As the Papers Told It

The Burr-Hamilton Duel · The full archive

February 1805

2 articles

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · Norfolk, Va.

This piece argues that Vice President Burr improperly interrupted Judge Chase's motion for a continuance during the Senate impeachment proceedings, citing legal precedent on when affidavits are required for such motions. It contends that despite strict rules of procedure, the accused should be heard patiently even when proceeding erroneously, given the gravity of impeachment charges.

Norfolk Gazette and Publick Ledger · 8 February 1805 · page 2

The interruption therefore v hich judge C hase expe rienced from col. Burr, was not warranted by the usages of any court of judicature ; and whatever might have been the nlthnnte judgment oflhc senate, in granting or refusing the motion, the reasons in support of it ought to have been calmly and dispas sionately heard. If it were necessary to suggest any reason in aid of those derived from the practice of courts of justice, in support of this sentiment, it might be added, that the reasons which the judge would have assigned, had lie not been interrupted, might have been so satisfactory to the managers of the impeachment, ns to have induced their consent to his motion, which, it must be remembered, was founded upon facts apparent to the senate from their own journals.

See moreSee less

It would seem, from the strictness of adherents to precedents required by Mr. Burr, to support the

See the clipping

Oracle Post · Portsmouth, N.H.

This Washington dispatch covers House debates on Georgia land claims and heated exchanges involving Randolph, Granger, and Lyon. It notes in passing that Aaron Burr has returned to Washington after meeting Governor Bloomfield in Philadelphia, resuming his duties presiding over the impeachment trial of Judge Chase.

Oracle Post · 19 February 1805 · page 2

NEW-YORK, FEB. 6. Aaron Burr, we are informed by the papers, has returned to Washington. After having met Gov. Bloomfield at Philadelphia to see what could be done with the .Nolle Presigue, and made his arrange ments, he has gone back to preside at the trial of Judge Chase. We were always sure that Burr would be in at the death ; [Evening Dost.]

See the clipping