As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

October 1806

7 articles

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

An informant reports that Colonel Burr is recruiting well-dressed young gentlemen to meet him at Pittsburg for an undisclosed scheme, paying generously and promising compensation if recruits withdraw. The writer speculates whether Burr's true object is seizing the Yazoo lands or plotting a dismemberment of the union, urging government vigilance.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 3 October 1806 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

IMPORTANT COMMUNICATION!

acquainted induce us to concur in the latter opinion? Is it not known that col. Burr has been travelling through every part of that country? What is his object there? Are his own pecuniary circumstances equal to the expense of this, if the object be merely

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The Farmer's Monitor reports suspicions that Col. Burr is conspiring to separate the western states from the Union and unite them with Louisiana into a new empire under his leadership, possibly as a viceroyalty of Bonaparte. It also notes the suspicious secret departure of Comfort Tyler, a former county clerk, as circumstantial evidence of the plot.

The Enquirer · 7 October 1806 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

From the New-York Commercial Advertiser.

The following article was originally published in the Farmer's Monitor, at Herkimer, in the county of Herkimer. The information contained in it, if correct, is certainly deeply interesting to our country. It should at least rouse the vigilance of government.

See moreSee less

Whether Col. Burr, as is conjected in this article, has enlisted partisans for the accomplishment of his projects, in the northern part of this state, we know not. But, that he has formed, and that he is now employed in executing, a scheme, highly injurious to the interest, the tranquility, and the welfare of the U. S. we have the strongest ground to believe.

Col. Burr may flatter himself that his plots are covered with an impenetrable shield--he may

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

A report describes Aaron Burr traveling in superb style with young recruits gathered at Pittsburgh, his debts mysteriously paid, and his stated claim that his secret enterprise is not against the government. The writer speculates it may involve the Yazoo lands or, more likely, a plot to dismember the union with Burr at its head.

The Enquirer · 7 October 1806 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

gain.

The informant further added, that it was conjectured in Onondago, that the object was either to get possession of the Yazoo lands, or an extensively preconcerted plan to effect a dismemberment of the union, with col. Burr at the head of the combination.

See moreSee less

Does not every circumstance with which we are acquainted induce us to concur in the latter opinion? Is it not known that col. Burr has been travelling through every part of that coun

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The article discusses Governor Claiborne's political troubles in Orleans territory, implicating Edward Livingston as a malign influence, before pivoting to reprint extracts about Aaron Burr's mysterious visit to Frankfort, Kentucky. It describes Burr's secretive meetings with Senator John Brown and speculates ominously about his fall from potential greatness into suspected conspiracy.

The Enquirer · 7 October 1806 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the interesting extract in this days paper from the Herkimer Monitor of New-York. Whether the designs there attributed to Mr. Burr, are correctly drawn, are yet obscure as his own unfathomable spirit;—but our mind naturally pauses to muse upon the destiny of such a man. What might he not have been? Within three years the president of the Union; in case of a Spanish war, the commander of our armies. Yet what is he now? Scathed by the lightning of republican indignation; his very steps dogged; and suspicion hunting him, wherever he roves:

See the clipping

The Enquirer · Richmond, Va.

The item describes Col. Burr's recent visit to Frankfort, where he reportedly met secretly with associates including Mr. Brown to plan operations of the 'Western Association' before departing for Lexington. It also notes a young Swartwout's suspicious passage through town and references the Spanish Conspiracy article as a clue to Burr's true purposes, promising fuller details in future issues.

The Enquirer · 7 October 1806 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

tion. At five o'clock in the afternoon of Wednesday he departed for Lexington : but we understand is to return in a few days. About a fortnight ago, one of his political pioneers, a younger brother of Mr. Swartwout, the dismissed marshal of New-York, passed through Frankfort. This youth as is the common practice of the various tools of col. Burr, displayed the greatest indifference as to the object of his visit to Kentucky. He appeared to have no introduction to any of the citizens of the town, and although he was doubtless well acquainted with Mr.

See moreSee less

Brown, yet it was good policy to appear a stranger in this place. "Various have been the conjectures of Col. Burr's visit to Kentucky, last year and likewise his return this season. The article of the Spanish Conspiracy, inserted in the Western World this day, may furnish the curious with a key to unravel the views of his mysterious journey. In some of our subsequent numbers about two months hence the complete detail will be laid before the public."

See the clipping

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

A letter reprinted from the Aurora discusses tensions with Spanish forces near New Orleans and reports that the Kentucky paper Western World has accused Judge Prevost, Edward Livingston, General Wilkinson, Aaron Burr, and others of a new conspiracy to separate the western states from the Union. The writer notes suspicions about Wilkinson's past conduct and urges the matter be fully investigated.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 15 October 1806 · page 2

Wilkinson, Mr. Burr, Mr. J, Brown, of Kentucky ; are charged as concerned, in a new conspiracy against the peace of the whole union, and a separation of this section from the eastern parts of the union.— Many people here are well acquainted with the old conspiracy ot a similar Lind concerted with the Spa niards and with the leading characters concerned in it, and many wonder how Wilkinson came to be ap pointed to the chief command of our force. One of general Wayne's old captains informed me that the story of Newmans conduct was stronger against Wilkinson than any thing yet published.

See moreSee less

This he speaks ol his own knowledge, and says the deposi tions were sent on to our government. I am soi ry to find that even general S. Smith is attempted to be implicated in a late paper on this subject. This subject since it has been stirred ought to be search ed to the bottom, whether as an act of justice to the country or to the individuals. If any niischiel was meditated it is now certainly checked, for all parties will be cautious.”—Aurora. • Son-in-law of Mr. Burr. '

See the clipping

Lynchburg Star · Lynchburg, Va.

This editorial laments Burr's fall from revolutionary war hero and political champion to a 'wandering intriguer' organizing associations that threaten to overturn the happiness and independence of western America. It references his alliance with Wilkinson and Brown, and notes an incident where a young Burr associate attempted to assassinate Joseph M. Street despite having praised Burr in print the previous year.

Lynchburg Star · 30 October 1806 · page 2

COLONEL AARON BURR,

Col. Burr even’ in his present wandering capacity, still retains his usual address and dignity of deportment, and has as former ly certain young men who volun teer themselves to perform the more menial offices of the drama which he is acting ; nor. are news paper puffers wanting to extoll his merits, weep over his: misfor tunes, and draw a veil across his passions for amorous delight. It is also a singular enough circum stance that the same .young man who lately attempted the assassi nation of Joseph Mi Street, by firing a pistol at his breast; should last year when colonel Burr was in h rank fort have written in the '!

See moreSee less

Palladium a highly finished pene gyvick on his character. , But notwithstanding the degra ding character that colonel Burr*1 future proceedings ofthe western association. At five o’clock in the afternoon, of Wednesday he departed for Lexington; but we understand is to return in a few days. About a fortnight ago, one' of his political pioneers, a younger brother of Mr. Swart wout, the dismissed marshal of New York, passed through Frankfort.' This youth, as is the common practice of the various tools of co'lonel Burr, displayed the greatest indifference as to the object of his visit to Kentucky. He appeared to' hav^Q .intro duction to any of the pf the town, and • although. he was doubtless well acquainted with Mr. Brown, yet it was good po licy to appear a stanger in this place. 1 . Various have been the conjec tures of col. Burr’s visit to Ken tucky last year, and likewise his return this season, The article of the Spanish conspiracy, insert ed in the Western World this day, may furnish the curious with a key-to unravel the views of his mysterious journey. In some of our subsequent numbers about two months , hence the complete detail will be laid before the pub lic. At present we shall take the liberty of offering a few remarks on the character of this excentric and dangerous politician ; whom one ofthe present senators in cop-' gress from Kentucky in a letter addressed . to general Wilkinson ■ last October,, was pleased to style, “ the great, good, and virtuous but persecuted Burr" One of the most melancholy ideas to the reflecting mind, is to behold, great abilities blended with corruptness of principle, and prostrated to purposes-of ambiti on, weakly and power.' If ever a man was formed to display a por trait of this description, he is Aaron Burr. Gifted by nature with a heart of steel, the most engaging adress,. and fascinating .eloquence, he was well fitted to perform on the stage of politics, that part of which he acted for; several years,; viz;; “ the intrepid champion of freedom,” but re linquishing this path of virtue’and . patriotism, at a moment when the interest of his • country required the full force of all his genius and talent, we now see him in the ca . pacity of a wandering-intriguer, exerting the same powers, the same enchanting manners, and irresistable arguments in the fla gitious endeavors of organising ^assaeiatidng^s .which if not broken, will finally overturn the happiness and independence of Western A merica. , > • Thevirtuous patriot who is solely guicied by the purity of "principle, and knows not . the trade of venal policy, can scarce ly credit that the same Burr, who, as a volunteer traversed the snows of Canada along with the brave Montgomery—who fought by the. side of Washington in New Jersey and Monmouth ; and afterwards for years combat ed the whole Hamiltonian pha lanx of monarchy, should now be. a solitary traveller through the wilds of Kentucky, the Indiana, and Louisiana territories, to pro mote the despicable arts of a Wil kinson and a Brown. Such a dereliction of principle, although it furnishes an ample field of con templation for those who Can take pleasure in viewing the dreadful frailty, of man, appeares visoriary and paradoxical to the mind of truth 'and integrity.'. Col. Burr even’ in his present wandering capacity, still retains his usual address and dignity of deportment, and has as former ly certain young men who volun teer themselves to perform the more menial offices of the drama which he is acting ; nor. are news paper puffers wanting to extoll his merits, weep over his: misfor tunes, and draw a veil across his passions for amorous delight. It is also a singular enough circum stance that the same .young man who lately attempted the assassi nation of Joseph Mi Street, by firing a pistol at his breast; should last year when colonel Burr was in h rank fort have written in the '! Palladium a highly finished pene gyvick on his character. , But notwithstanding the degra ding character that colonel Burr*1

See the clipping