As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1885

7 articles

The Canton Advocate · Canton, S.D. · and 2 other papers

A correspondent describes Dakota Territory's push for statehood, then shifts to recount sightings of Sitting Bull and Gall in Bismarck, noting their rivalry and reputations from the Custer fight. Gall is described as having been exhibited at a New Orleans exposition, while Sitting Bull is portrayed as now peaceful in old age.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 13 days earlier.

The Canton Advocate · 5 March 1885 · page 3

[From Our Bpecl»l Correspondent.] BISMARCK, Feb. 23, 1885. The Capital City of Dakota will soon be relegated to its wonted quietness, and the poker tables and other institutions of their class will be closed, or move to more congenial climes. Over forty days of the present session have passed, and the re mainder of the session will soon take wing yet there have been no such dis graceful scenes enacted as are sometimes witnessed away back in some of the so called "civilized" States. .Even Senator Vest could not find cause for complaint against the Dakota Legislature, unlets it be for the supreme contempt which the members entertain for him personally for the unmitigated ignorance which he man ifests of the rapid progress and wonder ful development of this bright star,which is now rising above the Northwestern horizon.

See moreSee less

Democrats and Republicans alike demand a division of the Territory and the admission of the southern half as a State. The demands and entreaties of half a million free people may be ignored, their rights denied, and their intelligence and honor ridiculed for a time but a day will come in the near future when Dakota will stand in the United States Congress as strong as her strongest traducers. You may then look out for a reckoning. Her people have adopted "Patience and Per severance" for their motto, and have con cluded to hammer away at the common object till they arrive at success, knowing no such word as fail. Bismarck is in the near neighborhood of the Indian country, as is evidenced by the frequent appearance of some of the red race upon her streets. Old Gaul, the chief who, it is said, planned and con ducted the celebrated Custer battle, has been showing himself in the opera houses of Bismarck. So, too, has the aged Sit ting Bull, to whom the credit of the Custer massacre has been universally awarded. Really, old Sitting Bull is the sage, or Big Medicine, while Gaul is one of the Field Marshals. The former is numbered with the old men, while the latter is numbered with the young. These bloody leaders are not on very friendly terms. The one very much dis likes to hear the other mentioned as a big chief, or as the victor in the celebrated massacre above named. No doubt Gaul is physically superior to his old rival. He is large of frame, weighs about 250 pounds, and is as fat as a corn-fed steer. He has been to New Orleans lately, being shown there as a part of the Dakota ex hibit. We have no doubt but Gaul would draw like a house on fire at New Orleans, but it is an open question whether or not he makes a very good im migration agent. His efforts the past in that direction have not produced the most flattering results. But Gaul was in trouble while in New Orleans. He found more to eat than he could dispose of, and it made him very unhappy. It was the chief anxiety of his mind. He thought of his people back here on the reservation on short Government rations and too lazy to work for more, and the situation was agonizing. His daily prayer was that when he and his people die they might go to New Orleans. Old Sitting Bull is now at peace with the pale face. His age forbids a contin uation of the pleasures surrounding the war-path, and there is evidently a taming down of the joy he has had to see the white man fall. Both Sitting Bull and Gaul are proud of their greatness and of their victory over Custer and his little band of Spartans, and frequently men tion the fact that the iron-talkers (tele graph) tell all about them, and that the iron-talkers speak only of great chiefs. Their vanity as boundless, their thoughts as childish, and their personal mannners as offensive as their warfare is brutal. The civilized quality of manli ness does not enter into their being. The people here have a mania for Indian relics. In the parlors, halls, and sitting rooms the eye of the visitor catches the familiaT beaded moccasin, the ted-stone pipe with its long, reed-like stem trimmed with tassels ana cords, In dian potterv, knives, sheaths, feathered arrows and beaded quivers. Infantile canoes trimmed with beads, porcupine quills and metallic buttons, are also among the objects of interest. Fort Lincoln is but five miles away, just across the river, and cau be seen from the hills near the city. The Fort is a place of interest here in both winter and summer. In winter time it affords a very fine sleigh ride upon the river, and be comes quite a resort for socials, parties, etc. The officers and their wives form an important factor of the society of the Capitol City. There are no society doings, which are complete without a rep resentative from the Fort, and, the offi cers in full dres9, with swords dangling about their feet and clattering among the furniture, with sometimes an accidental tear through some lady's silk dress, lends a royal air to the proceedings which nothing else can do. Bismarck is, in deed, fortunate in the near proximity of Fort Lincoln for the Fort is to Bismarck just what Governor's Island is to New York City—though we beg pardon of the city of Bismarck for the ridiculous com parison! Electricity is a subject of much inter est in this polar region. At the Capital building, by walking a few steps over tha carpets, a person becomes so charged as to make it somewhat funny, if not annoy ing, at times, to shake hands with a friend, or to touch or handle the furniture. As you extend your hand for the shake, just before the contact you are struck by lightning—an electric spark that carries with it a shock that is by no means trifling. Indeed, some of the members of the Leg islature have wholly ceased to put their hands upon the steam-pipes which are used i%heating the hall, as the shock re ceived is so great at times as to be ex tremely unpleasant. If a member take a few steps upon the carpet, and coming up behind an unsuspecting brother, points his finger at the top of his bald head or to his ear. the funny part is at once ap parent and Uiis little trick has been so often practiced that members now are mostly on their guard, and they always view with suspicion any attempt to pass behind them. A notable feature of this phenomenon is that all persons are not affected alike. Some are susceptible of but a very light charge, while others are so powerfully affected as to be feared in shaking hands and this electric charge is by no means in proportion to the physical strength of the individual, some of the stronger and stouter physiques being the weaker In electrical power. This electric effect is also greater as we approach nearer to the earth but it is sufficiently strong upon the fourth floor to afford no little amusement. The Legislature went off again last Friday on a junketing tour, this time to Fargo. During its absence, on Saturday, the third house met and transacted some business, introducing several ridiculous bills, among which was one proposing to amend the Lord's prayer. Your corre spondent .did not learn the nature of the amendments proposed, but is of the opin ion that the average member of the third house has little use for the Lord's prayer in in its present form. FBDBB.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D. · 4 March 1885
  • Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 5 March 1885

The Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

At a veterans' camp-fire gathering, Arctic explorer Lieutenant Schwatka recounted his limited combat experience against the same Sioux band under Crazy Horse and Sitting Bull that later surrounded and killed Custer's command. The rest of the piece describes entertainment, speeches, and a meal shared by the assembled veterans.

The Rock Island Argus · 5 March 1885 · page 4

JOLLY VETS.

Horse, Sitting Bull and others. It was the same band which shortly afterward surrounded and massacred Gen. Custer's command. They fought all day aud got

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

The piece sarcastically mocks the public fascination with Sitting Bull, who is earning money selling autographs in New York while being treated with celebrity-like deference. The author bitterly notes the irony of Americans fawning over a man associated with the killing of U.S. soldiers, suggesting he could have profited even more by selling scalps of his victims.

Morris Tribune · 11 March 1885 · page 6

States army, is entitled to the prece dence in bringing homage to the Sioux chief. Out on the plains, he ran after the United States soldiers, and now that it is safe to do so, thev should run after him. Sitting Bull and his Indians have ruurdered, tortured and robbed many white men, women, and children, who were in no why connected with the army, still tho fact that ho and his tribe killed aud scalped several hun dred United States oliiocrs and soldiers in a body, clearly make it incumbent on the army to take the ieud in the proces sion. Sitting Bull is undoubtedly a success,

See the clipping

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.

A Dakota Territory newspaper discusses the political push for statehood, then profiles Gall and Sitting Bull, both now touring and appearing in public, including Gall's trip to a New Orleans exhibition. It credits Sitting Bull with the 'Custer massacre' while calling Gall its actual field commander, noting rivalry between the two over who deserves the glory.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Hand County Press · 12 March 1885 · page 2

OUR BISMARCK BUDGET. The Session Draw ing to a Hose—Sitting Bull and Chief Gaul—Fort Lin* coin—Capital Gossip. | FYvim Our Special Oorrespi indent. I Bismakck, Feb. ’id, 1885. The Capital City of Dakota will soon be relegated to its wonted quietness, and the poker tables and other institutions of their class will be closed, or move to more congenial climes. Over forty days ot the present session have passed, and the re mainder of the session will soon take w ing; yet there have been no such riis \ graceful scenes enacted as are sometimes witnessed uwav back in some of the so called •’civilized” States.

See moreSee less

Even Senator Vest could not find cause for complaint against the I)ak< t i Legislature, unlos it i be for the supreme contempt which the ! members entertain for him personally for the unmitigated ignorance which he man j ifests of the rapid progress and wonder ful development of this bright star, which | is now rising above the Northwestern j horizon. Democrats and Republicans i alike demand a division of the Territory and the admission of the southern half as | a State. The demands and entreaties of half a million free people may be ignored, their rights denied, and their intelligence and honor ridiculed for a time; but a day will come in tbe near future when Dakota will stand in the United States Congress as strong as her strongest traducers. You may tin n look out for a reckon ug. Her I people have adopted ‘’Patience and Per i severance” for their motto, and liavecon \ eluded to hammer away at the common : object till they arrive at success, knowing no such word as fail. Bismarck is iu the near neighborhood | of the Indian country, ns is evidenced by i the frequent uj pearanee of some of the i ml race upon her streets. Old Gaul, the chief who, it is said, planned and con ducted the celebrated Cu-«ter battle, has been showing himself in the opera houses of Bismarck. So, too, has the aged Sit ting Bull, to whom the credit (?) of the Custer massacre has tie u universally awarded. Really, old Hitting Bull is the sage, or Big Medicine, vvh la Gaul is one of the Field Marshals. The former i* I numbered with the old men, while the latter is numbered with the young. I These bloody leaders are not on very ; friendly terms. The one very muc h disj likes to hear the other mentioned as a big i chief, or as the victor iu the celebrated massacre above named. No doubt Gaul : is physically superior to bis old rival. He is large of frame, weighs about 230

See the clipping

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.

A Bismarck-area report describes Gall's trip to New Orleans as part of a Dakota exhibit and his longing for abundant food, contrasting it with reservation rations. It also notes Sitting Bull's advancing age and both chiefs' pride in their victory over Custer, framed with condescending commentary about their character.

Hand County Press · 12 March 1885 · page 2

I the pule face. His age forbids a contin uation of the pleasures surrounding the war-path, aud there is evidently u taming down of the joy he lias had to see the white man fall. Both Sitting Bull and Gaul are proud of their greatness and of their victory over Custer and his little

See the clipping

The Cecil Whig · Elkton, Md.

In a newspaper interview, General Kilpatrick recounts Custer's personality, describing him as brilliant but overeager for personal glory. He claims Custer broke an agreement with Reno to rendezvous after four days, instead rushing ahead and being overwhelmed by the enemy at Little Bighorn.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

The Cecil Whig · 14 March 1885 · page 4

Gettr' ** Bade n,e > an( l told me . ,-4c would have hard figh'itig on the where he intended that I should be. .'Tie said: ‘This is the oppoitunity of your life !’ I told him that I was willin;.- to do anything he required, but that I should prefer to take my own brigade and do my own lighting—and that with 12,000 men I should have no generals. Some one—Pleasanton,! believe—said to Meade ‘You can make him some generals.’ Meade responded that he had no such power. Pleasanton responded, ‘Yes, but yon can reach those who have.’ The names of three captains, acting colonels or colonels were written down—-Custer was one, Merrett another, and Fanis worth a third.

See moreSee less

A despatch of suggestion was sent to Secretary Stanton, and in twenty minutes there came back the an swer, ‘They are made. They can be un made as easy !’ The three were sent for, and, w hen told of their sudden elevation, a’l three were strongly moved with emo tion. On the day following, when over on the left, at my designated post of duty I found Custer was not there and so sig naled to Meade. I soon learned that he was over on the extreme right, where lie perhaps thought l e could do some bi il liant work by himself and earn glory— and if he had not succeeded in doing it lie would have got into trouble. I tell you, now, that if Custer had stayed with me 1.3 would have licked out of the enemy. There never was such a splen did lot of cavalry got together as we would have had that day. “It was this same haste to win laurels on his own account,” continued Kilpat rick, “that at last cost Custer his life Said Reno to him on that fatal march on i the Indians, ‘How long will it take you to get there ?’ ‘Four days.’ Reno agreed to meet him at a designated point at the end of that time. Custer drove ahead day and night and in half the time nam ed reached the enemy and engaged him , in tight. lie went in all worn out and was cut to pieces. But he was a brave officer, and had his balance and judgment equaled his courage he would have made a great soldier. In fact, we were all too young, and had I worn in those days this bald head I would have been a better man in the Held by far than I was then.” He went in a second lieutenant and came out a major general. Of General Sherman he said: “He is a brave and gentle man, and will bear a great deal before complaining. He speaks well of men when it is in his power to do so.”

See the clipping

The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D.

This Washington Post dispatch praises Lieutenant Garlington's leadership during an Arctic expedition retreat, comparing him favorably to Lieutenant Greely. In passing, it notes that Garlington graduated from West Point at the time of the Custer massacre and joined the Seventh Cavalry during the Indian conflicts that followed.

The Hope Pioneer · 20 March 1885 · page 2

600 miles in open boats, and the conse quent saving of the lives of all his men, was pluckier and showed more jiul g ment than anything done by the last expedition. He was practically in the same situation and was further north when his ship was lost than Greely was at Cape Sabine. Greely, too, had boats, as Garlington had, but the lat ter took to them, made his journey, and saved his men, while Greely knocked his boats to pieces for fuel and lost most a brave man and desired success.

See moreSee less

He was 8er. graduated at West Point at the time of the Custer massacre and assigned to the seventh cavarly. Instead of taking'liis vacation to which he was entitled lie made haste to join his regiment at a time when it was expected that it would bo still further depleted by Indian con flicts. He is no carpet soldier but lias a laudable ambitiom to win famMkwhat ever dangers may be in his w»at ,iuot A

See the clipping