As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

December 1927

11 articles

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A 1927 article quotes Finerty's and Bourke's accounts of the Battle of the Rosebud, describing how Crook's forces nearly rode into a Sioux and Cheyenne ambush in a canyon trap. Crazy Horse later told Crook he had 6,500 warriors concealed and planned to lure the troops into a cul-de-sac for annihilation.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 1 December 1927 · page 3

It will be seen from what both Finerty and Bourke say of the Rosebud canyon that Grouard had noted things to a nicety as he passed down the "cul de sac" in advance of Mill’s courageous battallion. He knew, because his six years’ experience with these same Indians had been a practical lesson to him. that death awaited the entire command at the lower end of the canyon. One of the great wonders now is why Crazy Horse, when it was dis covered that Mills' battallion turned to leave the death trap, did not fall upon and annihilate it.

See moreSee less

The explana tion seems to be found in the words of Crazy Horse himself. He wanted the entire command, and even then had hopes of getting it. Failing, he repeated the tactics then attempted at the Custer massacre, and, with the same force he had thrown against Crook, caught the five troops of the Seventh Cavalry (rank and file) to the very last soul.—Author.)

See the clipping

The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.

A delegation of American Indians visited Chicago Mayor Thompson to point out historical inaccuracies in school textbooks, including the claim that the Little Bighorn battle was mislabeled a 'massacre' when it actually resulted from frontiersmen violating treaties. The mayor listened but offered no commitments, instead having them perform vaudeville routines.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 20 days earlier.

The Daily Worker · 3 December 1927 · page 2

Mayor Thompson of Few Real Lies in Histories CHICAGO, 111., Dec. 2.—A delega tion of American Indians called upon Mayor Thompson of Chicago yester day and notified him that there was some things in American school his tory books much more important to a person really seeking the truth about past events than the alleged pro-Britishisms he attacks. The delegation stated that there were no wars between Indians and whites until the invading colonists took over more and more of Indian lands, that scalping was not practised until the colonists began offering prizes to mercenaries for the heads of their foes, that the Black Hawk war was the result of the settlers attacking Black Hawk, and the Battle of the Little Big Horn, called “the massacre of Custer” was the result of the violation by the frontiersmen of treaties made with the Indians.

See moreSee less

Mayor Thompson had the Indians perform vaudeville stunts, but prom sed nothing.

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A first-person retrospective account describes the Battle of the Rosebud, including the dangerous canyon terrain and Major Nickerson's dramatic ride to summon reinforcements for Royall's hard-pressed troops. The narrator notes that Custer, marching with a comparable force, was annihilated by the same Indian enemy about eighteen miles away just eight days later.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 8 December 1927 · page 3

column some distance In the rear. The day had become absolutely perfect, and we all felt elated, exhlllrated as we were by our morning's ex perience. Nevertheless, some of the more thoughtful offi cers had their misgivings, because the canyon was cer tainly a most dangerous defile, where all the advantage would be on the side of the savages. Gen. Custer, al

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A scout describes seeing Indian smoke signals indicating a fight was underway, then riding out that night to follow troop trails toward the Little Big Horn. He recounts stumbling in the dark onto the battlefield, discovering a scalped body before realizing he had reached Custer's field.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 8 December 1927 · page 3

find some traces of hostile Indians; and one day, happen ing to be up on the mountains, I saw some Indian signals down on the divide between the Rosebud and Little Big Hom. These signals were to the effect that the Indians and troops were fighting, and the Indians liad the best of it. This was between 9 and 10 o’clock in the morn ing. Getting on my horse and going down into camp. I told the officers that the Indians were having a fight— I supposed with the troops—and had got way the best of them.

See moreSee less

The officers had never heard of Indian signals, and didn’t suppose such things were in existence. They laughed at the idea of Indians having smoke signals; hardly crediting my statement. It made me a little bit out of temper the way they talked about it. and I told them that I would prove to them I was right. I saddled up my horse and starred for where the signals had been given, reaching what at first seemed to be the trail of troops on the divide between the Rosebud and Little Big Horn just about dark on the night of June 25th, and soon found that troops had been along there. I started to follow up the trail, which led down a creek. In following up the trail, it led me almost to the mouth of the creek where it empties into the Little Big Hom, then turning off to the right, traveling along parallel to the creek and back into the bluffs. I found’ out afterwards that Custer and Reno had separated there! where the trail left this creek, but not knowing this at' the time, I could only follow the plainest trail I could find. I followed the trail out where the Custer command had tried to cross the Little Big Horn, out again, and

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A scout recounts riding across the Little Bighorn battlefield after the fight, discovering scalped soldiers' bodies among the dead. He then infiltrates the Sioux camp disguised as an Indian, revealing his identity as 'the Grabber' to an old Sioux herder.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 8 December 1927 · page 3

of the dead, and was forced to follow the ridge all the । way down. It seemed to me for a long time—l could ■ not see them, but could tell by. the way my horse acted —that I was traveling amongst dead people all the way down the • ridge. I don’t think I was over ten minutes riding down the ridge, but it seemed quite a while before I could get away. Finally I did get up through them, and went down and crossed the Little Big Horn to the other side onto the high lands, then turned and followed up the river, but keeping away in order to find the Indian trail, if possible.

See moreSee less

It was along toward morning before I found the trail leading up the Little Big Horn towards the mountains. Following that up and keeping off the main trail. I could hear the Indians traveling backwards and forwards, but could not see them. I heard no firing of guns. Reaching the outskirts of the Indian camp on Pass creek at the mouth of Twin creek on the Big Flat. I arrived at their main camp close to daybreak. Riding around from the lower end to the upper end. and keeping away from the lodges. I found an old Indian driving up his ponies, or herding them, rather. I rode up to him for the purpose of finding out. if I could, what had been the result of the battle I knew had so recently occurred. I was dressed up as an In-1 dian. and had a blanket over me. so the old fellow could not tell who or what I was. As soon as I commenced talking to him in the Sioux tongue, he asked me who I was. I told him that I was Sitting Bull's brother; that I was looking for my horse; that I had been out on a scout and had not seen the fight, as I had just got back that evening. He suspicioned me of not being what I said I was. and tried to find out who I was by getting up close to me. and I saw I could not get any informa tion out of him. It was then daybreak, and on his ask ing me again who I was. I told him that they had al ways called me the “Grabber.’’ That was the nickname the Indians had for me when I was among them. Quick as he heard who I was. the old man gave one yell and about two jumps, and was across on the other side of the creek hallooing that the troops were on them. Well, by this time the whole camp was in com motion. I had started back toward Tongue river on a pretty good gallop. I got quite a distance—five or six miles. I guess—before any of them came in sight, and by that time it was broad daylight. I had such a start o. them that they could not catch me. They ran me clear back

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

The passage from a 1927 biography of scout Frank Grouard criticizes Reno for not attempting to reach Custer's command on June 25, arguing public opinion held Custer would have tried to save Reno under reversed circumstances. It cites Grouard's claim, based on Indian accounts, that Custer attempted to cross the Little Big Horn at a point later identified by trail evidence.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 8 December 1927 · page 11

BY Joe Deßarthe From this statement of Benteen’s it does not seem that he had received any orders from Custer to attack any portion of the Indian village, and this view is further borne out by the statement of Benteen that he carried out the orders that Custer had given him. But both he and Reno must have known that Custer was battling with the hostiles at some point not far distant; and yet no effort was made to reach the Custer command the day of the 25th of June. There is little if any doubt but what Reno's com mand would have been annihilated had it not been for the timely arrival of Gibbon.

See moreSee less

The Indians claimed that they had Reno Just where they wanted him. but were not given time enough to move their camp far enough from the scene of battle before making their Anal cleanup of the soldiers. Notwithstanding this claim of the Indians, and admitting that Reno would have taken desperate chances in attempting to go to the assistance of Custer, the people of the United States will always think he should have taken the chances, and believe and know Custer would have not hesitated a second in making such a move had matters been reversed. Custer would have fought his way to Reno, under such circumstances, or died on the bluffs In making the attempt. Grouard, whose acquaintance with the Indians was more extended than that of any man who has ventured to speak on this subject, and who was on the battlefield at 11 o’clock on the night succeeding the day of the butchery, says the Indians told him Custer made an attempt to cross the Little Big Hom where the trail of the command was afterward discovered leading down to the edge of the river. But the Indians met him in great numbers at this point, and he found it impossible to cross. The water was high, and the bed of the river at all times is full of quicksand at this point, and the In dians told Grouard that one of the soldiers' pack mules, loaded with ammunition, was swallowed up In the sand when the attempt to ford the river was made.

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

This 1927 report recounts frontier scout Frank Grouard's secondhand Indian testimony about Custer's final movements, describing a failed attempt to ford the Little Bighorn River where quicksand swallowed a pack mule. It details how Custer was then pushed back onto the bluffs and surrounded by Indian forces attacking from multiple directions, with the entire engagement lasting less than an hour.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 8 December 1927 · page 11

when the attempt to ford the river was made. Custer then seemed determined, after his first re- [ pulse, to cross the river at a point lower down. To do, this he was forced back out into the Bluffs, and the 1 Indians, divining his intention, crossed the river below his command in thousands, attacking it on all sides at once. Custer must have recognized the almost hopeless ness of his position from the moment he found himself unable to cross the Little Big Horn where he first made the attempt; but that he did not lose his head is proved

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

The passage recounts scout Grouard's story of detecting Indian signals indicating a battle on June 25, and his subsequent ride to confirm the Custer fight. It also discusses confusion among officers about the exact timing of Reno's attack on the village and Custer's movements that morning.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 8 December 1927 · page 11

Indians, divining his intention, crossed the river below his command in thousands, attacking it on all sides at once. Custer must have recognized the almost hopeless ness of his position from the moment he found himself unable to cross the Little Big Horn where he first made the attempt; but that he did not lose his head is proved by the fact that he attempted to lead his command on [ to the bluffs ovtrlooking the valley. As soon, however, 1 as he left the river, the Indians got in between it and his command, so that, with the hostiles occupying the । draws on the south, the high bluffs on the east and the 1 river bottom on the west, the soldiers were forced to oc-' cupy a midway position between the higher points and the valley, and were driven along the slope east and north until the last one had been killed.

See moreSee less

•The Indians congregated so rapidly and were in such positions,’* said one of Grouard's Indian informants, “that there was no earthly chance for the command to; extricate itself. The troopers fought bravely and to the last, but the battle was over in less than one hour from J the time Custer made his first attempt to cross the Liti tic Big Hom.” I One peculiar thing about the entire matter is found in the uncertainty expressed by all the officers con cerning the time of day when the attack on the Sioux ' village (made by Reno's battalion) occurred. If. as the official reports claim. Custer was in the valley of thej Little Big Hom at eight o'clock in the morning of June 25th. it would seem highly probable that the attack oc-| curred long before noon of that date. Some of Reno's! soldiers claim that the two battalions (Custer's and | Reno’s) were still marching side by side when the indl-' cations of the Sioux village were so plain as to be un-! mistakable, and that the Colonel or the Seventh, elated at the prospect of an immediate engagement, cried. “Hur-! rah! Custer’s luck!” Immediately after this the com-.

See the clipping

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

Merritt B. Chichester, who served with General Custer on the plains up through the Little Bighorn battle, is shown at age 80 still holding a military bearing. The photo was taken at his home in Peabody, Massachusetts.

The Washington Daily News · 12 December 1927 · page 13

CUSTER S WAR MATE—Mer rit B. Chichester, w h o cam paigned against the Indians on the plains with Gen. George A. Custer right up until the his toric massacre, has kept his mil itary carriage unbent by 80 years. He posed for this photo at his Peabody (Mass.) home.

See the clipping

The Indian Leader · Lawrence, Kan.

A delegation from the Grand Council Fire of American Indians presented Chicago's mayor with a memorial protesting how history books label Indian victories as massacres while white victories are called battles. The memorial specifically cites the Custer battle, arguing Indians fought in self-defense against broken treaties and stolen land, and contrasts this framing with the Wounded Knee killings.

The Indian Leader · 16 December 1927 · page 1

GRAND COUNCIL FIRE OF AMERICAN INDIANS PRESENTS MEMORIAL

To the Mayor of Chicago: You tell all white men “America First.” We be We are the first Americans. lieve in that. We are the only ones, truly, that are 100 per cent. We, there fore, ask you while you are teaching school children about America first, teach them truth about the first Americans. We do not know if school histories are pro-British, but we do know that they are unjust to the life of our people, the American Indian. They call all white victories, battles, and all Indian victories, massacres. The battle with Custer has been taught to school children as a fearful massacre on our part. We ask that this, as well as other incidents, be told fairly. If the Custer Battle was a massacre,

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A 1927 newspaper account retells the story of the 'Sibley Scout,' in which Lieutenant Sibley and scout Frank Grouard narrowly escaped a large Sioux war party while scouting for General Crook's column, occurring around the same time as Custer's defeat. The piece includes details of two soldiers left behind, one of whom vanished and was presumed killed by Indians, and frames the episode as one of the most famous narrow escapes in frontier military history.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 29 December 1927 · page 3

■The 'Sibley Scout' is famous among Indian fighters as being one of the narrowest escapes from savages now on record. The hero (Lieutenant Sibley) of that hazard ous encounter with the dreaded Sioux, passed the whiter at this place In company with the writer." says a San Diego correspondent of the New York Tribune, "and fa vored him with a sketch of that memorable action of; a handful of troopers away up In the Big Horn moun tains, far from the mam command. It was in 1876, at the time of Custer's massacre, when E.

See moreSee less

W. Sibley of General Crook's column, then a young lieutenant, was ordered out with twenty-five mounted men to look about the country and see what was going on. Frank Grouard. one of the best scouts living, accompanied Sibley. The young officer was fresh from West Point, and rather In experienced In frontier warfare, so cautious General Crook bade him heed the scout’s advice should emergency arise, and off the troopers started almost at the very I hour when Cutter, a hundred miles or so away, was be ing cut to pieces by the cut-throats of Sitting Bull I Tbs scouting party was Ignorant of this, however?

See the clipping