New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
The passage is a literary critique comparing Longfellow's 'Hiawatha' and 'Evangeline' to other poets like Browning and Tennyson, praising his simple yet evocative depictions of nature, including mentions of buffalo herds roaming the prairies. It also discusses James Russell Lowell's 'Biglow Papers,' contrasting his energetic, city-loving style with Bryant's more contemplative nature poetry.
New-York Tribune · 11 July 1867 · page 6
Longfellow’s descriptions charm us more than they astouish. Inferior in luxuriance to those of “Enoch Arden,” in subtilty to Browning's Itulian pictures, they are superior in simplicity, They do not adorn nature as a mistress with the Sunjoghive ancies of a lover; they bring her before us as a faithful nurse careful for ber children. In “Evangeline” the poet follows the wheels of the emigrant’s wagon through “ billowy bays of grass, ever rolling in sunshine and shadows,” and “over them wander the buffalo herds, and the elk, and the roebuck.” “ Hiawatha” speaks of nature with the familiarity of an jnhabitant; there is no trace of the grandiose style of the tourist.
See moreSee less
In the best epirodes of the volume, as the account of the hero's childhood and his friends, of the woaing of Minnehaha, of the Son of the Evening Star, of the Ghosts and the Famine—the parable of human life, with its incidents of birth, love, and death, of civil