As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

May 1917

4 articles

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A review of a biography of Galusha Grow recounts his Pennsylvania farm boyhood, including a famous wild pigeon year when passenger pigeons darkened the sky and farmers fought to protect their grain. It describes pigeons covering trees for miles and being killed in large numbers for food, as part of the backstory before Grow's political career began.

The Sun · 6 May 1917 · page 30

SOME NEW BOOKS

nsed to. That was a famous wild pigeon year. Tho birds lnvuded northeastern Penn sylvania, in countless (locks. They darkened the day as they flewover their feeding" grounds. The farmers had to light for their grain, and fight Hard. At night they drove from miles around to the roosting places, and wltn poles swept the birds, by dozens at a blow, otf the trees. They took horns wagonloads ot pigeons, and salted down tho meat for winter use.

See the clipping

The St. Charles Herald · Hahnville, La.

An opinion piece on bird preservation recalls a New England legend about mass bird extermination causing crop and forest devastation. It cites the passenger pigeon, once numbering in the millions as late as 1880 but completely extinct by 1917, as a real example of such unconcern.

The St. Charles Herald · 26 May 1917 · page 2

Importance of Bird Preservation

By MRS. ROBERT T. SCO'IT A legend of a New England village relate.-- how the farmers, *? xa5 " perated over the toll taken from fruit and gram, handed together for th 0 extermination of all birds. They shot, trapped and poisoned until every native bird was extinct. That season the grain crops were destroyed,, the fruit did not mature and the tre#s stood brown and shriveled fr° m destruction wrought by insects. But more appalling than all was the nud» reproach of the voiceless forest and the absence of the twinkling ' of these "children of the air.'' The legend narrates how the birds were again trapped in adjacent localities, and.

See moreSee less

with great care and ceremony, brought to the desolated spot and released. Such wholesale slaughter could not easily be carried on at this present day, but the extermination of many birds through indifference is threat ened. One of the generally known results of unconcern is the fate passenger pigeon. As late as 1880 flocks of these birds contained mill' 0118 » and not a single pigeon is in existence todav. The stately snowy white egrets of Oregon and Florida were about to suffer the same doom when protective measures were organized. The decreased number of many other birds is troubling the bird lover, ami should trouble every agriculturist. Few people realize the enormous amount of insect and weed-seed food devoured by the birds. The scientist, examining the stomachs of different species at different seasons, reveals facts that are almost incred ible. An estimate based on these examinations made in two localities in ihe West where meadow larks are numerous, places the amount o insect food consumed by the nestlings about three hundred tons daily - In one state, where the tree sparrows winter, eight hundred tons of weed seeds were thought to be their season's portion. These two examples can be multiplied many times, the tiniest hum mingbird doing its share in the economic order of nature.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This article discusses federal vs. state efforts to regulate migratory game bird hunting season lengths. It cites the extinction of the passenger pigeon, said to have existed in 'countless millions' up until 1885, as a cautionary precedent for what happens without adequate protection.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 56 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 27 May 1917 · page 22

It Is or course lnui..iKi ... I'iVrr:1'" of ,h's,act m the column, of Tim Sim reserved for the mviri.m..'. rtMTt . . I 1 1 1 K 1 1 n 1 Tl-ltfU11 ... . . . . "I lilt, IIIIV. nil. l,n-K , - I transient by .the fact that local game la usually projected ten months each year while migratory game Is shot ten months each year, when computing the Hiring and fall fllghta and the winter season. This difference of course speljs final extermination., as formerly shown bv the complete destruction of the 'migra tory wild pigeon, which up to 1885 ex Isted In countless millions, and again by the small remnant of shore birds and the reduced number of water fowl, nie iuie -snoot a migratory bird I, Inn.

See the clipping

The Washburn Times · Washburn, Wis. · and 1 other paper

The report describes the passenger pigeon's extinction as one of the strangest mysteries in American natural history, noting that fifty years earlier the birds were abundant across the Midwest in massive migrating flocks. While acknowledging gunners killed vast numbers annually, it states investigators believe other unknown causes contributed to the species' complete disappearance.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Washburn Times · 31 May 1917 · page 4

Ths Wild Pigeon Myetery. That the wild pigeon, once so com mon in the United States, has become extinct is one of the strangest myste ries in American natural history. It is a puzzle which has baffled scientists and which probably never will be solved. Half a century ago wild pigeons w T ere abundant in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indi ana, Kentucky and all the states of the middle west. In their migrations they traveled in flocks numbering tens of thousands, and it sometimes took a sin gle flock the better part of an hour to pass a given point.

See moreSee less

Vast numbers of the pigeons were killed every year by gunners, but many investigators hold that the complete disappearance of the species must have been due in part at least to other causes. No other bird was ever so numerous in this country as the pigeon.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 23 August 1917