As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1924

12 articles

Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.

A newspaper commentary mocks competing claims about Lincoln relics, then notes it's been a year since the reported 'last survivor' of Custer's massacre died, joking that it's time for another such claim. This reflects an ongoing pattern of dubious survivor stories tied to the Little Bighorn legend.

Edgefield Advertiser · 5 March 1924 · page 1

“last survivor” of Custer’s massacre died. In order to keep up an unbrok en record it’s about time for a report on another last one.—Greenville News. Death of Mr. W. E. Turner The announcement of the death of Mr. W. E. Turner at the home of his son in Georgetown Tuesday of last week greatly depressed his Edge field friends. His health had been failing for more than a year but few, if any, of his friends realized that his condition was so serious Mr. Turner was born and reared in the McKendree community, filling a large place in the community life and in Kendree church.

See moreSee less

He will be greatly missed. The body was brought to his old home for burial, the funeral being held at McKendree church Wednesday. Mr. Turner is survived by three daughters and five sons. Mrs. Tur ner preceded him to the heavenly home prepared for the faithful.

See the clipping

The Pleasantville Press · Pleasantville, N.J.

Mrs. Laura Hayward, wife of Charles Hayward—described as one of the last survivors of the Custer Massacre—died March 1, 1924, and was buried March 5 at the Snyder Memorial Mission in Pleasantville. The notice appears among routine local community items.

The Pleasantville Press · 8 March 1924 · page 4

LOCAL EVENTS Lewis H. Lake’s new home, on Lin den and Windsor avenues, is nearing completion. The next meeting of the Cardiff So cial Club will be held Monday evening. March 10th. A large attendance is re quested. Spring business will be tran sacted. Refreshments served. H. C. Stockinger, Jr., of New road, is making repairs to his Shore road property, which he recently purchased from Elwood Bartlett. Mr. Stockinger and family will take possession of their property in the near future. Mrs. Laura Hayward, wife of Charles Hayward, who is one of the last sur vivors of the Custer Massacre, passed away March 1, and was buried March 5, at 3 o’clock, from the Snyder Me morial Mission, 25 S.

See moreSee less

Third street, Pleasantville. An orchestra has been organized in cluding ten pieces, for the Sunday School of the First Presbyterian Church. The orchestra is making rap id progress under the direction of Mrs. Ezra A. Lake. Rehearsals are being held every Thursday evening. Whitey Swanson and Jack Kinsell defeated George and Edward McGin ley. at Linwood golf links Monday of last week, by the score of 3 and 2. The return match was played at Northfleld last Monday, when Swan son and Kinsell again triumphed, this time 3 and 1.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article describes a museum's exhibits, including a 1913 Catholic University Bulletin account of relics donated by Father E. W. Lindesmith, a former Army chaplain stationed at Fort Keogh during the Sioux war. The collection includes Custer's camp trunk, recaptured rifles and bayonets from the 'massacre,' and numerous Sioux and Cheyenne artifacts.

Evening Star · 9 March 1924 · page 65

States Army, and now chaplain of St. Ann's Asylum of Cleveland, Ohio. This collection had bean gathered by the donor while he was stationed at Fort Keogh, Mont., during the Sioux war, shortly after the Custer mas sacre. It contains the camp trunk of Gen. G. A, Custer, several rifles and bayonets —relics of the massacre, which were afterward recaptured A by the American troops—a great number of army implements, swords, spurs, bits, shackles, etc., used during, the ‘Sitting Bull* campaign; over 100 specimens of Sioux and Cheyenne weapons, ornaments, saddles, beaded work, medicine sticks, etc., and.

See moreSee less

Anal ly, several objects used formerly by frontiersmen. Father Lindesmith has written opt a full description and his tory of most of these specimens on a large tag fastened to each object. These descriptions present a vivid picture of the garrison and officers at Fort Keogh, of the life at the post trader’s store and of the habits and peculiarities of the Indiana who con tributed to the collection.” Meatthe CtfSter collection is a fair-

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The Bismarck Tribune issued a golden anniversary edition featuring facsimiles of its early pages, including the front page of its 1876 Custer massacre 'extra' and its 1873 issue covering the Gordon-Gordon case. The article reviews the paper's history and Bismarck's growth from a 'lurid' town of 1,500 to a city of 10,000.

The Bismarck Tribune · 12 March 1924 · page 8

Custer massacre "extra’’, July G. 1,876. j “Bismarck town had only 1,500 people, according to a review of its history in the Bismarck Tribune,: when the' first copy of the paper i came out:- and was a “lurid" town. Today it is a city of 10,006.’"

See the clipping

The Minnesota Fiery Cross · St. Paul, Minn.

A Mason City, Iowa report speculates that a Thomas Nelson recently reported dead in Alaska may be the same man who buried $500,000 in gold coin in Iowa 40 years earlier before vanishing in the Klondike rush. The article recounts Nelson's mysterious past, including his time in the Little Big Horn country before the Black Hills gold rush.

The Minnesota Fiery Cross · 14 March 1924 · page 3

May Look for Lost Treasure Buried in Northern Iowa By Survivor of Custer Massacre

He landed in the Little Big Horn country prior to the discovery of the yellow metal in the Black Hills. While the excitement was at its

See the clipping

The Minnesota Fiery Cross · St. Paul, Minn.

A 1924 article recounts the story of 'Thomas Nelson,' later identified as a mysterious white-haired stranger, who claimed to have watched the Battle of Little Bighorn from a nearby hill and escaped as the sole survivor. He allegedly wandered five days without food before later striking gold in the Black Hills, with his fortune supposedly buried in Iowa.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Minnesota Fiery Cross · 14 March 1924 · page 3

height, Nelson fell in with a small detachment of Custer’s men and for a time was engaged in conveying wagon trains through dangerous ter ritory. When Custer made his last stand in the basin of the Little Big Horn, Nel son was within earshot of the battle. All that fatal day, the adventurer, whose gold is believed to be buried in lowa soil, watched the ebb and flow of the battle tide from an em inence overlooking the bloody basin in which was staged the most thrill ing, wild and savage drama ever enacted in the history of the west.

See moreSee less

After the battle was ended he was five days in finding his way back to safety in the breaks of the bad lands. During the five days he was without drink or food, save the slight nournishment derived from chewing the buckskin fringe of his coat, and eating his rawhide shoe strings. He alone escaped out of the death trap in the Little Big Horn— the sole survivor of Custer’s last campaign. During the mad and lawless days —days of gold in the Black Hills, he became a prospector and a miner in the camps at Lead and Gayville. He was credited with having amassed a fortune of $500,000. This is believed to be buried in lowa. In the summer of 1884, ten years after the discovery of the gold in the Black Hills, a stranger called at the Wheeler ranch near Wheelerwood, Cerro Gordo county. He was not an old man, but his hair was white as snow. He obtained work on the place and remained all summer . He gave his name as Thomas Nelson and explained that he was from the west. The late Charles Van Note was in charge of the ranch at that time. His son, R. M. Van Note, iB now a resident of Fertile, a few miles from Mason City. He recalls the days when Nelson worked for his father. He remembers that he always car ried a revolver,” said Mr. Van Note, “and people said he was a miner from the west. One day a neighbor came to the farm and found him in the barn counting gold coins. He had the money stacked up in a high pile. ‘Then he put the money all back in heavy bags and fastened them to a leather belt. It was rumored about that he kept his money buried some where on the ranch. A year or two later it spread about that he was un able to find his buried money. He remained in Cerro Gordo county for 10 or 15 years and spent most of his time on Lime creek, traveling up and down the stream. He joined the Klondike rush in 1897 and was neve heard of again.”

See the clipping

The Wolf Point Herald · Wolf Point, Mont. · and 2 other papers

This 1924 account describes the Far West and other steamboats loading Native American families and tepees for transport down the Yellowstone River, in a scene of chaos and farewells. The report notes the Far West's earlier fame as the boat that carried supplies during the 1876 campaign that ended in Custer's death at Little Bighorn.

The Wolf Point Herald · 20 March 1924 · page 3

Bachelier, the General Rucker, Katie P. Kountz, and the Nellie Peck. Through some misunderstanding the fifth boat had not arrived, The water in the river was falling fast and fears were entertained that it would fall to a point too low for the boats to make the trip down. After three days' wait the last boat put in its appearance. It was the Far West. The Far West was one of the most famous of the steamboats of the early days. It was the Far West that in 1876 carried supplies for the army in the campaign that ended with the massacre of General Custer and his men on the Little Big Horn. The day after the arrival of the Far West,

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • · · 21 March 1924
  • The Browning Review · Browning, Mont. · 21 March 1924

The Browning Review · Browning, Mont. · and 2 other papers

The report recounts how Two Moons' band of Cheyennes vanished from the Indian Territory reservation in 1883 and mysteriously reappeared on Lame Deer Creek in Montana by 1884, eluding detection the entire way. The author notes that despite personal acquaintance with Two Moons, the Cheyennes never revealed how they accomplished the journey, and the secret died with them.

The Browning Review · 21 March 1924 · page 5

Cheyennes were camped on Lame Deer. This was the reservation they wanted and they had come back to it from the Indian Territory. How they came and how they eluded all notice by white people on that long journey has never been found out. I have talked to Two Moons many times. He was an old acquaintance of mine. I knew him when he was a prisoner at Keogh. He would talk freely on any subject, especially the Custer fight, in which he and his band of Cheyennes took a prominent part.

See moreSee less

But the moment I would speak of the trip from the Indian Terri tory to Montana, he would quit talk ing and not one word could be got ten from him on the subject. Nor has anyone of the older Cheyennes ever divulged the secret, whether the younger people know of it I do not know, but not one of them will say a word about it and their trip north remains to this day a mystery. Through the efforts of General Mlles, the government set aside a reservation on Lame Deer for the Cheyennes and most of the ones who made that mysterious trip are burled on the banks of Lame Deer creek, their secret going to the grave with them and the few that are left are guarding the secret as faithfully as those who are dead.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Wolf Point Herald · Wolf Point, Mont. · 20 March 1924
  • · · 21 March 1924

Keowee Courier · Pickens Court House, S.C.

An article reprinted from The Mentor argues that broken treaties with the Sioux, especially over the gold-rich Black Hills, led directly to Custer's death at Little Bighorn. It also claims a later battle avenged Custer, describing Indians being gunned down after surrendering their weapons.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Keowee Courier · 26 March 1924 · page 3

"Scrap of Paper" Caused Massacre

New York, March 20.—The story of treaties with the Sioux Indians is the story of scraps of paper torn up at the white man’s will, says Roger Daniels, In The Mentor for the cur rent month. When the Sioux crossed the Mis souri river and went into the Black Hills country it was with the under standing that no white man should enter their territory without permis sion of the Sioux. Gold was discovered In the Black Hills and the white man wanted it. Custer marched into the Black Hills regardless of the fact that he was violating the Tr&aty of Laraine.

See moreSee less

He made a new treaty. A mere handful of Sioux were represented. Custer pushed on. Then came the Custer massacre. A few years later, there was an other fight in whfch Custer was avenged. The story of the fight is that the Indians had given up their arms when the United States cavalry opened fire on them and annihilated them.

See the clipping

Clarke Courier · Berryville, Va.

A promotional piece touts Chief Strongheart, a performer and lecturer, claiming descent from chiefs who fought Custer at Little Bighorn. It recounts his biography, film roles, and his lecture 'From Peace Pipe to War Trail.'

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Clarke Courier · 27 March 1924 · page 1

INTERPRETING THE LIFE AND SOUL OF THE INDIAN Chief Strongheart ia the,first de scendant from the old fighting blood of Custer’s day. His grandfather. Chief Standing Rock, led one of the tribes which aided Chief Sitting Bull and Chief Yellow Hand in victory over Col. Custer in that historic bat tle familiarly referred to as Custer’s Last Stand. He has the original war bonnet of Chief Standing Rock which was worn in that battle. Chief Strongheart’s father is Chief Yellow Running Elk, and the old Chief saw to it that the Chief went thru the life of adventure of a real Indian boy.

See moreSee less

Chief Strongheart was born at the Yakima Reservation, Cascades, Washington State. Chief Strongheart was the first man to -enroll under the draft law in New York City, Precinct 13, waiv ing all exemption claims to which ho was entitled. He was the first full-blooded Indian to offer liis ser vices for overseas duty with Colonel Roosevelt's proposed division of Rough Riders. Among his own people, the Yakimas,.he is an advis er and counselor in their many re servation problems, and his own efforts have done much to improve their conditions und those of other tribesmen of the great Northwest. He has appeared extensively in the “movies,” and had conspicious roles in “The Flaming Arrow,” “The Heart of Wd-Ta-Na,” “The Mail De spatcher,” and other plays of the legitimate stage. Chief Strongheart speaks, acts and interprets the very life and soul of a great but vanishing race—his own people. His lecture. “From Peace Pipe to War Trail,” is really a dramatic recital, highly entertain ing and yet of .uft&sual educational worth. 1 He appear&y m fwff Chieftain’s re- . galia and is Of exceedingly picture sque appearance. He brings out all the sentiment, the poetry and ro mance in the life of the early Red j Man. He leaves an impression stim-1 ulating and .enduring—and usually , in contradiction to the school book idea of the American Indian. He re veals their nobility, patience, inher ent goodness, faith and sfuferings. Chief Strongheart will be at the New Theatre—one night only—Fri day, March 28. —.-0- .

See the clipping

The Buffalo Voice · Buffalo, Wyo.

This editorial discusses Senator Kendrick's role in exposing the Teapot Dome oil scandal, crediting him with the first speech prompting investigation. It references Custer's fall at Little Bighorn only as a rhetorical comparison to Wyoming's famous battlefields, not as a report on the battle itself.

The Buffalo Voice · 28 March 1924 · page 4

FIRST SENSES SCANDAV (Clark McAdams in the St. Louis Post Dispatch.) It wan Senator John B. Kendrick, the only Democratic United States senator Wyoming ever had, who fired the first shot in the now cele brated oil war. Had Wyoming sent more Democrats to the Senate, It is just possible that she would have more than simply the two famout battlefields of the Little Big Horn, where Custer fell, and Teapot Dome where Denby and some oth era

See the clipping

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

A 1924 literary column about humorist Irvin S. Cobb and writer Bret Harte makes a passing joking comparison, suggesting a photo looks like it was taken during 'the Custer Massacre or the passing of Geronimo.' The reference is purely rhetorical, not a report on the event itself.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 30 March 1924 · page 4

WHO'S COBB AND WHAT

■* "uaneniy upon tne rac« again. The very Incongruity of Its al llance with laughter overwhelmed me and wonderlngly I read what he had written, not once, but every day, alwaya with tfie handi cap of that half-tone. If Cobb were an old er man, I would go on the witness stand and swear that the photograph was made when he was witnessing the Custer Massacre or the passing of Geronlmo through the winter

See the clipping