As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

January 1910

11 articles

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report describes two passenger pigeon specimens owned by Walter Rothschild, tracing their provenance from hunters in New York and the St. Lawrence River to the last known individuals shot near Grand Manan and by J.G. Bell. It recounts the species' dramatic decline from massive flocks in the Hudson Valley and Michigan in the 1860s-70s, where millions were slaughtered for cheap markets, to near-total disappearance by the time of writing, with only captive birds remaining in zoos and private collections.

The Washington Herald · 5 January 1910 · page 6

You see how carefully the roll is called and identifications are made when the battle is over. The battle is about over for the beautiful passenger pigeon. In 188 it came down the Hudson River in such numbers that the then owner of Claremont, near the place where Grant's tomb now is, shot from his reof 1 in a morning, Twenty-eight years later a “plgeon nesting” near Petoskey, Mich., occupied an area twenty-eight miles long, averaging four miles wide. That season (according to freighting records) 1,000, 000,000 passenger pigeons were destroyed in Michigan, when roosting, by guns, bludgeons, and pots of sulphur.

See moreSee less

Rall roads had been lald, and markets were ready. The birds sold in New York for a cent apiece, Nobody has noticed a passenger pigeon, and proved it, since i900. The only at tested living specimens for years past were in captivity. A few were in the Cincinnat! zoo, a few in Milwaukee; oth ery had been bred from a single pair owned by Prof, C. O. Whitman, of Chi cago University. Six years ago Prof. Whitman's refused further to interbreed. All that were known were presently dead, except one male in Cincinnati and one female in the Whitman aviary. The lone female was sent to the disconsolate male. Of the tremendous flocks which once flew over the I'nited States, only those two birds are left,

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The article describes a large pigeon farm near North Wales, Pennsylvania, that raises squabs for sale to major East Coast markets. It notes that wild pigeon flocks of 20,000 birds, once common in American forests a century or two earlier, are now rarely seen.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 9 January 1910 · page 31

probably but one place In the entlr , United States where so large a flock I of pigeons can be found, anil that Is j on a pigeon farm near the little town j of North Wales, In southeastern Pennj sylvania. ; Tho birds are boused in a series of | large, airy buildings and provided with ] clean and comfortable nests, an abundance of choice food and a suffi cient screened outdoor space wherein to exercise the!,, wrings. All day long, the gentle cooing of the thouands of birds gives musical proof of their con tentment.

See moreSee less

In return for their board j and lodgings they ar» expected to hatch ! out as many squabs as possible and rear I them until they arc tit for.the market. I From this farm is obtained the greater j proportion of the squabs that go to tho markets of New York, Philadelphia and ; the various winter and summer resorts of the east. Pigeon raising, says Mr. K. C. Cum mings. the man who founded and de veloped this farm, Is more profitable and less vexatious than poultry rais ing, provided the man who undertakes It thoroughly understands the habits and the needs of pigeons. Almost everyone knows something about raising chickens, or thinks he does, and four town dwellers out of five like to dream of a time In tho future when they may own little places out In the country and raise chickens and j supply eggs for tho city markets. Hut pigeon raisins on a large scale and sole ly for profit has been undertaken In few instances thus far. notwithstanding tha high prices which squabs command. To begin with, no incubators are re quired in raising pigeons and thus an Important Item of expense necessary on the poultry farm Is saved. Pigeons are remarkable for their monogamous habits, and when once the cock and the lien are suitably mated they re main firmly attached to each other. Roth assume equal shares In the duties of their household, including the lncubatlom ; of the eggs and the care of the young. However, the matter of mating must be well studied to avoid losses for In a mlsmated or lllassorted pen the cocks, J unlike the proverbial dove of peace, are ; likely to create great havoc, destroying squabs and eggs In fighting for the pos session of nests. At the Cummins farm all Is harmony for only well-ihated birds are Introduced into the pens.

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

The article traces the passenger pigeon from massive 19th-century flocks—including a billion birds destroyed in a single Michigan nesting season—to its near-disappearance by 1910. It notes only three mounted specimens survive worldwide with documented histories, and that just two living birds remain, a male in Cincinnati and a female sent from Professor Whitman's aviary to join him.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 13 January 1910 · page 16

Institution nt Washington. You seo how carefully the roll Is callpd and identifications aie made when the battle Is over. The battle Is nbout over for the beautiful passenger pigeon. In 1S It enmo down lb" Hudson river In such numbers that the then owner of "Clnremont." near the place whoto Grant's tomb now Is, shot ftom his roof 100 In a morning. Twenty-eight years Inter it "pigeon nesting" near Petoskey, Mich,, occupied an era 2S miles long, averaging four mlle wide. Thot season (according to freighting records) a bil lion passenger pigeons were destroyed In Michigan, when roosting, by guns,

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This report reflects on the sudden disappearance of the once-countless wild pigeon flocks from western New York and speculates on their fate. It repeats an unverified rumor that vast pigeon flocks were seen on an island near Tiburon in the Gulf of California, suggesting survivors may persist in remote regions beyond human reach.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New-York Tribune · 16 January 1910 · page 58

volume is the ampere. Resistance is also myriads of wild pigeons. ; ro We repeat this story ‘with the same serve maintained toward all similar ments about these bitds which have SU Still, it is the firm belief of mah nat ceded it. the wild pigeons of -their youth.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The report recalls the once-vast flocks of wild (passenger) pigeons remembered by older residents of Western New York and notes a rumor of a huge flock sighted on an island near the Gulf of Guinea. The writer treats the rumor skeptically but muses that the birds may have relocated to remote wilderness rather than been wiped out.

New-York Tribune · 16 January 1910 · page 58

volume is the ampere. Resistance is also precious metals were found in the ‘SFL of baron, 0 the Gulf of ive, weeks a party which recently spen there, the island fairly swarmed myriads of wild pigeons. ; ro We repeat this story ‘with the same serve maintained toward all similar

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The article discusses the high prices paid by collectors for rare and extinct bird specimens and eggs, such as the Labrador duck, great auk, and Carolina parakeet. It notes that a living passenger pigeon, by this time nearly or already extinct, would command an extraordinarily high price if found.

The Washington Times · 19 January 1910 · page 13

HIGH BRED BIRDS BRING BIG PRICES

England, a Labrador duck for 32! 000 John ILewis Childs, of Long Island. bought one in Liverpool for $1,086, and afterward sold it to John E. Thaver. of Massachusetts, for 35000, with some other birds to boot. A Hving specimen of this or of the passenger pigeon would bring forth amazingly high bids. Mr. Childs paid $10 each for three eggs of the Carolina parakeet. Eggs of the extinct great auk have cos: Mr. Thayer £1,206 each, and as no more will ever be laid the future price will he whatever owner and prospective buyer can agree upon.

See moreSee less

The expense gf maintaining a searcher in the field is from $106 to $20 a month, when boats or assistants are not neces sary. When they are necessary the cost may be doubled or trebled. At this rate Mr. Childs’ four eggs of the ivory billed woodpecker—which it took three years to get—may be reckoned to have repre sented an expenditure in money of 35,000 at the least—3%1,2506 an egg.

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

The article recounts extinct birds like the dodo, great auk, and Labrador duck, noting how few specimens remain and detailing their last sightings. It then transitions to the passenger pigeon, noting it was so numerous in 1848 that it darkened the sky over the Hudson River, but is now nearly extinct.

The Detroit Times · 19 January 1910 · page 10

Labrador duck was common in the markets. Sailors easily shot and brought it to port by thousands. Now only three are preserved in all the world. Walter Rothschild, of Eng land, has two of them—one obtained from Gordon Plummer of Brookline. Massachusetts, who bought it in Ful ton Market, New York, in 1860; the other from William Dutcher, of New York, by whom it was received from the widow of a man named Thomp son, who shot it in the St. Lawrence river In 1832. • Nine years afterward, one was killed on Grand Manan, and four years later the last to be known shot by J.

See moreSee less

G. Bell, who sold Its skin to the Smithsonian Institution at Washington. You see how' carefully the roll Is called and identifications are made when the battle Is over! The battle is about over for the beautiful pas senger pigeon. In 1848 It came down the Hudson river in such numbers

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

The report traces the species' destruction from mass shooting at Claremont to the vast 1878 Petoskey, Michigan nesting where a billion birds were killed by guns, clubs, and sulfur fires enabled by railroads and markets. It states no wild pigeon has been confirmed since 1900, leaving only two captive birds—a male in Cincinnati and a female from Professor Whitman's aviary—as the species' last survivors.

The Detroit Times · 19 January 1910 · page 10

I that the then ow ner of “Claremont,'* near the place where Grant’s Tomb ; now !s, shot from his roof one hun dred in a morning. Twenty-eight years later a “pigeon nesting” near Petoskey. Michigan, occupied an area i twenty-eight miles long, averaging ' four miles wide. That season (accord ling to freighting records) u billion pas : senger pigeons were destroyed In Michigan, when roosting, by guns, bludgeons, and pots of sulphur. Rail roads had been laid, and markets were ready. The birds sold in New York for a cent apiece.

See moreSee less

Nobody has noted a passenger pigeon, and proved It, since 1900. The only attested living specimens for . years past were in captivity. A few were in the Cincinnati Zoo, a few in Milwaukee; others had been bred from a single pair owned by Professor C, O. Whitman, of Chicago Unlver : sity. Six years ago, Professor Whit : man’s refused further to interbreed,

See the clipping

Newark Evening Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.

The article discusses prices paid for rare bird specimens, including a Labrador duck sold for thousands of dollars and eggs of the extinct great auk costing $1,200 each. It notes that a living passenger pigeon specimen would command astonishingly high bids, implying the species' growing rarity.

Newark Evening Star and Newark Advertiser · 21 January 1910 · page 13

Thero aro no "prices current” for rare birds, as for coins, or stamps, or orchids, or diamonds; nor is there any great murt with settled quotations, like that for. furred animals, In Hamburg. Individual birds frequently fetch sur prising sums. Wiliam Dutcher, of New Yprk, sold to Walter ItothschUd, of England, a Labrador duck for $1,000. John Lewis Childs, of Long Inland, bought one in Liverpool for $1,000. and afterward sold -it to John B. Thayer, of Massachusetts, for $6,000, with some other birds to boot. A living specimen of this or of the passenger pigeon would bring forth amusingly high bids.

See moreSee less

Mr. Childs puid $100 each for thfec eggs of the Carolina parrakeet. Eggs of the extinct great auk have cost Mr. Thayer $1,200 each, and as no more will ever be laid, the future price will oe whatever owner and prospective buyer can agree upon, says the writer in Everybody’s. The expense of maintain ing a searcher In the field Is from $10<i to $200 a month, when boats or as sistants aro not necessary. When they are necessary, the cost may bo doubled or trebled. At tills rate, Mr. Chllds't four eggs of the ivory-btlled wood pecker—which It took three years tr got—muy be reckoned to have repre sented an expenditure, in money of $6, 000 at the least—$1,250 an ogg.

See the clipping

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

Everybody's Magazine surveys recently vanished birds like the dodo and Labrador duck, then turns to the passenger pigeon's collapse from billions in 1878 Michigan nestings to near nothing. It reports that only two captive birds remain, one in Cincinnati and one sent from Professor Whitman's Chicago aviary.

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 26 January 1910 · page 9

Washington. i You see how ecarefully the roll is called and identifications are made when the battle is ever! The battle is about over for the beautiful passenger pigeon. In 1848 it came down the Hudson river in such numbers that the then owner of “Claremont,” near the place where Grant’s tomb now is, shot from his roof 100 in a morning. Twenty-eight years later a ‘‘pigeon nesting”’ near Petoskey, Mich., occupied an area twenty-eight miles long, averaging four miles wide. That season, (according to freighting rec ords) a billion passenger pigeons were de stroyed in Michigan, when roosting, by guns, bludgeons and pots of sulphur.

See moreSee less

Railroads had been laid and markets were ready. The birds sold in New York for a cent apiece. Nobody has noted a passenger pigeon, and proved it, since 1900. The only at tested living specimens for years past were in captivity. A few were in the Cincinnati Zoo, a few in Milwaukee; others had been bred from a single pair owned by Prof. C. O, Whitman of Chica go university. Six years ago Professor Whitman refused further to interbreed. All that were known were presently dead, except one male in Cincinnati and one female in the Whitman aviary. The lone female was sent to the ‘disconsolate male. Of the tremendous flocks which flew over the United States only these two birds are left.

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

Dr. Clifton Hodge of Clark College announced cash rewards for anyone who finds an undisturbed nest of wild passenger pigeons, including $300 from Col. Anthony Kuser and $100 offers from author William Mershon and bird imitator Edward Avis for specific states. The effort aims to raise awareness about preserving the species, which the report states is rapidly becoming extinct.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 27 January 1910 · page 12

I disturbed nest of wild passenger pigeons, in addition to the offer of S3OO by Col I Anthony R. Kuser. William B, Mershon, I author of the "Passenger Pigeon." has | offered SIOO for tin first nest to Infound in the state of Michigan, and Edward Avis, the bird imitator, has made a like offer for the state of Connecticut. John E. Thayer of Lancaster has made five SIOO offers to be distributed among the states of the I nion and the provinces of Canada, for which no local awards are made. Dr Hodge hopes to awaken inter est throughout the country in the preser vation of this species of pigeons, which is rapidly becoming extinct.

See the clipping