As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

January 1917

7 articles

Williston Graphic · Williston, N.D.

A 1917 editorial recalls the extinction of the buffalo, passenger pigeon, and heath hen as cautionary tales of unchecked slaughter. It warns western hunters to heed these lessons before species like sage grouse and prairie chicken suffer the same irreversible fate.

Williston Graphic · 4 January 1917 · page 4

hynters themselves did not realize it, and would not believe it until two years had elapsed! "The passenger pigeon millions went the same way, by commercial

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

Amid a commentary on wartime profiteering and consumer prices, the writer wistfully recalls 'the good old times' when a man could shoot wild pigeons from his front porch and get potatoes from his lawn. The passenger pigeon is invoked only as a symbol of lost abundance and cheap living, not as news in itself.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 4 January 1917 · page 12

aelvortisiiiK. ho wants to buy che-.ip H Is of nei concern t" bun that high prices . nr,v elrolillnivisst wcsiltll from lairope to crenliiLaji industrial and 'two yeani. has u-.nilH s the good o n limes vvni'ii peel- -m ' - - ..i c-..- sinnisold for 10 ce-iits a pound and soup . March for bones could be had for the iuikmp. It is not exactly t-ne that man nover is but always to be blexse Hewas blest when ho could shoot wild pigeons frr.m Ills front I pon'h and die his winter's i apply of pomtoes from his lawn, nm ne niun t unow It. He wasn't r-atlstled until he ordered his dinner by telephone niadi' he hon-e ic.

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A writer recounts validating Audubon's account of vast pigeon flocks to skeptical schoolchildren, describing personal memories of witnessing passenger pigeons roosting in Decatur County, Indiana. The piece describes their migratory habits, feeding behavior, and the massive nighttime slaughter by hunters that contributed to the species' extinction.

Evening Times-Republican · 9 January 1917 · page 4

A Oestruotion of the Wild Pigeon. The children in a school In Warren county read a story of Audubon about the wild pigeon, in which he «aid he had seen the wild pigeons tly so thick that he could not see the sky for sev eral seconds. In review, I found the children did not believe the story. They asked mo If I believed it. I was happy to be able to tell them, truthfully, that I had seen tiie same thing many times. Think of the vaat number of birds it ok to completely cover the sky.

See moreSee less

And now that beautiful bird Is entirely ex tinct. The wild pigeon was larger than the turtle dove, which it resembled, it was a harmless bird, living principally on mast. Heechnuts and acorns were its favorites. Klce was found in the crops of some pigeons taken in Indi ana, which they had eaten in Carolina, so rapid wa« their Ilighi and migra tory habits. These birds nested one year in Decatur county. Indiana, and 1 had a chance to observe some of their habits. They came in early springlike a cloud" from the south, and covered the trees. For hours they came. After resting a while they (lew down on tlie ground in search of food. They moved like an army, throwing the leaves over their backs, hunting for beechnuts and acorns. They selected their roosting place near Aiuscatatack creek, north of the Michigan road, where later they built their nests. They would fly south every morning, and back to the roost in the evening. They made a noise like falling water. Men came to the pigeon

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

The piece draws moral lessons from the commercial slaughter of buffalo herds and passenger pigeons, noting people refused to believe the pigeons were truly gone for ten years. It warns western hunters of grouse species to heed the heath hen's fate, as delayed closed seasons came too late to save it.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 9 January 1917 · page 4

"The passenger pigeon millions went the same way, by com mercial slaughter, so quickly that no one realized what was happen ing until it was all over! For ten years the American people refused to believe that all those millions o'f birds had gone forever but now they know it is true. "The heath hen,' or eastern prairie chicken, formerly of New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and Massachusetts, went not quite so rapidly, but it went just the same. The 5 and 10 year closed seasons which were iven it came so tardily that they were too late!

See moreSee less

The decimated birds could not recuperate. "Let every western hunter of sage grouse, sharp-tail and pin nated grouse rertiember the fate of the heath hen, and take to heart the moral of that tragic story. If it is a crime (grand larceny) to steal $21, what shall we say of those who rob a state or a nation of can a valuable bird or mammal species which no human power ever replace THE MISFIT SHOE Editorial in Minneapolis Journal. When the Crusaders returned home they brought back the Arabian horse. When Pizarro returned from Peru, he brought back the potato. When our militiamen returned from the Mexican border they brought back the army shoe.

See the clipping

The Oklahoma City Times · Oklahoma City, Okla.

An Oklahoma newspaper editorial recalls old-timers' memories of vast flights of wild pigeons now vanished from the state, using this as a cautionary example while urging stronger game laws to protect the declining prairie chicken and quail. It argues that market hunters threaten the quail just as they once threatened the passenger pigeon, and calls for extended closed seasons and tougher penalties.

The Oklahoma City Times · 10 January 1917 · page 12

STRENGTHENING THE GAME LAWS. PLD-TIMERS in this Mate can remember tht flight! of the wild pigeon, when countless number! of those birds thrived in Oklahoma; they can recall days when the prairie chicken wat to he found at almost any point on the prairie. But now the wild pigeon is absent; tht prairie chicken js alt bqt gone. v There was danger that the quail would follow the wUd pigeon, but a wise legislature, influenced by lovers of birds,

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Rod and Gun column reader writes in, defending brook trout and also pushing back on hunters who criticize so-called 'game hogs.' He notes that passenger pigeons have nowhere left to nest since their timber and beechnut food sources are gone, implying their decline was due to habitat loss.

The Sun · 12 January 1917 · page 13

up. kit et-Alius. New York, Jan. 8. Natural Cover Needed for Game. t have been reading the Rod and Gun column so many yeara that to miss a day now would throw me Into a nt. It Is even a pleasure to me to sit down on a Sunday morning and go over again all the Rod and Gun nasi for the week naat. In doing this I find that some of my nest friends wno write ror mis column slightly contradict themselves at different times. Reme nf them tread on my toes toe.

See moreSee less

Especially when writing of the flit) and game hogs. I hate a hog et this class as much aa anyone can, but soma of the arguments are rather tar retched. Take the buffalo. Where would be put the millions which were killed for the hides It we had them hark? Also the pigeons. Where Is the timber for them to nest In, and the beechnuts for

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A writer reminisces about his younger days when wild pigeons, trout, partridges, and deer were so abundant that he and others took them in enormous numbers without any sense of game laws or limits. He reflects that such overharvesting, combined with habitat destruction from logging and chemical factories, likely caused the disappearance of this once-plentiful wildlife.

The Sun · 12 January 1917 · page 13

ii;itt 111.ua iu:su llio 1 i ; 3.04 13:3.1 13:23 13.00 10.3S 11:18 t:M 3:47 1:05 l4 lil 1 I OV .dU them to feed on It thoy were here In 4UI great numbers a they once were, Whero would we put tho trout which once niled thousands ot strenma In Mih Kean. Potter, Elk, Cameron, Forest, Tioga, anil other counties In Pennsylvania It wa had them, when all ot these streams are black as Ink from the refunu of the chemi cal (actorles. 1 have In my young and thoughtleis days taken twentv to 100 dozen wild pigeons In a day with nets.

See moreSee less

I have caught trout alt the year round, twenty to fltty pounds a day, I havo killed over twenty part ridges In a day, anil over thirty woodcock, Tho section.-? where I did this are now bar pasture lands, or burnt over wastes where It would take torty acres to pasturo a eju"?. I I havo hunted deer ten months a year, and there are no more deer there. And no brush or timber, either. When 1 recall tint ast wealth of game existing then, and read the severe arraign mcnts or me game nog, 1 isei line preuy Small potatoes. Maybe It 1 and thousands like me had lived up tn the game laws, of of which we were totally Ignorant, all this game and fish might still be living In greet

See the clipping