As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

June 1911

10 articles

The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D.

An Emerson Journal item describes flocks of 'wild pigeons' recently seen locally, which old-timers identify as genuine passenger pigeons after decades without sightings. The writer speculates these are scouts for a larger migration and urges hunters not to shoot them.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Pioneer Express · 2 June 1911 · page 4

Xeche, N. D., May 31.—While driving over rough country roads at the rate of twenty miles an hour late Monday, Cal vin Ferch and Jacob Hoehn were thrown from an automobile. Hoehn re ceived serious injuries. He was hurled through the air with terrific force, strik ing a barbed wire fence. Collector of Customs LaMoure made a trip to Cannonball, on the Standing Rock Indian reservation, in the south western part of the state, this week, on business in connection with inspecting and measuring boats on the Missouri. A large part of the way south of Mandan was made by team.

See moreSee less

Deputy Game Warden Dunlop, of St. Thomas asks us io warn people from de stroying birds eggs and killing birds pro tected by law. Particularly is this no tice directed to boys who are in the hab it of roaming around with small rifles shooting promiscuously at birds that en joy the same protection as do the prai rie chicken. The penalty is equally se vere on destroying nests. Mr. Dunlop afso warns people from setting gill nets the liv'er or ifcs tributaries, An argument was made by counsel in the Icelandic church issue at Grand Forks last week for the re-opening of the case on the ground that there was a mistake in the assumption of Judge Templeton that a certain numbered sec tion of the constitution of the local church had been repealed, though it so appeared in the evidence. As this clause of the constitution was the prin cipal foundation for the decision given, a rehearing might therefore cause a change in the previous judgment. Attorney Laxdal was in the city Mor. day night on business connected with the application for pardon of a man named Flint who lived near Drayton and was sent to the penitentiary for twenty years for rape. This is the least sentence allowed under the terms of the law, bnt as there are extenuating circumstances, those who are acquainted with the particulars think that the sen tence should be changed to five years whieh would allow his liberation in Au gust of this year. Flocks of wild pigeons have recently been seen in this vicinity, and old tim ers say th»y are the genuine articli. These birds were very numerous at one time, but quite suddenly disappeared, and the pigeon has been lost track of for many years. Probably these here now are only forerunners to get the lay of the land and investigate prospects for a big immigration. They should receive every encouragement to multiply in this land of promise, and "gunnstera" ought not to waste ammunition in the destruc tion of these birds.—Emerson Journal. The Winnipeg Free Press says the list of students successful in securing schol arships at Harvard this spring' includes Thosbergur Thorwaldson, of the Mani toba college, who secured the highest scholarship granted by Harvard, the Hooper travelling fellowship of 91,150. Mr. Thorvaldson is a candidate for the degree of doctor of philosophy in physi cial chemistry this spring, and intends fo study during the coming year in Ger many, doing researth work in photo chemistry under Luther at Dresden.

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

The article recalls old-time pigeon hunters in New Hampshire and reflects on the once-abundant wild pigeon now vanished from the region. It reprints a Wisconsin reader's query asking whether reports of millions of passenger pigeons still existing in Alabama could be true, despite the species being considered extinct.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Mirror and Farmer · 8 June 1911 · page 8

8 THERE are not a few men living in New Hampshire today who remem ber when wild pigeons were as plentiful in this state as crows, when they were netted for the markets in this vicinity by the hundreds of doz en, and when men like the late James Thompson of Hooksett, "Pigeon" Parker of Merrimack, David Sprague of Bedford and others will known to those whose memory runs back 40 and 50 years ago, made good money in the pigeon business. Mr. Thompson once told the writer that when wild pigeons became scarce in New England he followed them to the grain fields of the West, and staid with them until the business of pigeon catching there, as in the country the birds had forsaken, became no longer profitable.

See moreSee less

The subject of this once favored bird, whose flesh formed, in the old-timer's opinion, a more delicious morsel for the table than either partridge, quail, wood cock or plover, is one which has not yet grown old, and the following from the Milwaukee Wisconsin has a bearing on it which will be read with Interest by those who recall 'the pigeon, and by others who have so often listened to stories of that once beautiful game bird of the North. , "A man told me," says a subscriber of the Wisconsin, writing to that paper, "that carrier pigeons, such as we used to have in Wisconsin by the million, are so numerous in the state of Alabama at this time that the farmers have appealed to the state legislature for permission to exterminate them. Can that be true, when we have b^en told for years that they are an extinct species? It is not more than a year or so ago that ^ome man offered a thousand dollars for one specimen, dead or alive. If you can give the information it would afford me great pleasure." * * * To the foregoing The Wisconsin made reply as follows: The pigeons which were formerly so numerous in Wisconsin are usually known by the name of wild pigeons or wood pigeons. Within less than a year there have been offers of considerable sums for live specimens and for precise infor mation as to their eggs and nests and the places in which they were found. There have been reports of the discovery of the birds in various localities, some of them in Wisconsin. Not long ago the statement was published that wood pig eons are still numerous in Alabama, and that the farmers there kill them when ever they can, believing that the de struction which they inflict ,on grain crops more than offsets their value as insect destroyers. On the other hand, there have been protests by ornithologists against this slaughter, and warnings that unless birds are given greater chance for existence than is accorded them at the present time in the United States insect pests will inevitably increase, to the se rious detriment of agriculture. There are extremists on both sides of the argument, and the . hue and cry to the effect that wood pigeons have been utterly exterminated in the United States was no doubt exaggerated. The extrem ists will take the stand that observance of the close season for birds and other game should not be required of farmers often resort to assertions that deer in eastern states are becoming so numerous as to menace the farmer's welfare, and it is quite possible chat complaints in the same spirit have been made of late regarding pigeons in Alabama, though the Evening Wisconsin . has not seen them. It is hardly conceivable that there can be a plague of wild pigeons in Ala bama in this year of grace, but quite possible that some Alabama farmers who consider pigeons good eating and be grudge the birds every mouthful which they gather in planted fields are restive a't any restriction put upon .the shooting or trapping of pigeons by farmers at any season of the year. Two wildcats that made their den in the ruins of the old farmhouse in which -Jake Moore and his aged housekeeper were found murdered more than ten years ago were killed by Fred Steiger and Wash Trenchard, local hunters. Together the cats weighed 55 pounds. For weeks the animals had terrorized the inhabitants of South Bushville, N. Y., with hideous cries at night, which at times could not be dis tinguished from those of a child. Women were afraid to venture out after dark, and the male population remained at home rather than take a chance at put ting an end to the disturbance. When the nows reached Steiger and Trenchard that big game positively exist ed in the swamp near Bushville they were not slow in getting together the best pack of hounds in town for an attack. Well aimed. the men drove to the Moore prop erty. and there let the dogs loose. It be came apparent that in order to rout the game, which evidently was concealed un der the debris partly filling the excava tion, it was necessary for one of them to go down into the pit while the other re mained on guard at the top. This Steiger concluded to do, and unstrapping his car tridge belt he made one end fast to a floor timber, and with the other end low ered himself to the bottom. One after an other the dogs plunged headlong into the cellar after their master. Removing a pile of boards, Steiger saw a pair of green eyes staring at him not more than three feet away. He reached for his gun and fired one barrel. As he did so out jumped two full-grown wildcats spitting and. snarling with rage. The next instant saw Stieger in a hand-to-hand conflict with them, supplemented by half a dozen dogs, while Trenchard looked on powerless to assist his companion. By good luck Stei ger succeeded in killing one of the cats as it was attempting to get away through the cellar drain, and the other was shot by Trenchard after it had fought off the dogs and was trying to escape across the fields. * * * It has taken Fisk Goodyear of Brush town two years to train his pet squirrels, but his efforts are now repaid. Gathering half a hundred or more of gray squirrels, Mr. Goodyear taught them to go into the woods and pick up nuts, carrying them to his home. On a night soon to come, at a dinner, his guests will notice a small board running from a window to a nut bowl. The host will give one knock on the table with his knife. A squirrel will hop down the plunk and drop a chestnut in the bowl. Two raps will bring a squir rel with a walnut; three knocks a shell bark. Finally a grave old squirrel will take his place and crack the nuts, wind ing up the performance by brushing off the crumbs with his thick, bushy tail. , Jim Gordon, a Texas range rider for W. W. Wilkins, whose big ranch is over near Howard tyells, was' surprised the other morning to see a large, black bear lumbering along ahead of him. It was in a rough locality and the bear was evi dently out to get its morning meal of sotol roots. Gordon stuck his "rails" into the horse and took after the bear. When he got within throwing distance he deftly circled the noose of his rope over the bear's head. The cow pony sat back on its haunches and drew the rope taut. The bear got orie of its paws un derneath the noose and prevented the rope from choking it into submission. Then began a struggle that lasted for more than an hour. Gordon dismounted and attacked the bear at close quarters with a knife. He had no other weapon. The bear rushed at him and knocked him down, uu: was prevented by the rope from following up its advantage. Thus the fight went on. Finally Gordon got hold of the rope, managed to tighten the noose so that the bear's wind was tem porarily shut off. and then rushed in and cut the jugular vein of the animal. An enormous silver tip bear gave Bean McCutcheon and two of his cowboys a lively race in the Davis Mountains. McCutcheon's pack of 'bear dogs had done good work in hunting black bears but had never run up against a silver tip. On this occasion they got on the scent of a bear and ran into a thicket. In a few minutes out came the dogs, yelping at every jump, with a big silver tip bear in close pursuit. When the bear saw the men on horses it turned Its attention to them and charged right at one of the cowboys with McCutcheon. Before any one could fire a shot all three horses broke away. One of the cowboys dropped his rifle and the other was carried away bv his frightened horse. McCutcheon got his horse under control with much diffi duced. culty and waited for the lumbering bear to come within good shooting distance. He fired at close range and the bullet struck the. animal, but did not stop it. The horse made another plunge and McCutcheon was thrown off. He managed to keep hold of his rifle and placed a bullet in a vital spot of Bruin just as the bear was about to lay hold on him. The deer which inhabit the canons leading into Devil's river are of an un usually .vicious nature. Belvis Sorge, who owns the Alamos Ranch, down In Crock ett county, will bear the marks which one of the big bucks gave him as long as he lives. Sorge and three or four men from his ranch pitched camp near the mouth of Dolan's creek for a hunt. The other members of the party made an early getaway one morning. Sorge had some things to attend to around camp and he remained behind. He was stand ing with his back to the creek, driving down a tent pin with an axe, when he heard a sudden rush behind him. and be fore be could turn to see what it was he was knocked half way up the side of the tent. Th* shock of the blow caused him to drop the axe, and he found himself on the ground with a buck standing over him, shaking its antlered head in rage. The animal turned its head sideways and struck Sorge on the right side of the face with one of its sharp pointed prongs. It ripped a long gash in the flesh and caused a flow of blood that nearly blind ed Sorge. The one-sided battle would probably have resulted in the death of gorge but for, the fact that he managed to get hold of the axe. He broke the an imal's front legs at the first two blows. It turned to flee, but could not make much headway in its crippled condition, and was soon overtaken by Sorge and killed. periment.

See the clipping

Forest City Press · Forest City, S.D.

An old hunter reminiscing in Outing Magazine contrasts a small flock of teal ducks with the once-immense flights of wild pigeons he remembered in Pennsylvania, so thick they blocked the sun. He begins recounting a strange hunting experience from one autumn when rabbits were scarce, but the passage cuts off before explaining the pigeons' disappearance.

Forest City Press · 15 June 1911 · page 3

Why the Pigeons Disappeared From the Outing Magazine. "Yes, there's a few ducks out there," and had Just got. to the barn lot when a flight of pigeons went over. They was just, above my head and when I

See the clipping

San Antonio Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The article recalls the passenger pigeon's path from incredible abundance to sudden disappearance, prompted by a news dispatch claiming two possible passenger pigeons were found nesting near Independence, Missouri. It recounts the species' former overwhelming numbers and the methods used to slaughter them by the millions before they vanished entirely.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

San Antonio Light · 15 June 1911 · page 6

THE PASSENGER PIGEON One of the greatest tragedies of modern times has been recalled by a news dispatch from Inde pendence, Mo., which states that two strange birds have been lo cated in the woods near that place and that they are (believed to be passenger pigeons. Scouts have been stationed at a distance from their home and nobody is allowed to approach too near for fear of frightening the birds, which are busily engaged in rais ing a small family, feater an ef fort will be made to capture them and propagate the species under conditions approaching as nearly as possible to their wild state.

See moreSee less

Forty years ago there were in the United States more passenger pigeons than birds of any other species. In the spring when they flew from the south to north they were slaughtered by the million without the slightest apparent im pression on their numbers. They came so thickly thaL. a flock of them would darken the sky like a cloud. Hunters would seat themselves on the ground, dis daining to walk after the game. They would fire only at birds passing directly overhead, not 'considering it worth while to point the gun to one side. At night the pigeons would settle in the woods in such numbers that men would knock them to the ground by striking the branches with clubs. So many were drilled that they sold for 50 cents a bar rel and there were no purchasers. Other stories could be told of their countless numbers which, although absolutely true, would sound incredible. Year after year they came and went in this way. Then one year they failed to come. They never came again. What became of the millions and millions of pigeons is a mys tery that no man has ever solved. It has been claimed that they flew one year too far to the north, and, being caught by sudden cold weather, were all frozen to death. Others have said that they were destroyed in forest fires or blown out to sea and drowned. No sat isfactory explanation has ever been offered for their disappear ance, but somehow and some where in a few brief months one of the most beautiful birds of North Anierica, which was also one of its best and most numer ous game birds, became practical ly extinct. It was a bird tragedy of appalling dimensions and the pity of it is that it never had and will never have an historian. The St. Louie burglar who carried a Bible in his kit merely shaped his life according to a paragraph he had un derlined in the good book: “Seek and ye shall find.” His trouble appeared to be that the police did some seeking and found him. » New Jersey, we are told, sinks 21 inches every 100 years. A state which mothers so many wicked trusts is doomed, and we are surprised that the rate of linkage la not 34 inches In St*-hours. The lowa man who learned the sign language in order to woo and win a deaf mute maiden took heroic meas ures to insure curtaln-lecture-laaa nlghta Because he did not want a woman on h!s "party" Une. a Connecticut man chopped down the telephone poles. Thia man was determined not to pay for something he could never use. In the light of « Bapttot minister’s explanation that six tuma the hair gray, one is surprised to find that more trust barons are not grizzled.

See the clipping

The Celina Democrat · Celina, Ohio

George Hedrick of Ft. Recovery, Ohio writes that he saw fifty or sixty wild pigeons flying near him, the first he had seen in over twenty years. He insists they were the true wild pigeon, recalling how he used to net them by the sackful as a boy on his father's farm.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Celina Democrat · 23 June 1911 · page 1

FAMOUS WILD PIGEONS THAT ONCE RULED THE ROOST

IRE GRIM REAPER ! Mamie Hay, aged 17 years, a daugh ter of Mr. and Mrs. Perry Hay, resid ing three miles northeast of Cold water, died after a brief Illness last Monday morning with uremic convulsions She was stricken on Sunday, but died without regaining consciousness, The decascd was born in this county. Funeral services were conducted Wednesday morning from the Spring Valley Church. Interment in Swamp College Cemetery. Mrs. Samuel Granger, aged 31, died early yesterday morning, following an operation for relief from appendi citis last Sunday morning. The de ceased was well known in the west part of the county, and was much ad mired among her acquaintances for her many virtues.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Granger is survived by her husband and three small children, one a babe of three months. She is also survived by her venerable mother Mrs. Elnoro Adams and three sisters and three brothers. The former are Mesdames James Spriggs, Tom Sloane and Alva Smritb. The brothers are Robert, Frank and Sherman Adams. Jitnios Hankins, aged Ho years, a veteran of tho Civil War and well known resident, died at his borne at Mendon at 4 o'clock last Friday after noon, following a brief illness. On Wednesday of last week ho suffered stroke of paralysis which left him in a semiconscious condition from which he never ralliod. He was tho father of ono son, who has not been heard of for several years. He is survived by ono brother, John Hankins, of Lock Two, and a nelce, Mrs. Cynthia Parrot, who has cured for him since the death or his wlfo. Funeral, services were hold nt Botbol Church, east of Mendon, Sunday afternoon, followed by interment at the cometery nearby. FAMOUS WILD PIGEONS

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

An old hunter reminisces about hunting wild pigeons (passenger pigeons) in Pennsylvania decades earlier, describing flocks so dense they blocked the sun. He recounts an exaggerated anecdote about shooting into a flock and his son later gathering a basket full of pigeon legs that had been shot off.

Yorkville Enquirer · 23 June 1911 · page 4

tumorous Jcpartmrut. Good Hunting. "Yes. there's a few ducks out there, remarked the old hunter as he gaze out across the marsh at the cloud c teal "milling" up and down in th storm, but they don't compare to th wild pigeons that used to be back i Pennsylvania. Why, sir, I nave se* the pigeons so thick back there that i we wanted to tell the time of day b the sun we would have to throw up club through the flight before he coul see it. "I mind me one time of the queer est experience I ever had.

See moreSee less

I was on hunting rabbits with an old muske It was late in the fall and the rah bits weren't very thick. I was comin home and had Just got to the barn 1c when a flight of pigeons went ovei They were Just above my head an when I looked up I thought that a cy clone was coming. As they passed I u with my old musket and let drive. B gosh, I never got a pigeon. "I went on into the house some dis gusted. Pretty soon my boy went ou with a basket to gather up some chip for a Are and when he come back h had that bushel baskpt full of legs, had shot under them pigeons and jus cut their legs off. The next day w went down to where they roosted I: the timber back of the house and g4th ered up the birds. They couldn't sit 01 the limbs, so they fell off and were ly ing on the ground."?Outing Magazine

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The writer notes that sportsmen and naturalists alike cannot explain the disappearance of the once-abundant wild pigeon. He recalls that within living memory, flocks so vast passed overhead that they darkened the sky for hours, with numbers once estimated in the hundreds of millions across the United States and Canada.

The Washington Herald · 25 June 1911 · page 43

W"-"""l HAT 1ms become of the wild pigeons, SWnwmllITniMn& Iy recurring question, which sports4Ulll?l7 lIlltt'B'sS men and uaturulisU ore alike unable WmW W8 1 to answer. Ml iMMfll 7 k that, even at that comparatidly recent date, the birds were, at certain Reasons, to be found

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The writer reminisces about the once-unimaginable abundance of passenger pigeons that darkened the sky for hours, and questions why they have nearly vanished despite the species' vast numbers exceeding any human slaughter. He theorizes the birds died off because deforestation destroyed their nesting grounds, leaving them unable to reproduce, and promises a personal account from 1832 Upper Canada.

The Washington Herald · 25 June 1911 · page 43

1 to answer. Ml iMMfll 7 k that, even at that comparatidly recent date, the birds were, at certain Reasons, to be found in hundredof thousands, almost everywhere in the United States and Canada, between the thirtieth and forty-eighth imrullels of north latitude. Whether they were ever plentiful to the north or south of these lines I cannot, of my own knowledge, nay, though some writers as sort that they ranged all the way from 25 degrees to 02 degrees: but I do know that,, within thehrst-named belt, their abounding numbers might have been at one time more loircctly estimated by hundreds of -millions, ra thcr than by tliousands.

See moreSee less

There arc many persons j et living who can remember when, in the first half of this cen tury, it was not unusual to sec pigeons pass ing over, in Hocks so vast and numbers so incalculable, that for hours nt such times the face of the hcacns was totally obscured; and when, these same flocks alighted, to rest or feed, immense tracts of land and great acrw of fores were completely covered by them. ' Where, then, have the birds gone? How ac ccuiit for their almost total disappearance? Do they still exist in considerable numbers " any part of this continent? If so, where? What region of America's temperate tone has not been mprc or less thoroughly explored rnd reporU-d upon, and ct. what tiaclcr says that he has anywhere found a solution of the mjBtery? Notwithstanding the act that, year after j car, in the olden time, tnj rinds of pigeons were shot, trapped and otherwise destrojed, tenfold the greatest slaughter ever made in their ranks by man was no more tlian a drop in the bucket, compared with their total num bers. Nor can it be reasonably maintained that, because of incessant persecution, the bird has merely changed its habitat, for this hy pothesis bring us once more to the query. ''Where is it?" " No, the wild pigeons have died off have be come nearly extinct, and, m my opinion, the reason is not far to seek. Their nesting haunts, alwayB located in tlv heart of dense forests, or in the depths o great, dry swamps, have been swept nway by the ax and fire of an cvt-r-tncroacJung civiliza tion, and the harassed birds, finding no safe re treat in which to rear their young, have sim ply ceased to reproduce. . It may be, too, that, in so far as the needs of our people are concerned, the pigeon's mis sion has been fulfilled, for we Know that, in the enrlv pioneer das, the herdless settler depended upon its annua) nnd frequently upon s semi-annual visits to supply no inconsider able portion of his spring andsummer food. It may interest the jouth of this generation to learn from an old-timer how exceedingly plentiful thwe. biida onec were, aniT I will preface my story by assuring the reader that every statement herein made is strictly true and the facts in no manner exaggerated. Early in the month of May, 1832, when I waa just past eight years of ngc, my father, then residing on a large, partly-cleared farm, in the province of Upper Canada, sixteen mUca northwest of little York, now Toronto, gac me permission to join several other bos and n party of grown .men our scattered neigh borsin an expedition to a "pigeon roost," which, we were informed, was in the town

See the clipping

Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis.

A small-town Wisconsin newspaper column from July 1872 notes that wild pigeons are numerous in the area, with hunters out shooting them from as early as three in the morning. It also reports on other local news items like livery business, visitors, and a marriage.

Wausau Pilot · 27 June 1911 · page 1

SATURDAY, JULY 27, 1872. Pigeons are taking their leave, and the hunters mourn their loss. We regret that Hon. W. D. Mcln doe is slowly declining, and there are but little hopes for ills recovery. Dan Scott lias put anew stage on tiie road between here and Jenny. It has springs, and spring seats. Dan proposes to run a daily stage. Doc. Bentley’s express is running daily between Wausau and Jenny. W. C. Silverthorn, M. H. Barnum, Jacob Kolter and others, with a view of seeing tiie country, went to Rib Falls on Wednesday afternoon. While in that town they were entertained by John Baeseman.

See the clipping

The Ocala Banner · Ocala, Fla.

A hunter reminisces about abundant wildlife in Michigan during his youth, including skies darkened by migratory pigeons, contrasting it with the depleted game of today. He notes the wild pigeon is now understood to be practically extinct, and recommends Florida as one of the last refuges for sportsmen.

The Ocala Banner · 30 June 1911 · page 4

There was much timber, and those woods were full of squirrel, partridge, quail, wild turkey, and often we would see a company of deer. During all the year the lakes and ponds were full of Mallards and woods ducks, while in the spring and fall the migra tory ducks came in innumerable hosts. The migratory pigeons would sometimes literally darken the sky. Now, there is little forest left. Once in a while a stray squirrel still makes a home in a hollow tree. You might, in a day s hunt, start a covey of quail, but probably you would not, and occasionally one sees a partridge or a few Mallards, but the summer, or woods ducks, and the pigeons are not there, and I understand that the wild pigeon is practically extinct.

See moreSee less

All

See the clipping