As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

November 1898

6 articles

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

Rev. G. W. Tuttle proposes that passenger pigeons were wiped out by a massive sleet and hail storm during migration, citing a sea captain's account of dead pigeons covering the ocean surface. The report treats this storm theory as a credible alternative to human-caused extinction, noting skepticism that man alone could have destroyed the species so quickly.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 41 days later.

Wrong

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 3 November 1898 · page 4

A NEW THEORY. Many efforts have been made to ac count for the sudden and complete dis appearance of the wild pigeons which formerly flew about in such numbers as to obscure the light of the sun, ac cording to the story of some inhabi tants who are not yet very old and hardened liars. A new and interesting theory is put forward by Rev. G. W. Tuttle, of Wallace Bay, Nova Scotia. Mr. Tuttle thinks that "an unparallel ed storm of sleet and hail" destroyed the birds during their migration.

See moreSee less

He writes: As nearly as my memory serv es me, it was when I was stationed as a missionary on the island of Bermuda that I fell In with a sea captain, who related to me some of his experiences when crossing the Atlantic during this storm. As nearly as I can remember at this writing, he said he encountered on his voyage quantities of wild pigeons beaten down by this storm, so many in number as actually to impede the progress of his ship. In places the whole surface of the ocean was thick with them.being piled one upon another by the force of the wind and the waves. This was a revelation to me. It told of the sad fate of the beautiful birds whosevariegated plumage and habits we so much admired. This theory has merit, and so has the captain's story, on which it is based. The wild pigeons have certainly gone, and it is difficult to believe that they were destroyed by man in a few years.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report describes woodland animals like the kangaroo mouse, deer, and bears competing for nuts in the Adirondacks during a bountiful chestnut year. It notes that destruction of beech ridges accelerated the disappearance of wild pigeons and warns deer may starve once these trees vanish.

The Sun · 14 November 1898 · page 2

the little nuts of the trees. The nuts are the life and death ot more crea tures than any other product of tho forests, ox cept acorns, and the destruction of the beech ridges hastened the passing of the wild pigeonsWhen these trees are gone in the Adlrondacks the deor will He down and starve.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The Smithsonian Institution reports that all efforts to obtain a live specimen of the wild or passenger pigeon have failed, despite offering a liberal reward and conducting extensive correspondence and inquiry. No live passenger pigeon could be produced.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Daily Kennebec Journal, 2 September 1898, Daily Kennebec Journal, 27 September 1898.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 25 November 1898 · page 5

Wild Pigeons Extinct

"Wild Pio-eons Extlact. The . Smithsonian institution has an nounced that all efforts on its part to ob tain a live specimen of the wild or passen ger pigeon have resulted In failure. Not withstanding a liberal reward was offered by the institution, and much correspond ence and inquiry werercarried on, no I've passenger pigeon has been produced.:

See the clipping

The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or.

The article notes that for years naturalists like Audubon and Wilson studied passenger pigeons without realizing robins also gather in large communal roosts. It describes robins massing by the hundreds in sheltered woods in spring, arriving stealthily and loudly before falling silent for the night.

The Corvallis Gazette · 25 November 1898 · page 4

Robin Roosts. For many years naturalists like Au dubon and Wilson studied and wrote of this bird before it was known, that there were "robin roosts" as well as pigeon roosts. Only within the last few years was the fact brought out that a bird more familiarly known than the passenger pigeon followed this mode of spending the night, although it adopted spring instead of fall for massing by hundreds in a high-sheltered wood for a nighfs protection from cold, or because It is the period before pairing time, or for some other reason at present beyond man's ken.

See moreSee less

With what stealth must this well-known and much-observed bird have found its way In such numbers to the same patch of timber night after night In the early months of the year, according to lo cality, coming from all directions so swiftly that a secreted observer could not count, -keeping up a chatter that could be heard for a long distance, un til the last bird, somewhat belated, per haps, found shelter In the darkening grove, when all became as silent as thousands of wings were folded to rest

See the clipping

The True Democrat · Bayou Sara, La.

The report describes how robins, like passenger pigeons, gather by the hundreds in sheltered groves at night, a behavior only recently documented by naturalists. It notes the birds arrive swiftly and silently from all directions, chattering until settling for the night, with the passenger pigeon used as a familiar reference point for this roosting phenomenon.

The True Democrat · 26 November 1898 · page 7

Chicago Times-Herald. Robln Roosts. For many years naturalists like Audubon and Wilson studied and pi wrote of this bird before it was known P that. there were "robin roosts" as well n as pigeon roosts. Only within the F last few years was the fact brought c out that a bird more familiarly known n than the passenger pigeon followed d this mode of spending the night, albi though it adopted spring instead of n

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The Smithsonian Institution reports that all its efforts to obtain a live specimen of the wild or passenger pigeon have failed. Despite offering a liberal reward and conducting extensive correspondence and inquiry, no live passenger pigeon could be produced.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 28 November 1898 · page 8

Wild Pigeons Extinct. The Smithsonian institution has an nounced that all efforts on its part to obJain a live specimen of the wild or passen ger pigeon have resulted in failure. Note withstanding a liberal reward was offered by the institution, and much correspond ence and inquiry were carried on, no live passenger pigeon has been produced. Sy

See the clipping