As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

December 1874

6 articles

The Toledo Chronicle · Toledo, Iowa

The passage summarizes Commissioner Smith's annual report on Indian affairs, discussing negotiations with Sioux agencies, the difficulty of controlling raids by Indians near the Indian Territory who remain close to buffalo herds, and proposals to relocate and civilize these tribes through farming and ranching. He argues the main obstacle to Indian civilization lies in government structures rather than Indian character, advocating personal sympathy over bureaucratic solutions.

The Toledo Chronicle · 10 December 1874 · page 4

Territory. The question of the future ol the wild Indians in the Indian Territory, he savs, is a very serious one. a« their deep and' avowed aversion to any settled life cannot be overcome so long as thev are on the border of vast, unoccupied plains, and almost within sight of herds of buffalo. andmake9 it well-nigh impossible to secure settlers in

See the clipping

Marshall County Republican · Plymouth, Ind.

The report describes the industrial-scale trade in buffalo hides, noting over 50,000 hides shipped in three months from Santa Fe railroad stations, with annual totals estimated at 125,000. It details the economics of the trade, from frontier hunters to Eastern dealers, and notes that Indian-prepared robes have become rare curiosities as white hunters dominate the business.

Marshall County Republican · 17 December 1874 · page 7

Attempts have been made from time to time to convert the buffalo hides into leather, but without much success ; and it probably has no very great value ex

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

A report of the Indian Commissioner discusses the difficulty of pacifying and settling Plains tribes while they remain within sight of buffalo herds, arguing this proximity undermines efforts to turn them toward farming. It also reviews land agreements with the Sioux, recommends consolidating wild tribes onto Cherokee/Choctaw/Chickasaw-ceded tracts, and calls for disarming them and exchanging ponies for cattle.

Mineral Point Tribune · 17 December 1874 · page 7

C" I.order of vast, unoccupied plains, and ■ thin sight of herds of buffalo, and makes i nigh impossible to secure settlers ’tt* rn Texas and New Mexico from pilfer ; murderous attacks by small parties or ■ .inals of these tribes. Tinremedy

See the clipping

The Kentucky Gazette · Lexington, Ky.

This report describes the extensive trade in gathering and selling buffalo skeletons from the plains, with bone-pickers supplying railroad depots along Kansas Pacific and Atchison lines. The bones are sold for fertilizer and for manufacturing buttons, combs, and knife handles, with occasional human remains found mixed in among the buffalo bones.

The Kentucky Gazette · 26 December 1874 · page 2

THE GREAT BONE HARVEST

From the Rocky Mountain News The extent of the collection assort ment and sale of the skeletons ol defunct buffaloes on the plains is surprising During the season hundreds of men en gage in the business and all the stations on ihe Ivansaa Pacific and Atchison and Topeka and Sante Fe railroads have bone-middlemen so called who make good profits by buying and shipping the pickings of the “pickers” Tho skele tons are of course plentifuly scattered over the plains and parties of half a doz en or more with wagons go in search of them and bring them into tho stations for shipment It is said since the first of last month from ten to twenty tones o!

See moreSee less

buffalo bones have been shipped over the above named lines every day The bones are worth delivered at the railway station an average of $5 a ton The bulk of them is sold for fertilizing purposes in the soil enfeebled districts ot the eastern and middle Statcp Philadel phia being the principal point of con signment - Certain portions of the buf faio skeletons however are adapted to nobler “uses than the invigoration of worn out aartb and are sold at a hand some price to the manufacturers of but tons combs and knife handles At al most every aailroad depot are great piles of these queer remains of the bounding bison awaiting shipment and the varia tions of the value of bones are of more interest to the people than the fluctua cion of the grain markets In assorting for market strange discoveries are some times made It is no uncommon thing for instance to find Indian skulls legs and arms and in some instances the skulls and vertebrae of women and child ren have been picked up These latter are usually tossed aside in a mde sort ol reverence for the helpless and innocent but no such respect is paid to the bones of the Indian An Indian skull is said to be worth a dollar and a quarter for combs and the Indian thigh makes knife handles that are beautiful to be

See the clipping

The Kentucky Gazette · Lexington, Ky.

The report describes the booming commercial trade in buffalo hides and meat along the Atchison Topeka and Santa Fe and Kansas Pacific railroads, citing shipment figures of over 125,000 hides and 2,000,000 pounds of meat annually. It details the economics of the trade, from frontier prices to eastern markets, and notes buffalo meat is now as common as beefsteak in northern cities.

The Kentucky Gazette · 26 December 1874 · page 2

MERCILESS BUTCHERY

New England or New York farmer re ceives for the hides of his cattle but the profit to the Eastern dealer as can be seen at a glance is considerable At tempts haye been made from time to time to convert the buffalo hide into leather but without success and it prob ably has no very great value except for uso as a robe

See the clipping

New York Dispatch · New York, N.Y.

The report describes the large-scale collection and sale of buffalo (and Indian) bones from the plains, with men gathering skeletons for shipment via the Kansas Pacific and Santa Fe railroads. The bones fetch about $5 a ton, used mainly for fertilizer in depleted Eastern soils, with finer parts sold for buttons, combs, and knife-handles.

New York Dispatch · 27 December 1874 · page 6

THE GREAT BONE HARVEST, Slaughtering the Monarchs of the Plains— Utilizing Bison and Indian Bones — Hide Hunters and Meat Jerkers. (From the Rocky Mountain News.)

See the clipping