As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

February 1912

9 articles

The Bennington Evening Banner · Bennington, Vt.

The article reflects on the extraordinary decline of the once-abundant wild pigeon, noting flocks that used to take an hour to pass overhead in states like Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana less than forty years earlier. It states that while gunners killed vast numbers, many investigators believe other causes contributed to the species' total disappearance, calling it a puzzle likely never to be solved.

The Bennington Evening Banner · 7 February 1912 · page 2

The Wdd Pigeon Mystery. Thnt the wild pigeon, once so com mon tu tlit Fulled Slates, ha become exttui-t Is one of the strangest mys teries In American natural history. It Is a puzzle whlrh hus ballled scientists and which prohablv never will be solv-. pd. Less I tin 11 forty years ego wild pigeons were abundant In Pennsylva nia, Ohio. Indiana. Kentucky and all the states of the middle west. In their mlgmtlous ihey traveled In flocks num bering lens of thousand, and It some times took a single Hoik the better part of an buur to pus a given point.

See moreSee less

Vast number of the pigeons were killed every year bj gunners, but many investigator hold thnt the complete dlsnppca ranee of the species must have been due in part at least to othtr cause. No other bird wa ever so nu I lerous In Ibis country us the pigeon.

See the clipping

The Columbia Herald · Columbia, Tenn.

Officials of the American Game Protective and Propagation Association are lobbying in Washington for federal legislation to protect migratory birds. They cite the wild pigeon and Eskimo curlew as species already annihilated by unrestricted shooting, warning that woodcock and wood duck face similar fates without federal intervention.

The Columbia Herald · 9 February 1912 · page 7

URGE PROTECTION OF BIRDS BY LEGAL ENACTMENT OFFICIALS OF THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION ARE IN WASHINGTON. LAW AN ABSOLUTE NECESSITY

NEW YORK, Feb. 8. John B. Burnham, president, and William S. Haskell, vice president and counsel of the American Game Protective and Propagation Association of New York City, are in Washington to urge ihe ppssage ot a billl for federal pro tection of migration birds. Enlightened sportsmen throughout the country agree that such a bill is necessary to prevent the speedy and total extinction of certain migraats. They point to at least two caBes that of the wild pigeon and the es

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Officials of the American Game Protective and Propagation Association traveled to Washington to push for federal legislation protecting migratory birds. They cite the wild pigeon and Eskimo curlew as species already annihilated by unrestricted shooting during breeding season, warning the woodcock and wood duck face similar fate.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 11 February 1912 · page 15

MIGRATORY BIRDS NEED PROTECTION OF NATION

tlon of migratory birds. Enlightened sportsmen throughout Ai the country agree that such a bill is . necessary to prevent the speedy and . ■? total extinction of certain migrants. They point to at least two cases— that of the wild pigeon and the Es quimau curlew—In which shouting during the breeding season has le- . K suited In annihilation. The woodcock and wood duck are In Immediate dan- ?! ger of a like fate as a result of un restricted shooting.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Officials of a game protection association lobbied Congress for federal migratory bird protection laws, citing the wild pigeon's extinction as proof that unregulated hunting leads to annihilation. A constitutional amendment was proposed to give Congress explicit power to regulate such protections, since many states had failed to act.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

Evening Star · 11 February 1912 · page 6

STATES NEGLECT TO ACT

Game Protective and Propagation Association say, agree that a bill providing federal protection for migratory birds is necessary to prevent the speedy and total extinction of certain migrants. They point to at least two cases?that of the wild pigeon and the esquiinau curlew?in

See the clipping

Elk City Mining News · Elk City, Idaho

The report states that wild pigeons, once numbering in the tens of thousands during migrations, have mysteriously vanished from the United States within less than forty years. It notes that while hunters killed vast numbers annually, many investigators believe other causes must also have contributed to the species' complete disappearance.

Elk City Mining News · 15 February 1912 · page 1

THE WILD PIGEON MYSTERY

I bering teus of thousands, and it some ÏÏSSÜ y ast numbers of the pigeons were billed every year by gunners, but many Investigators hold that the complete disappearance of the species must have been due ln part a t least to other No other bird was ever so nu causes. >> I merous in this country as the pigeon.— >> New York MalL

See the clipping

The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

Game protection advocates lobby Congress for a federal law protecting migratory birds, citing the wild pigeon and Eskimo curlew as species already driven to extinction by unrestricted shooting during breeding season. They warn woodcock and wood duck face similar fates without federal intervention since many states fail to protect migratory birds.

The Clarksburg Telegram · 15 February 1912 · page 5

Bird Protection is to Be Asked of the Federal Congress.

NEW YORK, Feb. 8.?John B. Burnham, president , and William S. Haskell, vice-president and counscl of the American Game Protective and Propagation Association of New York City, left last night for 'Washington to urge the passage of a bill for feder al protection of migratory birds. Enlightened sportsmen throughout the country agree that such a bill Is necessary to prevent the sptfedy and total extinction of certain migrants. They point to at least two cases?that of the wild pigeon and the esquiniau

See the clipping

Philip Weekly Review · Philip, S.D.

This item muses on the near-extinction of the American buffalo, likening it to the dodo and the passenger pigeon as creatures whose time has passed. It claims the pigeon disappeared due to 'the high cost of living' while the buffalo was deliberately slaughtered by humans, and notes prehistoric bison relatives also went extinct.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Philip Weekly Review · 22 February 1912 · page 3

By E. W. Caldwell, in Farmer and Breeder Gone to join t)ie dodo bird and the passenger pigeon in the re litis of the Hasbeeit, the Ameri can buffalo is anothev creature whose future is behind it. But while the dodo bird winked out because it wasn't fit to survive, and the wild pigeon quit on ac count of the high cost of living the poor buffalo succumbed to the most merciless slaughter ever waged against any species that ever flew or ran in all the his tory of this old world ox ours.

See moreSee less

There have been seasons with in the time of men now living wli between the Alleghenies and the Rockies there roamed as many as 8,000,000 or 10,000,000 head of buffalo—enough to have af forded every voter at any Unitwithin that period a barbecue of an entire animal for himself since first for their transportation to the laid them down carloads every forty minutes in each and every day and night, Sundays included, for a whole year enough tonnage to much more than equal the total weight of all the men, women, and chil dren in the whole United States today. And all these monster herds, with all their millions of progeny, have been utterly wiped out within a single hu man generation. Today, so far as known, there isn't on this entire continent a single animal left from all those multiplied millions, except a few incarcerated as curiosities. in the last quarter of a century not a single buffalo robe has been sent to market, while only ten yea 1*8 earlier there were a mil lion and a half robes sold per annum. All this slaughter was per mitted to proceed without a sin gle effective protest on the part of anybody. Ten years after the extermination was practically con pi etc, laws were passed by one or perhaps more of the states pro hibiting the killing of buffalo— laws similar to those which now exist upon almost every statute book for protection of other game. Indeed, there have been instances where legislation regula ing the killing of game seemed to occupy the chief attention of the lawmakers. One of Iowa's very brightest lobbyists for wo men suffrage, after an unsuccess ful campaign before the assem bly, sarcastically accounted for Hie failure of her measure by saying in her report to the Sioux City Political Equality Club: "The senators and representa tives are very nice gentlemen but they hadn't time this winter for women suffrage because their work was so entirely taken up raising the age of eonsent for quails." B«t tiie American buffalo (more properly called the bison) as it has been known within his toric times, is not the first of its species to become extinct. At least two and perhaps five other varieties are known to have roam ed this continent in prehistoric ages, from Alaska to Florida. One of these varieties had horns that spread twelve feet from tip to tip. which it would seem might have been enough in itself to ex terminate the race, if the ani mals crowded together like those of later generations—so many of them would "get the hook." At any rate, these predecessors of the distinctive American bison were not slaughtered for their robes or their tongue? or their pemmican, nor for "sport," nor to make an In dian holiday. Nor were their bones subsequently gathered from plains and foothills and shipped by the thousands of train v, topsis: place world. of heaven i 1

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu

The article recounts the passenger pigeon's abrupt disappearance from billions to none, comparing it to a mysterious mass migration of wild turkeys in Michigan and an unexplained owl invasion in British Columbia in 1897. It notes the pigeons' vanishing was less fortunate than the turkeys' because no one ever learned where they went.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Hawaiian Star · 24 February 1912 · page 15

trtmnri where Atr Mvtr had bon auch same tofor. No satisfactory oxnUwatton of thai migration, nnnrwwHiBHtod, to far as knowm was ever made, but the en-m-nl opinion among tportttnen ac-1 It waa forced by the partition!, ex cottlve and Indlacrliulnnle raids of the market hunters on those birds. An equally strange migration of wild turkeys once occurred In Michigan. Those big game birds were plentiful In the Michigan woods and wore being hunted mercilcsHly by organized par ties In the employ of dealers in Chi cago and other cities. They disap peared from their haunts as suddenly and completely aB If they hud never been there.

See moreSee less

Hut thoy could not hide their exodus, their numbers wore so great. It is chronicled that the mi grating host was a quarter of a mile wide and was several hours in pass ing. They Journeyed westward and In the course of time wild turkeys Were reported as more plentiful in the districts of West Michigan, where they had been rarely seen before. The mysterious disappearance of the .passenger pigeon, of which there were millions In this country one day and not one to bo seen anywhero the next, had not as fortunate n sequel as that of tho Michigan wild turkeys, for no word has ever been heard as to where the wild pigeons went. An unaccountable appearance of birds In large numbers and of a kind not common to the region was that of the myriads of owls that suddenly came down on the game covers in tho Saanach district of British Columbia in 1S97 and played havoc with the pheasants, grouse and -quail, as well as with domestic poultry. Where they came from was and is a mystery. They were chiefly the Virginia, where it seems to be partial to crow's as prey. Of these raiding owls in that Northwestern area 500 were killed on Vancouver Island, 200 In the city of Victoria by sportsmen who rose in' arms against them. More than 1500 owls were killed In a few weeks where perhaps not fifty of any kind had ever been seen before. It was supposed that Intense cold weather had driven tno destructive birds from their homes farther north. Detroit FretPress.

See the clipping

Saturday News · Watertown, S.D.

A 1912 article about the near-extinction of the American buffalo briefly compares it to the dodo and the passenger pigeon, quipping that the pigeon's decline was due to 'the high cost of living.' This is a passing analogy within a larger piece focused on buffalo slaughter and extinction.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Saturday News · 29 February 1912 · page 1

MILLIONS THIRTY YEARS AGO Territory Where Buffalo Roamed Now Covered With Homes of Prosperous People By E. W. Caldwell. tioae to join the dodo bird and the passenger pigeon in the realm of the Hasbeen, the American buffalo is a nother creature whose future is be hind it. But while the dodo bird winked out because it wasn't fit to survive, and the wild pigeon quit on account of the high cost of living the poor buffalo succombed to the most merciless slaughter ever waged aga inst any species that ever flew or ran in all the history of this old world of ours.

See moreSee less

There have been seasons within the time of men now living when between the Alieghanles and the Rockies there roamed as many as 8,000,000 or 10, 000,000 head of buffalo—enough to have afforded every voter at any United States presidential election within that period a barbecue of an entire animal for himself alone—or enough to have required for their transportation to the Sioux City live stock market a train of twenty-five or thirty carloads every forty minutes in eack and every day and night, Sun days included for a whole year ton nage onoagh to much more than «q*4 tile total w^jght$f all the men, wome» and children In the whole United States today. And all these monster herds, with ill,their millions ot progeny, have been utterly, jsjped out witnin ii single human generaToday, so far as known, there isn't on this entire continent a single ani mal left from all those multiplied mil lions, except a few incarcerated as curiosities. In the last quarter of a century not a single buffalo robe has been sent to the market, while only ten years earlier there were a million and a half robes sold per year. All this slaughter was permitted to proceed without a single effective pro test on the part of anybody. Ten years after the extermination was practically complete, laws were pas sed by one or perhaps more of tho states prohibiting the killing of buf falo—laws similar to those whicjj now exist upon almost every statute book for protection of other game. Indeed, there have beeninstances where legislation regulating the kill ing of game seemed to occupy the chief attention of the lawmakers. One of Iowa's very brightest lobbyists for women suffrage, after an unsuccessful campaign before the assembly, sar chastically accounted for the failure of her measure by saying in her re port to the Sioux City Political Eqal ity Club: "The senators' and representatives are very nice gentlemen but they hadn't time this winter for women's suffrage because their work was so entirely taken up raising the age of consent for quails." Those who have witnessed the mon ster aggregations of bison herds on the western plains, frequently number ing hundreds of thousands, declare no literature can describe the scenes. A suggestive instance of their numbers .'?»nd power is the fact-that sometimos steamboats on the upper Missouri were compelled to stop on account or the stream being packed full of swim ming animals crossing in their semi annual migrations northward or south ward. In Joseph Mills Hanson's book, "Conquest of the Missouri," which is a story of the life and exploits of Capt Grant Marsh, well known from St. Louis to Fort Benton, is the fol lowing account of such an Incident --which' occurred upon an autnmn voy age of (he "Stockdale" something over forty years ago "As the 'Stockdale'approached Elk •Miora Prairie, the buffalo increased rapidly in numbers on either bank. Vast herds extendlngaway to the boric** Uae of the northwftnt bluffs. Wfcre moving slowly toward the river,

See the clipping