As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

May 1919

8 articles

Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.

A memorial piece about the late T.T. Phillips of Lisbon, a Civil War veteran who had served under General Custer, noting he proudly wore a special scarf at Memorial Day parades marking this distinction. The article recounts that Custer and his entire command were wiped out by Sioux forces under Sitting Bull at Little Bighorn.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 34 days later.

Wrong

Norwich Bulletin · 1 May 1919 · page 6

, JEWETT CJTY , .The late T. T: Phillips, of Lisbon,, a veteran of the Civil war, had the dls tiQction of being one of the very few1 soldiers in this section who fought un der General Custer. He was the same General Custer who with, his entire command was completely wiped,!" out at the battle of Little Big Horn a few years later by the Sioutf Indians under Sitting Bull. Mr. Phillips always took pride in marching each Memorial day with the veterans in parade. He al ways donned on that day a bright red scarf necktie; on either end were two crossed sabres in white .

See moreSee less

embroidery. This tie, he explained with great pride. was the distinctive badge of those who fought with Custer. A relative of the family has presented this historic scarf to W. H. Brown in recognition of Mr. Brown's pride in collecting valu able war and genealogical relics. v? Kev. bamuel Thatcher of Last Hampton is the guest of friends in the borough. Mrs. E. A. Faust and Mrs. r . D. Ballou were at the home of their sister,! Mrs. A. H. Vaughn, to attend the meet-j ern Connecticut held at her home in Norwich Wednesday.' Misses Ellen Faust and Ruth Ballou assisted In eervin?. Will be at town clerk s ofnce, 9 to 4,1 today for purpose of receiving borough tax. Henry B. Olsen, Collector. adv. Mrs. Frederick Sperry and daughter Harriett of Woodbridge, Conn., are guests at M. W. Alling's for a week. Principal F. H. JP. Clement nas an nounced as valedictorian of the class of "19, Alexina Pepin, and salutatorian Louis B'akanowsky. Mrs. C. D. . Wolf had as her guests ' Tuesday Mrs. J. C. Atterbury and Mrs. William Kramer of Greeneville. j The receipts from the Jerushy Dowi Phootograph Album entertainment at! the Congregational church were oven $39. The vestry was crowded, over 190 persons attending. j Mrs. H. c. Webster nad daughter: Eunice go to Pawtucket today (Thurs-! day) to be the guests of Mrs. Hugh: Anderson for several days. j Herbert Wyatt, who has just arrived I from overseas, is home on a furlough, j Henry Cadieux and Hazard Arimonyj have also arrived on this side. For the remainder of the school year: Mrs. W. O. Soule is to fill the vacancy at the Riverside grammar school; caused by the resignation of Mrs. t Mabel Williams.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The article recalls Comanche, the horse of Captain Keogh who survived the Custer massacre despite seven wounds, and was nursed back to health by soldiers. It notes he was later mounted and displayed at the University of Kansas museum.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Arizona Republican · 2 May 1919 · page 4

WAR RECALLS A HORSE'S PLUCK (From the Detroit News) Stories of equine courage and forti tude displayed in the late war recall that of a famous horse, Comanche, sole survivor of the Custer massacre. Comanche was the mount of Captain Keogh, a relative of General Custer. He was found shortly after the maspa -ere about a day's journey from the battlefield. Suffering from seven bad wounds and very weak from loss of blood, it was at first despaired of get ting him back to camp. But the nol dters carried him on a litter con structed of strong poles and army blankets.

See moreSee less

Given the best of treatment, he fully recovered to receive an hon orable discharge. Custer's men used the bodies of their horses for barricades against the In dians. As they went into action on horseback every horse was saddled, but when Comanche was found, be was, without even a bridle, so It wan sup posed that the Indians, believing he was too badly wonnded to recover, stripped him and left him t die. Kvwy other horse was found in the heaps of the slain. The body of Comanche u mounted and is now in Dyche Museum at the University of Kansas. o This is Trophy Trara irblW, Ie"BOt 6 to 10 P. M. Adv. It

See the clipping

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

This 1919 editorial criticizes senators Lodge and Curtis for politicizing the League of Nations covenant, invoking their respective ancestries (New England and Native American). It references the 'Custer Massacre' only as a historical touchstone to argue that both Indians and New Englanders are more broad-minded than partisan politicians, then shifts to an unrelated item about Harry Lauder's knighthood.

South Bend News-Times · 9 May 1919 · page 8

Plymouth Kock and the Indian whose uncles par tieipaied in the "Custer Massacre" are alike more broad-minded than the republican bosses of the sen ate who strive to make party capital of a matter concerning' the peace of the world. Sitting Bull wou-il. if he wa re alive, be shocked at such a perfurrr.ance. and Thathleus Stevens would look upon it as iirnoble.

See the clipping

Sioux County Pioneer · Fort Yates, N.D.

A local obituary details Mr. Caddell's military career, including service with Custer's 7th Cavalry and participation in the battle of the Little Big Horn, dated July 26, 1876. He also served in later campaigns against Nez Perce forces in 1877.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 21 days later.

Wrong

Sioux County Pioneer · 15 May 1919 · page 1

during the civil war."J*\ A He came to No. Dak. in October, 1873, and served with Co. 7, U. 8. Cav. five years, and was in all of the Indian campaigns with General Custer. He also participated in the battle of the Little Big Horn on July 26, 1876. Was also with Nez Perry in 1877 under command of S. D. Sturges in the battle of the Big Canyon on the Yellowstone. one. of nine men Mr. Caddell waB chosen from the Companies from Ft. Lincoln who received the ap pointment as Sergeant.

See moreSee less

He also served as Commissioner of Morton county-for a number of years. In short, Sergeant Caddell has been a useful and highly respected citisen of North Dakota during these «r»«ny years and helped to make this a place where schools and churches could be established. The funeral services which were conducted by the Rev. Fr. Clemens at 1:80 p. m. at the Catholic ohurcb, Fort Rice, was largely at tended and a magnificient display of flowers were sent by friends from Mandan and Bismarck. .After the funeral services the remaina were laid at test in the Union Cemetery at Fort Rice. Thus ended the life of a true soldier, citi«en and friend. •'r-.bj

See the clipping

Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

A 1919 feature on Montana pioneer family history recalls the Big Hole Basin battle, noting soldiers feared 'another Custer massacre' when quelling the Nez Perce conflict. It mentions Lieutenant Bradley, a popular officer at Fort Benton, who was killed in that battle.

Great Falls Daily Tribune · 18 May 1919 · page 21

- m a: and the .sain«- herd was sold to Canadian buyers at ,$tX) per head. In 187.'! Mr. and Mrs. Stocking and children moved to a ranch four miles from Fort. Benton, the first ranch that was laid out in Chouteau county, which at that time constituted practically the whole of Montana. It was while living on this ranch that the battle of the Big Hole basin occurred and the soldiers then stationed at the fort were ordered to quell the Indian attack which bid fair to be another Custer massacre.

See moreSee less

Lieu tenant Bradley, then in charge of the fort with bis company of men, took part in this battle. Lieutenant Bradley being killed. lie was one of the most, popular officers ever stationed at the fort and a chair which lie made is in the possession of Mrs. Stewart.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

An Omaha Chamber of Commerce booster train crossed the historic region of the Indian wars, passing Fort Robinson, Fort McKenzie, and the Little Horn river where the article claims Sioux and Cheyenne were routed by General Crook. The train also passed near the Custer battlefield and was greeted by Crow Indians, including one of Custer's former scouts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.

Wrong

Omaha Daily Bee · 26 May 1919 · page 2

Agency, the capitol of the Crow In dian reservation, the famous Custer battlefield was visible. Reception By Indians. The Crow Indians who have al ways been friendly to the white men,

See the clipping

Estancia News-Herald · Estancia, N.M.

Colonel Theo. W. Goldin, a veteran of Custer's Seventh Cavalry at the Battle of the Little Bighorn, is touring Southern military camps for the Army YMCA entertaining soldiers with frontier stories. The article recounts how Goldin survived the battle while serving as a mounted orderly carrying dispatches to Major Reno.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Estancia News-Herald · 29 May 1919 · page 2

CUSTER VETERAN NOW WITHY. M. C. A, Survivor of "Battle of Bio Horn" Tour ing Southern Department Tell ing Experiences. Col. Theo. W. Goldln, a veteran Of Custer's famous Seventh cavalry, has for many months been devoting all of his time to war work with the Army Young Men's Christian association. He Is now on a tour visiting all mili tary camps In the six states of the Southern Military department enter taining the soldiers with stories of the great West of the long ago. Colonel Goldln has had an unusual and picturesque career on the frontier as soldier, government scout and quar termaster clerk, having participated In several Indian campaigns, among them the "Battle of the Big Horn," where Custer and some five hundred veterans went down before ten times their number of Indians.

See moreSee less

He has been In the Army Y. M. C. A. work since November, 1917, serving first at Fort Bliss and later at Presidio. He has been booked by the educational bu reau of the Southern Department Army Y. M. C. A. for a speaking tour in Southern department camps. Colonel Goldln owes his life to the fact that during the battle of the Big Horn he was serving as regimental clerk, and in that capacity was doing duty as mounted orderly. He was sent to Major Reno, some three miles away, with dispatches; but even then, during most of the ride, he was a farf Wv Wo.

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

The Fifth Cavalry band's concert program at Fort Bliss included a descriptive musical piece titled 'The Death of Custer; or, The Battle of Little Big Horn' by Leo Johnson. The synopsis outlines the piece's movements, depicting the night before the battle, Custer's march, the battle itself on June 25, 1876, and Custer's burial.

El Paso Herald · 31 May 1919 · page 2

INDIAN FANTASY ON CONCERT PROGRAM OF FIFTH CAVALRY

fantasy. "The leath of Custer; or. The Battle of Uttle BigBorn" (Leo John son). Synopsis: (1) Sioux Indian war dance, night before the battle: (!) Buge calls in Custer's camp Before rating the line of march: (1) Cus ter's cavalry on march to Siouxs camp, sound of horses' hoofs: (4) Ap-i proacn or eavairy, wiu nana piaying national air, th. Indians responding with their customary war music: (5) Battle of Little Big Horn June 25. 1S7(. in which Custer lost his life; 6 Indians rejoicing over the victory with scalp dance: (") Arrival of re inforcements.

See moreSee less

Gen. Ben tin. and cav-i airy: ) Custer's burial, volley ofj shots, muffled drums and bugle sound-; I W)f MI. ... VM v.a. - I vnv. Finale, -Nearer. My God. to Thee." Henry Fleck, assistant bandmaster, will direct the band.

See the clipping