As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

November 1898

12 articles

The Cumberland Echo · Cumberland, Ohio

The report announces the death of Walter Brown Holt, a 52-year-old ex-soldier and claimant to an English estate, who died at his home in New York City. It notes he had been a member of the relief forces sent to reinforce Gen. Custer at the time of the Custer massacre.

The Cumberland Echo · 3 November 1898 · page 6

PERSONAL AND POLITICAL.

Knapp, Peck & Thomson, publishers of the Auburn, N. Y., Daily Advertiser. Mr. Knapp was 80 years of age and had been connected with the Adver tiser for 60 years. Walter Brown Holt, aged 52, an ex soldier of the United States army, and a claimant to the immense Holt estate in England, died at his home in New York City on the 28th ult. He was a member of the relief forces on the way to reinforce Gen. Custer at the time of the Custer massacre. The following named officers have been ordered by the president to be honorably discharged from the volun teer army, the discharges to take effect December 31, their services being no longer required: Capt.

See moreSee less

James G. Blaine, son of ex-Secretary Blaine; Capt. Edward Murphy, son of

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

The report describes an ethnological 'Indian congress' exhibition featuring about 500 Indians from 35 tribes living in traditional dwellings. Among those noted is White Swan, a Crow scout who served under Custer at Little Bighorn, was wounded and left for dead, and remains a cripple and respected leader.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 4 November 1898 · page 9

RECORD OF COL GEORGE E. WARING VICTIM OF THE FILTH OF HAVANA. Au Eminent Mnuitnry Engineer, Seien. tiflv Farmer, Fnllnful Moldier nnd Worthy American. The death of Col Waring, at bis home in

See the clipping

The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D.

An unnamed veteran officer, quoted in Detroit, protests that the famous Seventh Cavalry—the regiment of Custer and Forsyth, associated with Little Big Horn and Wounded Knee—is being wasted on garrison duty in the southwest watching Indians instead of fighting in Cuba. He argues the Seventh has suffered more casualties and seen more hard service than the rest of the regular army combined, yet raw recruits are being sent to fight Spain instead.

The Herald-Advance · 4 November 1898 · page 8

have none on hand now, but have Marjorie, "and maybe you'll he think bed and listened. tll? "r°m placed your order on file, and ycu are ing I'm ungrateful. Mr. Ixirraine alIn a few minutes the sound was re­ likely to hear from us soon.'' ot alry. the regiment Of Custer and Forsyth, of Little Big Horn and Wounded Knee, There is a body of 'he toughest, hardiest troops in exl3

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This is an 1898 entertainment advertisement for the California Theater promoting a military melodrama called 'Northern Lights' that invokes the Custer Massacre as a dramatic draw. It is not a news report but a theatrical listing with ticket prices and other show attractions.

The San Francisco Call · 15 November 1898 · page 7

CALIFORNIA THEATER. GOTTLOB. MARX & CO.. Lessees and Managers. HEAR the Tale of the Custer Massacre! SEE the Indian Repulse! IMMENSE . SUCCESS OF. . William Calder and Company In the; ROMANTIC MILITARY PLAY.

See the clipping

The Indian Leader · Lawrence, Kan.

The article describes Bishop Hare's 25 years of missionary work among the Sioux, noting that some of his converts once fought alongside Sitting Bull at the battle where Custer died. It highlights the transformation from warfare to Christian worship, including a large annual outdoor convocation of Sioux church members.

The Indian Leader · 15 November 1898 · page 4

BISHOP HARE'S LIFE WORK

=— in this mighty band are warriersj 5,000. who fought with Sitting Bull in the bloody ! . . 1..... ( .. 11., . c . . fight where Custer lost his life, and others who often terror zed the pioneers in their scattered settlements along the Cpper Ais But those marauding days are over. souri. The spirit of this change is strikingly strikingly shown in the great convocation which the, Sioux eLurchuen hold every fall. in long

See the clipping

Barbour County Index · Medicine Lodge, Kan.

Published 22 years after the battle, this piece recaps the 1876 Sioux campaign, the converging columns of Terry, Gibbon and Custer, and Custer's division of his regiment among Reno, Benteen and McDougall before his own command was wiped out. It frames the disaster as a feat of Sioux generalship under Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

Barbour County Index · 16 November 1898 · page 4

CUSTER'S LAST FIGHT.

CTJSTiarS LAST FIGHT. How the Brave Cavalry Leader and Ills Heroic Band of Soldiers Met Death at Leaeh Lake. When the report was reached from the Leach Lake region that General Iiaeon and his little band of soldier had possibly been obliterated toy th Pillager band of the Chippewas, the mind of the old-timer turned instinct ively to the bleak hills and dangerous g-ulehe of the Little IiigHorn. If a Bludent of Indian warfare, he wooild then recur to the slaughter of Yellow Jacket pas, in Colorado, when the treacherous Utes ambushed and near ly destroyed the column underThorn-bur-h.

See moreSee less

Coster dashed to his death on the mornirtfof June 25, 1S76; Thorn-burgh ran into an asibuscade on September 22, 1S79. Jloi'h ofiicers, gallaut men, Ut ih?ir lives in the tierce battle which followed. Thonrnlxu rich's death and the manner in which it was ac complished . is known' to all; no sur vivor or eye witness of Custer's last fi.?hi unless he be. an Indian naa been discovered to ten the tale of the ii.-.i-sw.icre of nearly three hundred brave soldiers in. the mad fight against Sitting IVjll, Crazy Horse and the chiefs of the allied Cheyennes. No red skin who ever donned wax bonnet hated the paleface with such bitter animosity -an Sitting liull, medicine man, propheti and war chief. No Indian in the last 60 year did more to demonstrate this hatred. Cu-su r's dTii'all was the precurser and prognwst.:r.ator of the Jiort, sharp and bloody fight up n-r Standing Hook, when Itrd Tomahawk and Dull Head pumped lead into the vitals of the leader of the ghost dance uprising among the Sioux eight years ago. Few warriors have shown the generalship that the great priest and medicines man displayed in the Big Horn campaign. He slew has enemy .and went off free. Sitting Bull and Crazy (Horse, una ble, to incite th tribes of Montana Wyoming -and Dakota to revolt, be gan a systematic attack upon the) friendlies early in. 1876. Crook from Montana and Terry from Dakota and the, Platte were sent out to suppress the ires Mesa hos tiles. With Terry were Cutter and his regiment, the 6even'th cavalry. Though but sec ond in rank, the dashing cavalry leader waa in command ofi the Seventh. General John Gibbons, with 400 of ihis regimenit; Ouster, with 700, and Terry with a. force about as large, met iat the month of the Big Bloi-a ora June 9. From, this point Teirry decided on his campaign. Gibbon was to course to the nortfb end west. Terry was to follow on a shorter line and Ousterwas to plunge imto the "Bad Lands" -leading from the Rosebud westward. The three columns were to unite on or about June 27. Terry and Gibbons did unit on that d-ay, but Custer had "gone over the great divide" with nearly 300 mere of his command. Major Reno, with the remainder in a badly shaken condition, met the general in his ad vance. On June 23. in the little Bif Horn country, Custer's scout report ed a big Indian vMlage, and an im mediate attack was decided upon. The iinmwlom of this attack is be yond dispute. The gallantry and headlong bravery of officer and: ma is equally a matter of history. Ous ter divided his command. He senl Reno with six troops to cross ths river and come in. the valley whers the guikih gave him a good opening. Custer himself, with four troops, wai to dash straight in. Dcnteen and Mo Dougall, captains, with troop ea-ch, were to circle to the left and form a junction when the time for atbacJc had been reached. This is the plan as related by the three officers In command -after the fight. Jlcno essayed to carry out his or ders, but was -Roundly thrashed end forced to retreat back across ths river, his men falling at every step. Tienteen -and Mciltougall joined hina wijh great difficulty, andthe entire force thus united (battled radiantly against feaful olds during the entire day. That night Reno succeeded in drawing off his command and hold1 lng it in safety until joined by Terry the second day after the battle. Bui what of Custer? Silently the little band stole up the hill above the Indian camp. Inside the limits were between 3,000 and 4,000 painted and' savage bucks. In fhs attacking column, there were fewer than 400 men, but men eager for the fray, men who held the red foe in contempt, men who had woa with the odds in the favor of the In dian on many a hot field. When discovered by the Indians the charge was sounded and the unbroken line wept down into the valley of death. At first the wily Indians.' schooled by Sitting Bull, fell back before that im petuous charge. Then came the end. Dead troopers and Indians strewed the way, clearly marking the course of the fight. Then the troopers took position on a small hill and fought it out to the death. Horses and men were mingled in strange confusion. Dead Indians, too many to be carried away by the survivors for their run ners reported the coming of Terry were piled in win rows about the hill. How long that fight rasred about that knoll will never be known. But one by one the brave men went to their dooms. Step by step the horde of circling savages drew nearer in their wild career alout it. True to the Sioux plan of skirinih. they ap proached in ever shortening circle until at last a headlong forward cbarare was m-ade. In that ?r ctlarge many a irrave man went to the happy hunting'grounds. but when oui or. me rurtle and fierce struggle of the conflict the huge war bonnet of Sitting Bull emerged not a "yel low leg" was standing. All were down, their yells of defiance hushed in eternal sleep. I Crazy Horse was captured. Sitting Dull, the real instigator of the upris ing, sneaked away to Canada, where he waited and watched for a farora-! ble time to renew the fight. Driven back by the Can-adians, he too years ago was killed while resisting arrest Chicago Chronicle. An, Arkansas City man has cap u red flag from Manila. Could Not Understand the Difference Stuart Robson recently arrived at "Weehawken, and, tired and dusty, was awaiting the ferry-boat to take him cross to New York, when he was approached by a ragged individual, who was troubled with "the twitters." "Please, mister, will you be so good s to give a poor tramp a nickel?" be asked; "I am broke, and I want to pet across the river." Robson extract-" ed (the coin from his ticket-pocket, and, placing 'it inthe outstretched hand, said: There you are, my dear man; but I can not for the life of me understand what difference It makes which side of the river you are on so I asrj as yon are broke.' Old Ons Surprise. ! An Interesting experiment was made some time ago at Willetts Point, N. Y., by Capt. King, of the United 9tte Army. He took an old gun 16 feet long, wound it witlb. ten miles ot copper wire, and then connected it with, an electric (battery. The re sult was astounding. The old gua, osedi to repulsion, when opposed to Washington great forces, had changed' its char acter completely. It now exhibited wonderful attractive power. The cannot ball that once whistled from its moulflx now by an irresistabie j force leaped toward it. The iron ' and steel which it used to repel were now enticed. In short, Capt. King found that the disused' gun was the most wonderful magnet in the worl3. j

See the clipping

Barbour County Index · Medicine Lodge, Kan.

A newspaper recounts the Battle of Little Bighorn years later, describing Reno's retreat, Benteen and McDougall's arrival, and Custer's final stand on the hill. It embellishes the ending with Sitting Bull supposedly leading the final charge and later says Crazy Horse was captured and Sitting Bull fled to Canada before being killed resisting arrest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

Barbour County Index · 16 November 1898 · page 4

CTJSTiarS LAST FIGHT. How the Brave Cavalry Leader and Ills Heroic Band of Soldiers Met Death at Leaeh Lake. When the report was reached from the Leach Lake region that General Iiaeon and his little band of soldier had possibly been obliterated toy th Pillager band of the Chippewas, the mind of the old-timer turned instinct ively to the bleak hills and dangerous g-ulehe of the Little IiigHorn. If a Bludent of Indian warfare, he wooild then recur to the slaughter of Yellow Jacket pas, in Colorado, when the treacherous Utes ambushed and near ly destroyed the column underThorn-bur-h.

See moreSee less

Coster dashed to his death on the mornirtfof June 25, 1S76; Thorn-burgh ran into an asibuscade on September 22, 1S79. Jloi'h ofiicers, gallaut men, Ut ih?ir lives in the tierce battle which followed. Thonrnlxu rich's death and the manner in which it was ac complished . is known' to all; no sur vivor or eye witness of Custer's last fi.?hi unless he be. an Indian naa been discovered to ten the tale of the ii.-.i-sw.icre of nearly three hundred brave soldiers in. the mad fight against Sitting IVjll, Crazy Horse and the chiefs of the allied Cheyennes. No red skin who ever donned wax bonnet hated the paleface with such bitter animosity -an Sitting liull, medicine man, propheti and war chief. No Indian in the last 60 year did more to demonstrate this hatred. Cu-su r's dTii'all was the precurser and prognwst.:r.ator of the Jiort, sharp and bloody fight up n-r Standing Hook, when Itrd Tomahawk and Dull Head pumped lead into the vitals of the leader of the ghost dance uprising among the Sioux eight years ago. Few warriors have shown the generalship that the great priest and medicines man displayed in the Big Horn campaign. He slew has enemy .and went off free. Sitting Bull and Crazy (Horse, una ble, to incite th tribes of Montana Wyoming -and Dakota to revolt, be gan a systematic attack upon the) friendlies early in. 1876. Crook from Montana and Terry from Dakota and the, Platte were sent out to suppress the ires Mesa hos tiles. With Terry were Cutter and his regiment, the 6even'th cavalry. Though but sec ond in rank, the dashing cavalry leader waa in command ofi the Seventh. General John Gibbons, with 400 of ihis regimenit; Ouster, with 700, and Terry with a. force about as large, met iat the month of the Big Bloi-a ora June 9. From, this point Teirry decided on his campaign. Gibbon was to course to the nortfb end west. Terry was to follow on a shorter line and Ousterwas to plunge imto the "Bad Lands" -leading from the Rosebud westward. The three columns were to unite on or about June 27. Terry and Gibbons did unit on that d-ay, but Custer had "gone over the great divide" with nearly 300 mere of his command. Major Reno, with the remainder in a badly shaken condition, met the general in his ad vance. On June 23. in the little Bif Horn country, Custer's scout report ed a big Indian vMlage, and an im mediate attack was decided upon. The iinmwlom of this attack is be yond dispute. The gallantry and headlong bravery of officer and: ma is equally a matter of history. Ous ter divided his command. He senl Reno with six troops to cross ths river and come in. the valley whers the guikih gave him a good opening. Custer himself, with four troops, wai to dash straight in. Dcnteen and Mo Dougall, captains, with troop ea-ch, were to circle to the left and form a junction when the time for atbacJc had been reached. This is the plan as related by the three officers In command -after the fight. Jlcno essayed to carry out his or ders, but was -Roundly thrashed end forced to retreat back across ths river, his men falling at every step. Tienteen -and Mciltougall joined hina wijh great difficulty, andthe entire force thus united (battled radiantly against feaful olds during the entire day. That night Reno succeeded in drawing off his command and hold1 lng it in safety until joined by Terry the second day after the battle. Bui what of Custer? Silently the little band stole up the hill above the Indian camp. Inside the limits were between 3,000 and 4,000 painted and' savage bucks. In fhs attacking column, there were fewer than 400 men, but men eager for the fray, men who held the red foe in contempt, men who had woa with the odds in the favor of the In dian on many a hot field. When discovered by the Indians the charge was sounded and the unbroken line wept down into the valley of death. At first the wily Indians.' schooled by Sitting Bull, fell back before that im petuous charge. Then came the end. Dead troopers and Indians strewed the way, clearly marking the course of the fight. Then the troopers took position on a small hill and fought it out to the death. Horses and men were mingled in strange confusion. Dead Indians, too many to be carried away by the survivors for their run ners reported the coming of Terry were piled in win rows about the hill. How long that fight rasred about that knoll will never be known. But one by one the brave men went to their dooms. Step by step the horde of circling savages drew nearer in their wild career alout it. True to the Sioux plan of skirinih. they ap proached in ever shortening circle until at last a headlong forward cbarare was m-ade. In that ?r ctlarge many a irrave man went to the happy hunting'grounds. but when oui or. me rurtle and fierce struggle of the conflict the huge war bonnet of Sitting Bull emerged not a "yel low leg" was standing. All were down, their yells of defiance hushed in eternal sleep. I Crazy Horse was captured. Sitting Dull, the real instigator of the upris ing, sneaked away to Canada, where he waited and watched for a farora-! ble time to renew the fight. Driven back by the Can-adians, he too years ago was killed while resisting arrest Chicago Chronicle. An, Arkansas City man has cap u red flag from Manila. Could Not Understand the Difference Stuart Robson recently arrived at "Weehawken, and, tired and dusty, was awaiting the ferry-boat to take him cross to New York, when he was approached by a ragged individual, who was troubled with "the twitters." "Please, mister, will you be so good s to give a poor tramp a nickel?" be asked; "I am broke, and I want to pet across the river." Robson extract-" ed (the coin from his ticket-pocket, and, placing 'it inthe outstretched hand, said: There you are, my dear man; but I can not for the life of me understand what difference It makes which side of the river you are on so I asrj as yon are broke.' Old Ons Surprise. ! An Interesting experiment was made some time ago at Willetts Point, N. Y., by Capt. King, of the United 9tte Army. He took an old gun 16 feet long, wound it witlb. ten miles ot copper wire, and then connected it with, an electric (battery. The re sult was astounding. The old gua, osedi to repulsion, when opposed to Washington great forces, had changed' its char acter completely. It now exhibited wonderful attractive power. The cannot ball that once whistled from its moulflx now by an irresistabie j force leaped toward it. The iron ' and steel which it used to repel were now enticed. In short, Capt. King found that the disused' gun was the most wonderful magnet in the worl3. j

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This local history piece on early Dakota settlers recounts how Indian desperado Brave Bear killed Joseph Johnson in 1879 and fled to Canada to join Sitting Bull, who had crossed the border after the Custer massacre. It is a retrospective obituary-style account of pioneer settlement decades after Little Bighorn.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 25 November 1898 · page 11

PIONEER DEAD.

•Brave Bear of having committed tho deed, and followed the trail of the mur­ derer until he found he had gone int« the British possessions and joined Sit­ ting Bull, who fled over the border after the Custer massacre. Brave Bear later came ever the line into the United States again, and was arrested and after trial was hanged in Yankton. llfli In 1870, Chief Drifting Goose/who laid claim to all this portion of the James river valley, warned all the settlers to leave. There were not many of them in the valley at that time, but most of them left, among the number who went being tha family of H.

See moreSee less

H. Stack, who had built a cabin and was living near where Ran­ dall, post office was later established. The Johnson brothers refused to go. Drifting. Gooso gave twenty days in •m?

See the clipping

The Illinois Record · Springfield, Ill.

A speaker named Robert P. Jackson addresses a gathering, arguing that black soldiers saved Roosevelt from 'another Custer massacre' during the Spanish-American War. He uses this historical reference to criticize the government's failure to protect black citizens from lynching, especially after the Wilmington, N.C. riots.

The Illinois Record · 26 November 1898 · page 3

ROBERT P. JACKSON.

General Andrew Jackson himself testi fied that no heart was more loyal and no arm more strong and useful in the defence of righteousness than the Negro a-nd in the Spanish American war every oue knows what the Negro did. Roosevelt would not be governor of New York today if it had not been for the black soldiers, the 9th, 10th and 25th infantry; if the colored soldiers had not come to his rescue it would have been another Custer massacre.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

The article reviews notable U.S. military courts-martial, including the 1879 court of inquiry into Maj. Reno's conduct at Little Bighorn, prompted by author Frederick Whittaker's accusations against him. It claims the court largely upheld Whittaker's criticisms of the campaign that led to Custer's death.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Anaconda Standard · 27 November 1898 · page 3

ONE OF A LARGE NUMBER

were passed upon here. Whittaker had been In the service as lieutenant of cavalry in the civil war. He had the opportunity to re main, but devoted himself to a liter ary life. It was his criticism on the conduct of the campaign in the "bad lands" resulting in the Little Big Horn disaster and the death of Gen. Cleo. A. Custer that excited the country. Whittaker boldly condemned the dash.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

This retrospective piece recounts Major Marcus Reno's two courts-martial, including the 1879 inquiry into his withdrawal during the Battle of the Little Bighorn. It also compares his case to an earlier naval court-martial of Commodore Barron, noting that Reno was ultimately cleared of cowardice but never regained full standing.

The Anaconda Standard · 27 November 1898 · page 3

Me eom as the Brtish frigate Lepard, of 0 Nsu. The captain at the latter Met eM elscer aboard and maggad mamea as deserters. Barron fee comply with the de m"d and Ye Leopard opened Are when ).arses ws *n hie guard. He was ceippled Wd was compelled to give up the now The action of the commander at the Leopard was re pediated. Mea Namrres was haled image a court, tried Nor failure to do his duty, coavisted mad sentenced to live years seuspeisa from rank and pay. His trial was as much due to popular elamor naphias eise, as he acted really is as, ante with the timid policy at the .

See moreSee less

Later. In 183i, he besame involved In a personal quarrel with*Domtur; they fought. De cater was halle n aad Barroa sariously wounded. ae roeovered. but was nev. er afterward plaeed in command. Major Maoros A. Reno, 7th cavalry. hoed military tourts twice in his ca reer In the army. Once he was own ~aated fees t0 most serious oharge which ona be t against as em oer-cowarsete the sscend time he was dimissed from the senvice. Reo was second IS command in the rug: mast when Custer made his last fight. He coeemanded a squadron seat to the left when Custer made his des palate chags, was subseequently jeuied by Beatees and Campbell with their troops and withdrew from the Sald. He was "semt te Coventry" baesase of this withdrawal and In the and faced a court of ai the cbhrge of cowardice, aksueugh he was not the

See the clipping

Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A city library museum displays an Indian tepee said to have been captured after the Little Bighorn battle, made by Cheyenne chief Yellow Nose. A woman visitor identifies herself as knowledgeable about the tepee's history, recounting that Yellow Nose was a Ute captured by Cheyennes as a boy and is reputed to be the warrior who killed General Custer.

Kansas City Journal · 28 November 1898 · page 10

MRS. D. B. DYER KNEW ALL ABOUT HER INDIAN TEPEE

of the entire collection." continued Mr. Long, "and has a most strange historj-. It has been the home ot manjan Indian dur ing the eventful war with the SIout, and It was captured shortly after the battle of the Little Big Horn, where General Cus ter and his entire command was massa

See the clipping