As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

August 1919

13 articles

St. Tammany Farmer · Covington, La.

A newspaper profile describes Col. Theo. W. Goldin, a Seventh Cavalry veteran, now touring army camps for the YMCA telling stories of the old West, including his survival of the 'Battle of the Big Horn.' It recounts how he survived by being sent as a mounted orderly with dispatches to Major Reno during the battle.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

St. Tammany Farmer · 2 August 1919 · page 8

CUSTER VETERAN NOW WITH Y, M. C, A, Survivor of "Battle of Big Horn" Tour. Ing Southern Department Tell Ing Experiences. Col. Theo. W. Goldin, a veteran of Custer's famous Seventh cavalry, has for many months been devoting all of his time to war work with the Army Young Men's Christian association. He is now on a tour visiting all mili tary camps in the six states of the Southern Military department enter taining the soldiers with stories of the great West of the long ago. Colonel Goldin has had an unusual and picturesque career on the frontier as soldier, government scout and quar termaster clerk, having participated in several Indian campaigns, among them the "Battle of the Big Horn," where Custer and some five hundred veterans went down before ten times their number of Indians.

See moreSee less

He hds been in the Army Y. M. C. A. work since November, 1917, serving first at Fort Bliss and later at Presidio. He has been booked by the educational bu reau of the Southern Department Army Y. M. C. A. for a speaking tour in Southern department camps. Colonel Goldin owes his life to the fact that during the battle of the Big Horn le was serving as regimental clerk, and in that capacity was doing duty as mounted orderly. He was sent to Major Reno, some three miles away, with dispatches; but even then, during most of the ride, he was a tar

See the clipping

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

A Bismarck man named Jacob Horner, who served under Custer and was later discharged by General Hugh L. Scott, reminisces about his old commander ahead of Scott's planned visit to Fort Yates. Horner recalls their parallel courtships and marriages and praises Scott's character as a young officer.

Grand Forks Herald · 2 August 1919 · page 5

Hugh L. Scott, former chief of staff, to Fort Yates holds unusual interest unreasonably (f°r at least one Bismarck citizen, fighter undpr Custer and other famous 1

See the clipping

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

The report recalls a veteran, Mr. Horner, who served five years with the Seventh Cavalry, Custer's old command, and first met Hugh Scott (then a lieutenant) at Fort Lincoln in early 1876, before the Little Bighorn campaign. It is a nostalgic aside embedded in a roundup of unrelated North Dakota state news items.

Grand Forks Herald · 2 August 1919 · page 5

won the! respect and affection of men, and even as a green second-lieu-, the. river, early in 1876, before the statutes. Custer massacre on Little Big Horn, Thirty-eight years have passed since he last saw his beloved former commander, and if Hugh anywhere near this fojgi 'I Scott arrives post Veteran

See the clipping

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Bismarck resident Jacob Horner, a Seventh Cavalry veteran, reminisces about serving under young Lieutenant Hugh Scott at Fort Lincoln before the Custer massacre. He looks forward to Scott's upcoming visit after 38 years apart.

The Bismarck Tribune · 2 August 1919 · page 8

HORNER LOOKING FORWARD TO VISIT WITH OLD CHIEF

pers." Made Good Younfl. Major General Scott started in as a young man to make a good officer, says Mr. Horner. He never drank or indulged in other excesses which were then somewhat common on the part of officers and soldiers. He immedi­ ately won the respect and affection of his men, and even as a green second lieutenant he showed the promise that has since ibeen fulfilled. Mr. Horner, who served five years with the Seventh cavalry, Custer's old command, first met Major General Hugh Scott, then "Shavetail" Lieu­ tenant Scott, at Fort Lincoln, just across the river, early in 1876, ibefore the Ouster massacre on Little Big Horn.

See moreSee less

Thirty-eight years have pass­ ed since he last saw his beloved form­ er commander, and if Hugh Scott ar­ rives anywhere near this post Veteran Jacob Horner Intends to look him up.

See the clipping

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

A 1919 article reproduces reminiscences by a Missoula woman, Mrs. Woody, recalling that her father, Horace Countryman, carried the news of the Custer massacre by riding day and night from Columbus. The piece also recounts her family's earlier pioneer travels through California, Nevada, and Montana.

Grand Forks Herald · 5 August 1919 · page 3

WAS MADE PUBLIC Missoula in June, 1870, jotted down for the members of her family Bome of her reminiscences of the early days. These notes have just been made pub lic. One paragraph reads: "My father, Hdrace Countryman, carried the news of Custer's massacre,

See the clipping

The Ogden Standard · Ogden City, Utah

A Missoula newspaper publishes reminiscences of the late Mrs. Elizabeth Countryman Woody, a pioneer settler, including her account that her father rode from Stillwater to Helena to spread word of Custer's defeat after telegraph wires were down. The piece also recounts her family's earlier journey west across the plains amid Indian conflicts.

The Ogden Standard · 6 August 1919 · page 6

Life in Montana MISSOULA, Mont., Aug 5 Shortly before her death here. Mrs, Elizabeth Countryman Wooly who was one of the six pioneer white women living in Missoula in June, 1870, jotted down' for the members of her family some i of her reminiscences of the early days.1 These notes have just been made pub lic. One paragraph reads: "My father, Horace Countryman, oaf1 rled the news of Custer's massacre, ' riding day and night from Columbus.' Montana then StUlwftier, to Helena, and that is how it was 'given to the world, the.

See moreSee less

wires being down." Mrs Wooly was born In Yuba coun ty.. California In 1868 As an Infant, her parents returned to New York by way of the Isthmus of Panama, but in 1860 they again headed westward, and crossed the plains in a cavalcade

See the clipping

Sioux County Pioneer · Fort Yates, N.D.

An advertisement offers rare postcard prints of Standing Rock Reservation and Fort Yates scenes, including one labeled 'Custer Battlefield, 1902' among dozens of other historical images like Sitting Bull's cabin and tribal leaders. The postcards are sold by the Fiske Studio at 20 cents each or six for a dollar.

Sioux County Pioneer · 14 August 1919 · page 2

McLaughlin Messenger. Old Fort Yates an| Standing Rock Reservation Views Rare prints on postcards made to order at 20 cents each, 6 for $1. At the Fiske Studio, or by mail, prepaid. Sitting Bull's Cabin. 1891 Sitting Bull, himself, 1888 .j I2th. Infantry on parade, 18921 Custer Battlefield, 1902 Porcupine Station and old Mur phy store, 1903 Whitebull and wife, 1911 |:i Winona school houBe,' Spicer funeral, 1897 Mulhern store, Cannonball, 1903 John Grass, chief, 19lo Indian dance group, Tipi town, 1899 Red Hail, chief, 1901 Fort Yates and Agency from post water tank, views looking northwest, north, east, southeast and west, 1903 ,}' lBoat with load of dinkV loco motives, 191L

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This 1919 article profiles Eli Ricker, a man of letters and former Civil War soldier who became a government historian specializing in Indian affairs. It notes that he mapped both the Wounded Knee and Little Bighorn battlefields as a historian for the U.S. Senate, and details his extensive background and ongoing research plans.

Omaha Daily Bee · 17 August 1919 · page 30

We Are Also Distrib utors For Sno-Flake Polish he now terms the "Butcher of Wounded Knee." Later as historian for the United State senate he "mapped" the battlefield and also that in the Big Horn basin where Custer made his last stand against

See the clipping

Crossville Chronicle · Crossville, Tenn. · and 1 other paper

The article retells the story of Comanche, the horse of Captain Keogh, found wounded a day's journey from the Little Bighorn battlefield and nursed back to health. It notes that all other cavalry horses died with their riders, while Comanche survived stripped of tack, apparently spared by the Indians who thought him too badly hurt to live.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

Crossville Chronicle · 20 August 1919 · page 3

PERISHED WITH THEIR RIDERS Horses of Custer's Command Died as Bravely as Old the Soldiers They Carried. Stories of equine courage and forti tude displayed in the late war recall that of a famous horse, Comanche, sole survivor of the Custer massacre. Co manche, w - th -mount of Captain Keogh, a relative of General Custer. He was found shortly after the mass acre about a day's Journey from the battlefield. - Suffering from seven bad wounds and very weak from loss of blood, It was at first despaired of get ting him back to camp.

See moreSee less

But the sol diers carried him on a litter construct ed of strong poles and army blankets. Given the best of treatment, he fully .recovered to receive an honorable discharge. Outer's men osed the bodies of their horses for barricade against the In dians. As they went into action on horseback every horse was saddled, but when Comanche was found he was without even a bridle, so It was sup posed that the Indians, believing he was too badly wounded to recover, stripped him and left him to die. Every other' horse was found In the heaps of the sluln. Alone is eternal. Owen Thought Meredith.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Morgan County Press · Wartburg, Tenn. · 20 June 1919
  • Crossville Chronicle · Crossville, Tenn. · 2 July 1919

De Queen Bee · De Queen, Ark.

Colonel Theo. W. Goldin, a Seventh Cavalry veteran who survived as Reno's dispatch rider, is touring Southern Army camps in 1919 sharing stories of frontier campaigns including the 'Battle of the Big Horn.' The piece recaps his wartime YMCA work and frames Custer's defeat as five hundred veterans overwhelmed by ten times their number of Indians over a two-day fight.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

De Queen Bee · 22 August 1919 · page 4

GI'STERVeTeBAN NOW WITHY. M. CM. Survivor of "Battle of Big Horn” Tour ing Southern Department Tell ing Experiences. Col. Theo. W. Goldin, a veteran of Custer's famous Seventh cavalry, han for many months been devoting all of his time to war work with the Army Young Men' <".i' ': . : > 'atfon. ' He is now on a lour vidting all mili tary camps in the six stales of the Southern Military department enter- | raining the soldiers witli stories of the great West of the long ago. Colonel Goldin has had an unusual and picturesque career on the frontier as soldier, government scout and quar termaster clerk, having participated in several Indian campaigns, among them the "Battle of the Big Horn,” where Custer and some five hundred veterans went down before ten times their number of Indians.

See moreSee less

He has been In the Army Y. M. C. A. work since November, 1917, serving first at Fort Bliss and later at Presidio. He has been booked by the educational bu reau of the Southern Department Array Y. M. C. A. for a speaking tour in Southern department camps. Colonel Goblin owes his life to the fact that during the battle of the Big Horn lie was serving as regimental clerk, and in that capacity was doing duty as mounted orderly. He was sent to Major Beno, some three miles away, with dispatches; but even then, during most of the ride, he was a tar- /■ •

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

This is an obituary for General Pope, detailing his military career including his participation in the 1876 "reprisal" campaign against the Sioux following the Custer massacre. It also covers his later service in Cuba, the Philippines, and various military posts before his 1919 death and planned burial at Arlington National Cemetery.

The Washington Times · 26 August 1919 · page 7

Custer massacre he took part in the "reprisal"' campaign against the . Sioux tribe and later against the Bannocks in 'the fracas cf 1878. He was put In command of the United States military prison in 1887, remaining at this post until 1895. In 3J987, the year before the war with Spain, he waa .placed in charge of improvement work in Yellowstone Park. -During the Philippine campaign he served as General Merritt's chief qparte'rmaster. General Pope was recommended for distinguished and valuable serv ice" in fW campaign against the Kiowa other Indian tribes. He was .a member of the Society of the Ginetanati. Sons of the American Revolution. Xxyal Legion, , Order of

See the clipping

Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

The article profiles Dave Cummings, an elderly frontiersman traveling through Great Falls to find his mother's 51-year-old grave in Montana. Along the way it recounts his life story, including working as a mule skinner for Generals Custer and Terry and arriving at the Little Bighorn battlefield three days after Custer's command was killed.

Great Falls Daily Tribune · 29 August 1919 · page 7

GREAT FALLS SEEKING GRAVE OF FIFTY YEARS

daughter Bessie, passed through Great Falls Thursday from Buffalo, Wyo. Mr. Cummings, who is 63 years of age. is a frontiersman of the old school. Forty three years ago he was "bull whacking - ' between Fort Benton and Helena. As early as 1872 he went intu the wilds of northern Canada in com pany with Neil Campbell, an early day Montana prize fighter, and for three years was in the employ of the North western Fur company. His companion, Campbell, was drowned in the Mac kenzie river during the trip.

See moreSee less

_ In 1S70 Cummings returned to the United States and became a mule skiu ner for Generals Custer and Terry out of Fort Buford. He was with Terry at the time of the Custer massacre and arrived at the Custer battlefield three days after Custer's command had been killed. In 1878 he took to Buffalo hunting in eastern Montana with head quarters on Cherry creek and this vocation he followed for three years. During the years that followed he wandered through the west and south weft, going as far as the City of Mexico and working as a cattleman. Since 1903 he has resided on his ranch near Buffalo, Wyo.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

An elderly man calling himself Colonel Kit Carson is visiting Winnemucca and recounting his frontier days, including a claim that he was the first white man to reach the scene of the Custer massacre on June 25, 1876. He is now involved in mining ventures in Nevada and plans to ride in the local Labor Day parade with an old pony express companion.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Paper unidentified · 30 August 1919 · page 1

KAMO IN INDIAN FIGHTER IS VISITING IN WINNEMITC.* Colonel Kit Carson, pioneer Indian scout and frontiersman, is a visitor in Winnemucca for a few days from his home in Reno. Colonel Carson although 68 years of age and “pretty well punctured,” as he puts it. still enjoys very good health and at present is actively engaged in mining operations in this state. He has taken up his permanent residence at Reno and will devote his efforts In the toward developing the Dlack Panther Copper Company, a promising pros pect, situated eight miles from Reno on the Western Pacific.

See moreSee less

Colonel Car son was the first white man on the scene after the Custer massacre on June. 25, 1876, and the stories he tells of those eventful days are very in teresting. “Kit” met an old friend here today in the person of "Billy Buck” Roberts, now residing at Golconda. It is fifty five years since they have seen each other and rode pony express together then. They have been asked to take part in the big I-abor Day parade an.1 have accepted.

See the clipping