As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1890

14 articles

Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va.

A brief notice remarks that the location where the Custer massacre occurred years earlier is now a flourishing city. It appears as a short item amid a column of miscellaneous news briefs.

Staunton Spectator · 5 March 1890 · page 2

Where the Custer massacre occurred bit a few years since is now a fl mrishing city. ss—•—a— Mary J. Holmes, the novelist, received royalties on 77,000 copies of her books sold in 1889. Lord Wolseley is not popular with tbe oyal family of England. The Qieen es tecially dislikes him. 1 s> as -a The Grand Duke Paul, brothir of the izar, b<>3 been appointed to the command >f a regiment of bnzzars. a> ■» » The Virginia M. E. Conference wbicb was beld last week in Alexandria will be beld next year in Ronceverte, Greenbrier

See the clipping

The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · and 1 other paper

The piece reports that Comanche, described as the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is still alive and well cared for by the army in Dakota fourteen years later. It notes his scars from the battle and compares his fame to that of Sheridan's famous warhorse.

The Kanabec County Times · 6 March 1890 · page 4

Srow on the treeless plains of Texas, ew Mexico and Arizona, the bark of which ought to yield $5 per acre, counting the fuel as nothing.—lnter view in St. Louis Globe-Democrat. Survivor of the Custer Massacre. The old war horse Comanche, the only survivor of the famous Custer massacre, is still handsomely cared for at the government's expense. Dy special order of the military authori ties Comanche is provided with a comfortable stall, fitted up especially for him out in Dakota. Noone is per mitted to ride him, and he is not al lowed to do any work whatever.

See moreSee less

Rid dled with bullets and scarred by saber wounds, his body speaks eloquently of the perilous duty he has performed in his twenty-two years of service under the government. He will go down to history holding about as proud a place as that accorded the gallant black charger which once brought Gen. “Phil” Sheridan to the field in time to save the battle, “from Winchester, twenty miles away.”—Troy Telegram.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Clarke Courier · Berryville, Va. · 30 January 1890

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.

Colonel T. W. Goldin, now a Wisconsin militia inspector, recounts being a sergeant ordered to carry a message from Custer to Major Reno during the battle. He describes being wounded by ambushing Indians en route, and later finding all the men of Custer's five companies dead in the ravine, some still in formation with their horses.

River Falls Journal · 6 March 1890 · page 2

WISCONSIN STATE NEWS. WAS WITH CUSTER. What Colonel Goldin Saw at the UtUa n 'S Horn M*«»itcrp. Colonel T. W. Goldin, inspector of the small arms practice in the State militia, is one of the survivors of the Little Big Horn fight that cost Custer his life. Whan the firing first began Custer want ed to send a messege to Major Reno, th* n two or three miles away, and Colonel Goldin, then a sergeant of reg ulars. was ordered to carry the message. On his way to Beno Goldin was wounded by Indians in ambush.

See moreSee less

Afterwards he saw every man of the five companies who remained with Custer lying dead in the ravine. In some instances the troop ec end their horses lay on the ground •»1 angular ranks, just the way they stztW before the Indians opened their deadly fire.

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

Colonel T. W. Goldin, described as a Little Bighorn survivor and former sergeant, recounts being sent by Custer to carry a message to Reno and being wounded by Indians in ambush along the way. He claims to have later seen the bodies of all five companies that stayed with Custer lying in a ravine, some still in battle formation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Grant County Herald · 6 March 1890 · page 3

WAS WITH CUSTER.

What Colour! <«oldin s.iw nt the l.ittle Hie Horn Mn’oarrr. Colonel T. AV. Goldin, inspector of the small arms practice in the state militia, is one of the survivors of the Little Big Horn fight tiiat cost Custer his life. When tiie firing first began < aster want ed to send a messege to Major Reno, then two or three miles a wav. and Colonel Goldin, then a sergeant of reg ulars. was ordered to carry the message. On his way to Reno Goldin w as wounded by Indians in ambush.

See moreSee less

Afterwards he saw every man of the five companies who remained with Custer lying dead in the ravine. In some instances the troop ers and their horses lav on the ground in regular ranks, just the way they stood before the Indian* opened their deadly fire.

See the clipping

Idaho News · Blackfoot, Idaho

The article describes Comanche, the horse said to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, now living in comfort at government expense in Dakota. It notes he is excused from all work and compares his legendary status to that of Sheridan's famous warhorse.

Idaho News · 8 March 1890 · page 7

Survivor of the Custer Massa cre. The old war horse Comanche, the only survivor of the famous Custer massacre, is still handsomely cared for at the goverument 's expense. By special order of the military authori ties Comanche is provided with a comfortable stall, fitted up especially for him out iu Dakota. Nooneisper mitted to ride him. and he is not al lowed todo any work w hatever. Rid dled with bullets and scared by saber wounds, his body speaks eloquently of the perilous duty he has preformed of in in his twenty-two years of service un der tlie govern ment.

See moreSee less

He will go down to history holding about as proud a to place as that accorded the gallant black charger which once brought Gen. "Phil" Sheridan to the fielt! in time to save the bnttle, "from Win chester, twenty miles away."—Troy Telegram,

See the clipping

The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.

This passage advertises a book titled 'Warpath and Bivouac,' summarizing its contents about the 1876 campaign against Sitting Bull, including the Rosebud fight, the Sibley Scout, and the Custer massacre. It mentions the Indian version of events at Little Bighorn and references Reno's failure to support Custer.

The Citizen · 8 March 1890 · page 5

"WARPATH AND BIVOUAC."

participated in by P. Jones, G. Erb, F. Byrne ana A. M McLean. Then came Miss Kittle A. Carey in a recitation which portrayed the passion of an Irish Gael In a few Jesuitry remarks to a Bcotch Gael, in which England got the worst ot the fight, and a ter that Thomas Bren nan, of Omaha, addressed the assem blage. jar. ureonanwas eloquent ana rot cl Dip He began by Baying that it wai well that there wag one day in the year cn which Irishmen ehould pauae amid the strife ot life’s battle and look back upon the old land.

See moreSee less

It was well that there wag one day npon which those who held “extreme opinions" should gather together and through voice and action testity their ad herence to principles of such an extreme and radical nature as even the founders of this glorious republic in which we lived, fought for, and died for. There were very few days Indeed on which Irishmen could meet and commune together in a 181 Pearl 8t, N. Y celebration which would partake of pure joy. But they had met tonight to cele brate the memory ol a man who, through defeat, persecution, disaster, death, and— yea, even a nameless grave—bore uneul lied a martyr's crown. Too often, indeed, were Irishmen compelled to ponder over the gloom of a jail, nr the shadow of a gallows, but they, Irish nationalists, met that night to thank Ocd that their native land was the birth place of a Robert Emmet. Ireland cruld tell of martyrs. Bhe could not only tell of martyrs who, even though they diedcn the gallows, died in the noblest place that a man could die— where he died for mao; but she could for all organizations. alio tell of martyrs who were women and ern wilds. It also describes the march of the expedition against Bitting Bull, and the un equalled bufialo hunt participated in by the friendly Indians on both sides of the military column; how war correspondents are placed in Indian campaigns; the battle of the Rosebud, J une 17,1876; the mounted combat between the Crow and Bho-sho no Indians on the one side and the Sioux and Cheyennes on the other, in full view of the troops; remarkable rescue of Bergt. Van Moll by “Humpy,” a Crow Indian scout; the march of the cavalry down Dead Canon and the great peril in which Col. Royall was placed; the fall of Col. Henry, with a terrible wound in his face; the flank march of the battalions of Mills and Noyes; they fall on the rear of the Bloux, who retreat rapidly, thus relieving Royall’s command; horrible mutilation of dead Bloux by the Crow Indians; the Bho-sho nee weeping for their dead, and other incidents of the combat. The book then deals with the monotony of camp life, while Crook is awaiting reinforcements; how officers “sit down” on one another; the smoke of Custer’s battle, of June 25, seen in the distance by Col.Mills; how it was mistaken for a possible prairie fire; the hunt for giant game amid the eternal snows of the main Big Horn range; Italy surpassed in beauty; a enow storm in July; the return to camp over a new trail. Following this comes a graphic description of the author’s experiences in the famous Sibley Bcout, July 6-9,1876; the sighting of the hostiles; the retreat to the mountains; the firing from ambush by the Indians; the soldiers’ skirmish line In the edge of the forest; wounded horses; the Indian charge and its repulse; the death of the Indian leader; a prolonged conflict; how it feels to be looking death squarely in the face; Bibley advised by the scouts to retreat on foot and abandon the remaining horses; perils of the movement at a distance of fully fifty miles from the main camp; the passes occupied by the savages; the retreat 07er the crest of the mountains, with all its Btlrring and romantic incidents; the tempest on the summit at midnight; scaling a beetling precipice; the Indians appear again; taking up a strong position; crossing a mountain torrent in the dark hours of the morning; sufferings of the men; four miles in six hours; in camp at last.

See the clipping

The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.

This passage is a publisher's summary of a book covering the Sibley scout, the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn, Reno's failure to support Custer, and subsequent campaigns against the Sioux and Cheyenne including Slim Buttes and the deaths of Yellow Hand and American Horse. It compiles multiple 1876 frontier conflict episodes into one narrative retrospective.

The Citizen · 8 March 1890 · page 5

participated in by P. Jones, G. Erb, F. Byrne ana A. M McLean. Then came Miss Kittle A. Carey in a recitation which portrayed the passion of an Irish Gael In a few Jesuitry remarks to a Bcotch Gael, in which England got the worst ot the fight, and a ter that Thomas Bren nan, of Omaha, addressed the assem blage. jar. ureonanwas eloquent ana rot cl Dip He began by Baying that it wai well that there wag one day in the year cn which Irishmen ehould pauae amid the strife ot life’s battle and look back upon the old land.

See moreSee less

It was well that there wag one day npon which those who held “extreme opinions" should gather together and through voice and action testity their ad herence to principles of such an extreme and radical nature as even the founders of this glorious republic in which we lived, fought for, and died for. There were very few days Indeed on which Irishmen could meet and commune together in a 181 Pearl 8t, N. Y celebration which would partake of pure joy. But they had met tonight to cele brate the memory ol a man who, through defeat, persecution, disaster, death, and— yea, even a nameless grave—bore uneul lied a martyr's crown. Too often, indeed, were Irishmen compelled to ponder over the gloom of a jail, nr the shadow of a gallows, but they, Irish nationalists, met that night to thank Ocd that their native land was the birth place of a Robert Emmet. Ireland cruld tell of martyrs. Bhe could not only tell of martyrs who, even though they diedcn the gallows, died in the noblest place that a man could die— where he died for mao; but she could for all organizations. alio tell of martyrs who were women and trail. Following this comes a graphic description of the author’s experiences in the famous Sibley Bcout, July 6-9,1876; the sighting of the hostiles; the retreat to the mountains; the firing from ambush by the Indians; the soldiers’ skirmish line In the edge of the forest; wounded horses; the Indian charge and its repulse; the death of the Indian leader; a prolonged conflict; how it feels to be looking death squarely in the face; Bibley advised by the scouts to retreat on foot and abandon the remaining horses; perils of the movement at a distance of fully fifty miles from the main camp; the passes occupied by the savages; the retreat 07er the crest of the mountains, with all its Btlrring and romantic incidents; the tempest on the summit at midnight; scaling a beetling precipice; the Indians appear again; taking up a strong position; crossing a mountain torrent in the dark hours of the morning; sufferings of the men; four miles in six hours; in camp at last. After the description ot the Sibley Bcout comes a lucid account of the awful Custer massacre; the Indian version of the Little Big Horn tragedy; the failure of Maj. Reno to support Custer; Gen. Terry’s celebrated order to Custer before his fatal march; an atroclouB butchery of the doomed soldiers; the battle with Reno’s men in the blufls; the opportune arrival of GenB. Terry and Gibbon to the rescue; joy of the beleagured troops; ghastly scenes on the Custer battlefield. Next comes Gen. Wesley Merritt’s fight with the Cheyennes on War Bonnet creek; he drives them into Red Cloud agency; the chief Yellow Hand killed by “Bufialo Bill” in a hand to hand fight; thrilling adventure of a scout named Kelly; how to go through the Indian country in comparative safety; Merritt joins Crook’s column; pen pictures of notable officers and scouts; superb mountain and prairie fire and the wild flight of frightened animals; a night march on the Indian trail down the Valley of the Rosebud; meeting of Crook’s and Terry’s commands; the survivors of Custer's regiment; ghastly diecovery on Tongue river; the Bloux scalping knife; sufferings of the march; “everlasting wet,” and no tents to shelter Crook’s men; “Bleeping” under a deluge; remarks of the wearied soldiers; Crook and Terry sepa rate; ne terrible cross march to the Little Missouri and Heart river; horses die or “play-out” by the hundred; the soldiers, being almost starved to death, use them for food; all else falling, the flesh of the animals is regularly Issued for rations; the miseries of marching through mud; sickness among the troops. Then follows a vivid description of the fighting at Slim Buttes; harrowing incidents of Indian warfare; a ghastly group of dead; the wounded and captured chief American Horse; his desperate and heroic resistance; “Buflalo Chips" and others shot dead; death song of the Indian women; Gen. Crook’s humanity; the evening attack; Crazy Horse, after a gallant effort, fails to break our line; he finally retreats; next morning attacks the rear guard and is repulsed by Gen. Carr; the rain and mud grow worse and worse,' astounding hardships of officers and men alike; startling adventure of Bergt. Van Moll and Corporal Bessie; they ride through a hostile Indian village In the night time, and escape by the speed of their horses; arrival of supplies from the Black Hillssettlements; in camp on the Belle Fourche. The entry of Gen. Crook into the Black Hills: bis reception by the settlers; Deadwood as it appeared in 187C; a mountain municipality; gold dust as currency; hunting for horse shoers; the ride to Custer City; charming scenery; Crook as a path finder; a new mount and along, hard ride; wild gallop over the plains of the South Cheyenne; reaching Red Cloud; meeting with noted Indians; a red letter night with “the regular army O” at the sutler’s store; meeting with Gen. McKenz’e at a midnight camp fire: awlnter campaign; McKerzle gainB a brilliant victory over Dull Knife; Lieut. McKinney killed; surrender of Crazy Horse; bis base treachery and tragical death; Silting Bull seeks the shelter of the British territory; Gen. Nelson A. Miles “settles his hash’’ a little later on.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

This item recounts anecdotes about artist Tavernier, including his generosity toward a poorhouse-bound old man and a story of him having a toothache pulled with a monkey-wrench by Sitting Bull while in the chief's camp before the Custer fight. It then transitions into an unrelated story about an inventor's snow velocipede sleigh.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 16 March 1890 · page 2

:jan. Tavernier used to tell with huge delight of an experience he bad while In the camp of Sil ting bull, not a great while before the Custer massacre. 11-: had a bad case ot toothache, and it became gradually worse until he eonla stand it no longer. Not 'to let the Indians know be was weakening, he sought bitting Ball and told him he must go to the agency lor more paints. "What matter fare?" asked the big chief. "Nothing much: only alittie toothache, replied the artist, bravely. ' "Me fix him." said Sitting Bull; and with that he went to his tepee, produced a monkey-wrench, and forced Taver

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This article recounts the 1885-86 Apache campaign, detailing Crook's replacement by General Miles and the change in military policy against hostile Apaches. It references Custer's 1876 death at Little Bighorn only briefly, as a credential establishing Sitting Bull's reputation as a dangerous adversary that Miles had previously defeated.

New-York Tribune · 21 March 1890 · page 5

of the country, the demand for the abolishment of Crook's ludtan poliey,” as it was called, and his relief from dusy in that locality, became so pronounced and vehement, even ‘nthe halls of Congress, if recollect aright, that General sheridan was sent out from Washington for investigation. Just at this timo tho death of General Hancock ocenrred, thus necessitating a change in the geographical divisions and departments of the Army and th commanders thereof, and it wis presumed that Gene eral Crook requested to be relieved from duty in Arizona and ordered to Omaha, Neb.

See moreSee less

Le this as 1b may, General Crook was relieved by order of the Presulent, and brevet Major-General Nelson A. Miles, 1. SA... whose victories over Chief Joseph, of the Nez Perces, and later over Sitting bull, of the slony (who in 1276 massacred Custer and his devoted heroes on the Little Big Horn), was sent to command

See the clipping

Telegram-Herald · Grand Rapids, Mich.

This item is a profile of Buffalo Bill Cody describing his scouting feats, his famous ride covering 350 miles, and an anecdote about his bravery after the Custer massacre. It also praises his later career as a showman and briefly transitions into a separate profile of journalist Charles A. Dana.

Telegram-Herald · 22 March 1890 · page 5

foot. This in a 6'f A Hi follow or a w. r. oodt. bridge to cro4 the ureata. Tha alf sacrificing spirit and niar? eloua endur wiki of BuIIaIo Uill uado irrat an iuaprrjion on Geji. Sheridan that he called th scout to hii hadquartera and said: '"Cody, I appoint jou ohief cf cxit cf the oomiaand." TLe writer, when on the frontier, after thd Custer maatacre, k.w an Uistance cf Cody 'a njrve. A ncoutinf party was riding among the foothiili of the Wind Iiiver mountains, in Montana, While oing through a email defile from iu fides came the crack of rifles.

See moreSee less

Every one aeerued paralyzed but Buffalo Bill. "It's death to run; there's a chance in fighting," he cried. "Up with you, boys.' And he led the way. A dozen Indians composted the ambuscade. They were "good" Indians when the tkirmish ended. The whites lort one man. While in the government service Cody did gallant work until the year subse quent to the Custer massacre aw the ho,ti!r Indians subdued. He was long the idol of the frontier, and the enthusi astic cowboys of the Platte elected him to the Nebraska legislature. At present he ii displaying his handsome figure and his Wild West show to the nations of Europe. He is a man v. hom the judg ment of future historians will rank with Daniel Boone and Kit Carson as a bul wark of the border. About two decade3 ago Charles Ander son Dana began to insist that The New York Sun should thine for all, and to enunciate his oft repented order: "If any man assaults the English la n guage, shoot him on theppot." De spite his sev enty odd years Mr. Dana is

See the clipping

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Arizona Territory Ariz.

A short item observes that the location of the Custer massacre, which occurred only a few years earlier, has since become a flourishing city. It offers no further detail on the battle itself, just a passing remark on development at the site.

The St. Johns Herald · 27 March 1890 · page 2

Where the Custer massacre oc curred but a few years since is now a flourishing city.

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

This 1890 German-American newspaper article praises General George Crook's long career against the Apache and Sioux, contrasting his careful leadership with Custer's recklessness. It recalls that the Sioux triumphed over 'Long Hair' (Custer) and his men at the Little Bighorn, but credits Crook with eventually pacifying the same vast territories.

Freie Presse Für Texas · 27 March 1890 · page 2

Die Unternehmungen CrooPg gegen die Jndianer waren ebenso umsichtig als lühn geplant. Er war ebenso tapfer wie Custer, aber kein Tollkon wie die ser. Ueber »Langhaar« und die mit ihm am Little Big Horn gesallenen Reiter triumphirten die Sioux. Aber der ,.Graue Adler« wußte fie dennoch zu bändigen und den ungeheuren Länder gebietew welche so lange Zeit von ihnen beunruhigt waren, den Frieden wieder zu geben Dabei erzählen wohlunterrichtete Of fiziere und Feldzugsberichterstatter, daß General Crook selbst gegen Söldner des stehenden Heeres niemals ein Schimpfwort, geschweige denn die Faust, gebrauchte, sondern sie durch freundliches und fürsorglicheg Bened men zur treuen und freudigen Pflichter füllung auf den fürchterlichsten India nerseldzügen in der Wildniß anzuhalten verstand.

See moreSee less

Sie ertrugen die größten Anstrengungen, Entbehrungen und Lei den ohne Murren, weil der General diese mit ihnen theilte und der genüg samste und standhafteste von Allen war. (Jlls. Stztg.)

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A nostalgic story recounts how General Crittenden's young son once scolded him for having made his beloved horse 'John J.' retreat during the war. The piece notes that this same boy later died fighting alongside Custer at the Little Big Horn.

The Indianapolis Journal · 30 March 1890 · page 7

Confidence In the Old Horse, narper's Drawer. The little son of General Crittenden was devoted to his father's war-horse, that was named for the illustrious John J. Cnttcn den. of Kentucky, the child's grandfather. He asked his father to toll him of a retreat be made during the war. but at a certain woint said: "Father, were you on John J.?" Being answerod affirmatively, the young ster slid down from the paternal knee, and was toddling ott as fast as his little legs could carry mm, wnen nis iatner said: Where are you going, my son!"

See moreSee less

"Father." he said, turning and showing a face fnll of reproach, "John J. never would hare retreated If you hadn't turned him 'round.' This same boy grew to manhood, and died with his face to tho foe with Custer and bis men on the Little Big Horn.

See the clipping

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

This German-American newspaper article is a retrospective on General George Crook's campaigns against the Apache, Sioux, and Cheyenne, written around the time of his death. It mentions that the Sioux triumphed over Custer and his men at Little Bighorn, but credits Crook with ultimately subduing the tribes through skill and fair treatment of his soldiers.

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 31 March 1890 · page 4

Indianer waren ebenso umsichtig als kühn geplant. Er war ebenso tapfer wie Custer, aber kein Tollkopf wie dieser. Ueber „Lang—- haar“ und die mit ihm am Little Big Horn gefallenen Reiter triumphirten die Sioux. Aber der „Graue Adler“ wutzte sie dennoch zu bändigen und den ungeheuern Länderge— bieten, welche so lange Zeit von ihnen beun— ruhigt waren, den Fieden zu geben. Dabei erzählen wohlunterrichtete Offiziere und Feldzugsberichterstatter, daß General Crook selbst gegen Söldner des stehenden Heeres niemals ein Schimpfwort, geschweige denn die Faust, gebrauchte, son dern sie durch freundliches und fürsorglihes Benehmen zur treuen und freudigen Pflichterfüllung auf den fürchterlichsten Indianerfeldzügen in der Wildniß anzuhalten verstand.

See moreSee less

Sie er— trugen die größten Anstrengungen, Entbeh— rungen und Leiden ohne Murren, weil der General diese mit ihnen theilte und der ge nügiamste und standhafteste von Allen war.

See the clipping