As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

November 1904

5 articles

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

A flock of about 500 birds resembling wild pigeons was seen passing over Chardon, Ohio, witnessed by many familiar with the species' markings. Their reappearance after a 23-year absence sparked speculation among sportsmen, as market hunting had long been blamed for the species' disappearance.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 55 days later.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 November 1904 · page 1

FLOCK, OF WILD PIGEONS. Irda Seen at Chardon, O., After an Absence of Many Yean. A flock of fully 500 wild, pigeons passed over Chardon, O., the other aft ernoon, says the Cleveland Plain Deal er. Hundreds of people who are famil iar with the markings of the wild pi geon witnessed the sight. The flock was also seen at Aquila lake. , The re appearance ot these birds after an ab sence of twenty-three years has caused considerable speculation among the sportsmen of Chardon. Wild pigeons were last seen near Chardon in April.

See moreSee less

1883. . ' The last great flight of these birds in northern Ohio was witnessed in ' the spring of 1876. The pigeons reappeared in the spring of 1877, but in greatly di mlnished numbers. Their total disap pearance later caused the belief to be come general that the birds had been annihilated by market hunters. For 1 years the rimithsorilan institute has had, a standing offer of $1,000 for a single specimen of the American wild pigeon . ' . ' A large and handsome lot of, folders, tickets and show cards, latest designs, just received at. the. Democrat office. Get 'your.-printing done here and get free notif fca "Coming Events" column.

See the clipping

The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.

A dispatch from Chardon, Ohio describes a flock of about 500 wild pigeons seen passing overhead, the first sighting in 23 years. Sportsmen speculate whether the birds, long believed exterminated by market hunters, have survived after all.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 31 days later.

Wrong

The Forest Republican · 9 November 1904 · page 3

WILD PIGEONS RETURN

Found Dead In Ills Wittfon. Charles Detar was found dead in bis wagon while returning from a trip to IJallton, Elk connty, last Saturday. He had been In the employ of N. F. Hoover, of Marionvillo, who has been jobbing In the bark woods at Wyukoop run, In the edge of Elk county, and Mr. Hoover had sent him out with the last load of bark, and to br'ng back a load of feed. On h's way back be came up with another team ster and had lain down on the bags con taining the feed.

See moreSee less

The head teamster sup posing tliat ho had fallen asleep, kept watch of the horses. Mr. Hoover, know ing the roads to be rough and that dark ness would probably overtake him, had started on the way to meet Detar, which he did about hall way between the two places. Slopping the team be attempted to rouse the supposed tleeper, when he found to bis utter astonishment that he vas dead. All efforts to find any signs of life failed, though the body was still warm, and Mr. Hoover thinks the man could not have beeu dead moie thau fifteen or twenty minutes. Arrange ments were at once instituted for the holding of an inquest, the jury returning a verdict tl a', the mini had come to h a death by unknown causes. The deceased was well known In the vicinity of Ty lersburg, where he was roan d in the fam ily ol Mrs. J. II. Smith, having been left an orphan when but a mere child. He was aged about 35 years, aud single. M r. Hoover had the body prepared for burial and conveyed to Tylorsburg, where the funeral was bold yesterday. Ihiiitinir Horse Thieves. On Friday night a mare, buggy and harness were stolon from the stable of J. K. Dale, of Pitchpine, Clarion county. Mr. Dale is a member of the Anti-Horse Thief Association and his home is equip ped with a farmer's telephone. Insido of an hour after the loss was discovered there were 40 able-bodied farmeas and their sons scouring the country in all di rections for the missing property and the Ihioves. Two of the party, Austin Sig worth and .1, W. Kountz, arrived hereon Sunday afternoon, having been on the search for two days, but secured no trace of the property. The animal is fat, 14 years old and has never been more than 20 miles sway from the owner's barn, alio l bay In color, with a white stripe on her face. The buggy is black, with ied wheels and greeu cushions. As the anlninl was very slow In locomotion it is believed that (lie thieves abandoned her alier a i-hoit drive. The gentlemen who wore here Sunday explained tho methods of the association. They each and all p'ede themselves to respond to any call made hy a member and keep up the chase for three days if necessary, paying each his own t xoenses. These associa tions aro becoming common, and with the system of ?o operative telephone lines maintained by larmeis, t. e occu pation of the horse thief is about gone in thia si ctiou. Derrick. Wig Fire la Oil City. The Smart A Silberberg store, In Oil City, ono of the finest iu Northwestern Pennsylvania, was completely gutted by fire on Monday evening of this week, the first discovery of the flames being about 10 o'clock. George J. Veach's art store occupied a porlioii of the ground Hour of the big block, and bis stock was also practically ruined. A tier of ollicts oc cupied a part of the second lloor, and o'.her oflices were located on the third lloor. The losses are estimated at about $275,000, wilb probably not more thau one-third the amount covered by insur ance. The proprietors of this line empo rium, Mtssrs. Smart A Silberberg, are young business men, chock full of oner gy and grit, and before the tire was com pletely under control, they bad issued a bulletin in the Derrick announcing that, while they could not tell just where or when, but as soon as circumstances would permit they would make Iheir opening known, and their busiuess would progress as usual. Wild I'iseoiis My Keturn. A special from Chardon, Ohio, of recent date says: A flock of fully 500 wild pig eons passed over Chardon last Saturday afternoon. Hundreds of people who are lamiliar with the markings of the wild pigeon witnessed the sight. Tho llock was also seon at Aquila lake. The reap pearance of these birds after an absence of 23 years has caused considerable spec ulation among the sportsmen of this lo cality. Wild pigeons were last seen near Clmrdon in April, 188:1. The last great flight of these birds iu Northern Ohio was witnessed in the spring of 187(1. The pigeons reappeared In the spring of 1S77, but in greatly di minished numbers. Their total disap pearance later caused the belief to become general that t' e birds bad become anni hilated by markot hunters. For years the Smithsonian Institution has had a standing offer of $1,000 for a single speci men of the American wild pigeon, At various times the presence of pigeons has been reported iu remote sections of for eign countries, but all efforts to locate the birds in the United States has proved fruitless. A Surprise I'nrlr. On Nov. 3d, the Kellettvile Hive, No. 210, gave their esteemed Lady Com urtnder one of the happiest surprise parties of ber r-collection. The ladies gathered at the ball at 10::10 a. in, and a tor considerable lung exercise started out on foot over the rugged hills of Kings ley t iwnship, to a little village known as the Branch, bore they surprised the hostess and enjoyd one of the mo t boun tiful luncheons iu the history of the hive, after which they gave their Lady Com mander a fond adieu, and proceeded homeward. But before we could lose the last glimpse of the little village the la lies made a motion that Lady Gillespie make a stump speech which was im mediately carried out, aud still feeling that bor speech had done justice to tho occasion she followed by a parody "Did your fathor pcddlp fish," followed in the 0'jorus by the remaining ladies of tho bivo; and then proceeding homewaid experienced no more excitement, as all the wild beasts within the radius of miles after hearing our charmuig voices ro treated into tho jtingUs. Co R K ks lo N D I N ( i Com wrri'KK. That new suit, right in the pink of fashion, made upon honor and guaran teed to lit tunl wear, awaits you al this store. Hopkins. It Found Dead In Ills Wittfon. Charles Detar was found dead in bis wagon while returning from a trip to IJallton, Elk connty, last Saturday. He had been In the employ of N. F. Hoover, of Marionvillo, who has been jobbing In the bark woods at Wyukoop run, In the ahead : edge of Elk county, and Mr. Hoover had sent him out with the last load of bark, and to br'ng back a load of feed. On h's way back be came up with another team ster and had lain down on the bags con taining the feed. The head teamster sup posing tliat ho had fallen asleep, kept watch of the horses. Mr. Hoover, know ing the roads to be rough and that dark ness would probably overtake him, had started on the way to meet Detar, which he did about hall way between the two places. Slopping the team be attempted to rouse the supposed tleeper, when he found to bis utter astonishment that he vas dead. All efforts to find any signs of life failed, though the body was still warm, and Mr. Hoover thinks the man could not have beeu dead moie thau fifteen or twenty minutes. Arrange ments were at once instituted for the holding of an inquest, the jury returning a verdict tl a', the mini had come to h a aud legal cause. death by unknown causes. The deceased was well known In the vicinity of Ty lersburg, where he was roan d in the fam ily ol Mrs. J. II. Smith, having been left an orphan when but a mere child. He was aged about 35 years, aud single. M r. Hoover had the body prepared for burial and conveyed to Tylorsburg, where the funeral was bold yesterday. Ihiiitinir Horse Thieves. On Friday night a mare, buggy and harness were stolon from the stable of J. K. Dale, of Pitchpine, Clarion county. Mr. Dale is a member of the Anti-Horse Thief Association and his home is equip ped with a farmer's telephone. Insido of an hour after the loss was discovered there were 40 able-bodied farmeas and their sons scouring the country in all di rections for the missing property and the Ihioves. Two of the party, Austin Sig worth and .1, W. Kountz, arrived hereon Sunday afternoon, having been on the search for two days, but secured no trace of the property. The animal is fat, 14 years old and has never been more than 20 miles sway from the owner's barn, alio l bay In color, with a white stripe on her face. The buggy is black, with ied wheels and greeu cushions. As the anlninl was very slow In locomotion it is believed that (lie thieves abandoned her alier a i-hoit drive. The gentlemen who wore here Sunday explained tho methods of the association. They each and all p'ede themselves to respond to any call made hy a member and keep up the chase for three days if necessary, paying each his own t xoenses. These associa tions aro becoming common, and with the system of ?o operative telephone lines maintained by larmeis, t. e occu pation of the horse thief is about gone in thia si ctiou. Derrick. Wig Fire la Oil City. The Smart A Silberberg store, In Oil City, ono of the finest iu Northwestern Pennsylvania, was completely gutted by fire on Monday evening of this week, the first discovery of the flames being about is as follows : 10 o'clock. George J. Veach's art store occupied a porlioii of the ground Hour of the big block, and bis stock was also practically ruined. A tier of ollicts oc cupied a part of the second lloor, and o'.her oflices were located on the third lloor. The losses are estimated at about $275,000, wilb probably not more thau one-third the amount covered by insur ance. The proprietors of this line empo rium, Mtssrs. Smart A Silberberg, are young business men, chock full of oner gy and grit, and before the tire was com pletely under control, they bad issued a bulletin in the Derrick announcing that, while they could not tell just where or when, but as soon as circumstances would permit they would make Iheir opening known, and their busiuess would progress as usual. Wild I'iseoiis My Keturn. A special from Chardon, Ohio, of recent date says: A flock of fully 500 wild pig eons passed over Chardon last Saturday afternoon. Hundreds of people who are lamiliar with the markings of the wild pigeon witnessed the sight. Tho llock was also seon at Aquila lake. The reap pearance of these birds after an absence of 23 years has caused considerable spec ulation among the sportsmen of this lo cality. Wild pigeons were last seen near Clmrdon in April, 188:1. The last great flight of these birds iu Northern Ohio was witnessed in the spring of 187(1. The pigeons reappeared In the spring of 1S77, but in greatly di minished numbers. Their total disap pearance later caused the belief to become general that t' e birds bad become anni hilated by markot hunters. For years the Smithsonian Institution has had a standing offer of $1,000 for a single speci men of the American wild pigeon, At various times the presence of pigeons has been reported iu remote sections of for eign countries, but all efforts to locate the birds in the United States has proved fruitless. A Surprise I'nrlr. On Nov. 3d, the Kellettvile Hive, No. 210, gave their esteemed Lady Com urtnder one of the happiest surprise ueighbor. parties of ber r-collection. The ladies gathered at the ball at 10::10 a. in, and a tor considerable lung exercise started out on foot over the rugged hills of Kings ley t iwnship, to a little village known as the Branch, bore they surprised the hostess and enjoyd one of the mo t boun tiful luncheons iu the history of the hive, after which they gave their Lady Com mander a fond adieu, and proceeded homeward. But before we could lose the last glimpse of the little village the la lies made a motion that Lady Gillespie make a stump speech which was im to us. mediately carried out, aud still feeling that bor speech had done justice to tho occasion she followed by a parody "Did your fathor pcddlp fish," followed in the 0'jorus by the remaining ladies of tho bivo; and then proceeding homewaid experienced no more excitement, as all the wild beasts within the radius of miles after hearing our charmuig voices ro treated into tho jtingUs. Co R K ks lo N D I N ( i Com wrri'KK. That new suit, right in the pink of fashion, made upon honor and guaran teed to lit tunl wear, awaits you al this store. Hopkins. It

See the clipping

The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.

A flock of about 500 birds resembling wild pigeons was seen passing over Chardon, Ohio, witnessed by many familiar with the species' markings. Locals noted the birds had not been seen in the area for twenty-three years, sparking speculation among sportsmen about their survival.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 50 days later.

Wrong

The Barre Daily Times · 14 November 1904 · page 8

FLOCK OF WILD PIGEON'S. Uirris Seen lit ChnrUon. O.. After an Altxfiiee f Mnn Vearx. A flock of fully ,"(io wiiil nk-eons passed over ('liardmi, O.. the other aft ernoon, says the Cleveland Plain Deni er.. Hundreds of people who arc famil iar with the markings of the wild pi geon witnessed the Right. The flock was also seen nt Aquila lake. The re appearance of these birds after an ab sence of twenty-three years has eaused considerable speculation among the sportsmen of Chardon. Wild nitreous were last seen near Cbardon In April.

See moreSee less

188,'t. The last treat flicht of these birds In northern Ohio was witnessed in the spring of 1870. The pigeons reappeared hi the spring of 1S77, but in greatly di minished numbers. Their total disnnpearance later enused the belief to be come general that the birds had been annihilated by market hunters. For years the Smithsonian institute bus had a standing offer of $1,000 for a single specimen of the American wild pigeon. ft

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Hudson Valley correspondent reports several flocks of wild pigeons, including one of several hundred birds, seen flying over the area, with nostalgic recollection of the massive pigeon flights that once darkened the sky before slaughter by farmers and hunters. The report treats these recent sightings as a hopeful sign of the bird's return.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 38 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 27 November 1904 · page 38

1 of scrub cedars and hemlocks and allowthemselves or crawl under the low hanging branchesof themselves be snowed under and thusshut shut out from light air and food the freezestarve starve and dieLast Last winter many grouse or partridgesas as they are called here and quail soughtthe the barnyards and fed with the domesticfowls fowls The farmers did nothing to scarethem thorn away and the few birds that thehunters hunters have secured this fall are no doubtthose those thus preservedTwo Two years ago the whistle of tho BobWhite White was heard everywhere in Ulstercounty county and was as common almost In thegardens gardens of Kingston as the piping of therobin robin while people driving along thosuburban suburban roads were frequently startledby by the whirr of the partridge almostunder under the wagon wheelsThis This year tho whirr and tho drum of thogrouse grouse and the plaintive cry of tho BobWhite White have not been heard to any extentand and hunters report not enough game topay pay for alMa leatherMany Many sportsmen Incline to the beliefthat that the quail which under certain circumstances cumstances is a migratory bird movedto to the South lost fall In great n umbers before fore the severe winter set in That the birdsare are gone Is a certainty and quail potfle laan an unknon delicacy in Ulster this f 8Sportsmen Sportsmen are having good sport rHhwild wild rabbits this fall They are plentifulend and fatBelgian Belgian hares have been set at largo inmany many localities and it is believed they nrecrossingwith CroMlng with the native stock aa manyrabbits rabbits have been killed this year whichhlle sIdle they resemble In some decree thoBelgian Belgian hare are neither Belgian hares nornative native bro7 h rabbits They are shorterand and have lonrer lees than the native rabbitand and have hair nearly the same color nsthe the domestic maltese rabbitHunters Hunters say thee are not nearly so wild asthe the native brown or brindle rabbit Woreit it not the fact that these rabbits have boonshot shot all over the county It would be HUSpected pected that some pet maltese rabbits hadtaken taken to the woods and returned to thewild wild stateMany Many wild ducks and geese are beingshot shot on the Esopus Cats or middle crovndsIn In tho Hudson River oT this place lieports ports from further up the river wy duckare are plentiful on all the mud flats This Istho the first time In several years that there ha vobeen been any eeeee or ducks seen or taken inthis this localityReports Report from the backwoods up tho Rondout dout tell of the arrival of several fiocksof of wild pigeons A few days ago a flockcontaining containing probably several hundred birdspassed passed over this village flying eastwardThis This same flock baa been seen several timesduring during the season going and comingYears Years ago the flight of pigeons from thoCaUkill Catskills In this vicinity was so greatthatthey they darkened the sun at midday fillingthe the sky with a great blue mass like a cloudThen Then they wery slaughtered by thousandsfarmers farmers and hunter laid g them by the

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The article claims passenger pigeons, after disappearing since a huge 1867 flight, have reappeared in small numbers at Ketchum Hollow and have since quadrupled, with hopes they will multiply back into the millions. It notes they are protected under wild bird law since there is no open season for them.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 37 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 27 November 1904 · page 38

meal bag and barrel to market andsalting In 1807 after a marvellous flight of tho IIIn salting down thousands for winter use birds they disappeared and never reap peared until last Bummer won a small nock made their appearance nesting up In Ketchum Hollow They were allowed to remain there undisturbed and this yoar the flocks have quadrupled or more Innumber number It Is hoped that they have come back to stay and that the flocks seen willrapidly rapidly Increase to millions again aa thy surely will if they are lot alone and undisturbed I disturbed for a few years There is plentyof of food for them particularly beech nuteof of which they are fondAs As there Is no open season for wild pigeons eons and oa they como under the law whichprotects protects all wild birds except those of prey there la every reason to believe that theday day is coming wen the great flight ofpigeons pigeons of tory or fifty years ago may be seen againAJSII

See the clipping