As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

February 1913

20 articles

Oxford Democrat · Paris, Me.

In a folksy opinion letter about literary plagiarism, the writer compares hunting down a bad poet's imitators to the way passenger pigeons were hunted until extinct. The reference treats the pigeons' disappearance as already an established fact of 'boyhood days' nostalgia.

Oxford Democrat · 4 February 1913 · page 2

John's Letter. Iu these days when the woods are full of tb j "Birds of Prey" the timely words of "Johnny Long" (Beg pardon, but what is written is writ) might well ap pear iu every publication in Christendom. There should be no close time on that •ort of game, but it should be bunted down with dog and gun till it has be come extinct like the passenger pigeons of our boyhood days. How does vermin strike you a* a destructive? O, the unblushing che* k of Macdoodle, or whatever tbe fellow's name, who claitr s the authorship of oue of Will Caritton's poems!

See moreSee less

Why not claim the entire bunch as belonging to bis own lit tle il conspicuous self? Each and every, one and all, wear tbe same distinctive "ear marks," read and known of all men. We could easier believe that Bacoi wrote Shakespeare than that Macdoodle wrote Carleton. Picking a dead man's pocket is not tbe most ele vating spectacle in tbe world. Well, Greetiwood, we authorize you to inform Squire Doodle that he is a liar, and that lying is a leading trait of the Doodle family. And you may tell him we said so. John.

See the clipping

Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.

A U.S. Senate bill to protect migratory birds is reported, with the writer citing the extinction of the wild pigeon as proof of what happens without such laws. The piece recalls how pigeons were slaughtered by the thousands at roosting sites during their seasonal migrations between north and south.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

Americus Times-Recorder · 5 February 1913 · page 4

FEDERAL PROTECTION FOR MIGRATORY BIRDS

Hadn’t you better begin practicing ahead of time, governor? t tion?” flight back ?nd forth was a perilous one, as the people along their route would visit their roosting places and slaughter them by the thousands. The pawnshop! ” result is that now we never see a wild pigeon. They have been brutal ly and wantonly slain. Another migrato bird is the robin. They are now being slaughtered as the pigeons was slaughtered. It was formerly considered great sport to visit the robin roost and slaughter these insectivorous and valuable birds, and a practice even yet indulg ed in in some localities.

See moreSee less

Ducks and geese are not as plentiful now as they have been, as they, too, are kill ed in the spring s well as early fall and winter. In addition to a federal law for the his confrere: protection of migratory birds, the different states should vigorously en torce whatever laws they have on the matter of bird protection, and where the protection is not ample for the preservation of bird life additional law-s should be enacted. performance?” Georgia has set a good example for its sister states in this particular. Game birds and all other feathered griends of mankind have been protect myself.’ ” ed better the last year than ever. The migratory birds now unprotected in the face. should be included in (he list of those protected in Georgia. A little powder is a handy thing. courts. President Andrew M. Soule.

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

A philosophical nature essay discusses how war, pestilence, and famine maintain population balance among species. It cites the passenger pigeon, like the dodo, as an example of a species driven to total extinction.

The Detroit Times · 6 February 1913 · page 10

—like the fossil animals we read of and see In the museums, the dodo just spoken of, and the passenger pigeon which many people now living have seen, but

See the clipping

Newark Evening Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.

This philosophical piece discusses how war, pestilence, and famine keep animal and plant populations in balance, citing the passenger pigeon and dodo as examples of species that have been wiped out. It questions whether humans, as animals, are exempt from these same natural checks on population.

Newark Evening Star and Newark Advertiser · 6 February 1913 · page 8

and pests bad, the race decreases. There is always a tide In the affnirs of animals and plants as in those of men—it either ebbs or flows. Some times it ebbs until a race is wiped out—like the fossil animals we road of and see in the museums, the dodo just spoken of, and tho passenger pigeon which many people now living have seen, but which is no more. This

See the clipping

Essex County Herald · Guildhall, Vt. · and 1 other paper

A taxidermist in Lincoln, Maine, named W. J. Clayton had a chance to buy two passenger pigeons for $200. The report notes the birds, once abundant across the country, are now nearly extinct and highly prized.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 17 days earlier.

Essex County Herald · 7 February 1913 · page 3

Practically Exterminated. Lincoln, Me. W. J. Clayton, taxi dermist had an opportunity recently to buy two passenger pigeons for the small sum of $200. Probably mem bers of the older generation can re member when these birds abounded in large numbers all, over the country. They are now nearly extinct and are prized very highly.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I. · 7 February 1913

Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon

The report describes bird protection efforts in England and New England, including sanctuaries and bird clubs. It also notes that W.H. Mershon, author of 'The Passenger Pigeon,' is offering essay prizes to Michigan schoolchildren for bird-related projects.

Daily Capital Journal · 14 February 1913 · page 5

work. W. H. Mersho of Saginaw, Mich., au thor of "The Passenger Pigeon" nnd an ncllve worker for bird protection, has olfered seven prize medals to the school children of Michigan for vari ous essays on birds, for feeding birds, for photographing them and for suc cess with bird housm. Tho prizes will he distributed next May on Arbor and Iilrd day.

See the clipping

The Bridgeport Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.

Massachusetts ornithologist Edward Howe Forbush writes in support of the McLean bill for federal protection of migratory birds, citing the passenger pigeon's extinction as proof that states cannot adequately protect such species. He quotes an 1868 Ohio legislative report dismissing the pigeon as needing no protection, contrasting it with the bird's total extinction less than fifty years later.

The Bridgeport Evening Farmer · 18 February 1913 · page 7

FEDERAL PROTECTION OF MIGRATORY BIRDS

Committee of ' the Senate of Ohio in 1868 on a bill proposing protection of the passenger pigeon.. The passenger pigeon needs no pro tection.' Wonderfully prolific, having the vast forests of the North as its reeding grounds, traveling hundreds of miles in search of food, it is here today and elsewhere tomorrow, and - iu ordinary destruction can lessen them, or be missed from the myriads that are yearly produced." Less than fifty years later, the wild or - passenger pigeon known, except those in 'captivity, was killed . and

See the clipping

The Daily Missoulian · Missoula, Mont.

Embedded in an unrelated article about mercury-vapor lamp water sterilization, the paper includes a brief editorial note promising that tomorrow's edition will feature a story on the Passenger Pigeon. No details about the pigeon itself are given here.

The Daily Missoulian · 20 February 1913 · page 4

markable than electricity itself. (Tomorrow-The Passenger Pigeon.) MORGAN GOES DRIVING. London, Feb. 19.-J. P. Morgan, ac cording to a dispatch from Cairo, went out driving today. He is recovering from his attack of indigestion. His

See the clipping

Highland Recorder · Monterey, Va. · and 2 other papers

The Baltimore Sun reports that a wild pigeon, once so numerous it was seen in the billions, has become a rarity, noting that a specimen mailed from Quebec to the Montreal Witness was identified as a passenger pigeon. The article recounts the species' history and attributes its near-disappearance to hunting, deforestation, and harsh winters between 1860 and 1870.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Highland Recorder · 21 February 1913 · page 1

3IHD KGW ALMOST EXTINCT | Wild Pigeon, Once Counted In Mil* j lions, So Rare 33 to 3s Account ed a Curiosity. The great reduction of bird life in America Is illustrated by a stoiy from Montreal of the capture of a bird now rare which formerly was Been by the million. This unusual ornithological specimen was sent, carefully packed in a pasteboard box, J by parcel post from Odell Town, Quebec, to the Montreal Witness. The bird was taken to J. B. Innes, j secretary of the Society for the Pre- : vention of Cruelty to Animals, and also secretary of the Quebec Fish and Game club.

See moreSee less

He definitely identified the bird as a wild pigeon or dove, a species now almost extinct. Ouicers connected with the society entered the office while Mr. Innes was inspect ing the bird, and they each at once recognized it as a wild dove. The sender of the little feathered creature was John Hough, of Odell Town, Quebec. He explained his rea son for mailing it was to have It identified, as he had heard queries had been made -regarding wild pigeons. The wild, or passenger, pigeon, so named from its habit of passing from one part of the country to another, was once a resident of southern Can ada and the northern United States. One naturalist computed that there were more than a billion of these birds in a continuous stream which he saw on one occasion. Incessant slaughter and the clearing away of the forests destroyed the pigeons, the disappearance of which was hastened by a series of very cold winters be- . tween I860 and 1S70. i

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn. · 16 December 1912
  • The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 23 December 1912

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article notes the recent illness of the last surviving passenger pigeon at the Cincinnati Zoo, prompting naturalists to recall the species' incredible former abundance. It recounts Audubon's famous eyewitness account of massive pigeon flights and the brutal commercial hunting that led to their extinction.

Evening Star · 21 February 1913 · page 10

?the extinction of one of the most remarkable birds that ever inhabited the earth. Millions of people are still living whose eyes have witnessed the flight of the myriad hosts of passenger pigeons, and yet only one of all the vast numbers of those pigeons is known to survive? and that one occupies a place of honor in the Cincinnati Zoo. When he dies it is probable his body will be presented to the nation, to be preserved in alcohol at the National Museum. work. In these days it is hard for the younger

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article recalls John James Audubon's celebrated eyewitness description of a massive passenger pigeon migration near Louisville in 1813, including his method of estimating flock numbers by counting dots per minute. It details his calculations suggesting over a billion pigeons passed in just three hours, with the flight continuing for three days total.

Evening Star · 21 February 1913 · page 10

THE PASSENGER PIGEON

forward with the wings of the wind in undulating and angular lines, descending and sweeping close to the earth, then mounting perpendicularly so as to resemble a vast column, and when high in the air once more, wheeling and twisting within their continued lines, which then resembled the coils of a gigantic serpent. For hity-flve miles Audubon traveled on to Louisville, with the serried columns of | pigeons still floating over his head, and for three days the flight continued. Bach flock did exactly as the one ahead had done; If the one ahead darted down when passing over a brook or dodging a hawk the flock behind did the same.

See moreSee less

Audubon attempted to estimate the number of pigeons in that great flight. lie assumed that the column averaged a mile in width, which was far below the average in point of fact. Then he assumed that the birds flew at the rate of sixty miles an hour, also a conservative assumption. Upon this basis the pigeons passing in three hours wotild form a streak 180 square i miles in area, and, counting two pigeons ! to the square yard, there would he nearly | a billion and a quarter pigeons in such a flight. How many there must have been

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article recounts Audubon's famous calculations of a massive passenger pigeon flight, estimating over a billion birds based on column width and speed, and daily food consumption. It also describes his visits to a huge roosting site in Kentucky, where hunters, farmers with hogs, and locals gathered to slaughter pigeons as trees collapsed under the birds' weight.

Evening Star · 21 February 1913 · page 10

I7V.U7 nlmnnn tvoro tr> ho aoen hilt thero ' " I were great numbers of people, who, with horses and wagons, children and dogs, guns and ammunition, had established camps on the borders of the forest. Two farmers had driven more than three hundred hogs over a hundred miles to fatten them on pigeons that were to be slaughtered. in plucking and salting the catch ;

See the clipping

The Daily Missoulian · Missoula, Mont.

The article reports on the recent illness of the last surviving passenger pigeon at the Cincinnati zoo, noting it will likely be preserved at the National Museum after death. It recounts the species' former incredible abundance, the brutal hunting practices that led to its extinction, and references Audubon's famous 1813 eyewitness account of massive pigeon flights.

The Daily Missoulian · 21 February 1913 · page 4

By Frederic J. Haskin. Thei recent sickness of the passen ger pigeon in the. Cincinnati zoologi oal gardens-the last survivor of a mighty host-has served to call the attention of naturalists again to one of the most remarkable birds that ever inhabited the earth. Millions of people are, still living whose eyes hoIle witnessed the flight of the myriad hosts of pasenger pigeons, and yet only one of all the vast numbers of those pigeons is known to survive-and that one occupies a place of honor in the Cincinnati zoo. When he dies it is probable that his body will he presented to the nation, to be preserved in alcohol at the Na tioll mutumnl.

See moreSee less

In these days it is hard for the yvountger people to believe the story iof the passenger pigeon, so incredible wtre their numlltbers, so remarkable were their flights, and so strange were their nestings. And the story of the brutality that rtmarked the work of thte lt hunters iwho followed them as a tiger stalks his prey, relentlessly ,ursuing themt using the telegraph to keep inl touch with their flights and their nestings, is a story of revolting cruelty nld butchery. The world is inldebted to John Jlamles Audubon, the great naturalist, for what is llperhaplls the Iest ccount of the passnger ligeon \'ever written. Andt his truthfulnest s and scie'ntific ac cural'y mIake it a story to be accepted ;it its face v'alue. lie rtelates that In the autumn of 1813 he left his house ot Henderson, on the banks of the (thi,, to go to Louisville. In passing over the lilrrens a; few mnlets froml liardl'llnsburgh hie o hserved pigeons flying I'rlom the nollrtheast to the sttouth..

See the clipping

The Daily Missoulian · Missoula, Mont.

The report recounts naturalist John James Audubon's famous observations of an immense passenger pigeon flight near Louisville, describing a sky darkened by birds for three days straight. It details his mathematical estimates of the flock's size, speed, and food consumption, as well as his visits to a vast roosting site on the Green River in Kentucky.

The Daily Missoulian · 21 February 1913 · page 4

For 55 miles Audubon traveled on to Louisville, wilth thlte serried colunlns of pigeons still floating over his head, tutd for three days the flight contin utied. Each flocik did exactly as the one ahead had donle; if the one ahead darted down \\ hen passing over a brook, or dodging a hawk, the flock behind did the same. Audubon at tetmpted to estimate the number of pigeons in that great flight, He as sumed that the colu:nn averaged a mile in width, which was far below the average in point of fact. Then he assumed that the birds flew at the

See the clipping

The Daily Missoulian · Missoula, Mont.

The report recounts John James Audubon's famous eyewitness description of massive passenger pigeon flights, including birds crashing roosts and feeding predators and scavengers. It then traces the extinction to professional pigeon hunters who used telegraphs and trained stool pigeons from around 1840 onward, citing the 1878 Michigan roost that yielded 300 tons of shipped birds.

The Daily Missoulian · 21 February 1913 · page 4

Everything was uproar and confusion. The people could not hear themselves talking to one another, and even the reports of shotguns and blunderbusses could not be heard . above the great noise. Audubon sent a man out from the forest to see how far the noise could be heard, and it was plainly audible three miles distant. By mid night the stream of arrivals began to fall off, but before the break of day the advance guard began to move out again. While no one dared go in the woods while the pigeons were in the trees, they were able 'to kill and crip ple enough of them uto keep all the people busily employes next day, with enough left over to give the 300 hogs, the wolves, the foxes, the lynxes, the cougars, bears, raccoons, possums, polecats, eagles, and hawks a more than satisfactory breakfast, and at the same time to save enough back for the vultures that came to supplant the animals and the birds of prey.

See moreSee less

James Fenimore Cooper also saw the flights of the passenger pigeons, and he said that in a single flight he had seen enough birds to provision Xerxe's army for a month and enough feath ers to provide a downy couch for ev ery person in the country. The white man and his net are re sponsible for the disappearance of the passenger pigeon from the face of the earth. They began their forays about 1840. The profession of pigeoner came into existence, and 'these men banded themselves together to exploit the pigeon. By the telegraph they were able to keep in close touch with the mo\vements of the pigeons, and no pigeon roost could be established for nany days before the pigeoners were on hand to get in their deadly work. They carried with them trained stool pigeons by which they were enabled to call down great flocks of passing

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

The article reports that the last known passenger pigeon, housed at the Cincinnati Zoological Gardens, recently fell ill, reviving naturalists' interest in the species' dramatic decline from billions to one. It reflects on the once-vast flocks and the brutal hunting that led to their near-total extinction, noting plans to preserve the bird's body at the National Museum after death.

El Paso Herald · 21 February 1913 · page 6

ASHINGTON, D. G, FeD. 21. w The recent sickness of the passenger pigeon in the Cincinnati zoological gardens the last survivor of a mighty host has served to call the attention of naturalists again to one of the most remarkable of all stories df Nature's library the extinction of one of the most remark able birds that ever inhabited the earth. Millions of people are still liv ing whose eyes have witnessed the flight of the myriad hosts of passen ger pigeons, and yet only one of all the vast numbers of those pigeons is known to survive and that one occupies a place of honor in the Cin cinnati Zoo.

See moreSee less

When he dies it is prob able that his body will be presented to the nation, to be preserved in alcohol at the National Museum. In these days it Is hard for the younger people to believe the story of the passenger pigeon, so incredi ble were their numbers, so remark able were their flights, and so strange were their meetings. And the story of the brutality that marked the work of the pot hunters who followed them as a tiger stalks his prey, re lentlessly pursuing them, using the telegraph to keep in touch with their flights and their nestings, is a story of revolting! cruelty and batchery. Audubon's Story of Illnln.

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

The article reflects on the near-total extinction of the passenger pigeon, noting only one survivor remains at the Cincinnati Zoo. It then retells John James Audubon's famous 1813 account of witnessing an immense, days-long flight of pigeons near the Ohio River.

El Paso Herald · 21 February 1913 · page 6

of revolting! cruelty and batchery. Audubon's Story of Illnln. The world Is indebted to John James Audubon, the great naturalist, for what Is perhaps the best account of the pas senger pigeon ever written. And his truthfulness and scientific accuracy malfe it a story to be accepted at its face value. He relates that in the au tumn of 1813 he left his house at Hen derson, on the banks of the Ohio, to go to Louisville. In passing over the bar rens a few miles from Hardensburgh he observed pigeons flying from the northeast to the southwest, in greater numbers than he had ever seen before.

See moreSee less

After they had been passing for about an hour he dismounted, seated himself on an eminence, and made a dot with a pencil, for every flock that passed. In a short time he found that he was putting down dots at the rate of 1C3 in 21 minutes. He resumed his Journey and still the pigeons came; the light of day was darkened as if by a solar eclipse. Like a torrent, "and with the roar of distant thunder, they gathered in a solid mass, darting forward with - the wings of the wind in undulating and angular lines, descending and sweeping close to the earth, then mounting perpendicularly so as to. re semble a vast column, and when high in the air once more, wheeling and twisting within their continued lines, which then resembled the coils of a gigantic serpent. Over Billion Pigeons In Flight.

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

The report recounts naturalist Audubon's famous descriptions of passenger pigeon flocks so vast they darkened the sky, estimating over a billion birds in a single flight. It also details his visit to a Kentucky roosting site, where the sheer number of birds broke trees and attracted hunters who slaughtered them by the thousands.

El Paso Herald · 21 February 1913 · page 6

gigantic serpent. Over Billion Pigeons In Flight. For 45 miles Audubon traveled on to Louisville, with the serried columns of pigeons still floating over his head, and for three days the flight continued. Each flock did exactly as the one ahead Had done; if the one ahead darted down when passing over a brook, or dodging & hawk the flock behind did the same Audubon attempted to estimate 'he number of pigeons in that great flight. He assumed that the column averaged a mile in width, which was far below the average in point of fact.

See moreSee less

Then he assumed that the birds flew at the rate of 68 miles an -ijour, also a conserva tive assumption. Upon this basis the pigeons passing in three hours would form a streak ISO square miles in area, and, counting two pigeons to the square yard, there would be nearly a billion and a quarter pigeons in such a flitrht. How many there must hare been in the three days' flight he did not undertaketo say. Audubon s ob servations were that each pigeon eats fully a half a pint of food a day. The pigeons in a three-hour flight would thus need nearly nine million bushels of food a day. Rixnt Three allies In Breadth.

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

A newspaper column mentions a previous day's Herald story by Haskin about a flight of one billion wild pigeons, used only as an exaggerated comparison to describe crowds of children getting circus tickets. The actual passenger pigeon story is not detailed here, only referenced in passing.

El Paso Herald · 22 February 1913 · page 6

when Truth shall be enthroned. Washington dead? It is a lie. Washington lives and lives eternally stern, human, kindly, just unselfish, moderate, orderly, shrewd, tireless, cheerful, wise, idealistic, practical, modest pleading suffering patient lonely Washington. i That flight of 1,000,000,000 wild pigeons that Haskin told about in yester day's Herald wasn't a circumstance to the sights around the Herald building when the kiddies were getting their circus tickets. o

See the clipping

The Times Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A 1913 newspaper review discusses a conservation book that catalogs North American bird species destroyed by human activity between 1840 and 1910, naming the passenger pigeon alongside the great auk, Labrador duck, and others. The review emphasizes the book's argument that game laws have been shaped by hunters rather than conservationists, and calls for reform to protect remaining wildlife.

The Times Dispatch · 23 February 1913 · page 44

1!'10. These species are: ?he great auk. Pallas cormorant, Labrador >\ >? V. passenger pigeon, Kakimo curlew, Cu ban, ? ;oosh?-> a rid 'Snndaloijpe rna'ovr. Ine \ellov. winged green parrot ;??,/] the purple <;uadaloup's parakeet of ' i""'lna \ partial J i ??? of bird* th r?-a t ?? i' > d V|f. ...rly extermination Includes rv,,.?t. adiuonal M.< A list i.f ri..imrri;i Ih extinct or r.eariy ? x tim t ih f jr :n? h?-fj, .? HtkT"

See the clipping