The Dickenson County Herald · Clintwood, Va.
This opinion piece argues that habitat loss, not just shooting, drives species decline, citing the passenger pigeon's extinction and the buffalo's near-extinction as examples where deforestation and land conversion were major factors. It calls on sportsmen to organize around broader conservation efforts beyond hunting restrictions.
CorrectionThis set right an article from 150 days earlier.
The Dickenson County Herald · 23 August 1928 · page 1
AWAKE TO NEED FOR ORGANIZATION . While this is repetition, it seems necessary to retiterate that shooting is only one of many factors responsible for the reduction of gameIn some cases it is not even the chief factor, though some propagan dists continually harp on the one string, that smaller bags, shorter seasons and other re strictions are the one and only remedy for disappearing game. Without food, cover, sanc tuary, brood stock, control of enemies, and adequate range, insists teh American Game Pro tective Association, shooting may be entirely prohibited to no effect.
See moreSee less
Game will disappear. It would seem that this should be self evident, yet some who assume to pose as authorities refuse to heed. That game can not live in a desert where there is no watei or food, in a burned forest where cover and food are de stroyed, or on intensively cul tivated farms where no nesting sites are permitted, no one will dispute, and wherevei these barren conditions are per mitted, the wild life is always proportionately reduced. The extermination of the passenger pigeon and the near extermination of the buffalo are the two threadbare ex amples always cited as illus trating the effect of man’s de structive propensities. It may be that excessive killing by man was the chief destructive factor in both instances, yet there were other influences nearly is not quite as effective in wiping out the millions of these creatures which once swarmed over the country. The plow and the cow made it impossible for a herd of buffalo to find wild range any where in the United States. The axe and the saw played havoc with the roosting and nesting groves of the pigeon. Just so the displacement of the worm rail fence, the stone wall and the hedgerow by the wire fence has obliterated the cover of bob-white; the steam shovel and the ditching ma chine have sucked out the water and dried up the homes of the waterfowl and the musk rat; the same engines have caused an impenetrable crust to form where the woodcock was wont to bore for food; fire pasturage, defrestation and cul tivation have ruined the resorts of grouse, deer and moose; all these agencies added to poison ous pollution have obliterated the streams or made them un tenable for fish. These things can not be charged to “sportsmen,” the the man with the gun must bear his rightful share of the blame, because the common rur of gunners are not always sportsmen. A few hoggish in dividuals have brought odium on the whole fraternity It is up to the man who is not reconciled to hang up his gun and rod for keeps to help solve this problem in a con structive wayHe must work through organization, local and national, to put effective meth ods into operation. More re restrictive laws will not suf fice. There must be more food, more cover, more sanctuary, more breeding and stocking and better law enforcement.