As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

February 1922

7 articles

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper quiz column lists ten general-knowledge questions for readers to answer, one of which asks 'Is the passenger pigeon extinct?' The previous day's answers to similar trivia questions are also printed.

The Washington Herald · 17 February 1922 · page 16

MEMORY TESTS

Published Tomorrow. 1. Who was the author of the phrase "entangling alliances?" 2. What was the estimate of Archimcdes on the capability of the lever? 3. What is the butcher bird and why is it so called? 4. What is the population of Africa? 5. What forms the dividing line between the States of Georgia and South Carolina? 6. Is the passenger pigeon ex tinct? 7. Where is the greatest center for the manufacture and distribu tion of pianos in the country? 8. Which of the Great Lakes have bottoms below sea level, and which above?

See moreSee less

v 9. What three Presidents of the United States were Harvard grad uates? 10. Who took the office of James Abram Garfield as President of the United States after his assassina tion? When was Garfield killed?

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper trivia/quiz column answers the question 'Is the passenger pigeon extinct?' by stating ornithologists unanimously agree it went extinct about fifty years earlier, comparing it to the dodo. The item appears among other general-knowledge trivia answers unrelated to current events.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 47 days later.

Wrong

The Washington Herald · 18 February 1922 · page 16

MEMORY TESTS, paling Its prey. Insects, beetles, grasshoppers and even mice, on thorns for use as a later meal. 4. What Is the population of Af rica? 142,872.063. according: to the "Statesman's Year Bookfor 1926. 5. What forms the dividing: line between the states of Georgia and South Carolina? The Savannah River. 6. Is the passenger pigeon ex tinct, This wonderful native birr* which used to fly over the conti nent by the millions, took its place with the Australian dodo as extinct half a century ago, accodring to unanimous opinion of ornithol ogists.

See moreSee less

v 7. Where is the gratest center for the manufacture and distribution of pianos in this country? Chicago. 8. 'Which of the great lakes have bottoms below sea level, and which above? Lake Erie Is the only lake whose bottom is above sea level, hencc the only lake that could ever be drained. v 9. What three President's of the United States were Harvard gradu ates? John Adams. John Qulncy Adams and Theodore Roosevelt. (George Washington received an honorary degree from Harvard in 177f. 10. Who took the office of James Abram Garttefd as President of the United. States after his assas sination? When was Garfield killed? Viee President Cheater Alan Ar/ thur. July 2, 1881.

See the clipping

The Daytona Daily News · Daytona, Fla.

An advocate for creating a tropical national park in Florida argues that without quick action, the region's deer, bear, and other wildlife will disappear just as the passenger pigeon and prairie chicken did. The piece calls for the American Game Protective Association, Audubon Society, and motor clubs to push the government to protect the area before land speculators and hunters destroy it.

The Daytona Daily News · 19 February 1922 · page 14

j turtles. kwr heads, rays of the 1m1I and. riant varieties and the vfeo V - ia this ttaraest and only real wild Royal Palm --t J Ut Um tartarcstot ; forest in the united states, me raosi j JIjt t3k auspices of ttw'deer. bear and cat I" icivacatc establishing "They are t&ere now. but m five i "ir5roity department years hence they will have gone the f Jrin and research, way of the wild pigeon and prairie

See the clipping

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.

A business economics opinion piece argues that modern commerce requires broad economic literacy, comparing successful men ignorant of global affairs to passenger pigeons in their rarity. The reference uses the bird's extinction as a well-known cultural touchstone for extreme scarcity, unrelated to any direct pigeon reporting.

The Frontier · 23 February 1922 · page 7

Putting it in the bluntest terms possible it Is going to become in creasingly difficult for the ignorant man in business to "get past" and show a profit; successful men who boast that they confine their reading to baseball reports aro going to be come about as scarce as passenger pigeons. This is because virtually every business lias lost its old local limitations and is touched and moved by new and complex influences radi ating from conditions In countries thousands of miles from our shores. America is no longer an Isolated Utopia; she has moved dangerously near to the center of the world slags and it is up to her average citizen to broaden out and get the firing range on the new situation—even if he has to neglect ills golf occasionally to do so.

See the clipping

Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.

A longtime resident recalls seeing large herds of deer and also remembers when passenger pigeons were abundant and caught in large numbers. The piece notes the Audubon Society's reward for a passenger pigeon nest and repeats competing folk theories about the bird's extinction, including a storm at sea and netting.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

Baraboo Weekly News · 23 February 1922 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

E. D. KING RECALLS DAYS OF MANY DEER

When Carrier Pigeons Were Caught in Large Numbers

Since Mr. Steinke moved onto the Teel farm in Sumpter the early February thaw melted the snow from the south slope of the hill, uncovering the grass which made a welcome feast for the deer that came from the brush and snow of the north slope, as they do on such occasions, sometimes in large numbers at a time. A few years ago, Charles Watkins saw 20 on his winter wheat at one time. Many years ago Ralph Elmendorf counted 40 deer in a drove.

See moreSee less

Now comes the recent report that Mr. Steinke saw 23 in one drove and 40 at another time which was certainly remarkable and also indicates that they are well protected.

Although the rascals do a lot of damage to shocked corn that happens to be left in the field over winter, and also to orchards, we would dislike having them exterminated as was the passenger pigeons that were numerous in the early pioneer days.

Offer Reward for Nest

Now the Audobon society has offered over one thousands dollars for a nest of those splendid game birds, hoping to get them propagated again. The theory was advanced that the passenger pigeons were lost in a

See the clipping

Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.

A writer from Wisconsin reminisces about the immense flocks of passenger pigeons seen in his youth, describing how they devastated newly sown grain fields and were hunted with muzzle-loading shotguns and large nets. He recounts specific anecdotes, including his uncle's homemade rope-net trap used to capture pigeons for sale.

Baraboo Weekly News · 23 February 1922 · page 2

It was then that the old muzzel-load ing shot gun did its best work. At one time my brother shot twelve with a single barreled shot gun and on a similiar occasion Albert Jameson shot twenty-five with a double-barreled gun. At another time J. B. Fowler and E. Vanderhoef Simultaneously shot into a flock that was passing over and one pigeon dropped to the ground and was [claimed by each party. Finally Fowler got the bird and Vanderhoef got a black eye. Dur ing those early days my uncle Hosea and his son-in-law bought the farm now owned by Walter Welch and lost it by foreclosure.

See moreSee less

Afterward Uncle and Aunt moved into a part of my father's house, where Rjoy Hoover now lives. Although quite young, I remember seeing Uncle Hosea mak ing a rope.

See the clipping

The Morning Tulsa Daily World · Tulsa, Okla.

A correspondent from Oklahoma relays claims that passenger pigeons may have migrated elsewhere rather than gone extinct, prompting interest in capturing specimens for a reported government offer. The account recalls commercial netting operations from 1886-1890 near Siloam Springs, Arkansas, where thousands of pigeons were caged, fattened, and shipped for sale to markets in New York, Baltimore, and Boston.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 39 days later.

Wrong

The Morning Tulsa Daily World · 26 February 1922 · page 43 · transcribed from the page image

Wild Pigeons Once Numerous Over-Oklahoma

Special to The World.

See moreSee less

TAHLEQUAH—J. E. Kelly, vice president of the Kelly Mercantile company of Kelleyville, Okla., in a recent communication to a citizen of this section, gave some interesting information concerning the wild pigeons. It has been supposed by many persons that the pigeons have become extinct, though the probability is that they migrated to some other portion of th[e] earth. Having learned that the United States government had, or was reported to have made an offer for specimens of the pigeons, Mr. Kelly, in the event such an offer has been made, proposes to capture some of the birds, if any of them are to be found. Referring to a period of some 30 to 36 years past, he mentioned that he was at the time located in the eastern part of the Cherokee nation and during the years from 1886 to 1890 netted thousands of dozens of the birds. After their capture in the extensive roosts south of Siloam Springs, Ark., and west of the town of Cincinnati, in the same state, and across the boundary line of the Indian territory, in the rugged valleys of the Going Snake district mountains, the pigeons were placed in crate-like enclosures, built from lumber procured from Lew Williams' saw mill on the Illinois river. In these crates the pigeons were "stall-fed" and when they had become plump and in prime condition they were shipped to a number of eastern cities where they sold readily. In New York, Baltimore and in Boston, Mass., there were buyers who took large numbers of the small fowl. Associated with Mr. Kelly in the pigeon netting and selling was Robert Garrett, at one time clerk of the Going Snake district and afterward a citizen of Tahlequah. The pigeons, in the fall of the year, arrived at the roosts "by the million," the limbs of large trees being broken off by the immense weights the clustered masses as wave after wave of the birds flew down and perched among the trees.

A number of the birds were kept from one season to another to be used as "stool birds" in order that the wild ones could be more readily enticed. It was no trouble to keep the birds, according to Mr. Kelly, as they soon became accustomed to their new environments, but never would they mate while in captivity.

Besides engaging in the netting and shipping of the wild pigeons Mr. Kelly killed many wild turkeys, these fowls then being very numerous, as well as many fine deer. The hill country more than 35 years ago was practically unbroken and one could ride for miles without seeing a house. Wild game found abundance of food in the valleys and the hunter experienced little difficulty in securing any quantity of turkeys he desired, while several deer could be killed within a radius of a few miles or less.

While in the Cherokee nation Mr. Kelly assisted in cutting thousands of walnut logs which were floated down the Illinois river to a destination some distance away, and made a trip on one occasion with a big consignment of logs down the swift flowing stream.

Among other events of interest recalled by Mr. Kelly was that of having attended a noted murder trial at the old Going Snake district courthouse. Two brothers, George and Fred Dunawas, were tried for the murder of Wash Lee, a former sheriff of the district. The prosecution was by E. C. Boudinot and W. W. Hastings of Tahlequah, while the defense was conducted by Judge Dick Wolfe, for a number of years a senator in the Cherokee legislature. The boys were convicted and hanged on a gallows in the yard of the old Cherokee prisc[n]. in Tahlequah, after all efforts to secure a commutation of their sentence from the principal chief of the Cherokee nation had been in vain.

As to the wild pigeons, it is said that they exist in vast numbers in the United States of Columbia in South America, and by some it is supposed that the birds made their

CONTINUED ON PAGE THREE

See the clipping