As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

November 1907

13 articles

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb. · and 5 other papers

Decades after Little Bighorn, Sioux veterans including Dr. Charles Eastman and warrior No Flesh reenact the battle at a Pine Ridge festival, with aged Red Cloud looking on. The event blends traditional ceremony with memories of the actual 1876 fight.

The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 1 November 1907 · page 2

OLD RED CLOUD STILL LIVES

' 'ways , the old Indian ceremonies brought forth the Indian's love of his own people. Every fullblood entered Into the ceremonies with complete abandon , Or. Charles A. Eastman Is a gradu ate of Belolt. Knox and Atnherst. He Is one of the best educated Indians In history. He has traveled about the world and addressed many audiences , always appearing In dress and manner exactly as any other cultured gentle man. His Yankee wife and his six children were at their homo In Amherst - herst while Dr. Eastman was at Pine Ridge among his people.

See moreSee less

It was with evident pride that the distinguished scholar donned the eagle feathers and took the most prominent part , that of Chief Crazy Horse , In the realistic re production of the great Custer battle. To see him with his erecf bearing , his towering head dress , and his Hashing eyes , one would scarcely imagine that this was a man accustomed to addressIng - Ing mutiopolitan audiences in polished accents. There were others , too , who had been away in school at Carlisle who laid aside their acquired culture , for got for the moment the white man's ethical theorizing , and threw them selves heart and soul into the spirit of the festival , even including the feast of dog llesh.

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • The Bon Homme County Independent · Tabor, S.D. · 24 October 1907
  • The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D. · 24 October 1907
  • The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D. · 25 October 1907
  • Forest City Press · Forest City, S.D. · 31 October 1907
  • Kingsbury County Independent · Desmet, S.D. · 1 November 1907

Kingsbury County Independent · Desmet, S.D.

The Ogalalla Sioux held their summer festival at Pine Ridge, featuring a realistic reenactment of the Custer massacre, now treated as a Fourth-of-July-style celebration. Aged chief Red Cloud, blind and feeble, was carried to the grounds to witness the event, with his son Jack Red Cloud serving as herald wearing medals bearing Grant's portrait.

Kingsbury County Independent · 1 November 1907 · page 2

RE-ENACTED BY SIOUX Chamberlain, S. IX, Oct. 23.—The great summer festival ot the Ogalalla Sioux Indians, one of the chief features of which is a realistic reproduction of the Custer massacre, has just taken place at Pine Ridge. The statement that Red Cloud, the most famous of the Ogalalla Sioux chiefs, is dead, has often been printed, but the aged war-, li,ir was there in the flesh participating in the celebration of bis people which i h«s now been conventionalized as a sortj ,of Fourth of July. old Red Cloud is totally blind antj very feeble, and his mind is wavering, but bis people carried him reverently to the camp grounds, about three miles fioin the Pine Ridge agency, and paid him all the deference tint he has earned by many years of wise counsel and courageous leadership.

See moreSee less

His son, Jack Red Cloud, acted as herald for the numerous functions. Orj the breast of the young man were two silver medals fully five inches in |e:**r. One of them had been given td 1 is father and the other to his uncle,

See the clipping

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.

A serialized adventure story depicts a tense confrontation between a man named Hampton and an outlaw named Murphy, with Murphy confessing to a crime that wrongly cost Hampton 15 years of suffering. The scene is set near Custer and the Seventh Cavalry, used as a dramatic backdrop rather than factual reporting.

The Irish Standard · 2 November 1907 · page 3

BOB HAMPTON OF PLACER

^Hands Upf. Not a Move, Muhpryl I Have the Drop!" "Up yonder before Custer and the officers of the Seventh, when we get In." "They'd nab me—likely."

See the clipping

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.

This excerpt is from a fictional serialized story, depicting Custer and Reno splitting forces to attack an Indian village from two directions. Reno's troops advance into the valley and are suddenly met with heavy rifle fire, throwing the column into brief confusion before rallying.

The Irish Standard · 9 November 1907 · page 3

CHAPTER XXXII. The Fight in the Valley. Far below. In the heart of the sunny depression bordering the left bank of the Little Big Horn, the stalwart troopers under Reno's command gazed up the steep bluff to wave farewell to their comrades disappearing to the right. Last of all, Custer halted his horse an instant, silhouetted against the blue sky, and swung his hat be fore spurring out ef sight. The plan of battle was most simple and direct. It Involved a nearly slm ultaneous attack upon the vast Indian village from below and above, success depending altogether upon the prompt co-operation of the separate detach ments. Scarcely had Custer's slender

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The Ogallalla Sioux held a summer festival at Pine Ridge, South Dakota, featuring a realistic staged production of the Custer massacre. Aged chief Red Cloud attended in person, while educated tribal member Dr. Charles Eastman donned eagle feathers to play the role of Crazy Horse in the reenactment.

The Madison Daily Leader · 11 November 1907 · page 2

INDIAN FOURTH

Easterner. Stew Vork Herald The %imt sum mer festival of tbe Ogallalla Sioux Ic-1 (lians, one ot the chief features of which -iw a realistic production of the I Custer massacre, has just taken place at i Pine Ridge, S. D. The statement that Red Cloud, the most famonH of the Ogallal-la Sioux chief.^is dead, has often been printed, but the aged wairior! was there in the flesh participating! in a popular celebration, which -has! now become conventionalized as a sort!

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

An 1907 feature profiles Bird Necklace, an 82-year-old Sioux man who fought under Sitting Bull and witnessed Custer's defeat, now appearing in a Wild West show. It recounts his later service with the government and a medal given by President Arthur.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 13 November 1907 · page 5

fought under Sitting Bull and saw the massacre of Custer, is appearing at the J Bijou theatre this week in "Young Buf falo, the King of the Wild West." Bird Necklace was once as daring and as pitiless as any Sioux wiio ever gal loped over the plains, combating the advance of the whites with a fearlessness and gallantry that won the admiration of their foes, but today he is a patriarchal old man who looks down on life from the eminence of 82 years and answers with a friendly clasp of the hand and a com prehensive grunt the salutation of his white visitors.

See moreSee less

Bird Necklace has had a career that equals the wildest dreams of the small boy, saturated with blood and thunder talcs and longing for adventure in a wild west that Is now, alas, a thing of the past. Tile old fellow was a sub-chief un der Sitting Bull during much of that famous warrior's struggles ugalnst the soldiers of Uncle Sam and he was in the battle of the Little Big Horn river, July 20, 1870. He saw the massacre of Custer and muny another bloody scene in those days and his body hears the scars that he received in battle on the plains, both against the troops and with them, for Bird Necklace went over to the Side of the government and distinguished himself for bravery. Suspended by a cord around liis neck flie chief wears a gold medal, nearly as large as a saucer, which was presented to him for signal bravery as a runner for Uncle Sam and a bearer of dispatches. This medal bears on one side the bust of President Chester A. Arthur, by whom it was presented to Bird Necklace, and the date, 1881. On the obverse side are the figures of an Indian and a white man with their hands clasped and the i inscription, "Peace," In raised letters of gold. This huge medal is not only valu able for the honor which it denotes, but for its intrinsic worth in dollars and cents. Bird Necklace is justly proud of tlie ornament ami wears it about Ills neck when lie appears on the stage. The old chief is accompanied on his travels by his wife, who bears the pic turesque and poetic name, Moonbeam. They have been married 69 years and have four children living and three grand children. All are Christians and attend school. Tlie home of Bird Necklace is at Pine Ridge, South Dakota, where he re sides when not on the road. He made his first public appearance at the Buffalo exposition. Later he appeared at the Si. Louis show. After that he* drifted into melodrama, where he Is a striking figure, lie makes no pretense of being an actor, but he and ids companions, in or 12 in number, lend wonderful realism to tin* sliow with their brilliant costumes and painted faces. Bird Necklace is highly respected u. his home-in South Dukiua and while he can't speak English, he takes a lively interest In all matters concerning his people. Sere and stolid, after so many stirring adventures and after facing death unnumbered times. Bird Necklace is an interesting relic of a people who have already lost many of the characlti istics that made them heroic.

See the clipping

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn. · and 1 other paper

This is a highly detailed, novelistic account of Custer's command forming a defensive line after the initial surprise attack, naming troop commanders like Calhoun, Keogh, Smith, Yates, and Tom Custer. It depicts repeated charges and volleys, with soldiers hoping to hold out until Reno's relief arrived.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

The Irish Standard · 16 November 1907 · page 3

CHAPTER XXXIV.

Yates, with Tom Custer holding the extreme right. Thus they waited grim ly for the next assault. Nor was it long delayed. Scarcely had the troopers recovered, refilled

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Roswell Daily Record · Roswell, N.M. · 5 September 1907

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn. · and 1 other paper

This is a chapter from a fictionalized novel narrating Custer's advance toward the village and the sudden Indian ambush, including invented dialogue between officers like Calhoun and Hampton. It dramatizes the moments before the annihilation of Custer's command with literary embellishment rather than factual reporting.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Irish Standard · 16 November 1907 · page 3

CHAPTER XXXIV. The last Stand. It was shortly after two o'clock in the afternoon when that compact col umn of cavalrymen moved silently forward down the concealing coulee toward the mo»e open ground beyond. Custer's plan was surprise, the sudden smiting of that village in the valley from the rear by the quick charge of his horsemen. From man to man the whispered purpose travelled down the ranks, the eager troopers greeting the welcome message with kindling eyes. It was the old way of the Seventh, and they knew it well.

See moreSee less

With Custer riding at the head of the column, and only a little to the rear of the advance scouts, his adjut ant Cook, together with a volunteer aide, beside him, the five depleted troops filed resolutely forward, dream ing not of possible defeat. Suddenly distant shots were heard far off to their left and rear, and deepening into a rumble, evidencing a warm engage ment. The interested troopers lifted their heads, listening intently, while eager whispers ran from man to man along the closed files. "Reno is going in, boys It will be our turn next." "Close up! Quiet there, lads, quiet," officer after officer passed the word of command. Yet there were those among them who felt a strange dread—that firing sounded so far up the stream from where Reno should have been by that time. Still it might, be that those overhanging bluffs would muffle and deflect the reports. All about them hovered death in dreadful guise. None among the© saw.tltow cruel, spying RM new cavalry jacket. Donald Bran' eyes watching froih distant ridges, trotted down the stage road bordering peering at them from concealed ra the Bear Water, his heart alternating vines none marked the rapidly mass between hope and dread. ing rliordes, hideous in war-paint, The familiar yellow house at the crowded into near-by coulees and be cross-roads appeared so unattractive hind protecting hills. as to suggest the thought that Naida It burst upon them with wild yells. The gloomy ridges blazed into their 1 must have been inexpressibly lonely startled faces, the dark ravines hurled during those months of waiting. He at them sScurrying horsemen, while, knocked at the sun-warped door. Without delay it was flung open, and wherever their eyes turned, they bea vision of flushed face and snowy held savage formB leaping forth from drapery confronted him. hill and coulee, gulch and rock shad "Why, Lieut. Brant! was never ow. Horses fell, or ran about neigh more surprised in my life. Do. pray, ing men flung up their hands and come right in. Yes. Naida is here, died in that first, awful minute of con and I will hava her sent for at once. sternation, and the little column Oh, Howard, this is Lieut. Brant, just seemed to shrivel away as if consum back from his awful Indian fighting. ed by the flame which struck it, front How very nice that he should happen and flank and rear. It was as if those to arrive just at this time, isn't it?" men had ridden into the mouth of The young officer silently accepted hell. Mr. Wynkoop's extended hand, and Yet it was scarcely for more than a found a convenient chair, as Miss minute. Men trained, strong, clear of Spencer hastened from the room to brain, were in those stricken lines— announce his arrival. men who had seen Indian battle be "Why 'just at this time?'" he ques fore. The recoil came, swift as had tioned. been the surprise. Voice after voice rang out old familiar orders, steady* ing instantly the startled nerves dis married this evening—Miss Spencer cipline conquered disorder, and the and myself. We shall be so delighted shattered column rolled out, as if by to have you witness the ceremony. It magic, into the semblance of a battle is to take place at the church, and line. It was magnificently done. Custef and his troop commanders brought their sorely smitten men into a posi tion of defense, even hurled them glowing with enthusiasm. "Why, I cheering forward in short, swift charges, so as to clear the front and you, Howard? Now Lieut Brant and gain room In which to deploy. Out of Naida can stand up with us. You I confusion emerged discipline, confi will, won't you. Lieutenant?" dence, esprit de corps. Safe beyond the range of the troop ers' light carbines, the Indians, with their heavier rifles, kept hurling a constant storm of lead, hugging the gullies, and spreading out until there eyes met, and the color mounted was no rear toward which the harass swiftly to the girl's cheeks. Then he ed cavalrymen could turn for safety. stepped resolutely forward, forgetful One by one, continually under a heavy of all other presence, and clasped her fire, the scattered troops were form hand in both his own. Neither spoke ed into something more nearly re sembling a battle line—Calhoun on thing of what wail in the heart of the the left, then Keogh, Smith and other. Yates, with Tom Custer holding the "Will you walk outside with me?" extreme right. Thus they waited grim he asked, at last. "I have much to ly for the next assault. say which I am sure you would rather Nor was it long delayed. Scarcely hear alone."« had the troopers recovered, refilled She bent her head, and with a brief their depleted cartridge belts from word of explanation to the others, the those of their dead comrades, when young officer conducted her forth into the onslaught came. The soldiers the bright July sunshine. They walk waited their coming. The short, ed in silence side by side along the brown-barrelled carbines gleamed at bank of the little stream. Brant glanc the level in the sunlight, and then ed furtively toward the sweet, girlish belched forth their message of flame face. Then he spoke. into the very faces of those reckless "Naida," he said, gravely, "I have horsemen. It was not in flesh and come back, as I said 'i would, and blood to bear such a blow. With surely I read welcome-in your eyes?" screams of rage, the red braves "Yes." swerved to left and right, leaving "And I have come to say that there many a dark, war-bedecked figure ly is no longer any shadow of the dead ing dead behind them, and many a between us." riderless pony skurrying over the She looked up .quickly, her hands prairie. Exultant over their seemingclasped, her cheeks pushing. "Are ly successful repulse, the men .flung 1 you sure? Perhaps you misunder themselves again upon the earth, stand perhaps you mistake my mean their cheers ringing out above the ing." thud of retreating hoofs. "I know it all." he answered, sober "We can hold them here, boys, until ly. "from the lips of Hampton.' Reno comes," they shouted to each "You have seen him? Oh, Lieut. other. Brant, please tell me the whole truth. The skulking red riflemen crept I have missed him so much, and since ever closer behind the ridges, driving the day he rode away to Cheyenne not their deadly missiles into those ranks one word to explain his absence has exposed in the open. To the command come back to me. You cannot of the bugle they discharged two understand what, this means, how roaring volleys from their carbines, much he has become to me through hopeful that the combined sound years of kindness." might reach the ears of the lagging "You have heard nothing?" Reno. They were hopeful yet, al though one troop had only a sergeant "Not a word." left in command, and the dead bodies Brant drew a long, deep breath. Ha of their comrades strewed the plain. had supposed she knew this. At Ivt It was four o'clock. For two long he said gravely: "Naida, the truth hours they had been engaged in cease will prove the kindest message, I less struggle, and now barely a hun think. He died in that unbroken ring dred men, smoke begrimed, thirsty, of defenders clustered about Gen. bleeding, half their carbines empty, Custer on the bluffs of the Little Big they still formed an impenetrable ring Horn:" around their chief. The struggle waB Her slight figure trembled so vio over, and they realized the fact. lently that. he held her close within When that wave of savage horsemen his arms. swept forth again it would be to ride "There was a smile upon his face them down, to crush them under their when we found him. He performed horses' pounding hoofs. his full duty, Naida, and died as be Like a whirlwind those red demons came a soldier and a gentleman." came—howling wolves, now certain of "But—but, this cannot be! I saw their prey. On both flanks of the the published list his name was not short, slender line struck Gall and among them." Cra?y Horse, while like a thunderbolt "The man who fell was Robert Crow-King and Raln-in-the-Face at Nolan." tacked the center. These three storms Gently he drew her down to a seat converged at the foot of the hill, upon the soft turf of the bank. She crushing the little band of troopers. looked up at him helplessly, her mind With ammunition gone, the helpless seemingly dazed, her eyes yet filled victims could meet that mighty on with doubt. rushing torrent only with clubbed "Robert Nolan? My father?" guns, for one instant of desperate 1 He bent over toward her, pressing struggle. Shoulder to, shoulder, in his Hps to her hair and stroking it ever-contracting circle, officers and tenderly with his hand. men stood shielding their commander to the last. Twenty or 30 made a de "Yes, Naida, darling it was truly spairing dash, in a vain endeavor to Robert Hampton Nolan who died in 1 burst through the red enveloping battle, in the ranks of his old regi lines, only to be tomahawked or shot. ment—died as tic would have chosen but the most remained, a thin strug to die, thank God! completely cleared gllng ring, with Custer in its center. of every stain upon his honor. Sit Then came the inevitable end. The up, little girl, and listen while I tell red waves surged completely acrosB you. There is in the story no word the crest, no white man. left alive which does not. reflect nobility upon upon the field. They had fought a the soldier's daughter." good fight they had kept the faith. She uplifted her white face. Two days later, having relieved me," she said, simply, "all you know." Reno from his unpleasant predica He recounted to her slowly, care ment in the valley, Terry's and Gib fully, the details of that desperate bons's infantry tramped up the ravine, Journey northward, of their providen and emerged upon the stricken field. tial meeting on the Little Big Horn, In lines of motionless dead they read of the papers left in his charge, of the fearful story and there they Hampton's ridirs forward with dis found that man we know. Lying upon patches, and of his death at Custer's a bed of emptied cartridge shells, his side. While he spoke, the girl scarce body riddled with shot and mutilated ly moved her breath came in sobs with knives, his clothing torn to rags, and her hands clasped his. his handsgrasped a smashed and "These are the papers, Naida. I twisted carbine, his lips smiling even opened the envelope as directed, and in death, was that soldier whom the found deeds to certain properties, in Seventh had disowned and cast out, cluding the mine in the Black Range but who had come back to defend its a will, duly signed and attested, nam chief and to die for Its honor—Robert ing you as his sole heir, together with Hampton Nolan. a carefully prepared letter, addressed

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan. · 21 February 1908

The Oakes Times · Oakes, N.D.

This is a promotional advertisement for a serialized novel, 'Bob Hampton of Placer,' by Randall Parrish, featuring a blurb from Gen. Charles King praising the story. The novel is described as being developed from the events leading up to and culminating in the Battle of Little Big Horn, where Custer and his command were massacred by Sioux forces under Sitting Bull.

The Oakes Times · 21 November 1907 · page 4

By RANDALL PARRISH, 4 From the incidents leading up to and culminating in the battle of the Little Big Horn, in which General Custer and his command were massacred by the Sioux under Sitting Bull, Mr. Parrish has developed a story of dramatic power and action that will stir the blood of every lover of a keen^ exciting story. 4 The reader who delights in the ring of the horse's hoofs on the rocky trail of the wilderness, and who would see a dramatic picture of the West in that period of large and spectacular situations, will find in Bob Hampton of Placer," a story that will hold the attention, fixedly, to •the very end. The charming romance skilfully woven into the narra

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

A steamer arrives at a frontier post carrying news that Custer and all his men were killed by Sitting Bull's forces at the Little Bighorn, plunging the garrison into mourning. A scheming character named Matthews seizes on the news to manipulate four captive Indian chiefs, falsely promising to secure their freedom.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 26 November 1907 · page 11

His conduct earlier in tbe day and the fight at the sutler's gave place that afternoon to other and more direful news. A steamer touched on its way down tbe river and told of the Custer massacre. Not a trooper at Brannon but had lost a friend; not an officer but ' had lost several. Gloom settled upon ' tbe post, and Matthews was forgotten. He took advantage of that Before an order went out to prevent him be went through the wicket of tbe sliding panel and gathered around him the four chiefs named in Cummlngs' ulti matum.

See moreSee less

They were more sullen, un happy and discouraged than ever. A few words and he had them breathless with Interest. "Ton must look to tne alone for free dom now," be said. "There baa been a great battle in the valley of th ' Greasy Grass. Custer, tbe Long Hair, met Bitting Bull and his allies, and Custer and all hla men are dead."

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

A fictional narrative describes storekeeper Lounsbury learning from an officer that news of Custer's defeat has reached the East, prompting him to ride alone toward Fort Brannon through Indian territory. The passage is part of a dime-novel style serial drama built around the aftermath of the battle.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 26 November 1907 · page 11

"Pretty sassy. How about Bran non?" "Nothing since old Lancaster" "I heard that Fraser wrote me." Lounsbury gritted his teeth. "And our poor Custer?" "Ah, poor Custer! The east's talk

See the clipping

Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho

A newspaper promotion for 'The Plow Woman' by Eleanor Gates, a frontier novel set in North Dakota immediately following the Custer massacre. The ad touts the heroine's hardships battling hostile Indians and land-grabbing settlers.

Lewiston Evening Teller · 28 November 1907 · page 6

BY ELEANOR GATES In this tale erf North Dakota at the time immediately fol lowing the Custer massacre we have one to stir the blood of the most jaded novel reader. The Plow Woman plowed because she must and los none of her womanly sweetness in doing so. Threatened by hostile Indians and more dangerous enemies of bei own race who sought to oust her with her sister and help less father from their quarter-section, she becomes a heroin« characteristically American and possible only in America Illustrated by Parker A story of the west worth reading

See the clipping

The Oakes Times · Oakes, N.D.

This is a newspaper advertisement for Dr. Pierce's Golden Medical Discovery and Pleasant Pellets, combined with promotional blurbs for a serialized novel by Randall Parrish that culminates in a fictionalized account of the Custer massacre. It is not a news report about the actual Little Bighorn battle but a commercial promotion using the historical event as a literary hook.

The Oakes Times · 28 November 1907 · page 2

Old Frontier," etc. St. Paul Dispatch—A compelling interest biases the reader in favor of this tale, which, with a wealth of dramatic power, reaches its climax in a description of the Custer massacre. Injustice makes men restless, and Bob Hampton was no mean specimen, but the love he bears his old commander, General Custer, like a magnet draws him with unfailing fatality, so that, with his old company, he, reinstated, falls with that gallant leader. Houston Chronicle—The story is decidedly the ttest Mr. Parrish has written, and the popularity of his former vol umes in connection with the excellence of this latest will make it one of the widely read novels of the day. In this story he has, perhaps, reached the summit of his art.

See the clipping