Justice William E. Morris, a former Seventh Cavalry corporal who survived Little Bighorn with Reno's command, challenges the veracity of Crow scout Curly's story about the battle. Morris, twice wounded that day, reacted angrily after reading Curly's account given to Chicago reporters while traveling to Washington.
Indian's Story Is Fantastical W 11,1.1AM K. MnltltIS, now a Justice of the Munit'liml Court In TinHronx, was n trooper in till' Seventh Pulled State Cavalry when Gcorgo 12. Custer and IiIm command, consisting ( .71 men of Unit regiment it tul some civil ians .iud Indian scouts, were wiped out at tlic battle of Uir Utile Hk' Horn, Mont., fought on Juno .T.-'Jti. 1876. against Sloux uml Northern Cheyenne Indians. Justice Morris wan with Major Itcno's command two miles away 'from fluwe tie of the liattle at the time of the disaster ami thus escaped the fate of III comrades.
See moreSee less
Justice Mor ris has u strong grievance against Curly, a Craw Indian wont. Mr, Morris studied law uml was mi ni It ted to the luir after having been hoiioralily discharged from the army, lie entile to New York to live it mi 111 -I xt of j cur ago. In atldltlon to hold ing tiel office of Justtco he Im a Cap tain hi the Sixty-ninth regiment, Na
A 1914 newspaper report describes Justice Morris's anger at Crow scout Curly's long-standing claim to be the sole survivor of Custer's battle, citing testimony from the official Court of Inquiry that four Crow scouts, not just Curly, survived by leaving the column before the main fighting and hiding in the river. The piece recounts how Curly's myth was later capitalized upon by a promoter during the Chicago exposition.
The Sun · 18 January 1914 · page 36
CURLY, CUSTER INDIAN SCOUT, DENOUNCED AS ROMANCER
War tvpnrtinent some months after the Kittle, jfor the purpose of ascertaining the fiiel.H connected with the killing of ncnrl-f.vne-lialf of the Seventh Cavalry It woh .shown that four Crow scouts. Curly, Hull Plenty, Hairy Moccasin and Man-Thnt-Goes-Ahciid, were with Custci's column until within half an hour -r less of the commencement of the u'utual lighting with the Inutile, llloody Knife, a Hee scout, was with Major 'Heno's column. Tim Wal Curly, whose photograph ac companies this article and whom the court of Inquiry verltled. Is mentioned in the "Vanishing Utice" hy Hodman Wunilniakcr.
See moreSee less
Just la-fore the Sloux and Cheyenne attacked Custer, having lirst attacked Iteno down the valley, the four Crow scouts. In accordance with the recog nized custom which existed in the early days In the West, were permitted to leave the Custer column for the pur pose of stealing ponies from the en emy, If possible: then making their way to their own camp, many miles distant. The four Crowe found the Sloux and Northern Cheyenne in such force that It mis all they could do to save their own lives, which they did by making their way through the hostile lines to the Utile ltig Horn Hlvcr. a couple of miles away, and there lying submerged "th nothing but their noses showing ubove the water until night, when they succeeded In getting away in the dark ness undiscovered by the enemy. Curly's claim to be the sole survivor of the Custer battle has long been known In the West. .t the time of the Chicago exposition a white man who had lived In Montana for many years and was designated as a squaw man, having married an Indian wife, saw an opportunity to capitalize Curly as "the
The article describes Curly, a Crow scout promoted as the only survivor of Custer's Last Stand, and recounts his increasingly sensational and contradictory claims made decades later, including stories about Rain-in-the-Face eating Capt. Tom Custer's heart. Captain Morris refutes many of these details as fabrications inconsistent with established records.
The Sun · 18 January 1914 · page 36
Sloux stibchlef, who In the next day's tight, as has been proved by the records,! killed Capt. Tom Custer, a brother of the General, and ate his heart In the ftlltilmeiit of nil oath he took when Capt. Custer iirrested him at the Title Hldge agency for the murder of u white army veterinary surgeon: that the night before the battle he was sent by Hen. Custer to summon Major Kcno and Capt. Henteen to hli aid, that he reached Iteno, who refused to obey the order: that he then went on to Henteen, who was a short disr nice away with a de tachment of the Seventh, and who sent a number of soldiers, under a subordi nate otllcer, to "Custer's assistance, and that alt of these men died with the Gen eral.
See moreSee less
"In the famtl.ir picture of 'Custer's Last Fight' the llgtire of an Indian is shown pushing his way toward Custer as he falls," sold Curly. "Well. I nm that Indian. I reached Custer's side and held his head as he fell back dead." Curly declared that the artist who painted this picture should not have shown Custer and his men scalK'd or otherwise mutilated on the Held of bat
The article describes 'The Vanishing Race,' a book by Dr. Joseph Kossuth Dixon featuring photographs from the Rodman Wanamaker expedition and the first-person accounts of Crow and Sioux participants in the 1876 Custer battle. It begins recounting the story as told by Custer's scout White-Man-Runs-Him.
The Review · 22 January 1914 · page 2
For the first time the Indians whn nn.twinated in it have told their own story of the Custer fight in 1876, which resulted in the utter annihilation of Gen Custer and nis Standing on the Custer field, in the Little Big Horn valley mountains, facing the monuments in honor of Custer and his men, the In
This 1914 article presents retrospective first-person accounts from Custer's Crow scouts—Curly, Goes-Ahead, and an unnamed narrator—recalling the final hours before the Little Bighorn battle, including Custer dismissing them to safety and praying before the fight. The scouts describe watching Reno's engagement from a distance and later learning of the total destruction of Custer's command.
The Review · 22 January 1914 · page 2
to my wet horse. Custer and the soldiers were my friends and com panions and I cried all night long as I rode through the rain to tell No-Hin-Bone the news. Gen. Custer was a brave and good man, a straight forward and honest man. If Gen Custer was living today I would get better treatment than I now receive. Curlv. another Custer scout, is quoted in. part as follows: "We started on our journey and followed the Sioux trail. When we got to the camp we found that a battle had been fought, for we found the scalps and the beards of white men.
See moreSee less
These we took to Custer. He then said: 'This is the main point these Sioux have been killing white people, and I have been sent here by the Great Father to con quer them and bring them back to their reservation. I am a great chief, but I do not know whether I will get through this summer alive or dead. If they massacre me they will still suffer, for they have dis obeyed orders.' The next day we saw the Sioux camp. Custer said: 'We will charge upon them now that settles their journey, ouster split up bis com mand at Little Reno creek and told Reno to follow the creek down. I came down with Custer as far as the creek. Then he gave me a mes sage to fake to Reno. Whilcl was delivering the message Reno was fighting his battle, but it was not very fierce, and when I got to Cus ter with his message he was fight ing at the mouth of the creek. Later Custer told me to go and
Decades after the battle, Sioux chief Red Cloud gives his account of fighting Reno and then Custer at Little Bighorn, describing how warriors surrounded and killed Custer's men. He explains that Custer was not scalped out of respect for his bravery, and that the Sioux were provoked by soldiers while defending their hunting grounds.
The Review · 22 January 1914 · page 8
INDIAN SCOUTS TELL OF CUSTER MASSACRE AT LITTLE BIG HORN
Even more realistic is the story of the Sioux Indians who fought Custer on that memorable day. Red Cloud, the Sioux chief says: "Suddenly we heard firing and we found out that the soldiers were on us. The women and children were all frightened and. started to run across the hills, and we men mounted our horses and started to ward the enemy. I remember that we pushed Reno back until he had to cross the river and go up against . 11 Of I a l C M mm tne Diuns ana men some oi uui Sioux rode around the hill to OaO him off and we had him in a pock et.
See moreSee less
"After we had killed many of Reno's men Custer came along the ridge and we were called off to fight Custer. We kept circling around Custer and as his men came down the ridge we shot them aown. And then the rest dismouuted and gath ered in a bunch, kneeling down and snooting from behind their horses. We circled round and round, firing into Custer's men until the last man was killed. "I did not see Custer fall, for all the Indians did not know which was Custer. One reason why we did not scalp Custer was because the In dians and the white soldiers were so mixed up that it was hard to distinguish one man from another and another reason was because Custer was the bravest man of all and we did not want to touch him as he made the last stand. This is also the opinon of Rain in -the Face. "Regarding the cause of the Cus ter fight I must say we were pursued by the soldiers, we were on the waroatn. and we were on tne war
In 1914, Sioux chiefs Rain-in-the-Face, Runs-the-Enemy, and Two Moons give first-person accounts of the Little Bighorn fight, explaining they were defending their hunting grounds after being pushed out of the Black Hills and attacked by Custer's soldiers. They describe the chaos of battle, estimate about 2,000 warriors engaged, and claim roughly 50 Sioux dead, insisting the fight was a battle rather than a massacre.
The Review · 22 January 1914 · page 8
MASSACRE AT LITTLE BIG HORN
IUlll liliu HIV vavr" uiin v'liivi triHc waro trvind Hri,, iiiuc, ' v mil v J iijs w uhiv them back from the huniing grounds and the soldiers came upon U3 and we had to defend ourselves. ."We were driven out of the Black Hills by the men seeking gold and our game was driven off and we started on our journey in search of game. Our children were starving and we had to have something to eat. There was buffalo in that region and we were moving, simply camping here and there and fight ing our Indian enemies as we ad vanced in order to et the game that was in this country.
See moreSee less
"We fought this battle from day light up until 3 o'clock in the after noon and all of the white men were killed. I think Custer was a very brave man to fig'jt all those Indians with his few men from daylight un til the sun was almost going down " Runs-the-Enemy, another Sioux ciuei, says iu pan: "When we had killed all the soldiers we felt that we had done oir duty and felt that it was a great battle and not a massacre. With reference to the real reason for this fidht 1 mav sav thf talk nmnnd tht "o j j "& Indians was thai they were going to j
The passage presents retrospective testimony from Indian participants, including an unnamed chief and Chief Two Moons, describing the battle's chaos, the killing of Custer's command, and prior clashes at Tongue River and Powder River. It closes with an author's admiring assessment of Custer as a brave and skilled officer facing difficult discretionary orders.
The Review · 22 January 1914 · page 8
country. Our purpose was to move north and go as far north as possi ble away from the tribes. "rwind thAfnctprfidht nt tontal were not attacked, but after the battle the women gathered up their dead husbands and hrothers and laid them out nicely in the tepees and left them. I understand that after we had left the soldiers came and burned the tepees. "According to my estimate three were about 2,000 able bodied war riors engaged in this fight; they were all in good fighting order. The guns and. ammunition that we gathered from the dead soldiers of Custer's command put us in b tter fighting condition than ever before, but the sentiment ran around among the Indians that we had killed enough and we did not want to fight anymore.
See moreSee less
"There has been a good deal of dispute about the number of In dians killed. About the closest esti mate that we can make is that 50 Sioux were killed in the fight and others died a short time afterward from their wounds."
A local newspaper advertises an upcoming showing of the Indian war film 'General Custer's Last Fight' at Movie Johnson's picture show. The ad notes everyone is already familiar with the story of the 'Custer Massacre' and promises a large crowd to see it dramatized on screen.
The Pioneer Express · 23 January 1914 · page 4
"General Custer's Last Fight," an Indian war there parts, will be film in the leading attraction at "Movie" John son's picture show this Friday evening. This attraction needs no every commeDt, body is familiar with the story of the Custer Massacre and to see in real it action, will attract the largest crowd ever gathered in the hall. Already some have spoken for seats, but as these cannot be reserved, it will a case of first come first served, so you had better come early and secure your seats. There will be the usual number of good comedies.
See moreSee less
The Custer feature costs $10. extra, but the price of admission will be the same as usual. A Masquerade Carnival will be given at the Pembina Ice Rink on Saturday evening, Jan. 24th. The following priz es will be given by the merchants of Pembina:—Best gent's costume, fancy kid gloves, J. B. Parker most comic gent's costume, pair overshoes, J. Hen eman best ladies' costume, toilet set, Drug Store most comic lady's cos tume, head scarf, Branchauds best small girl's costume, gold jewel box, M. H. Miller best small boy's costume, hockey stick, G. G. Thompson boy's race, under 16 yrs., pocket knife, King Booker girls' race, a street hat, Mrs. &
A Dickinson man named Sterland, who served with the column that marched from Fort Lincoln, recounts decades later his memories of the 1876 campaign, describing the march route, the division of Custer's command into battalions under Reno and Benteen, and the arrival of Terry's relief force. He claims the full scope of Custer's defeat was not known until Terry's men reached the battlefield after days of fighting.
The Dickinson Press · 24 January 1914 · page 1
I This City. a recent issue of the (Coloi.) News tells inci hurley, the Crow Indian, ror of the Custer massacre *ly be credited by men ik part in this famous 3. Steriand of Dickinson -resting facts connected ^rable battle. He was 0, whose command was of the Little' Big 1battle was fought on |»lls the bringing in re-inforcement by vien the. battle was only a few White Gurley circled to the group and taking jupaint of a' fallen of the enemy, imorable campaign, )b: "The Seventh of Gen. Custer left about four miles Mandan, in May 'some 600 strong, teno, Col. Benteen (al. We followed
A veteran recounts, decades later, Custer's division of his regiment into companies under Reno, Benteen, and McDougal before the battle on June 25th, and describes the fighting, the eventual arrival of Gen. Terry, and the discovery of Custer's defeat. The account continues with the wounded being evacuated by steamboat and the army making camp near the Yellowstone before continuing campaigning with Gen. Miles's forces.
The Dickinson Press · 24 January 1914 · page 1
Horn rivej-. Bugler. with orders to hurry ahead with amunjtion. vancing met the main forces and gave them I retreated a shbrt ways ai by Col. Benteen and Ce Together we repulsed and Indians till the evening when Gen. Terry came to Was only then that we 1 massacre of Gen. Custer a ment. While the battle four miles from where would have been impossi his rescue had we known as from the morning of thi evening of the 27th we ously engaged in battl Indians. After the arrival' of Gt went diwiy.tOjthe mouth Big Horn riyer, where 1 wounded moi ujon the "Far West,:" in .commi Marsh, to be taken to hei medical aid., ^We camped of the Yellowstone rivei Miles joined us^with the later Gen.
See moreSee less
Creek: with th Cavalry. Wecampaign summer and fall." FORME^CKlSQIiih
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.
Episcopal missionary Rev. A. McG. Beede, author of the book 'Sitting Bull and Custer' which is being dramatized for performance at several colleges, is visiting Aberdeen for a Masonic reunion. The article also recounts his separate advocacy campaign against mismanagement of Indian affairs at Standing Rock reservation.
The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 24 January 1914 · page 2
BEEDE TALKS IN SOUTH DAKOTA
Sitting Bull and Custer, which is being dramatized and will be present ed in an outdoor play at the North Dakota Agricultural college, Beloit college and several other institutions next spring.
A 1914 feature on Dr. Dixon's Wanamaker expedition to American Indian tribes recounts presenting a flag to various elders, including Two Moons, a Cheyenne who fought at the Little Bighorn and now kissed the flag in a gesture of reconciliation. The piece also describes Navajo marriage customs encountered during the tour.
Evening Star · 25 January 1914 · page 49
THE SOLEMN CEREMONY OF PRESENTING THE FLAG TO THE SIOUX AT DEVILS LAKE, N.D.
T*ie Iroquois Indians adopted Dr. -K???-n tribe, naming him J?1 Sunsh*ne-" from the speed with which he traveled and the messages of good cheer which he brought to them. * * * Many Interesting anecdotes are told by Dr. Dixon of his trip among the tribes? of the different manner in which he was greeted; the demonstrations made over this, the first flag the red men had ever had; of the difficulties encountered in traveling and the hope inspired in many through the expedition. Possibly no talc told by the leader is more significant than is the one relating to Two Moons, who was one of the Cheyennes active in the Custer massacre. Two Moons is now about eightv years
The Keota News · Keota, Colo. · and 3 other papers
Decades after the battle, this piece quotes a Sioux chief's account of the fighting against Reno and Custer, along with Rain-in-the-Face's concurring views on why Custer wasn't scalped. It also includes poetic remarks from Crow chief Plenty Coups at a ceremonial 'Last Great Council' organized by the Wanamaker expedition.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Keota News · 30 January 1914 · page 4
Destruction of the Indian Great Lou to the Nation—Their Ambitions Are Destroyed. Chief Two Modus. night climbing the mountains and wading the rivers. During the day we made a concealed camp. “When we reached the top of the Wolf mountains we saw tbs enemy's camp, near where the Custer Field la at the present time. Ouster wns re joiced and anxioua to.go ahead and make the battle. Custer sent me to a high knoll. *Oo and look for mew* he said, ‘and see where I can make a success. ’ He left It to me.
See moreSee less
When I was up there 1 looked around, and the troops were very close upon me. I motioned to them to corns on. and we passed up the ridge. “The Indian scouts stood In front of Custer and led his men. The Sioux fired at us. We looked over the river and saw Reno in his engagement with the Sioux. “Finally they wiped out Reno, and he retreated to the hills. “Custer and all of us got off our horses. The enemy were surrounding us. They were banging away at u. Custer then came up and said: Ton have done your duty. You have led me to the enemy's camp. And now the thing for you to do Is to obey orders and get away. You go; I am now going with my boys.’ “Had Custer not ordered me to go, the people who visit Custer Field to day would see my name cm the monu ment Even more realistic Is the story of the Sioux Indians who fought Custer. Their justification of their conduct ts Interacting. Red Cloud, a Sioux chief, says: "Suddenly we heard firing, and we found out that the soldiers were on us. The women and children were all frightened, and started to run across the hills. and we men mounted our horsee and started toward the enemy. I remember that we pushed Reno back until he had to cross the river, and go up against the bluffs, and then some of our Sioux rode around the hill to head him off. and we had in a pocket. “After we had killed many of Re no’s men. Custer came along the ridge, and we were called off to fight Custer. We kept circling around Cus ter. and aa his men cams down the ridge we shot them down. And then the rest dismounted and gathered In a bunch, kneeling down and shooting from behind their horses. We circled round and round, firing Into Custer’s men until the last man was killed. “I did not see Custer foil, for all the Indiana did not know which was Custer. One reason why we did not scalp Cuater waa because the Indians and the white soldiers were so mixed up that it was hard to distinguish one man from another; and aaotber reason was because Custer waa the bravest man of all and we did not want to touch blm, aa be made the last stand. This is also the opinion of Raln-in-the-Fuce. "Regarding thg cause of the Custer fight, I must say we were pursued by the soldiers, we were on the warpath and we were on the warpath with the Crows and other tribea. “We were driven out of the Black Hills by the men seeking gold, and our game was driven off. and we start ed on our Journey In search of pm* Our children were starving and we had to have something to eat There was buffalo in that region and we were moving, sf-cply camping here and there and fighting our Indian enemies as we advanced. In order to get the game that was In thfo coun try. We fought this battle from day
Vilas County News · Eagle River, Wis. · 4 February 1914
The Mingo Republican · Williamson, W. Va. · 13 February 1914
The Bridgeport Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
The Wheeler & Wilson band will perform a concert including Lee Johnson's masterpiece 'The Death of Custer,' a descriptive fantasy depicting events leading to the Battle of Little Big Horn, the Indians' war dances, the arrival of reinforcements, and Custer's burial. A young piano prodigy will also perform on the program.
The Bridgeport Evening Farmer · 31 January 1914 · page 8
' W, & W. BAND CONCERT. Another of those delightful and suc cessful concerts will be given by the Wheeler & Wilson band' at the Plaza theater, Sunday nigtht. One of the most Jnteresting features of the con cert will be the" rendition of Lee John son's famous masterpiece, a descrip tive fantasy entitled "The Death of Custer." The events leading up to the battle of "Little Big Horn," in which the famous general lost his life, the Indians' war dances and rejoicing over their victory, the arrival of reinforce ments and the burial of Custer are described in thebars : of '- music as vividly as in the story.
See moreSee less
Little Mary MarafH, the fourteen year ' old piano -phiend, will be an important figure on theprogram. All tickets for the con cert a-re now on sale at the Plaza box office. - - - . . -