At a Rotary luncheon, General E. A. Williams recalled how General Grant refused to shake hands with Sitting Bull at the 1894 laying of the North Dakota capitol cornerstone. He noted this occurred years after Sitting Bull and Gall's Sioux warriors had defeated Custer's forces at the Little Bighorn during Grant's presidency.
The Bismarck Tribune · 6 November 1929 · page 9
GEN. WILLIAMS SAW GRANT SNUB SITTING BULL IN BISMARCK
How one distinguished man refused to shake hands with Sitting Bull at the laying of the capitol cornerstone in 1894 was related by General E. A. Williams at the Rotary luncheon, at noon today, when he was speaking on the induction of North Dakota in to the national union as a state, the constitutional convention that pre ceded that event und the laying of the capitol foundations. General Grant was the man who snubbed the old Indian. He placed his hands behind his back and gave Silling Bull a stony stare. It was during Grant's presidential adminis tration that the Sicux under Gall and Sitting Bull had wiped out Custer and his battalion at the battle of the Little Big Horn. General Wil
The writer recounts his boyhood acquaintance at Fort Keogh with Cheyenne and Sioux participants in the Little Bighorn battle, including Two Moons, Fire Crow, and Wolf Voice. He recalls gathering their personal recollections of the fight in which Custer and his command were killed.
The Poplar Standard · 7 November 1929 · page 7
NONE KNOWS WHAT INDIAN KILLED GENERAL GEORGE A. CUSTER
version of the Custer battle as related to him by Indian participants. had been captured and brought into Fort Keogh as prisoners. Among the Indians I became acquainted with were Two Moons, who was fighting chief of the Cheyennes in the battle; Fire Crow, a Cheyenne; Wolf Voice (“Indi an Jim”' who was a Gros Ventre, but who had married a Cheyenne girl and lived with the Cheyennes; High Walk ing, a sub-chief of the Cheyennes, who, I think, is still living on the Lame Deer reservation: Raln-in-the-Face, who was a Sioux chief and a deadly enemy of Colonel Tom Custer; American Horse, Sioux; Hump, an Ogallala chief, and numerous others.
See moreSee less
tured. I was on very friendly terms with three in particular—Two Moons, Fire Crow, and Wolf Voice, and I secured a great deal of information from them concerning the Custer battle. Two Moons and Wolf Voice both spoke good English. Fire Crow talked English brokenly. Two Moons Tells of Battle Two Moons and his squaw were fre quent visitors at my home as my mother always found something for them to eat and that is an item an Indian never overlooks. My step father, Charlie White, (known to the Indians as Big Knife), and Two Moons over.” were firm friends. My step-father spoke the Cheyenne language fluently and used to hold long pow-wows with Two Moons. Two Moons called me Boy White.
A writer recounts decades-old conversations with Native American scouts and veterans about the Custer battle, comparing their accounts to one by a Mr. Daly. The informants disagree on whether Crazy Horse or Gall was the principal fighting chief, and offer varying estimates of warrior numbers and battle duration.
The Poplar Standard · 7 November 1929 · page 7
read, a thing he was much interested in. He learned quite fast. He was a scout for General Miles in 1879. Being at my home so often, those two afforded much opportunity for me to ask questions of which I took ad vantage, and asked them a great many questions on the different fights be tween the Indians and soldiers, mainly, though, on the battle between Custer’s command and the Indians. Gall, the Fighting Chief Mr. Daly gives aoout the best de scription of the Custer fight, I think, I have ever read, but he aiders on one point from the way I got it from sol diers of the Second cavalry and Fifth Infantry and from the Indians.
See moreSee less
He gives the leadership of the Indians to Crazy Horse. l~wo Moons and Wolf Voice, and others to whom I spoke, all recognized Chief Gall as being the fightin" chief in that battle. Mr. Daly says Custer played directly into the hands of the Indians. Two Moons, Wolf Voice and Fire crow all told me exactly the same thing. Two Moons said, "Indians fool Cus ter. Only few Indians show up and shoot, put up few tepees where Custer can see, big camp up river where sol diers not see it. Custer think only little camp. All soldiers come on. Then lots of Indians show up around sol diers and in little whue kill all the soldiers." Wolf Voice Confirms Story Woll Voice told me practically the same thing. I asked ootn of these In dians how long the tight lasted and they both said it was over in not more than three-quarters of an hour after the stand was made on the ridge to where Custer had fallen back after he realized he was up against an over
A 1929 reminiscence recounts interviews with Indian veterans like Two Moons and Wolf Voice, who insisted Sitting Bull was a medicine man who stayed in his tepee during the battle rather than a fighting chief or strategist. It also describes prisoners at Fort Keogh like Rain-in-the-Face and Fire Crow, and disputes the Curly-escaped-in-a-blanket story.
The Poplar Standard · 7 November 1929 · page 7
tured. Mr. Daly in his narrative explodes an idea that the public long held as a fact and one whlcn I have often looked to see contradicted—that is, that Sit ting Bull was the chief of the Sioux and also the brains of the fight, the main strategist and planner. Both of the Indians whom I mention told me that Sitting Bull was a medicine man and not a chief. When I asked Two Moons about the BuU, he spat on the ground and said, “Sitting BuU no fighter, he medicine man, he not in fight at aU, he in tepee making medicine, no come tiU fight over.” Gall Slapped Sitting BuU Wolf Voice said Sitting BuU had nothing to do in the fight as far as fighting was concerned.
See moreSee less
He stayed in his medicine tepee two miles from the battle ground making medicine and he (Wolf Voice) did not see Sitting BuU
The piece profiles Captain Belk, a longtime Missouri River steamboat pilot and later Bismarck police magistrate, noting he was a captain during the time Custer's forces were massacred at the Little Big Horn. It details his career hauling soldiers and supplies, his family history, and his later life as a riverman and ferry captain.
The Bismarck Tribune · 13 November 1929 · page 9
Webb Block Phone u trip north to Fort Benton. Montana, and Belk obtained the post of ap prentice pilot on one of these carry ing supplies to the army posts along the river. From thence on he plied the Missouri till the days of boating came to their close. Some years ago, when Frank Fiske, the Fort Yates chronicler, was writ ing an article about river steamboat ing, a list was compiled of the boats on which Captain Belk had served in the capacities of pilot or captain and it totaled 75 names. Rising through the ranks of steam boat men, Belk. was a captain when Custer's forces were massacred at the Little Big Horn. He never luul
Former Bismarck Tribune printer McBride recounts in 1929 how news of Custer's defeat reached the town, claiming actual word of the battle arrived three days after Comanche was brought in. He describes the frantic rush to print a makeshift extra edition on the old hand-cranked press.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Bismarck Tribune · 20 November 1929 · page 2
DEVIL’ OH TRIBUNE, RECALLS OLD HUES E. A. Mcßride Was in Bismarck in 1876, When Custer Made His Last Stand When the old Washington ' arm strong" presses still were in use and when the makeup man still used “shoot sticks and mallets" to lock up the forms—them were the days, ac cording to E. A. Mcßride. Mcßride, who resides in Fargo had a hand in publishing the Bismarck Tribune when Colonel C. A. Louns berry was editor, publisher, reporter, business manager and what have you. That was back in 1876.
See moreSee less
the year that Custer made his last stand. "I was a printer's devil, about 13 years old. and I guess I did more work then than any three printers put to gether nowadays.” he said. “There weren’t any unions in those days and there weren't any newfangled type settin' machines either. All the type was set by hand, and believe me, it was some job.” The Tribune then was publishing about 700 copies a week, all set by hand, all printed on the old ‘ arm strong” isocallcd because one used his arms to operate it * and every copy folded by hand. Above People’s Tin Shop The shop was in a small room above George People's tin shop. T.vi>c cases, stock for the job press and the old “armstrong” and all the rest of the material was all mixed up to gether. said Mcßride. It usually took from 24 to 26 hours to run the 700 editions off the press—hours of hard labor. The sheets of paper were laid out on a flat form and a huge crank was turned by hand and rollers run by hand over the forms. Then the printed pages were stacked up and when the job was finished they were folded. The actual printing, however, was but an incident. Mcßride said. The real work came with setting the type by hand, which usually took most of the week. It was customary, he recalled, that after the paper was "out” a bottle of whisky was brought forth to “celebrate.” The printing "crew" consisted of two men and the “devil.” Frank Boles was the job foreman and Van Gor don. who came up from the St. Paul Pioneer Press, ran the press. McBride did the “dirty work." The paper consisted of eight pages and delivery was made through the mails, newsboys having no place in the sun then. Report Three Days Late It was while Mcßride was working on the Tribune that news reached Bismarck of Custer's death. Custer’s horse. "Comanche.” Mcßride recalled, was found down the river by a boat crew and brought to Bismarck. When the animal was found its saddle had been twisted under its stomach. Ac tual news of the Indian victory didn't reach Bismarck until three days later, recording to Mcßride. The town was greatly shocked and he recalled the frantic efforts of the Tribune crew to get out an extra. The first attempt failed, but finally a make shift edition was. prepared on the job press and distributed. Mcßride came to Bismarck in the spring of 1874, making the trip with his parents by ox team. The family came to Fargo in 1873 and the father bought some lumber and built a small shack In which they lived during the winter. In the spring he bought two teams of oxen and two wagons and the trip to Bismarck was begun. It took them 27 days for the journey. Mcßride said. There were no roads and very few trials at that time, he added.
An 84-year-old farmer named Phillip Wanger claims to have been a courier who tried to deliver a message to Custer that arrived too late. He describes finding Custer's body face down with spent shells and pistols nearby after the battle.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
South Bend News-Times · 23 November 1929 · page 36
Courier for Custer, Gives New Light on Death of Leader
A. Custer, killed in the massacre of j the Little Big Horn during the Civil war, was recently divulged by Phillip Wanger, 84, Indian fighter and cour ier, now & farmer living near here. Because the message Wanger had been entrusted to deliver to Custer arrived too late to be rtad by the famous leader, the aged courier never cared to discuss his perilous ride through Indian country and the spec tacle that dimmed his then youthful eyes at the termination of the ride. Custer Surrounded .Born in Belgium In 1845, Wanger was an infantryman assigned to Com pany K of the Second United States Infantry.
See moreSee less
His five years service was spent for the most part In the sad dle. He was bugler and orderly to Captain Sam McKeever of the Sec ond. . On June 25, 1876, Custer was hard pressed. His supporting columns had failed MmA number of couriers | were sent out for aid, but history re i cards that only one other man be sides Wanger, a member of a cavalry | outfit, was able to break through the Indian lines. When Wanger had completed his long ride from Powder Creek Valley to the place where Custer had fallen with his regiment in the rocky ter ritory of Little Big Horn, he found Custer on the ground, face down. A pile of shells from his rifle and a brace of pistols were beside him. Custer, the hero of the Civii war and innumerable Indian fights had been dead for more than an hour. He had been shot more than 20 times.
A veteran named Wanger, recounting his experiences, describes finding Custer's body after the battle among many scalped soldiers, but states Custer himself was not scalped. He claims friendly Indians later told him Custer was too great a chief to suffer that indignity, and that a message he was tasked to deliver to Custer was lost at headquarters.
South Bend News-Times · 23 November 1929 · page 36
Nearly all of the soldiers about him had been scalped by the savages. Custer Not Scalped ; Custer had not been scalped. Wan-' ger related that he learned later from friendly Indians that even among the ranks of the savages Custer had been respected and that “he was too big a chief‘s to suffer such ignominy. Wanger declares he never learned the contents of the message he was to deliver to Custer. He returned it to bis commander after he had help ed to bury the dead general and his ill-fated followers.
See moreSee less
In the furore that followed Wanger said the message was lost at general headquarters. Wanger readily admitted he did not join the army in 1875 to be an, In dian fighter, nor was a career of thrills his purpose in enlisting. He declared he joined the infantry, be cause jobs in Cleveland were so scarce he could not earn enough to eat. The army post paid htm $13 a month. Of that he saved $10 each month and sent it to his mother.
The article recounts a 1886 commemorative gathering at the Little Bighorn battlefield, where Chief Gall and several survivors, including General Godfrey and Lieutenant DeRudio, revisited the site a decade after Custer's defeat. It also reports on Montana's new state geographic board formed to standardize place names.
The Poplar Standard · 28 November 1929 · page 3
nals of the nation. • Softly walked the gathered hosts over the sod of that battlefield on the evening before the tenth anniversary of Custer’s annihilation. Beneath the surface of the earth lay 13 officers, 191 men, four civilians and three scouts. Five troops of Custer's command had been completely wiped out within a brief period on that memorable Sun day afternoon a decade since. Chief Gall Near Monument Chief Gall stood there that afternoon of the day preceding the celebration. He was near the monument that is erected on the hill commanding a view of the scene of the strife in which he had played an immortal and tragic part. Before, him rose the forms of valiant men and their commanders. General Custer was in the forefront.
A 1929 article recounts the Battle of the Little Bighorn through the memories of Chief Gall, describing troop positions and the deaths of Custer's officers. It details Reno's retreat across the river and Gall's deployment of Crow King, Crazy Horse, and Rain-in-the-Face against Custer's forces.
The Poplar Standard · 28 November 1929 · page 3
The shadows of the departed moved again. Over there was Captain Keogh and Lieutenant Porter directing the movements of Troop I. Captain Yates and Lieutenant ReUy maneuvering the men of Troop F. Right near the com manding general, Captain Tom Custer and Lieutenant Harrington, Troop C, listened to and followed the directions of their chief. Yonder on the edge of the hill Lieutenants Smith and Sturgis, Troop E, were making a determined stand against heavy odds and were be ing pushed back by the oncoming, shouting, enemy host. Not far away Lieutenants Calhoun and Crittenden at the head of Troop L, saw that the tide of battle was moving against them and decided to go back toward the center of the attacking forces but were shot down one by one.
See moreSee less
Lieutenant Cook, adjutant, was in constant com munication with General Custer. Dr. G. E. Lord, the medical officer, was running here and there administering to the sick and dying and in turn was mowed down in the general onslaught. Through the mind of Chief GaU ran the events as they had transpired, and he remembered the details. They were yet fresh in his memory, but there was no betrayal in his countenance that he was sorry. His stoicism was in strange contrast to the flowers of memory, sad and subdued in variegated hues, grow ing then in the garden of conflict. Reno Held in Check Chief Gall remembered that Major Reno had crossed the river, as he was Instructed by Custer, and was repulsed and driven back across, losing a num ber of men in the letreat. He re membered that he detailed a group of savages to hold him on Reno Hill while he galloped away to lead the main body of Indians against the White Chief. He icmdmbered that he sent Crow King, Crazy Horse and Rain-ln the-Face into the fray with orders to give no quarter and expect none. Chief Gall remembered that he watched Crow King, a real cavalry commander, charge right through Custer’s men, shooting them right and left. The whole panorama of the bloody engagement spread out before his mental vision on that eventful tenth anniversary of the great conflict. Chief Gall, standing near the monu ment and envisioning the tragedy of the Little Big Hom, was approached by a small group of white men. Mr. Barry says of him that he was the master mind and the great Indian gen eral of the Indians. In few words he told those who inquired of him what he saw and knew. His first observa tion was that General Custer never crossed the river to fight the Indians in the valley. His next observation, which was corroborated by Lieutenant Deßudlo, was that the fight lasted about 35 minutes. The brief silence that followed these statements on the part of Chief GaU was broken by Gen eral Godfrey, who asked: “GaU, tell us how many Indians were there here fighting the Big Chief, General Custer?” Number in the Battle No words came from the Ups of the Indian chief. He stood there in a col orful silhouette against the background ot the white men-gathered about him eager to listen to his answer. Slowly he raised his hand. With appropriate gestures he pointed out where Crazy Horse and his band of Indians were fighting; he showed the place and pointed out the position he occupied in the battle; he Indicated where Crow King, cavalry leader, and Rain-in-theFace were out there near the timber. “Oh, tell us,” interjected General Godfrey, "how many Indians there were altogether here at this point fight-