As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

January 1886

6 articles

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

The report details a regimental exchange between Major Benteen (7th Cavalry) and Major Merrill (9th Cavalry), reviewing their Civil War and postwar service records. It notes Benteen's role commanding troops under Reno at the time of 'Custer's massacre,' and traces how his earlier refusal of a majority in a colored regiment affected his later rank.

The National Tribune · 7 January 1886 · page 4

Lieutenant-Colonel of that regiment. In July,lSC3, he was appointed Colonel of a U. S. Colored regi ment of infantry, and upon the reorganization of the army in 1SG0 was offered a Majority in the 9th Cav., which he declined because it was a colored regiment, and subsequently accepted a Captaincy in tho 7th. Bentccn was with this regiment in all its lights with the Northern Indians under Custer, his troops forming part of Maj. lieno's command at the time of Custer's massacre. After seving 10 years as Captain in the 7th regiment, Bentccn was regularly promoted to a Majority in the 'Jtlt, the same position which he declined in 1SGC.

See moreSee less

Had he accepted the Majority in 1S0G, Bentcen would now be near the top of the list of Lieutenant-Colonels of cavalry, instead of being number '2.0 on tho list of cavalry Majors. Maj. Merrill, who has exchanged with Bcnteen, was recently found unfit for further active service

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A reader writes to the Indianapolis Journal's Q&A column asking whether any of Custer's soldiers escaped the massacre at Little Bighorn. The paper responds that none who were actually with him at the time survived.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Indianapolis Journal, 14 December 1885, The Oskaloosa Herald, 31 December 1885.

The Indianapolis Journal · 10 January 1886 · page 4

CHINESE CANDLES. To the Editor of tlio Indianapolis Journal: Os what are Chinese candles made! s. & City. Os the berries of the candleberry myrtle, which are fragrant and yield a bright light. the ouster massacre. To the Editor of tho Indianapolis Journal: Did any of Custer’s soldiers escape the massa cre! D. A. H. Paxton, Ind. None who were actually with him at the time of the massacre.

See the clipping

The Eaton Democrat · Eaton, Ohio

A disheveled old man named Sebastian Beck tells a reporter he was captured by Indians in 1875 near the Black Hills, held for ten years, and forced to fight alongside them, including at the massacre of General Custer. He claims to have been made a chief, married a squaw, and eventually escaped with help from an officer at Fort Walsh.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

The Eaton Democrat · 21 January 1886 · page 4

CAPTURED BY INDIANS. Strange Adventures of a Philadelphian in the Black Hills. "This is -, a Tery strange story of mine," said a queer old man to a re porter yesterday. , His garments were filthy, and he was old. and feeble and wretched looking. "My name is Se bastian Beck, and in 1875, during the Black Hills mine excitement I left Phil adelphia with a party of men and their wives and. children to go in search of gold. -I have just come back. We worked veins in Wyoming and Dakota, and bad amassed f 10,895 worth of gold nuggets, and were just starting a colony wben one day three thousand Indians swooped down on us, took our gold.

See moreSee less

and blindfolded and strapped .us on ponies. Then the Chief, Black Moon,1 went one way with the women and chil dren, whom we never saw afterward, and Silting Bull took ns men into Montana, For ten years we were kept with the In dians, and almost became Indians our selves. In their battles' with the whites we were compelled to take part, and were dressed like warriors, with paint. , feathers, bows and arrows and toma ' hawks. 'I was present at the massacre of General Custer, and had on my paint and feathers, ' arid did my share of the whooping and lighting. "I was made Chief of a band of In dians, and according to' the rules of the tribe, bad to marry a squaw...- Some tima am, wtiila fidiinn T ui Ana sTif the officers of Fort Walsh, and, calling mm, told him my story, tie helped me escape . from tbe Indians, and wben I reached the fort I could hardly make them believe I wasn't an Indian. Ever since my escape I have been working my way East.'' Philadelphia Times

See the clipping

Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.

A disheveled old man named Sebastian Beck tells a reporter he was captured with a gold-mining party in 1875, forced to live as an Indian for ten years, and claims he fought at Custer's Last Stand in paint and feathers. He says he eventually escaped near Fort Walsh after recognizing an officer while fishing.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Ceredo Advance · 21 January 1886 · page 4

CAPTURED BY INDIANS. StrHUKs .IiIti ntnrr* of a ThllMilrlphlan in the lllaek Hill*. “This i* a very strange story of mine," said a queer old man to a ro )>ortor yesterday. His garments were filthy, and he was oltl ami feeble and wretched looking. “My name is Se bastiau Beck, and in 1^75. during the Black Hills mine excitement 1 left Phil adelphia with a party of men and their wives ami children to go in search of gold. I have just come hack. We worked veins in Wyoming and Dakota, and hail amassed $10,896 worth of gold nuggets, ami were just starting a colony wrien one day three thousand Indians swooned down on us, took our gold, and blindfolded and strapped us on ponies.

See moreSee less

Then the Chief, 'lilack Moon,' went one way with the women and chil dren. whom we never saw afterward.and Sitting Hull took us men into Montana. For ten years we were kept with the In dians, and almost became Indians our selves. in their battles w ith the whites we wen* compelled to take part, and were dressed like warriors, with paint, feathers, Iwnvs and arrows and toma ha" ks. 1 was present at the massacre of General Custer, and lnnl on mv paint and feathers, and did my share of the whooping and lighting. "I was made Chief of a band of In dians, and according to the rules of the tribe, had to marry a squaw. Some

See the clipping

The Hickman Courier · Hickman, Ky.

A disheveled old man claims he was captured by Indians during the 1876 Black Hills gold rush, held for ten years, forced to fight alongside Sitting Bull's warriors at Custer's last stand, and even made a tribal chief. He says he finally escaped with help from an officer at Fort Walsh.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 29 days later.

Wrong

The Hickman Courier · 22 January 1886 · page 2

CAPTURED BY INDIANS.

1 was present at the massacre of General Custer, and had on ni paint and feathers, and did my share of the whooping and fighting. "I was made Chief of a hand of Indians, and according to the rules of the triW, had to marry a .quaw. Some time ago while fishing, 1 sighted one of the oflicers of Fort Walsh, and, calling him, told him my story. He helped me escape from the Indians, and when I reached the fort I could hardly make them believe I wasn't an Indian" Ever since my escape. I have been working my way E:ut.l'iiludclphia Times.

See the clipping

South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.

A disheveled old man named Sebastian Heuk tells a reporter a fantastical story of being captured by Indians in 1875 during the Black Hills gold rush, forced to live as a warrior for a decade. He claims to have participated in the massacre of General Custer, dressed in full Indian war paint, before escaping a decade later.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 27 days later.

Wrong

South Branch Intelligencer · 22 January 1886 · page 4

CAPTURED BY INDIANS.

For ten \ ears wc were kept with the In dians. imd almost became Indians our selvcs. In their battles with the xvhitea we were compelled to take part, aud were dressed like warriors, with paint, feathers. l*ows and arrows and toma hawks, I was present at the massacre of General Custer, and had on mv paint and feathers, and did my share of the

See the clipping