As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

October 1880

7 articles

The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis.

This 1880 tribute recounts Custer's rapid Civil War promotion and skill as an Indian fighter, portraying him as a virtuous, disciplined officer. It argues that his defeat at Little Bighorn resulted not from his own error but from Benteen's failure to bring reinforcements as ordered, comparing the situation to Wellington's near-defeat at Waterloo.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 29 days earlier.

The Kenosha Telegraph · 8 October 1880 · page 3

GENERAL GEORGE A CUSTER. The soldier of the nineteenth cen tury differs from the soldier of other centuries only in the degree of his military training. The same war-like spirit enters into the constitution of the soldier of every age and every land. What the military academy is to the United States regular, endur ance is to the Indian warrior, and the school of chivalry was to the ancient knight. But different motives prompt the people of different nations to the culture of the art of war. The knight trained himself that he might be more valiant in the 'defence of his lady.

See moreSee less

The red-skin subjects himself to the most severe torture and exposure that he may be Defter able to avenge the wrongs of his forefathers. But the soldier of our land receives military training that he may with greater skill defend his government against all foreign and domestic foes. Although the age of chivalry has passed, the knightly spirit has been granted as a special gift to certain men of modern times. Chief among our nation’s knights is General George A. Custer. Born in seclusion, reared a farmer boy with muscles trained to hold the plough or “wrestle with mad men, ” he grew to be a strong and har dy youth. From his childhood his highest aspirations were to be a soldier. By fortune and his own exertions he obtained an appointment as a cadet at West Point. Four yeaia of military drill made of him a lieutenant with the beauty of Diogenes and the phy sique of an Apollo Belvulere. His military education was completed and he stepped forth to serve the nation at a time when there was need of such as he. Lincoln had just “ stepped his foot upon the earth,” and thousands of men fresh from their shops and farms stood ready to be led to meet the foe, Haying the choice of quiet duty for a while or being sent at once into active service, his restless and energetic spirit chose the latter. He was soon given the command of a corps of cavalry, when he displayed the heroism of a Murat. His influence over his men was wonderful. Not spurring them on to the charge by the use as angry words, as many generals do, but rid ing at the head of his ranks, his long golden curls flying from under his broad-brimmed hat, he would put spurs to his horse and waving his bright Toledo blade above his head, would shout, “ Comelon, boys!” and the whole line of charging cavalry would rush to certain victory. No officer through all that desperate struggle of four years made a more glowing record than he. Never be fore was known such swift promotion. At the close of the war, at the age of twenty-six, Custer stood a major-gen eral complete. His subsequent expe rience on the plains was no less fortu nate, for he became the most success ful Indian-fighter of his time. Being quick to learn, he took every means of becoming skilled in the art of Indian warfare. While planning a night at tack on some Indian village he would go far in advance of his men with his most wary scouts that he might see the state of things with his own eyes, and thus know better how to order an attack. Not one of his campaigns re sulted in disaster until unwillingly de prived of his command, he was com pelled to do the bidding of another. Nor would he then have fallen had his commands been properly executed. Like Wellington at Waterloo, had the Prussian reinforcements been delayed but half an hour longer, the British must have been defeated, and that which gave Wellington his fame would have resulted in disaster. Thus, if Benteen, according to command, had hastened with his reinforcements to the scene of conflict, the Indians might have been defeated and Custer and his party saved, and that which men now call his disgraceful defeat have proved the crowning victory of his life. Custer fell ! But not until his man ly worth had won for him imperish able honor. Pure as a virgin, frank and open-hearted as a child, opposed to the use of tobacco, liquors, and pro fane language, free from political cor ruption, cool and courageous in the midst of the fiercest battle, he has left to us the model of a Christian warrior, E. M. Stannabd. __ A Much Needed Reform. First the newspapers and now the Clergy are calling attention to and uttering their disapproval of the costly and elaborate floral decorations at funerals. In one instance (that of A. T. Stewart) a bill for $20,000 for flowers alone was presented, and in another, that of an ordinary tradesman, for SSOO, when his entire estate did not foot up over $5,0001 The latter was wisely and justly refused payment by the surrogate, who * held that it was unnecessary, out of place and illegal.» The former,, wo presume,* was paid,T a£ the estate was immense, the amount as a trifle to the sum total, and there was no one to object. Twenty thousand dollars for .“floral decoration”, at a funeral! Hew much better it would ihave .been to [have donated the sum' to the suffering' poor of the great city in which he died? And another thing, of what.benefit was this ostentatious display to either the dead or the living? The cold clay in the coffin knew nothing of. tea roses, and camelias, and pansies, and tube-roses; cared nothing for them when absorbed in business; had no i sympathy with them or their culture; no love /or their beauty or exquisite perfume. st!— * But that is not the point.» When a millionaire dies his heirs have the right, we presume, to_ do what they pleas® with the money—to bury him in jasa* mine and sprays of smilax if it suits their fancy, but the example is pernicious and leads others to indulge in foolish rivalry, when those left behind can little afford the cost, and must suffer from the Flowers are beautiful at all times, arc touching tributes to those “who have gone out with the tide.” A. handful of violets upon the coffin of a sinless babe, a little sheaf of ripened wheat upon that of the aged, tell the entire story, and speak to every heart; and thahisenough. The loading down with wreathes and crosses, and anchors and broken columns, are simply gross vanity, vulgar show, and ambitious pomp to excel others. In ninety-nine cases out of every hundred love does not prompt the expenditure, and the very abundance makes a mock ery of death. The dead should be respected and remembered; that is a holy duty; but it, is not by flowers that soon will wither it Bhould be done. A more lasting memorial is to be found in the heart, and reckless extravagance simply to create wonder and envy is next to insult. —r The matter has grown into formidable proportions, to a ruinous cost, and it is higU time there should be some check. Funerals, especially in cities, as now managed, are more for the living thaH the dead, and sorrow is swallowed up in miserable and selfish display. Even if the expense was not (in the majority of instances) little, if any, better than lobbing those who remain behind, yet a profusion of flowers reveal want of taste, and the effort to “keep up” with others should be condemned. We have outgrown the stem simplicity of the funerals of our fathers. Then there was nothing to mar the carrying away of the dead; nothing to detract the mind from the lessons taught. Now all is flowers and silvered caskets, and plumed hearses, and a seeking after notoriety that is fetal to tears. Truly such things are but the “trappings and the pomp of woe,” and it will be well for us when they are abolished, and we agflin give to the dead their due respect, and not waste their substance in riotous display and momentary charm, to the deafening of the ear and the debasement of the heart, ? *

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

This item covers unrelated frontier army news: Gen. Morrow being sent to Europe to recuperate, new quarters built for the 6th Infantry, and a humorous anecdote about railroad dining stops. It references the 'Custer massacre' only briefly as a historical marker for when Gen. Miles volunteered his regiment for Montana service.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 12 October 1880 · page 4

“widows'* and children ure being kind ly cared for by Geu. Pope, at Fort I>*av euworth, who with characteristic kind ness always provides for the families of officers in tlie field.—his generous treat ment being still remembered towards the families of the sth i man try in 1875, when Gen. Miles volunteered with his regiment for service in Montana imme diately after the Custer massacre. -o TH»: IXXIOI M riNSKSURR.

See the clipping

Press and Daily Dakotaian · Yankton, S.D.

A gold watch belonging to Lieutenant Crittenden, killed at the Little Big Horn in 1876, was later sold by a Sioux warrior to a half-breed in Canada, who sold it to a Winnipeg resident. That buyer traced the engraved maker's details and contacted the army to confirm the watch's connection to the fallen officer.

Press and Daily Dakotaian · 19 October 1880 · page 2

How Lieutenant Crittenden's Watch waa Restored to His Friends. A special dispatch from Washington A most interesting and curious in Bays: cident has just occurred in connection with the terrible story of the massacre of Custer's command on the Little Big Horn on the 25th of June, 1876. Among

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

A correspondent visiting the Milk Creek massacre site reports that the government plans to erect a monument there similar to the one commemorating the Custer massacre, though no action has yet been taken. The piece also covers Ute removal negotiations and construction of a new military cantonment nearby.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 October 1880 · page 12

being from Ohio, and a .relative of wash MoLean, of (ho Cincinnati Enquirer. On tho anniversary of • TUB TIIOUNllUlimt MASHACRB, nt Milk Crook, Sent. 20,, your correspondent rode over to that historic place, about twenty live miles distant trout this etttnn. Bavo tho almost obliterated lines of rlllo-plts and tho landmarks of Nature,-tho steep batiks of tbo crock, and tho hills beneath tho rocky cliffs, where (ho Indians built their rooky breastworks, —nothing exists to mark tho seono of Indian treachery and massacre! oven the spot where fell the bravo commander Is unmarked by mon ument of any kind,—unnoticed and unknown to tho passer-by.

See moreSee less

Tho Government, tho olllcers In formed me, intends to erect upon the battleHeld a monument similar to that which com memorates tho seono of tho Custer massacre; but Jims far no slops have been taken towards such a desirable end. This road Is now but little traveled, both the mall and tho passenger stages and tho Government trains taking tho now military road, lying to Iho west, surveyed and opened last fair by Mont. Met'mihiy with n party of civil engineers. Resides being shorter and a natural route, tho “cut-off " Is free from tho steep grades and frequent cations said tuaboutm along tho old route passing tho battlellold. TUB CONBTUWHTON OF THIS CANTONMENT

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

General Terry orders Colonel Miles to delay troop movements near Fort Keogh so as not to intimidate Sitting Bull, who is reportedly moving toward surrender. Major Walsh, in Canada, disputes claims he detained Sitting Bull, saying the chief persuaded his own followers to surrender last year.

The Sun · 23 October 1880 · page 1

SITTING BULL OVER THE LINE

SITTING HULL OVKR 2UE 11 DEn Movement orrruopa Delayed Under a lie llef Itt lie snilt Vion piurreniler WASHINGTON Oct 22Gomi Alfred Terry commanding limo Department of Dakota has telegraphed to CpI Miles at Tort Keogh Mon tana to delay all movements from Hooch or Custer until further orders AdjutantGeneral Drum Is of opinion that this order was Issued to prevent intimidating Sitting Bull Col

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

A gold watch taken from an American officer killed in the Custer massacre was traced through its maker in Liverpool to Lt. John J. Crittenden, son of Gen. Thomas L. Crittenden. The watch had been found in a Sioux trader's possession near Portage la Prairie, Manitoba, and is being restored to the family.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Chicago Daily Tribune · 28 October 1880 · page 10

RECOVERY OF A FAMILY RELIC. A valuable relic bas been discovered In Mani toba. Col. James W. Taylor, United Blntes Con sul, gives the fuels to the J/nnHoLa I'icc Vres* ns follows;* Bomo time in July last, Mr. H. W. Gtgot, of Portage la Prairie, found la tho bauds cf an Indian trader u gold buntlng-enso wnteb, which tba Bloux Imlluu from whom It was ob tained said be had taken from tho body of on American olllcor whom ho had killed. After correspondence with the maker in Liverpool. It was found that bo Lad sold tho wuieb—No.

See moreSee less

. I*»,7W—ln IHAO to a Mr. UriiU'iuloii, now (lon. T. I^CrUiendeu,of the United Butt-sunny. Uun. Crittenden had given tbo watch to bis son, tho JstoLlouU John J. Crittenden, who was killed at the Custer massacre. Hu was tbo General's ©nly sen. and tbo restoration of this valuable relfo will bo a source of great satisfaction to Ms father, and to his friends generally. Noether Whisker Dvo equals Hill's—4o cents

See the clipping

The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich.

A letter to the Adjutant General describes a gold watch purchased in Canada from a half-breed, who said he got it from a Sioux warrior claiming to have killed its owner at the Little Big Horn. The watch's engraved maker's details suggest it belonged to Lieut. Crittenden, son of Gen. Crittenden, who died in Custer's command.

The True Northerner · 29 October 1880 · page 3

RELIC OF THE CUSTER MASSACRE.

A short time ago tho Adjutant General of tho army received a letter from a resi dent in tho Winnipeg countrv in Canada asking whether any olliccr bearing tho name of Crittenden had taken mrt in tho luckless expedition of Custer. The writer gave ns his reason for making tho in quiry that ho had purchased somo timo ago from a half-breed a gold wateli which the half-breed told him ho had obtained from ono of tho Sioux warriors who sought refuge in Canada after tho mas sacre of tho Little Big Horn.

See moreSee less

The watch here no owner's name. The works had been trilled and tampered with after tho manner of the savages by the Sioux from whom it was procured, and who assured tho half-breed that ho had slain tho w hite brave to whom it belonged in the battle with Custer's men. The writer of tho

See the clipping