As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

March 1901

5 articles

Jerome Mining News · Jerome, Ariz.

A citizens' petition to the Arizona legislature urges passage of a game protection law, citing animals like the buffalo and 'wild pigeon' that have already been decimated. It notes the pigeon's total absence from its once-famous haunts as common knowledge, using this as a cautionary example to spur action before other species meet the same fate.

Jerome Mining News · 2 March 1901 · page 2

PROTECT THE GAME!

First Legislature of Arizona. countless thousands is a matter well known to one and all, and animals have followed in the wake of our buffalo, and your members, the lion. Tbos, B. Campbell, had lavished upon our land. Remember the wild pigeon. HARDWARE... Implements.... DICUS & HUMBERT. City Transfer

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Jerome Mining News · Jerome, Ariz. · 9 March 1901

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A sentimental poem describes a childhood memory of watching wild pigeons fly like arrows across the sky, alongside other birds such as wood doves and wrens. The poem reflects wistfully on nature's universal law of home and love, set against a recollection of a vanished rural scene.

Evening Star · 16 March 1901 · page 24

With the Birds. Writ ten f,.r The Eveninsr Star by Cla. I. 10-16. Lovng years ago. one sunny day Alas, how dim mud far away That bright day nw apiwars - Onranpaniouless and lonely, 1. For pastime, watched the ,ioul' g by. As since have gone the years. I wandered where the brook leaped dos Its rocky channel by the town In foamy, ceaseless fnow; I saw wild pigeons rise and Gy. IAke armws, cleaving the bright sky,

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A news digest item about the millinery trade's devastation of songbirds in Japan notes that in the United States, the wild pigeon has already been exterminated. It cites this as a comparison to the appalling scale of bird killing worldwide.

The Saint Paul Globe · 23 March 1901 · page 4

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

A Vermont editor confesses that an earlier report of a passenger pigeon colony near Milton was mistaken, after young birds thought to be pigeons matured into common mourning doves. He also notes ongoing rumors of passenger pigeons reappearing in Wisconsin, which he likewise attributes to mourning dove sightings.

The Mirror and Farmer · 28 March 1901 · page 12

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

A writer recounts correspondence from a Wisconsin correspondent who tracked pigeon rumors but concluded the birds were gone, while the article's author insists the passenger pigeon is not extinct and may be surviving in small flocks in Wisconsin, Michigan, and Minnesota. The piece reflects on the species' former vast abundance and the mass slaughter and commercial exploitation that depleted it.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 35 days later.

Wrong

The Mirror and Farmer · 28 March 1901 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

12

FOR SOME time past I have made it my interest to investigate reports of the reappearance of the passenger pigeon, the bird that shares with the buffalo the pathetic distinction of being on the verge of extermination. An account of one experience will show the kind of amusement one may get from this sort of hobby.

See moreSee less

Early last summer, writes Mark Sullivan, in the Boston Transcript, I learned from an officer of the League of American Sportsmen that passenger pigeons had been seen in Vermont. The patient tracing of many previous reports from the same source had caused me to "hae my douts," as the Highlanders say, about the existence of passenger pigeons in Vermont. Nevertheless I started on the trail of the rumor.

My informant had heard it at a banquet. The man who told it at the banquet had read it in a sporting magazine. The editor of the magazine had got it from a friend. By this time the capture of that rumor began to have a Sherlock Holmes interest. I was having all the pleasures of the chase with no more trouble than the writing of gan to have a Sherlock Holmes interest. I was having all the pleasures of the chase with no more trouble than the writing of letters. Rumor chasing deserves a place in the catalogue of sports. Finally I brought it to earth. It was in the shape of the following clipping from a paper bearing the curious name, The Rays, published in Milton, Vt.

* * *

"E. A. Frost has a pair of young wild pigeons that he is having the best of success in raising, as they are strong, healthy birds and are growing rapidly. The passenger pigeon has been supposed by many to be extinct or nearly so, and such publications as 'Recreation' have referred to them as a bird of the past. It seems, however, they are appearing again in some localities, but in diminished numbers. These birds were taken from the nest when quite young, and added to friend Frost's collection. They bid fair to grow up to useful pigeonhood. A small colony has nested in Milton for several seasons, and we are informed that those who knew their resting place have wisely refrained from killing the birds or allowing others to do so."

On reading the clipping, I wrote two letters—one to Mr. Frost and one to the editor of the Milton Rays. Mr. Frost did not reply—he is probably the sort of man who doesn't enjoy telling a joke on himself. He still owes me a two-cent stamp. The editor, however, very courteously, replied. Here is his letter:

* * *

"Milton, Vt.

"Dear Sir:—I have very much regretted the insertion of the report you refer to, as it was an error sent in by one of our country correspondents, to which we gave editorial credence. The point is as follows: Last spring about nesting time a report came in that a small colony of the passenger pigeons were occupying a small grove not far from the village. A friend went down and procured two of the young ones only a couple of days old, and he and others testified that they were indeed bona fide pigeons. As I saw nothing but the young, we were not in a position to positively state what they were, but on testimony of a sportsman (who ought to have known, as he saw the old birds) we inserted the article that has misled you, and for which we deeply repent. The birds grew, thrived, and today are in the window of our local druggist—beautiful specimens of the 'mourning dove.' The small colony of passenger pigeons proved to be only the "Carolina mourning dove,' common from Maine to Florida. We are somewhat excusable mourning dove.' The small colony of passenger pigeons proved to be only the "Carolina mourning dove,' common from Maine to Florida. We are somewhat excusable, only seeing the very young, as you will admit it is almost impossible to distinguish the difference until the second feathers appear. I am very sorry you were misled by our error."

* * *

This is evidently a conscientious editor. One regrets that his field is limited to a Vermont village. That his conscience extends beyond his editorial field and that his sentiments on other subjects are correct is shown by the remainder of his letter:

"I am deeply interested in the passenger pigeon and have traced every possible rumor. I have shot them by dozens in Wisconsin, and have heard rumors from my old home in Juneau county that they were returning there after an absence of several years. Some insist that a few scattered flocks were seen last season around their old haunts at Kilbourn and in the Lemonweir valley, but really I place them with the mourning dove. When I think what 'hogs' men are (hogs is a mild name) to destroy creatures God gave life, for the paltry gain there is in it, and mercilessly pursue every living creature that has a cent of value or promises a moment's so-called sport! I only shot what I needed for my own daily use, and never sold a dollar's worth of game in my life. At Kilbourn, Wis., the pigeons were so persecuted that they were driven out of the country. Chicago people crated the young by the thousands when just about to leave the nest, and shot and netted the old without mercy, and local people cleared up the scatterings. It is no wonder they are extinct or have sought regions unknown to the so-called civilized man."

* * *

This is a typical experience of one who runs down such rumors. Nine out of ten of them turn out to be utterly baseless. Nevertheless, I am certain that the passenger pigeon is not extinct. Moreover, I believe if it has half a chance it will thrive and increase. Within the past three years various reports, reliable enough to be credited by the American Ornithological union, have been received, stating that small flocks had been seen at various places in Wisconsin, Michigan and Minnesota. Its present habitat is the sparsely settled forests along the lake shore in northern Wisconsin and Michigan. Twenty-five or fifty years ago hardly a space a mile square from the Gulf of Mexico to Hudson bay but knew the passenger pigeon and knew its in enormous numbers. But the stories of the immense numbers of these birds, of schooner loads senger pigeon and knew its in enormous numbers. But the stories of the immense numbers of these birds, of schooner loads of them brought down the Hudson to New York, where they were sold for a cent apiece, of breeding grounds covering a hundred thousand acres, of dozens of carloads shipped out of Michigan in 1878—all this is a tale that is told. But one can hardly forbear repeating this extract from an address said to have been made during a discussion i[n]

[a]me laws in the Ohio legislature in 1861: "The passenger pigeon needs no protection. Wonderfully prolific, having the vast [fore]sts of the North as its breeding grounds, [trav]eling hundreds of miles in search of [food], it is here today and elsewhere tomorrow, and no ordinary destruction can lessen [the]m or be missed from the myriads that [are] yearly produced."

[S]urely the lesson is plain. Thickly settled as this country now is, not a bird that [flie]s, nor a beast that walks, but needs protection if it is to be saved.

* * *

[It] has been said that the Lacey act, which [wen]t into operation last May, begins a new [era] in bird and game protection. I feel more [like] saying it is the beginning of protection, for the well-informed will agree with [me] that the protection laws of the past have [bee]n practically dead letters. The Lacey [act] puts the duty of punishing violators of [the] bird and game laws largely into the [han]ds of the federal government; and—exec[ute] it who will—the federal government [is] many times more effective in enforcing [the] law than any state government. And [ther]e is more fear of the federal government. Some philosopher may tell why it [is] that a man who will shake his fist under [the] nose of a local constable will quake and [tremb]le when he learns that a federal officer [is] after him. I once read in a textbook on government: "The further from [the] center of authority the weaker the power of the executive." It isn't so. A man [does]n't fear his next door neighbor recently [e]lected sheriff half as much as a mysterious unknown quantity of a federal officer, [in] the vague power of the government [beh]ind him, who comes from a distant city. Moreover, the federal government doesn't [dep]end for conviction on a local jury, more [than] half of whom are as guilty of violat[ion]s of game laws as the man in the dock.

discovered and seized 2600 gulls in a large wholesale millinery house in Baltimore. Two hours after the seizure Dr. Palmer had a telephone message from the house asking that the new law be explained to them, and promising to exclude carefully from their stock all protected birds, that is, practically all birds except those imported from foreign countries.

A few days later Dr. Palmer had a call from the proprietor of the largest wholesale millinery house in Baltimore. The milliner requested that the department send a man to Baltimore to examine his stock. The dealer wanted to throw out all protected birds and keep them out in future. Three weeks later Dr. Palmer made a visit icognito to these millinery houses. In neither did he find any violation of the law, and in one he found signs posted on the walls reading something like this:

"To our traveling salesmen:—Our attention has recently been called to the law forbidding the sale of"—here followed a list of the various protected gulls, terns, etc.—"We hereby give notice that we will not in future deal in these birds; and we desire our salesmen to take no orders for these birds, and to discourage their use and sale as far as posible."

* * *

"Trade trembles before uncertainty," as Mr. Mark Hanna or any other Republican will tell you when the Democrats begin to talk about the tariff. The millinery trade is no exception to the rule, and Dr. Palmer has the power to throw that trade into a flurry sufficient to bankrupt a large part of it at any time. The wholesale millinery houses are not going to buy thousands of gulls and terns and herons which they can't sell for two or three years, when they know Dr. Palmer may step in any day and seize the whole lot. They are not going to ovet, the federal government doesn't end for conviction on a local jury, more half of whom are as guilty of viola s of game laws as the man in the dock.

* * *

eretofore the trouble has been this: A e warden sees a dealer in New York hibiting quails or venison, or what it may for sale. "This is the close season for ls in this state," says the game warden, rrest you." "I didn't buy that game in state," says the dealer; "I bought it in nsylvania." And the end of it was that dealer grinned and the warden ground teeth. The dealer probably got the e in New York, and the warden knew ut there was no way of proving it. The assertion that he got it in Pennsyl ia saved him.

ight here the Lacey act becomes effec . It is a sort of interstate commerce which prohibits the sale in one state birds illegally killed in another state. er the Lacey act the game warden can "Very well, this is close season in nsylvania, too; I'll turn your case over e federal authorities." That portion of Lacey act which relates to this matter ls as follows:

t shall be unlawful for any person or ons to deliver to any common carrier, for any common carrier to transport n one state or territory to another state erritory, any animals or birds where such als or birds have been killed in viola of the laws of the state, territory or rict in which the same were killed.

All packages containing such dead ani . birds or parts thereof, when shipped nterstate commerce, as provided in sec 1 of this act, shall be plainly and clear marked, so that the name and address he shipper and the nature of the con s may be readily ascertained on inspec of the outside of such packages. For evasion or violation of this act the per shall, upon conviction, pay a fine not exceeding $200; and the consignee wingly receiving such articles so shipped transported in violation of this act shall, conviction, pay a fine of not exceeding ; and the carrier knowingly carrying or sporting the same shall, upon convic , pay a fine of not exceeding $200."

will be observed that the Lacey act a duty on the transportation compa and imposes a penalty for violation of This is one of the strongest features of bill. It is pleasant to know that the sportation companies have entered into spirit of the act, and by their attitude make illegal game traffic practically im ble.

* * *

guns and terns and herons which they can't sell for two or three years, when they know Dr. Palmer may step in any day and seize the whole lot. They are not going to engage in any uncertain business. The con sequence is they are doing just what the signs quoted above indicate. They are dis couraging the use of protected birds in the millinery trade. Take up the current is sues of The Millinery Trade Review. Ex amine the models of hats for the coming seasons. Not a single model has feather decorations. One other indication of the ef fectiveness of the Lacey act: I am told on good authority that not one-tenth as much game is being sold in Boston markets as a year ago. The seizure of illegal game ship ments in Chicago and at other western points accounts for it. The report of a game warden in the western part of Massachusetts gives an account of the futile efforts of a wealthy New York merchant to get two quails for a sick member of his family.

* * *

Just one thing is needed to supplement the Lacey act. Congress should make an appropriation to enable the department of agriculture to employ inspectors. When this is done Dr. Palmer will have a detective force. He will be able to keep an eye on the illegal market and plume hunters that line the coast from Maine to Texas, and when that is done violation of the Lacey act will be as risky as counterfeiting or smuggling.

In addition to the regulation of inter state commerce in birds and game, the Lacey act contains two other important pro visions. It regulates the importance of for eign birds and animals, and it enables the department of agriculture to transplant birds and animals, so to speak, and propa gate them in parts of the country where they have become scarce or extinct. In the line of the latter duty, nothing has been done as yet; in the line of the former, strict regulations have been in force ever since the first of last July. If you want to import a bird from Europe or South America now, you must get a permit from the secretary of agriculture. In your application you must state the kind and quantity, and whether they are "to be liberated or kept in cap tivity, and whether imported for propaga tion, exhibition or other purposes." Cer tain species are prohibited entirely. You cannot legally import a flying fox, a mon goose, an English sparrow (truly, this is locking the door after the burglar is in the house), a starling, or any other species which the secretary of agriculture may exclude at his discretion. To avoid unnecessary hard ship, permits are not required for seafowl, canaries, parrots or specimens intended for zoological collections. During the first three months of the operation of the law, 500 permits were issued for birds and 200 for mammals. The largest number was brought in at New York, the next largest number at San Francisco. If this law had been passed fifty years ago we should have been spared that chattering pest, the English sparrow. As it is, there are still a few states where the plague has not yet reached: Idaho, Montana, New Mexico, Oregon, Washington, Wyoming, Arizona and Nevada. Possibly the efforts of the department may keep it away from those states. * * * The starling, too, is already with us. As a rule, a man who meddles with the balance of nature is in serious danger of bringing on a calamity, but there is always some one ready to rush in. The American Acclimatization society, in 1877, set free a number of starlings in Central Park, New York, and the bird is now common along the Hudson valley, near Pittsburg, and near Portland, Ore. The rapidity of its increase is ominous of another English sparrow experiment. The legitimate importation and propagation of birds considered desirable by the department is provided for by the Lacey act, but as no money was appropriated for the purpose all the department can now do is to ward off undesirable importations and advise private individuals and associations that may wish to engage in the work. Much in this line has already been done. In 1889 and 1892 the Portland (Ore.) Society for the Acclimatization of European Song Birds spent $2000 in importing twenty species, including skylarks, black thrushes, starlings and green linnets. Twenty-five years ago the Cincinnati Acclimatization society spent $9000 for the same purpose. The only European song birds that have survived and spread have been the goldfinch and skylark; at a few points in this country is to be found the bird that has inspired the pens of many English poets. Within the past few years various game associations—chiefly on the Pacific slope—have imported foreign game birds with great success. Seven varieties of Asiatic and English pheasants are now common along the Willamette valley in Oregon, where the movement was started by a former American consul-general at Shanghai. I have heard an unconfirmed report that a few years ago a patriotic German-American imported some German wild boars to stock his country estate in Pike county, Pa. The animals escaped from the preserve ac- peals, new trials and changes of juris on. What they did know was that they gone with enthusiasm into the work of cating various state laws in the past, seen the acts passed with a sense of ph, had begun prosecutions under them 1 had seen the offenders escape by the loopholes which state statutes afford. wanted to know whether the Lacey vas really going to do the work. By its ts shall you know it. Dr. Palmer him related this experience.

* * *

few days after the Lacey act went effect the department of agriculture a few years ago a patriotic German-American imported some German wild boars to stock his country estate in Pike county, Pa. The animals escaped from the preserve, according to the story, and are now to be seen occasionally in the forests of the northeastern part of the state.

* * *

Governor Jordan has affixed his signature to a new and revised code of fish and game laws of New Hampshire, which passed the house and senate without opposition. The new code in the main embodies the ideas of the council of sportsmen which met in

MIRROR AND FARMER. THURSDAY. MARC[H]

Manchester just prior to the opening of the legislature.

The most important change in the laws is that which makes it unlawful to dispose by sale of woodcock and partridges. This is a solar plexus blow at the market hunter, who in late years has had the cream of game bird shooting in this state, while the sportsman proper has had to put up with skimmed milk. The following is a noteworthy addition to the laws:

"No person shall, within this state, kill or catch or have in his possession, living or dead, any wild bird other than a game bird, nor shall purchase, offer, or expose for sale any such wild bird after it has been killed or caught. No part of the plumage, skin, or body of any bird protected by this section

vered and seized 2600 gulls in a large sale millinery house in Baltimore. hours after the seizure Dr. Palmer had phone message from the house asking the new law be explained to them, and

No. 29.—A

1. A large bo[x]. [illegible]able. 3. A pl[illegible] To ratify. 6. plants embracin[g] plants. 7. A pl[illegible] native of Aral[illegible] bundle of goods [illegible]

See the clipping