As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

April 1909

8 articles

The Plymouth Tribune · Plymouth, Ind. · and 8 other papers

William Dutcher, president of the National Association of Audubon Societies, warns that killing insect-eating birds costs America $500,000,000 annually in crop losses. He urges continued vigilance in bird protection legislation, citing the extinction of the bison and wild pigeon as a wasteful legacy future generations should not repeat.

The Plymouth Tribune · 1 April 1909 · page 7

000,000. according to William Dutehrr. president "of the National Association of Audubon Societies. If we permit the heritage of wild birds that still exist to be further was teil and destroy ed, we are robbing our children, de clared Mr. Duteher. The people, as trustees, are in honor bound to pre serve these 'wild birds for those that follow us. We do not wish our chil dren to feel about us ns we do about our fathers, who permitted the wanton and useless extinction of th? bison and the wild pigeon.

See moreSee less

In the matter of bird legislation there is no resting place; the only price of satisfactory bird pro tection Is eternal watching of legis latures, for in an unguarded moment an amendment may bo passed that will undo the work of years.

See the clipping

Also printed in 8 papers
  • Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 2 April 1909
  • Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 8 April 1909
  • Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · 8 April 1909
  • · · 9 April 1909
  • Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis. · 13 April 1909
  • Manchester Democrat · Manchester, Iowa · 14 April 1909
  • Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb. · 15 April 1909
  • The Dakota Chief · Gann Valley, S.D. · 15 April 1909

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

A reader's letter urges Massachusetts lawmakers to pass a bill preventing spring shooting, citing expert ornithologists who warn that species like the passenger pigeon and Eskimo curlew are now believed extinct. The writer also defends the state's fish and game commissioners against recent public criticism.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 1 April 1909 · page 7

IN APPEAL TO REAL SPORTSMEN

fowl or shore birds had disappeared. . . » To-day the belief obtains among ornitholo gists that both the passenger pigeon and Eskimo curlew are extinct.” Dr George W. Field, chairman of our commission on fisheries and game, is strongly in favor of this measure, and his

See the clipping

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

A general nature column discusses how human activity—clearing land, plume hunting, and millinery demand—has reduced many bird species in Wisconsin, citing the raven, curlew, egret, and Mormon gull as examples. It mentions the passenger pigeon's extinction only briefly as a well-known fact, alongside recent laws banning feather trade for hats.

The Manitowoc Pilot · 8 April 1909 · page 4

PROTECTION

All of these are now practically driven northward from our state. The wild tur key is extinct in Wisconsin. The story of the passenger pigeon is well known.

See the clipping

Montour American · Danville, Pa.

A judge and other elderly men in 1909 reminisce about the once-countless wild pigeons that darkened the sky, describing nets, trapping, and the birds' migratory habits. The report claims the species became practically extinct around 1860 due to merciless hunting.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Montour American · 15 April 1909 · page 1

IN 1 DAYS OF ID Pill Associate Judge Frank Q. Blee spent several hours in this city jesterday. While at the courthouse he found time to converse with several old tim ers on the great changes that fiave tak en place during their lives. Wild pigeous became the theme of conversation. Of conrse, the young person of the present day knows noth ing about wild pigeons; but when the judge, who is now seventy, was a boy wild pigeons were a factor that the sportsman reckoned with. Joseph R. Fatton recalled that when ho was young he used to see wilil pig eons galore They frequently swarmed over head in millions,shutting out the rays of the sun and casting a shadow on the earth.

See moreSee less

Judge Blee described a net for catching the pigeons used by him as a boy, which was sixty feet long and wide in proportion. At one catch he trapped forty dozen. The wild pigeons were victims of indiscriminate and merciless slaught er. They were captured throughout the country by every means that in genuity could devise. They not only afforded delicious food in season but their diminutive carcasses were pre served by smoking and other means and they graced the farmer's table at intervals during the whole year. The wild pigeon very closely resem bled the tamo pigeon. Each fall reg ularly they migrated south, returning in the spring. During the winter they sought tho rice swamps of the south mid during their flight northward in the spring Judge Blee recalls shooting pigeous that had rice in their ctaws. The birds spent tho summer in the mountains uort'i and wp4 of this section. Not only wore the pigeous obliged to run the gauntlet in their migrations spring and fall, but they were pursued by avaricinnperscua into the very mountains where they were breeding and were shot and entrapped in r.ets. As a result of this indiscriminate slaughter the pigeons became practic ally extiuct about IStiO. For some years afterward a few might have been seer spring and fail, wiuging their flight overhead, but long ago the last wild pigeon passed out of existence. When Judge Blee was a boy nearly every farm had a few wild jdgeons «'Oo;nd up. which had been captured and were being kept as stool pigeons, t < b>t uned a= decoys to draw others within the net, when tho latter was employed as a means of capturing the birds.

See the clipping

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

The report states that the passenger pigeon, now practically extinct, was among the most rapid continuous flyers of game birds despite a wing length disadvantageous for speed. It cites claims that pigeons shot in Canada had wild rice from the Carolinas in their stomachs, and that some authorities estimated their speed as high as 120 miles per hour.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 44 days later.

Wrong

Bisbee Daily Review · 18 April 1909 · page 8

SURELY HAD'MONEVB WORTH. Uncls Hod Had Cone Far to Get It and He Got It. There being no dentist in the little, town where he resided Uncle 'Hod Kowdybush had gone to tho county seat to have an aching tooth ex tracted. "I see It's one of your largo molars," said tho dentist at whose ofthat way?" "It won't seem any tlmo at all to you. You, go to sleep and you seem to wake up Immediately and the tooth is out." "And I don't feel it come out?" "Not a particle."

See moreSee less

"Uncle Hod reflected. "Well," he said, "I've come 27 miles to have tMs tooth pulled and I think I'm entitled to tho satisfaction of knowing when you yank It out to say ncthla' of davln' a dollar. I don't want no gas." From the manner In which Uncle Hod gro?icd during tho subsequent operation tt was inferred that he had fully a dollar's worth of "satisfaction." Youth's Companion. Speed of Flight of Pigeons. Of our game birds tho most gre garious and most beautiful passenger pigeon, now unhappily, practically ex tinct. Is or was doubtless the most rapid of continuous flyers; yet to a total length of 1GU Inches its wings' !rngth is about seven and eight-tenths Inches, a proportion less favorable for speed than with certain other . less iapld species' of Its family, says a writer In Outing Magazine. Their ,Mtained speed certainly exceeded a mile a minute, and some authorities have estimated it 0.3 high as 120 miles per hour. The fact, often quoted, ihat the wild rice of the Carollnas was .sometimes found in the stomachs of birds shot In Canada shows both mar vel" us speed and endurance. "Shadow Theater" for Berlin. Prominent actors and musicians la BerKn have been engaged for the "shadow theater" which will soon bo opened In that city. It will be con Jucted, according to the prospectus .hat has been printed, as the Schatten jplelthcater In Munich nd a similar dace of amusemsnt in .ris. ened like that of one long exposed to the weather. The hair on the top of its head Is of a distinct auburn and bristles out In a shock like that ot one long un acquainted with comb and brush. The rear feet, upon which It walked, aro like those of a human being, except for the nails, that are like bear claws. The front feet are like those of a dog, with very long toes and a thumb set well back for grasping. Tne mouth Is long like that of a dog, but tbe face Is hairless, like ttit of a monkey, with heavy eyebrows and a slight chin whisker. It was shot In the chest by Gaspar Romero and Jesus Valentla, two well known vaqueros, after It had killed their two dogs. . iiiiitn Officers: .Dr. C. L. Edmund son, president; Asa T. Hoy, vice president; Ray B. Kerbs, secretary; H. W. Owen, treasurer.

See the clipping

The Columbian · Bloomsburg, Pa.

The article recalls Judge Blee's boyhood memories of wild pigeon hunting, describing their migration patterns, use as food, and capture via nets and stool pigeons. It claims the birds became 'practically extinct' around 1860 due to indiscriminate slaughter, with only occasional sightings afterward.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 56 days later.

Wrong

The Columbian · 22 April 1909 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

In the Days of Wild Pigeons.

When Associate Judge Blee of Montour County was in Danville the other day, he and several others were talking of changes that had taken place during their lives, says the Danville News.

See moreSee less

Wild pigeons became the theme of conversation. Of course, the young person of the present day knows nothing about wild pigeons; but when the judge, who is now seventy, was a boy wild pigeons were a factor that the sportsman reckoned with.

Joseph R. Patton recalled that when he was young he used to see wild pigeons galore. They frequently swarmed overhead in millions, shutting out the rays of the sun and casting a shadow on the earth. Judge Blee described a net for catching the pigeons used by him as a boy, which was sixty feet long and wide in proportion. At one catch he trapped forty dozen

The wild pigeons were victims of indiscriminate and merciless slaughter. They were captured throughout the country by every means that ingenuity could devise. They not only afforded delicious food in season but their diminutive carcasses were preserved by smoking and other means and they graced the farmer's table at intervals during the whole year.

The wild pigeon very closely resembled the tame pigeon. Each fall regularly they migrated south, returning in the spring. During the winter they sought the rice swamps of the south and during their flight northward in the spring Judge Blee recalls shooting pigeons that had rice in their craws. The birds spent the summer in the mountains north and west of this section.

Not only were the pigeons obliged to run the gauntlet in their migrations spring and fall, but they were pursued by avaricious persons into the very mountains where they were breeding and were shot and entrapped in nets.

As a result of this indiscriminate slaughter the pigeons became practically extinct about 1860. For some years afterward a few might have been seen spring and fall, winging their flight overhead, but long ago the last wild pigeon passed out of existence.

When Judge Blee was a boy nearly every farm had a few wild pigeons cooped up, which had been captured and were being kept as stool pigeons, to be used as decoys to draw others within the net, when the latter was employed as a means of capturing the birds.

Woman's Home Companion for May.

The burden of our changing social order falls upon our daughters, claims the Woman's Home Companion for May, and this magazine shows by striking examples and figures how topsyturvy is our way of training girls.

In this same issue is a charming article by Margaret Sangster, showing that the millionaire mother is by no means as black as she is painted. Mary Heaton Vorse, in her own inimitable style proves that if we are fat it is our own fault.

In more serious mood is a trip through the Metropolitan Museum of Art with Sir Caspar Purdon Clarke as guide. This valuable article is illustrated by exquisite reproductions of famous paintings. Other articles of interest are "The Art of Economy," by Mrs. John Van Vorst, and "The Commuters of New York," by Albert Bigelow Paine. "An Imperial Wraith," by Clara Morris, contains charming reminiscences of the Empress Eugenie. "Lucy Green," a friendless seventeen-year-old girl, tells how she went to Boston penniless, in search of a job, and how she got one.

"Afraid" is a story in Zona Gale's exquisite style, "Hearts and the Highway" has Cyrus Townsend Brady's usual swing and dash, and "The Four Adventuresses" is another story by Hulbert Footner, whose freshness and humor have established his reputation.

This issue of the Woman's Home Companion is distinguished by two features—a poem entitled "The Grandmother," by James Oppenheim, and a full-page drawing by Harrison Fisher, showing Margaret and Gerard, from "The Cloister and the Hearth."

Gave Salary to Charity.

Senator J. Henry Cochran, representing this Senatorial district, has turned over his salary for the session just closed—$1587.60—to be used as an ice fund for the benefit of the sick and poor of Williamsport and vicinity. Mr. Cochran, it is said, will not again be a candidate for public office.

See the clipping

The Colfax Gazette · Colfax, Wash.

A 1909 poultry column reminisces about the once-vast flocks of American wild pigeons, citing an 1813 Kentucky account of birds blotting out the sun for days. It notes their decline to extinction, comparing their fate to the buffalo, destroyed by netting, nest-robbing, and other exploitation.

The Colfax Gazette · 23 April 1909 · page 6

THE AMERICAN WILD PIGEON. "What a whopper.'' remarked ■ hearer as the oldest resident told that a flock of wild pigeons was so thick ho couldn't drive through it with a two h'>rse team. Hut do you believe us when we tell you a modern locomotive couldn't do the stunt? If the jack rabbit grasshoppers of the west can stall a train, 2,000.000,000 pigeons ought to do it, and some flocks were estimated at that number. In 1813, in Kentucky, a naturalist counted 163 Socks in two hours, the flocks increasing in size and continu ing to pass for three days.

See moreSee less

"The air was filled with pigeons. The sun was eclipsed. The continual buzz of wings lulled the senses to sleep, while their excrement fell like now." Hut they went like the buffalo. They were caught in nets. Their nests were robbed of squabs, and even droves of hogs wore fattened on pi geons. They were properly a species of dove that live in the woods and roost on trees. Our tame pigeons came from the old world. About the only time they alight on a tree is when they are shot at and missed by so called sportsmen who continue the cruel practice of using live birds for targets.

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

A Louisiana game warden reported 42,000 ducks killed in one parish over three winter months, prompting warnings that without federal protection, wild ducks would meet the same fate as the passenger pigeon and buffalo. The item treats the pigeon's extinction as an already-known cautionary precedent.

Evening Times-Republican · 27 April 1909 · page 4

Unless wild fowl are given govern ment protection in less than a decade the wild duck will go the way of the passenger pigeon and buffalo. Accord ing to Game Warden Ferdinand Bell of St. Bernard, La., who has submitted his report to the game commission, 42,000 ducks were slaughtered in -that parish during the months of December, January and February. Just think of it—42,000 ducks slaughtered in one parish in Louisiana in three months, or an average of 14,000 ducks a month, and yet there are men who will say that water fowl are as plentiful as ever. Thoughtful sportsmen know bet ter than this, however.

See the clipping