A 1904 newspaper item reviews contents of several magazines, including Pearson's Magazine's special article 'Indian Fights and Fighters' by Cyrus Townsend Brady, which recounts the last stand and destruction of the Seventh Cavalry and Custer's death. The piece is part of a broader roundup of magazine contents with no new factual reporting on the battle itself.
The Republican Journal · 1 September 1904 · page 6
last stand, and the cutting-up of the Seventh Cavalry, and the death of that most celebrated of all Indian fighters— Custer. Albert Bigelow Paine con tributes an instalment, “The End of the
This is an advertisement for Pearson's Magazine's September issue, highlighting various fiction stories and special articles including one on 'Indian Fights and Fighters' that discusses Custer's last stand. The passage is promotional content for a magazine, not a news report on the battle itself.
The Gold Leaf · 1 September 1904 · page 4
sunme". "The King and Queen of smugglers" is a charming love and adventure story by Ilalli well Sutcliffe. "The Gem of Life" is a story of love and mj-stery garnished with the breath of life among the golden maidens and the brown men of far-away India. Then there is a stirring "Don Q" story, separate and complete in itself, as is every story in this famous series. And three other bright stories are there. In the special articles. Cyrus Town send Brady's "Indian Fights and Fight ers" tells of the last stand, and the cut ting.up of the Seventh Cavalry, and tint death of that most celebrated of all Indian fighters Custer.
See moreSee less
Albert Bigelow J'aine contributes an installment "The End of the King," in his Thomas Nasi article. And in "California," in the "Stories of the State" series, is told the early days of lawlessness, murder and vigilance committees down to the pres ent magnificent prospects of this Cnesus
An interview with actor/producer Kyle describes efforts at theatrical authenticity for a stage play based on John Ermine, including importing actual alkali dust, a real log hut, and rifles claimed to have been found on the Custer battlefield. The article emphasizes the play's historical accuracy regarding events and uniforms from 1875-76 Indian Wars era.
The Washington Times · 4 September 1904 · page 12
River, which, by the way, is the actual gcene of the play, where Mr. Reming ton knew there was a log hut. This was carefully taken down, placed on wagons, and dragged nearly 100 miles across the hills to the nearest railway station. It was then loaded on flat cars and shipped to New York. Mr. Rem ington wanted us to use that nut on the stage, but allowed us to make a perfect copy of it when he found that it would take four men a full day to set lit un, and as long again to take it down.
See moreSee less
“Another item was that of weapons. We have secured rifles actually in use during the Indian wars, two of then, {in fact, having been found on tie field jof the Custer massacre, the battle of {the Little Big Horn. As far as possi i ble we use uniforms which were actuni {lv in use in tbe year of 1875, in which tne jevents from which our play is made
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 1 other paper
This Pearson's Magazine excerpt describes the discovery of Custer's command's bodies by Terry and Gibbon's relief force two days after the battle, noting the men died in formation around Custer rather than fleeing in disgrace. It also addresses a theory from Col. Dodge that Custer's unscalped body suggested suicide, which the author dismisses as likely incorrect.
Iron County Register · 8 September 1904 · page 3
BEATEN BUT NOT DISGRACED
Brady, in Pearson's Magazine. There, the second day afterward, Terry, with Gibbon, having relieved Reno's men, found them on the hills which they had immortalized by their desperate valor. They had been stripped and most of them mutilated. Custer's body was shot in two places, In the side and in the temple. ' It was not scalped or mutilated. Col. Dodge, an authority on Indian customs, declares that if he was not scalped or mutilated he is con vinced that Custer committed suicide. None of the officers with whom I have communicated and who inspected the body are willing to indorse this state ment; on the contrary, I am sure that Col.
See moreSee less
Dodge must be in error. The In dians give no particular information as to Custer's death. All that is known ie that his body was there with those ol his brave men.
The Holt County Sentinel · Oregon, Mo. · 30 September 1904
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.
A 1904 article describes a congressional irrigation committee's steamboat tour along the Missouri River near Bismarck. It notes that Captain Marsh, piloting the boat, had decades earlier captained the steamer that brought down the wounded and dead from the Custer massacre.
The Washburn Leader · 10 September 1904 · page 1
the Reclamation Congressman Marshall, State Engineer Chan Bureau. dler and party in this city, on Sunday evening, they were met by General Williams, president of the State Association, and on the next morning the Soo was taken to Washburn. The party was augmented by the presence of General Williams, Captain Baker, Superintendent Derrick of the Soo Line, and Hon. E. G. Patterson, acting mayor of Bismarck. Editor Jewell could not go owing to the absence from the state of his associate in the land office, Hon. John Satterlund. On arriving at Washburn, the steamer Washburn was placed at the disposal of the Quests by Capt.
See moreSee less
Baker, and Capt. Marsh took charge of the boat. It would be a pleasure to take a trip anywhere with the last named gentleman, but particularly along the Missouri, as he has been in service on this stream for over fifty years, and was the captain of the steamer bringing down the wounded and dead of the Custer massacre. He is a quiet, unassuming man, but full of reminiscence of other days and no one understands the shifting sand bars of the Missouri better than Captain Marsh. Washburn wras left at 2 o'clock, and it was about 1) o'clock before the boat tied up at Mannhaven. Here it was coaled from a mine within 10 feet of the boat, where an 8-ft. vein stood right out over the river. At 4 o'clock the next morning, everybody was up and the start was made for Coal Harbor. On the way, breakfast was served, and a little before 6 o'clock the steamer was tied up at Coal Harbor,where Hon. E. S. Neal, of Bismarck, was found with a spanking team of horses. Chief Engineer Newell, and several other gentlemen, drove to the town of Coal Harbor and from there to Ft. Stevenson, where they met the boat again and a start was made on the return. The boat tied up again at Scuten landing, where another team was in waiting, arid a drive was made to Mannhaven, where connection was made with the boat, The journey was continued by boat down the river to Washburn, the speed being from 15 to 20 miles an hour, while in going up the river only 6 or 8 mi. per hour was made. The return to Bismarck, via the Soo Line, and were driven to the waterworks reservoir, then down to the pumping station, showing how water was raised 214 feet by one series of pumps, while the bench lands that had been viewed during the day, were only from 30 to 60 feet in height as a rule. The next point of interest was the alfalfa fields of Capt. Baker on the Bismarck flats, where the seed was sown three years ago and two crops have already been secured this year, and another is nearly ready for cutting.
An advertisement promotes the Cummins Wild West, Indian Congress and Rough Riders show at the St. Louis World's Fair, featuring a daily reenactment titled 'The Custer Massacre, or Battle of the Little Big Horn.' It boasts 650 chiefs, Indians, soldiers, cowboys and frontiersmen participating in vivid, 'horrowing' depictions of the battle.
The St. Louis Republic · 11 September 1904 · page 18
AMUSEMENTS. Custer's Massacre IEIINNINI ST. LOUIS DAY Tkon.ar, Sept. 15, THE CUSTER MASSACRE ...OR,.. BATTLE OFTHE LITTLE BI6 HORN Tivtonted dailr, ,wiih, all It vlv'rt realism ant) hnrrowiug OOOOQ-
The report describes Colonel Cummins' Wild West show at the 1904 World's Fair, which will feature a reenactment of 'Custer's massacre' as its most spectacular offering. The piece touts the show as surpassing previous efforts, with cowboys, cavalrymen, and performers staging the dramatic battle scene for popular entertainment.
The St. Louis Republic · 11 September 1904 · page 33
.our .Money's Wrth or .Money Back." I i mous warrior C"!oreI Cummins will e. llpse II bis fnrm"r efforts, an.1 ho de clares fiat Custer s massacre will be the prospect of rain. .p-shaf of his successful offering as a . pirveyor of popular amusement and cdu jciii.nal exhibition The raid of the red skins and their terrible onslaught of the i h rofc handful of whites will be the most i i turesfji. of the spectacles yet pre-s-nte.1 yesterday A herei ifure cavalrymen and rough i -alers a.roixts and other entertainers of 1 both sex. " will ul-rlay their ability, under &ue j-i ,qai u. - ..wi. v. v...w..c ,uu.....iv polnz.
Colonel Frederick Cummins announces his Wild West Indian Congress will reenact the Battle of the Little Big Horn starting September 15, featuring Indian chiefs who allegedly fought in the original battle. The show also claims to have hired the only surviving white participant, with Cummins himself playing General Custer.
The St. Louis Republic · 11 September 1904 · page 33
harrowing detail", this famous hattle. So reall-tlc has Colonel Cummins en deavored to make iMs reprmiuetion thai he ha sreclally ega-ed for this atlntr tkm many of the famous chiefs ami other Indians who actually participated In the conflict, it conectlon with which he has engaged the services of the only llvins white survivor, who will take part In the battle as he was. wont to do under his celebrated commander. Colonel Cummins has carefully studied out the character and style of General Custer, and will himself represent this fa-
A 1904 newspaper correspondent describes a steamer trip up the Missouri River piloted by Captain Grant Marsh, noting Marsh's earlier fame for bringing the first news of the Custer massacre to Bismarck. The article mainly focuses on the river's potential for irrigation and coal-powered development, with the Little Bighorn reference serving as nostalgic historical color.
The Republican Journal · 15 September 1904 · page 2
THE FORCEFUL MISSOURI.
Custer, Forsythe, Sheridan, Miles, and an important factor in many Indian ex peditions. There was little in common in my uneventful trip and such a one as when Captain Marsh brought back to Bismarck the first news of the dreadful Custer massacre, which made 20 widows
The Cummings Wild West Show staged its first performance depicting the Custer massacre, drawing an audience far exceeding the invitations sent out. The dramatic reenactment was enthusiastically received by the large crowd in attendance.
The St. Louis Republic · 15 September 1904 · page 9
cvsTEK Mcm: itKPitfTnrrKi). rirat Perlormnnce at Cnmotlna Mmss llntlianiaatlralls Itet-clsefl. At the first production of the Custer massacre at th Cummings Wild West Show last ni?ht the big amphitheater was filled with distinguished persons. Invitations to the number of Z.V't w-re sent out, and the number that attended the initial performance was several times that. The Custer massacre is a most thrilling performance, and the large crowd was well pleased.
A Montana cattle rancher recalls that old-time army officers and Plains Indians often had friendly, respectful relations even during the Indian wars of the 1870s. He tells an anecdote of Sioux scouts near the time of Custer's Little Bighorn campaign who let a familiar young lieutenant and his men pass by unharmed rather than attack.
The Wheatland World · 16 September 1904 · page 6
WERE FRIENDS WITH OFFERS Indian* of the Plain* Treated Them a* Brother*. “The best friend the Indian ev • had was the old-time regular army f fleer,” said T. I*. Montgomery, a cl tie raiser of Miles City, Mont., “ar. 1 Incidentally, the best friend the your - cub officer just of West Point ever h was the old-time Indian. I have !iv« I in Montana. Nebraska and Idaho prr tieally all my life, and I saw and to part In many of the Indian campalp: of twenty and thirty years ago.
See moreSee less
D» ing the Indian wars I saw bund re - of things to prove to me the bonds of friendship existing between the boy officer and the wily old Indian, ev< when the latter was on the warpath. “In the summer of *76, about th time of Custer and the Little Big Horn, I was In Montana. The Che; enne Sioux were giving the settler trouble, and two troops of cavalry ha been sent after them and were er. ’ camped on what Is now my own rand. The old officers at that time had a habit of sending out a lieutenant whh 1 three or four men on sr-outing expert. . tions. “One old Indian told me afterwarrt : (bat he and a party of his scouts were j 1n hiding one afternoon when a lieu . tenant and throe privates rode by. [ looking for them, and less than twen j ty yards from where the Indians were t hidden. Did the Indians shoot? Os [ course not. They knew the young lieutenant, had probably swapped »o --» bacco with him. and they allowed him I to pass by unharmed.” r
This piece reflects on the Little Bighorn disaster, questioning whether Major Reno's failure to follow Custer's orders contributed to the massacre. It notes the earlier court of inquiry cleared Reno of wrongdoing, but cites a new book by Rev. Cyrus Townsend Brady arguing Reno lost his head and thus lost Custer.
Omaha Daily Bee · 17 September 1904 · page 10
WHY RENO FAILED CUSTER
Little HI Horn. Chicago Inter Ocean. The slaughter of General Custer and his whole Immediate command Is t' e grest. est tragedy of our Indian wars. Whether Custer's plan of battle Invited disaster,
This 1904 article revisits the Little Bighorn disaster, questioning whether Major Reno's failure to support Custer caused his death, and cites a claim relayed through a magazine that Reno privately admitted drunkenness explained his conduct that day. It also notes Reno's later dismissal from the army for drunken misbehavior.
Omaha Daily Bee · 17 September 1904 · page 10
WHY RENO FAILED CUSTER
answer can never be given. 1 Whether Reno could have done what lie was sent to do Is also a question on which experts differ, and to which a pos itive answer Is equally Impossible. The court of Inquiry which Major Reno de manded declined to advise any further action In hit case. Tet many army offi cers held him highly culpable, and some accused him of cowardice as well at In competence. That Reno was no coward his civil war career, during which he waa twice pro moted for gallahtry.
See moreSee less
would seem to prove. The court of Inquiry, after careful In vestigation, declined to . say that he did not do all he could under the circum stances. Yet Rev. CymS Townsend Brady( In a narrative on the disaster Just pub lished and evidently based on the most careful study, reaches the conclusion that Reno "certainly lost his head, and when he lost his head he lost Custer." Whether Reno's failure to do what he was sent to do really did cause Custer's death whether Reno did all he could may be left as open questions. The un disputed fact that remains. Is that Reno failed to de what he vat sent to do, and thus contributed to Custer's disaster, even if he did not cause It. Why did Reno lose his head, If he did lose It? Why did he fall, as ha certainly did? What was the explanation of his conduct? The Northwestern Christian Advocate In commenting on Mr. Brady's study and de scription of . the -affair, gives an explana tion which. It asserts, comes directly from Major Reno himself, and which Is new to the general public. It tays: "Major Reno himself told the late Rev. Dr. Arthur Edwards, then editor of North western, that his strange actions were due to the fact that he was drunk. To Arthur Edwards, who knew him well and con tinued his faithful friend, Major Reno often unburdened his heart, and one occasion In deep sorrow said that hta strange actions were due to drink. His action at the bat tle of the Little Big Horn was cited as one Instance." i Major Reno was dismissed from ' tha army four years after the Custer dis aster for getting drunk, publicly assault ing a fellow officer and otherwise be having scandalously. It Is certain ' that his use of liquor brought this soldier's career to a disgraceful end. If his drinking of whisky on the day ot the battle of the Little Big Horn caused him to fall to do what Custer had sent him to do, as Dr.' Edwards' successor says he told Dr. Edwards It did. ad thereby, caused him at least to contribute to the death of Custer and all his men, the simple fact Is one of the most powerful temperance lectures ever given. . .
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
A newspaper filler item quotes a regular army soldier recalling the 1876 campaign against the Sioux following the Custer massacre. He jokes about Crow scouts mysteriously acquiring extra ponies overnight, with no one asking where they came from.
The Anderson Intelligencer · 21 September 1904 · page 7
The Remounts. "When you talk about enterprise % never saw anything to beat the In . diana of the old northwest," said a regular army soldier who was in the campaign against the Sioux af tel the Custer massacre in 1876. Hfl explaine d Indian . enterprise thii way: "We had a lot of Crows employed as scouts, and they were quite useful. They had their own ponies, but sometimes they would wako up is the morning with nary a po. jr to their credit. They would start oui afoot, and they always came back at night with plenty bf ponies. No? body ever asked where they got thc ponies."-Seattle Post-Intelligencer.
Decades after Custer's defeat, this piece revisits the unresolved question of whether Major Reno's failure to follow orders caused or contributed to Custer's death. It cites the court of inquiry's inconclusive findings and a newly published book accusing Reno of losing his head in battle.
Arizona Republican · 22 September 1904 · page 2
Kean St. Charles will not be the next councilman from Mohave. The demo crats of that county have already at tended to the little matter. St. Charles fell down at the primaries. It is to be feared that he will now turn to the republican party, but it is thought like ly he may find a home among the so cialists. WHY RENO FAILED CUSTER. iThe slaughter of General Custer apd his whole immediate command is the greatest tragedy of our Indian wars. Whether Custer's plan of battle in vited disaster, or brought it only bo cause of the failure of Major Reno to do what Custer sent him to do, is a
A 1904 newspaper piece revisits the Little Bighorn battle, citing the Northwestern Christian Advocate's claim that Major Reno confided to Rev. Dr. Arthur Edwards that his failure during the battle was due to being drunk. The article notes Reno's later dismissal from the army for drunken misconduct and frames the drinking claim as a cautionary temperance lesson.
Arizona Republican · 22 September 1904 · page 2
Rev. Dr. Arthur Edwards, then editor of Northwestern, that his strange ac tions were due to the fact that He was drunk. To Arthur Edwards, who knew him well and continued his faithful friend. Major Reno often unburdened his heart, and on one occasion in deep sorrow said that his strange actions were due to drink. His action at the battle of the Little Big Horn was cited as one instance." Major Reno was dismissed from thi army four years after the Custer dis aster for geting drunk, publicicly as saulting a fellow officer, and other wise behaving scandalously.
See moreSee less
It is cer tain that his use of liquor brought this soldier's career to a disgraceful end. If his drinking of whisky on the day of -the battle of the Little Big Horn caused him to fall to do what Cuf-ter had sent him to do, as Dr. Edwards' successor says he told Dr. Edwards it did, and thereby caused him at leas', to contribute to the de.ith of Custer and all his men, the simple fact is one of the most powerful temperance lectures ever given. Chicago Inter-Ocean.
A church paper editor claims Major Reno confessed to being too drunk to know what he was doing during the fight at Little Big Horn. The report frames this as a cautionary tale about the destructive effects of alcohol, noting Reno later became increasingly addicted to whiskey.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 22 September 1904 · page 3
THE RENO AFFAIR.
Christian Advocate, concerning task of carrying relief to General C-fS-•out ter at Little Big Horn, and who failed that he lost it by becoming intoxicated "fv J16 .co"/l Generof tl)e nancial
Amid garbled text about business and politics, a stray fragment references a 'surprising revelation about the Custer massacre' tied to details kept in a record book. The surrounding content is mostly unrelated newspaper filler about currency policy and the 1904 election.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 22 September 1904 · page 3
And well he might. The surprising! ^0aRi°l thing is that with such an experiOT.c he did not have sense or courage enough to let the stuff alone. As has been remarked this latest revelation about the Custer massacre ,n cIl)b L? 1 ,P„°te™ te™perancei lectures In the world. It adds one more to the list of illustrations that. by the young tend to show no man if placed In a po-ian(j the
A veteran Indian fighter and self-styled Sioux war chief reminisces in 1904 about a frontier incident near the Little Bighorn in the early 1870s, before Custer's famous battle there. He sets the scene of ongoing settler-Indian conflict and introduces a rider bringing news of a breakaway band of braves.
The Tupelo Journal · 23 September 1904 · page 2
It is of an Indian fight that 1 am going to write now. Not the stereotyped dime novel battle, where “in five minutes Pawnee Pete had wiped out the whole tribe.' hut of one incident in one fight which has stamped itself forever on tuy memory. It was in the early 70's, and the scene was the region of the Little Big Harn, where later Custer and his command were cut to pieces by Sitting Bull, the medicine man, and his famous Eleven Tribes. The basin of the Little Big Horn was a favorite haunt of the Sioux.
See moreSee less
The country about, there had once been fair ly alive with game. The Indians at first ■ resented the advent of the white settler, who came to take a large share of his food, and later he resented the settler's trying to force him from his own heredi tary country. This resentment took the form of massacres, the burning of settle ments and similar outrages which form the native idea of voicing the sentiment: “I am displeased.’’ For years these casual raids had gone on, and for years the white man, with true Anglo-Saxon doggedness, had re built the burned cabin and repopnlated the ravaged country.
A dispatch from Cody, Wyoming reports that Colonel Cody obtained a rifle in Scotland said to have been used by Sitting Bull during the Custer massacre and other battles. The weapon had passed through Canada to a Sir Thomas Dawson Brodie, who gave it to Cody for his frontier relic collection.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.
Wrong
The Commoner · 23 September 1904 · page 7
An Associated Press dispatch under date of Cody, Wy6'.,"Se'pt. 13, says: "Word from Scotland states that 'while showing there . recently Colonel, Cody came into possession of the rifle usecl by Sitting Bujl in the Custer massacre and other
The Cummins Wild West Show on the Pike, which staged a reenactment of the Custer Massacre, was sold by court order after a strike by cowboy performers led to vandalism and arrests. The new owners, Colonel Cummins and Colonel Harrison, hired fifty cavalrymen to replace the striking cowboys for the show.
The St. Louis Republic · 27 September 1904 · page 9
WILD WEST SHOW ON PIKE SOLD BY ORDER OF COURT.
cowboys who went out on a strike. The otwboys resented their dismissal, and. going Into tho rear of the arena, made a target of the kitchen and other buildings, perforating them with bullet, and causing a stampede of those In the vicinity of the show. The police were called and several arrests made, but upon the promise of friends of the belligerent cowboys that they would tak them out of the grounds, they were released. In stead of the cowboys. Colonel Harrison en gaged fifty cavalrymen to take part in the Custer Massacre.
A Montana cattle rancher recalls that old-time army officers and Indians often had mutual respect, even during wartime, citing the Cheyenne-Sioux troubles around the time of Custer's Little Bighorn battle in 1876. He tells of Indians sparing a young lieutenant's scouting party rather than killing them.
Yorkville Enquirer · 27 September 1904 · page 4
tiings to prove to me the bonds of -iendship existing between the boy ofcer and the wily old Indian, even hen the latter was on the warpath. "In the summer of '76, about the ime of Custer and the Little Big Horn, was In Montana. The Cheyenne ioux were giving the settlers trouble, nd the two troops of cavalry had
The Holt County Sentinel · Oregon, Mo. · and 1 other paper
A 1904 Pearson's Magazine account by Cyrus Townsend Brady narrates the final annihilation of Custer's command by Gall, Crazy Horse, Crow King, and Rain-in-the-Face. It describes the discovery of the bodies two days later by Terry and Gibbon, noting Custer's body was shot but not scalped or mutilated.
The Holt County Sentinel · 30 September 1904 · page 7
BEATEN BUT NOT DISGRACED
Gall and Crazy Horse now determined to end the affair. Massing their war riors in the ravine they fell upon both flanks at the same time that Crow King and Rain-in-the-Face led the direci charge against the front of the thinned and weakened line. They swept over the little band of men, j probably now out of ammunition, In a redwave of destruction. There was a fierce hand-to-hand struggle with clubbed guns and tomahawks, ' and all was over. Some 20 or 30 men with out their officers, who had probably all been killed where they stood, for their oodies were found grouped around that yt Custer on the highest hill, endeavored j to break through on the right.
See moreSee less
They were ilaughtered to a man before they reached the river. A few scattered bodies here ; and there in different parts of the field indicated that separate men had made futile dashes for freedom. But the bulk of the command was found just where it had fought with the troopers in line, their officers in position. They had been beaten and killed. Not an officer or man lived to tell the story, but they had not been disgraced, says Cyrus Townsend
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · 8 September 1904
The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · and 7 other papers
This 1904 piece recounts the Battle of Little Bighorn, describing the Indians' attack on Custer's position and the soldiers' futile defense. It narrates the deteriorating situation as ammunition ran low and horses were lost, culminating in the discovery of Sergeant Butler's body between Custer's and Reno's positions, suggesting a failed attempt to send for reinforcements.
The Ely Miner · 30 September 1904 · page 3
Brave Men. The Indians attacked at once. Riding at full gallop along the front of the line on their ponies, they poured a heavy fire from their long-range rifles upon the soldiers, to which the latter made a brave, steady, but not very effective re ply with their inferior carbines, writes Cyrus Townsend Brady, in “The Last of Custer,” in Pearson’s. The force menacing them was so great that Custer dared not leave his position on the hills. To retreat was hopeless, to advance impossible. They must stand on the defensive and pray that the ad vance of Reno’s command up the valley, which they probably hoped that Benteen would reenforce, would compel the withdrawal of the Indians from their front.
See moreSee less
They fought on. therefore, coolly and resolutely, husbanding their ammu nition and endeavoring to make every shot tell in their galloping, yelling foe men. The Indians, in their accounts, speak of the cool, deliberate courage of numbers of the officers and men, whom they singled out for their bravery. Yet the troopers suffered great loss as the afternoon w'ore on. Their ammunition began to run low. and the contracting, whirling circle of Indians drove them closer and closer together. The horses w'ere at last stampeded, and with them went some of the reserve ammunition. It appears that at this time Custer must have endeavored to send a mes sage to Reno, for the body of a solitary soldier, Sergt. Butler, was found after the battle at a point half way between Custer and Renos command. A little heap of cartridge shells lay near his body, evidencing that he had sold his life dearly. It was evident to all on the hill as the afternoon drew to its close that they were doomed. It was ha'rdly possible that a counter attack by Reno would save them now, and there were no evi dences that he was anywhere in the vi cinity. “Where, in Gods name,” they must have asked themselves in their de spair, “could Reno be?” One of the Crow scouts has said —although his account is generally disbe lieved —that he went at last to Custer, as yet unharmed, and told him that he thought he could get him aw r av, and that Custer refused to leave the field. The Crow' altered his appearance to look as much like a Sioux as possible, and in the confusion of the fight got away safely. He w r as the only human surviv or of the field. What occurred after is a matter of conjecture, based upon the contradictory and inadequate testimony of the Indians themselves.