As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

May 1873

5 articles

The Daily Phoenix · Columbia, S.C.

The piece argues that forcing older Native Americans off the plains would spark war, but educating the young could create a foundation for eventual civilization while the old generation dies out. It notes that once the buffalo herds vanish, Indian hunting culture will naturally end, and includes a sympathetic plea attributed to Indians asking for mutual respect, trade, and peaceful coexistence with white settlers.

The Daily Phoenix · 6 May 1873 · page 2

tbe game is gone. The appeal of these old Indians is irresistible. They say, "We know no thing about agrioalture. We havo lived on game from infancy. We love the obaae. . Here are tbe wide plains over which the vast herds of buffalo roam. In the spring they pass from Sooth to North, and tho full return, traversing thousands of miles. Where they go you bavo.no settlements; and if you bad, there is room enough for us both. Why Jimit ns to certain boundaries, beyond which wo eh all not follow the game? If you want tbe lauds for settlement, come nnd settle them. We will not disturb

See the clipping

The Daily Phoenix · Columbia, S.C.

This editorial argues for a gradual civilizing policy toward Native Americans rather than forced removal, predicting that once the buffalo disappear, Indians will cease hunting and must adopt agriculture. It includes an imagined Indian appeal for peaceful coexistence and criticizes broken white promises as the root of mistrust.

The Daily Phoenix · 6 May 1873 · page 3

The appeal of these old Indians is irresistible. They say, "We know no thing about agrioalture. We hnvo lived on game from infancy. We love the ohase. Here are the wide plains over which the vast herds of buffalo roam.

See the clipping

Clearfield Republican · Clearfield, Pa.

The editorial argues for gradual civilization of younger Native Americans rather than forced removal from the hunt, warning that forcing older generations away from buffalo hunting will provoke war. It presents an Indian perspective pleading for coexistence and fair treatment, and criticizes broken white promises as the source of distrust.

Clearfield Republican · 7 May 1873 · page 1

The appeal of these old Indians is irresistublo. Ihey say, "Wo know nothing about agriculture. We have lived on gume since infancy. We love the chase. Here are the wide plains over which tho vast herds of buffalo

See the clipping

Pioche Daily Record · Pioche, Nev.

A dispatch describes how Montana beef contractors, paid to supply meat to Indian agencies, exploit vague contract terms by sending Indians to hunt wild buffalo herds rather than provide tame cattle. This practice allows them to profit while fulfilling government contracts at low cost.

Pioche Daily Record · 23 May 1873 · page 2

The Way it is Donk. Up in Montana, as h ird as times now are there compared with the flash times of former days, beef cuttle are worth five ceuts a pound on foot ; and eoutractors agree to f uruish beef at the various Indian Agencies at from 2' ; to 2J ', cents a pound. How can they do it? the unsophistocated may ask. "It's as as easy as rolling off a log;" the terms of the contract don't say whether the beef shall be wild or tame, aud so when they want to make out a bill against the Government for a few tons of meat furnished, they just send the Indians out to drive in a herd of buffalo.

See the clipping

The Findlay Jeffersonian · Findlay, Ohio

This editorial discusses the Modoc War as a reflection of the broader fate of Native American tribes displaced by white settlement. It argues that the destruction of buffalo herds and game by white settlers justified Indian warfare from the Indian perspective, while noting the Indian temperament resists assimilation into white society.

The Findlay Jeffersonian · 23 May 1873 · page 1

name and a memory behind them. Can we imagine the Indians doubt ing that they bad all the rights cf tbe nnarreL when the white man first came to disturb the forests that had belonged to their fathers Irom time immemorial? The silent twang the bowstring scarcely disturbed of the game, as the hunter glided stealth through tbe underwood. Ihe noisy firearms of the new-comers norm drove tbe elk and cteer out ol the woods, spreading starvation routd wigwams where there used to De more than plenty. So it was beyond the Missouri and Mississippi when the white strangers with their ill omcced color firs', made their appear ance from the great settlements. The herds of buffalo that were the wealth

See the clipping