not rest or roost in widely scat tered places but only in certain fa vorite groves. When these were de stroyed the remaining birds disap peared. It is not difficult to visualize the advance of the stock ranger and his domestic herds, even if wholesale and wanton killing had not been resorted to. The balance of nature is bound to be disturbed wherever man makes his habitation. Civilized man cannot exist except through the disturbance of na ture’s balance. What would become of agriculture if nature were permitted to take her course? The pampered plants which have been developed to supply the world with food could not thrive except by artificial encourage ment and so the more desirable kinds of wild creatures can be increased and made more abundant under artfirial conditions and encouragement that they can in any perfect state of na ture. By protecting the desirable spe cies from the destructive ones, by sup plying sufficient quantity and ' , ariety of foods, by providing shelter, the Bob white quail, pheasant, Hungarian par tridge, and other kinds of game birds could be made far more abundant than they ever could be in a state where na ture’s balance prevailed. The forces of nature are remorse less; their results of the destruction of the weak and the prevalence of the strong, regardless of man s require ments. That is and has been for all time the course of evolution in natural history.—Park Rapids Enterprize.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper Q&A column responds to a reader asking where passenger pigeons bred when they were numerous, stating Michigan was their breeding ground and that outside breeding season they ranged across the Eastern United States. The item appears among unrelated trivia questions on topics like freight cars, Siamese twins, and glider clubs.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 54 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 28 September 1929 · page 6

Q. When passenger pigeons were numerous, where was their breeding J place?—D. D. I A. Michigan was the breeding ground iof the passenger pigeons. Outside of | breeding seasoi they were found over

See the clipping