INEVITABLE HAD RENO BFEN THERE~NEGLECTED AND SHALLOW GRAVES, To the Editor of The Tridune, Sir: I have been spending portions of two days lately in looking over the Custer battlefield. There is no sweeter valley that the sun shines on than this of the Little Big Horn River. Iapprodched ft across tho country from the Rosebud River in pearly the same direction as that slong which General Custer led bis men on the last march of his life to this fatal place. The Jour ney for a large portion of the way is extremely dificult.
See moreSee less
One passes over miles and miles of bad lands. There are great stretches of dreary emptiness, unrelieved by trees, with never any flowers. ‘The only vegetation are the sorawny sage-hush and faint spears of straggling grass. But at last the traveller reaches the soft and verdant Valley of the Little Big Horn. Luxuriant cottonwood trees stand in thick ranks along the river banks. Draperies of the densest and the finest grasses hang apon the shoulders of the hills and sweep downward until their folds are lost amid the shadows of the trees, In the blue distance tower the ranges of the Big Horn Mountains. Here, spotting this valley with its lodges, and from these hills upon which we are just now standing, General Custer, on the 25th of June, 1876, caught sight of the great Indian village be had been searching for. It was a confederated village, made up of the discontented Indians of various tribes, gathered under the controlling mind of Sitting Bull. General Custer had with him nearly 500 men and friendly Indian scouts, a sufficient force to have captured the village bad his commands been thoroughly obeyed. Tt has been frequently sald that the General disobeyed his orders, But it is capable of perfect proof that his orders were given sabjeet to is own diseretion, and that he in no wise disobeyed, since he thought a victory certain with the forces at his own dizposal. General Custer has been blamed, too, for dividing his command, for not throwing his whole force with one blow at fome single point of the village. It is true that General Custer did divide his command. He left a portion of it under the leadership of Major Reno. This oMicer was to descend the hill, fora the river, and under the shelter of the timber, at one end of the Indian village, begin the attack, Meanwhile, General Custer, passing nlong the erest of the Wills, was to make a descent in another place, seek another ford, and 80 come upon the Indians in their rear and flank. For such disposition of his forces the dead hero has been greatly blamed. But it {a to be said, in answer, that with Just such tactics as these he had been successful before, in many Indian fights, and when there had been as great disparity between his own forees and those of the enemy. From a careful review of the whole ground T do not think one ean resist the conclusion tha the wassacre occurred simply because the commands of General Custer were bo not obeyed. Major Reno did begin the fleht in the tim. ber at oue end of tue village, but for some strange rea- «on Le did not stay there. There was a little firine. The gathered Indians displayed themselves on the low hiils, and then thus portion of tbe command upon which General Custer depenved beat a retreat. They fell back ont of the timber, retreated along an oven space, reforded the river, cltiubed a difficult bill, there entrenched themselves, and waited. One can find graves along the line of the retreat, but lew, comparatively, however, in the timber, There was Little fizhting tuere, Here on this hillside and hill-iop teis portion of the commana stood still Then the Ludians left them, and with their whole force turning their atienton upon Coster, who was coming down upon the village from the guareer lie bad chosen, they drove him back frow the river he was about to | Then the massacre began. One can see the lines of graves where toe brave men fell, as, contesting inch by fuch and position alter positi n, they sunk in their paces, while the survivors fell slowly back, Out of about 260 men, forty only had survive d when they made an attempt go escape turough a ravine. Before thoy bal traversed two-thirds of the short distance they were every one of them cut down. Meant me, upon the other hill, not more than four miles trom the place where this flzLting was going on, what were those other men doing upon that bill's crest? There were no Indians before them. They must have known tha. the entire strength of the enemy was turned agaiust Custer, and what are they doing? Just there is tow mystery that remain: to this day unexplamed, They are doing nothing, They are simply waiting; that is all. And they are in stronger force than when they first gained that hill. And had they attacked the saves, ns far as one can sec, Cnster and many of lis noble men might have been saved. I beard a Cheyenne Indian, who leat is hand to the work of massacre, sav, there on the spot, that if this force on the uill-top had struck then In their rear, tuey could not have waited to complete their bloody work. They woitld have been between two flcos. And this 18 the question which haunts one tke s nightmare, as he rides over this rearful field, Why did Major Reuo and bis command, even if they were urable successfully to carry through the ordered nitack upos the Indian village there among the timber fu the valley, artes tuoy had reacted the hill in coer res treat, wait upon the summic and let Custer and Lis mea Ko down to such a dear? Tne battlefield now is in a most shamefu! plight. At least men who gave their lives away 80 bra ely ought to Lave decent burial, Certainly some memorial of tins sad herole fight ought to stand there pointing out the place. But if anoilier year goes round in the same careless way, the storms aud rains will complete thelr work of devastation snd obliteration. Over the voor dead wien a few spades of caro have been heaped up, but a few only—you can in mnititades of instances see the bones protruding. This battiedsla ought not to remain 10 iis present dlsgraceiul condition fou another month, Tae dust of pa'r ots 18 sacred. FH. Comp at the Mamoneti Hot Springs, Yellowstone Park, Sept. 16, 1878, rm tpn